Although immortality literally means “not mortal,” its more specific and commonly used meaning refers to a conscious entity, or a part of that conscious entity, not being subject to non-existence by death and eternally existing, in whole or in part, once it exists. Some immortal entities, such as God or gods, are believed to have always existed and are not subject to death. All known animals, including humans, however, are mortal—meaning, in the least, their physical body dies. Numerous philosophies and theologies, however, maintain that the death of the body does not entail the nonexistence of conscious entity, in whole or in part. If the part of the conscious entity (e.g., life force, energy, or atoms) that continues to exist does not also confer and maintain personal identity then such immortality is said to be metaphysically thin. If, however, the conscious entity maintains its personal identity such immortality is said to metaphysically thick. In philosophy of religion, it is the latter that has received the lion’s share of attention: specifically how it can be conceived that an individual (human) person can continue to exist beyond the death of the physical body in such a way that she not only retains personhood but also her unique identity.
Several options from various philosophical and religious traditions have been offered as to how a human individual can survive her own death; these include reincarnation, resurrection (of the body), disembodied soul, and ethereal (astral) body. Reincarnation, also known as transmigration of the soul, has the longest philosophical legacy, and was the type of immortality favored since at least the time of Pythagoras, and accepted by Socrates (through his mouthpiece, Plato). In this tradition, some type of identity conferring essence (e.g., soul) of the person is said to continue to exist after death and be reborn into another mortal body (with some exceptions) in perpetuity. Resurrection of the body is the official doctrine of Christianity. This doctrine states that once an individual dies (immediately or at some future time) God will resurrect (and perfect) the individual in his entirety. This resurrected individual (including the body) will never die again, and thus is immortal. The idea of humans continuing to exist after the death of the physical body as a disembodied soul has been discussed in philosophy since at least the time of Plato, but the ideas major exegesis did not come until Descartes. Descartes argued that he was “a thing that thinks” (i.e., a thinking thing, a mind) and that this thing was his soul. This soul was an immaterial substance and immortal and separated from the physical body at the time of death. Whether or not the soul was ever again joined with a physical body was irrelevant. The essence of a person, and his identity, was his soul, and his soul alone. The ethereal (astral) body hypothesis has largely been ignored in philosophy, but is perhaps best represented in mythologies, folk tales, religious representations, literature and movies. It is the idea that a person continues to exist after their physical death as some sort of ghostly, supernatural immortal apparition that is still in some way recognizable as the deceased individual.
The question of immortality is closely tied to questions of personhood and personal identity. Can a person be essentialized to one or more characteristics that maintain personhood and their identity? To what extent is a body necessary for both personhood and identity? If a person is resurrected, is it the same person or a replica of the original person? What (if any) identity conferring properties can be used to positively identify a person who has been reincarnated, resurrected, disembodied, or ethereal?
Immortality also plays an important role in other areas of philosophy of religion, including the problem of evil and subsequent theodicies. For instance, why would an all-good, all-knowing, all-powerful being (e.g., God) create beings that would suffer death? Does the death of the physical body serve a divine purpose? Why would the knowledge that humans are immortal be hidden from them? Are immortal persons rewarded or punished eternally for their actions during their Earthly life? If so, is that just?
The idea that humans and other beings are immortal has largely been taken for granted for most of the history of philosophy. With the rise of skepticism and atheism in the Modern Era forward, however, arguments for and against immortality have become more and more logically complex, and little is taken for granted.
- Fission and Split Brains (92)
- Dissociative Identity Disorder (65)
- Brain Transplants (4)
- Mind Uploading (12)
- Thought Experiments in Personal Identity (19)
- Puzzle Cases in Personal Identity, Misc (8)
- Afterlife (347 | 1)
- Resurrection (139)
- Personal Identity, Misc (413)
- Reincarnation (38)
- Philosophy of Religion (27,579)
- Divine Eternity (50)
Graduate studies at Western
Using PhilPapers from home?
Click here to configure this browser for off-campus access.
Monitor this page
Be alerted of all new items appearing on this page. Choose how you want to monitor it:
David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Catarina Dutilh Novaes
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers