Abstract
This paper aims at integrating the work onanalogical reasoning in Cognitive Science into thelong trend of philosophical interest, in this century,in analogical reasoning as a basis for scientificmodeling. In the first part of the paper, threesimulations of analogical reasoning, proposed incognitive science, are presented: Gentner's StructureMatching Engine, Mitchel's and Hofstadter's COPYCATand the Analogical Constraint Mapping Engine, proposedby Holyoak and Thagard. The differences andcontroversial points in these simulations arehighlighted in order to make explicit theirpresuppositions concerning the nature of analogicalreasoning. In the last part, this debate in cognitivescience is applied to some traditional philosophicalaccounts of formal and material analogies as a basisfor scientific modeling, like Mary Hesse`s, and tomore recent ones, that already draw from the work inArtificial Intelligence, like that proposed byAronson, Harré and Way.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
REFERENCES
P. Achinstein: 1968, Concepts of Science. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.
J.L. Aronson, R. Harré and E.C. Way: 1995, Realism Rescued: How Scientific Progress is Possible. Open Court, Chicago.
P. Bartha: 1994, Analogical Reasoning and Plausibility in the Sciences. Doctoral dissertation, Department of Philosophy, University of Pittsburgh.
M. Black: 1962, Models and Metaphors. Cornell University Press, Ithaca.
M. Black: 1979, More about Metaphor. In A. Ortony (ed.), Metaphor and Thought. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 10-43.
R.B. Braithwaite: 1953, Scientific Explanation. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
J.R. Brown: 1986, Sellars, Concepts and Conceptual Change. Synthese 68: 275-307.
N.R. Campbell: 1920, Physics: The Elements. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
N. Cartwright: 1993, How We Relate Theory to Observation. In P. Horwich (ed.), World Changes. The MIT Press, Cambridge, pp. 259-273.
A. Clark: 1993, Associative Engines: Connectionism, Concepts and Representational Change. The MIT Press, Cambridge.
J. Cushing: 1982, Models and Methodologies in Current Theoretical High-Energy Physics. Synthese 50: 5-101.
T. Dartnall (ed.): 1994, Artificial Intelligence and Creativity: An Interdisciplinary Approach. Kluwer, Dordrecht.
G. Dejong: 1989, The Role of Explanation in Analogy; or, The Curse of an alluring Name. In S. Vosniadou and A. Ortony (eds.), Similarity and Analogical Reasoning. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 346-365.
C. Dierbach and D. Chester: 1991, A Formal Basis for Analogical Reasoning. In J.A. Allen, R. Fikes and E. Sandewall (eds.), Principles of Knowledge Representation and Reasoning: Proceedings of the Second International Conference. Morgan Kaufmann Publishers, San Mateo.
R.M. French: 1995, The Subtlety of Sameness: A Theory and Computer Model of Analogy-Making. The MIT Press, Cambridge.
D. Gentner: 1982, Are Scientific Analogies Metaphors? In D.S. Miall (ed.), Metaphor: Problems and Perspectives. Harvester Press, Brighton, pp. 106-132.
D. Gentner: 1983, Structure-Mapping: A Theoretical Framework for Analogy. Cognitive Science 7: 155-170.
D. Gentner: 1989, The Mechanisms of Analogical Learning. In S. Vosniadou and A. Ortony (eds.), Similarity and Analogical Reasoning. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 199-241.
D. Gentner and D. Gentner: 1983, Flowing Waters or Teeming Crowds: Mental Models of Electricity. In D. Gentner and A.L. Stevens (eds.), Mental Models. Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, pp. 99-129.
R. Giere: 1988, Explaining Science: A Cognitive Approach. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
N. Goodman: 1976, Languages of Art. Hackett Publishing Co., Indianapolis.
R.P. Hall: 1989, Computational Approaches to Analogical Reasoning: A Comparative Analysis. Artificial Intelligence 39: 39-120.
R. Harré: 1970, The Principles of Scientific Thinking. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
R. Harré: 1987, Varieties of Realism. Blackwell, Oxford.
R. Harré: 1988, Where Models and Analogies Really Count. International Studies in the Philosophy of Science 2: 118-133.
D.H. Helman (ed.): 1988, Analogical Reasoning. Kluwer, Dordrecht.
