Skip to main content

Advertisement

Log in

Biography of a "Feathered Pig": The California Condor Conservation Controversy

  • Published:
Journal of the History of Biology Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

In the early 20th century, after hundreds of years of gradual decline, the California condor emerged as an object of intensive scientific study, an important conservation target, and a cultural icon of the American wilderness preservation movement. Early condor researchers generally believed that the species' survival depended upon the preservation of its wilderness habitat. However, beginning in the 1970s, a new generation of scientists argued that no amount of wilderness could prevent the condor's decline and that only intensive scientific management - including captive breeding - could save the species from certain extinction. A bitter and highly politicized battle soon developed over how to best preserve the condor. For 5 years the condor was extinct in the wild; however, by the time that officials released the first captive-bred birds the condor recovery program had garnered widespread public support, even among its former critics. Today, condor advocates from the scientific and activist communities work together to manage the species and protect its habitat. The condor's story illustrates some of the tensions, problems, and successes that have accompanied the rise of conservation biology as a scientific field and environmental movement in the United States.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Similar content being viewed by others

References

  • Ainsworth,E.1953.''Hunt Starts for Pair of California Condors.''Los Angeles Times February 10:II-22.

  • Alroy,J.2001.''A Multiple Species Overkill Simulation of the End-Pleistocene Megafaunal Mass Extinction.''Science 292:1893-1896.

  • Armstrong,S.1991.''Flight of the Condor (and Ferret).''The Christian Science Monitor,September 25:p.8,col.2.

  • Audubon Leader (anonymous article),1977.National Audubon Endorses Captive Prop-agation and Release of California Condors Because of Precarious State of This Endangered Species:Science Panel to be Set.National Audubon Society.

  • Baker,J.H.1951.Letter from National Audubon Society President John H.Baker to Society members entitled ''What is a Condor Worth?''Harry Harris archive,Ornithology Collections,Section of Vertebrate Zoology.Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County.

  • Barrow,M.Jr.2002.''Science,Sentiment,and the Specter of Extinction:Reconsidering Birds of Prey during America 's Interwar Years.''Environmental History 7:69-98.

  • Beebe,C.W.1906.''The California Condor.''Bulletin of the Zoological Society of New York 20:258-259.

  • Bergman,C.1990.Wild Echoes:Encounters with the Most Endangered Animals in North America.McGraw-Hill Publishing Company.

  • Bishop,R.C.and Clement,R.C.1975.''Conservation of the California Condor (a Socioeconomic Study of a Survival Problem).''XII Bulletin of the International Council for Bird Preservation.

  • Brower,D.1981.''The Condor and a Sense of Place.''In D.Phillips and H.Nash (eds.).,The Condor Question:Captive or Forever Free?Friends of the Earth.

  • Brower,D.1987.''The Uneasy Chair:Any Places That Are Wild.''Earth Island Journal 2:2.

  • Burcham,L.T.1981.''California Rangelands in Historical Perspective.''Rangelands 3: 95-104.

    Google Scholar 

  • Callicott,J.B.and Nelson,M.P.(eds.).1998.The Great New Wilderness Debate. University of Georgia Press.

  • Callicott,J.B.(ed.).1987.Companion to Sand County Almanac:Interpretive &Critical Essays.University of Wisconsin Press.

  • Carlson,T.1986.''Last Days of the Condor?''The New York Times,February 8:A-1.

  • Cohn,J.P.''Saving the California Condor.''Bioscience 43:864-868.

  • Cooper,J.G.1890.''A Doomed Bird.''Zoe 1:248-249.

  • Crawford,M.1985.''The Last Days of the Wild Condor?''Science 229:844-845.

  • Cronon,W.1995.''The Trouble With Wilderness;or,Getting Back to the Wrong Nature.''In W.Cronon (ed.),Uncommon Ground:Rethinking the Human Place in Nature.W.W.Norton &Co.

  • Dunlap,T.1988.Saving America 's Wildlife:Ecology and the American Mind,1850-1990.Princeton University Press.