C.G. Hempel: 1965, Aspects of Scientific Explanation. Free Press, New York.
M. Hesse: 1954, Models in Physics. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 4: 198-214.
M. Hesse: 1961, Forces and Fields. Littlefield, Adams & Co., Totowa.
M. Hesse: 1966, Models and Analogies in Science. University of Notre Dame Press, Notre Dame.
M. Hesse: 1967, Models and Analogy in Science. In P. Edwards (ed.), Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Vol. 5. pp. 354-359.
M. Hesse: 1988, Theories, Family Resemblances and Analogy. In D.H. Helman (ed.), Analogical Reasoning. Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp. 317-340.
D. Hofstadter et al.: 1995, Fluid Concepts and Creative Analogies. Basic Books, New York.
K. Holyoak and P. Thagard: 1989, A Computational Model of Analogical Problem-Solving. In S. Vosniadou and A. Ortony (eds.), Similarity and Analogical Reasoning. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 242-266.
K. Holyoak and P. Thagard: 1995, Mental Leaps. The MIT Press, Cambridge.
B. Indurkhya: 1992, Metaphor and Cognition. Kluwer, Dordrecht.
S. Kedar-Cabelli: 1988, Analogy — from a Unified Perspective. In D.H. Helman (ed.), Analogical Reasoning. Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp. 65-103.
P. Kroes: 1989, Structural Analogies Between Physical Systems. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 40: 145-154.
R. McLaughlin: 1982, Invention and Appraisal. In R. McLaughlin (ed.), What? Where? When? Why? Reidel, Dordrecht, pp. 69-100.
M. Mitchell: 1989, Analogy-Making as Perception. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
C.T. Morrison: 1994, Analogy and Constructive Representation. Master thesis, State University of New York at Binghamton.
E. Nagel: 1961, The Structure of Science. Routledge & Kegan Paul, London.
N. Nersessian: 1987, A Cognitive-Historical Approach to Meaning in Scientific Theories. In N. Nersessian (ed.), The Process of Science: Contemporary Philosophical Approaches to Understanding Scientific Practice. Nijhoff, Dordrecht, pp. 161-178.
N. Nersessian: 1992, How do Scientists Think? Capturing the Dynamics of Conceptual Change in Science. In R. Giere (ed.), Cognitive Models of Science. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, pp. 3-44.
S. Owen: 1990, Analogy for Automated Reasoning. Academic Press, Boston.
S.E. Palmer: 1989, Levels of Description in Information-Processing Theories of Analogy. In S. Vosniadou and A. Ortony (eds.), Similarity and Analogical Reasoning. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 332-345.
M. Redhead: 1980, Models in Physics. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 31: 145-163.
L.J. Rips: 1989. Similarity, Typicality, and Categorization. In S. Vosniadou and A. Ortony (eds.), Similarity and Analogical Reasoning. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 21-59.
W. Sellars: 1965, Scientific Realism or Irenic Instrumentalism. In R.S. Cohen and M.W. Wartofsky (eds.), Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science, Vol. 2, pp. 171-204.
M. Steiner: 1989, The Application of Mathematics to Natural Science. Journal of Philosophy 86: 449-480.
P. Thagard: 1992, Conceptual Revolutions. Princeton University Press, Princeton.
B. van Fraassen: 1987, The Semantic Approach to Scientific Theories. In N. Nersessian (ed.), The Process of Science. Nijhoff, Dordrecht, pp. 105-124.
S. Vosniadou: 1989, Analogical Reasoning as a Mechanism in Knowledge Acquisition: A Developmental Perspective. In S. Vosniadou and A. Ortony (eds.), Similarity and Analogical Reasoning. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 413-437.
S. Vosniadou and A. Ortony (eds.): 1989, Similarity and Analogical Reasoning. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
E.C. Way: 1991, Knowledge Representation and Metaphor. Kluwer, Dordrecht.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Abrantes, P. Analogical Reasoning and Modeling in the Sciences. Foundations of Science 4, 237–270 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009623823171
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009623823171