  • Eaton,J.1991.''Wilderness:From Aesthetics to Biodiversity.''Wild Earth 1:1-2.

  • Ehrlich,A.and Ehrlich,P.1981.''Foreword.''In D.Phillips and H.Nash (eds.).The Condor Question:Captive or Forever Free? Friends of the Earth.

  • Emslie,S.D.''Age and Diet of Fossil California Condors in Grand Canyon,Arizona.'' Science 237:768-770.

  • Errington,P.L.and Hamerstrom,F.N.Jr.1937.''The Evaluation of Nesting Losses and Juvenile Mortality of the Ring-Necked Pheasant.''Journal of Wildlife Management 1:3-20.

    Google Scholar 

  • Finley,W.1908.''Life History of the California Condor II.''The Condor 10:5-10.

  • Flemming,J.H.1924.''The California Condor in Washington:Another Version of an Old Record.''The Condor 26:111-112.

  • Ford,R.1986.''Saving the Condor:Robert E.Easton 's Fight to Create The Sisquoc Condor Sanctuary.''Noticias XXXII (Bulletin of the Santa Barbara Historical Society) 4:61-74.

  • Gass,P.1904.Gass 's Journal of the Lewis and Clark Expedition.A.C.McClurg &Co.

  • Geyer,C.J., Ryder,O.A., Chemnick,L.G.and Thompson,E.A.1993.''Analysis of Relatedness in the California Condors,from DNA Fingerprints.''Molecular Biology and Evolution 10:571-589.

    Google Scholar 

  • Gosselin,L.2000.''On Human Intervention.''Audubon 102:6.

  • Graham,F.Jr.2000.''The Day of the Condor.''Audubon 102:46-53.

  • Grayson,A.J.1891.quoted by Bryant,1891,and transcribed by Harry Harris.Harry Harris archive,Ornithology Collections,Section of Vertebrate Zoology,Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County.

  • Harris,H.1941.''The Annals of Gymnogyps to 1900.''The Condor 43:3-9.

  • Harvey,M.1994.A Symbol of Wilderness:Echo Park and the American Conservation Movement.University of New Mexico Press.

  • Henshaw,H.W.1920.''Autobiographical Notes.''The Condor 22:3-10.

    Google Scholar 

  • Hornaday,W.T.1898.''The Destruction of Our Birds and Mammals:A Report on the Results of An Inquiry.''2nd Annual Report of the New York Zoological Society:77-126.

  • Johnson,T.C., Scholtz,C.A., Talbot,M.R., Kelts,K., Rickets,R.D., Ngobi,G., Beuning,K., Ssemmanda,I.and McGill,J.W.1996.''Late Pleistocene desiccation of Lake Victoria and rapid evolution of cichlid shes.''Science 273:1091-1093.

    Google Scholar 

  • Jones,R.A.1991.''When Ugly is Okay.''Los Angeles Times June 19:A-3.

  • Kelly,D.2002a.''Condor is Free to Roam After 15 Years in Protective Custody.''Los Angeles Times,May 2:B-8.

  • Kelly,D.2002b.''Welfare State for Vultures.''Los Angeles Times,July 24:A-1.

  • Kelly,D.2002c.''Last of Three Wild Condor Chicks is Found Dead.''Los Angeles Times,May 2:B-8.

  • Koford,C.B.1953.The California Condor.Dover Publications.

  • Koford,C.B.1979.''California Condors,Forever Free?''Audubon Imprint (newsletter of the Santa Monica Bay Audubon Society) 3: 1-7.

  • Lopez,B.1978.Of Wolves and Men.Simon &Schuster.

  • Los Angeles Times (Editorial),2002.''Coveting Condor Land,''March 16:B-20.

  • Mathews,J.1987.''Last Wild Condor of Species Netted.''The Washington Post,April 20:A-3.

  • McMillan,I.1981.''An Objection to Feeding Condors.''In D.Phillips and H.Nash (eds.),The Condor Question:Captive or Forever Free? Friends of the Earth.

  • Meretsky,V.J., Snyder,N., Beissinger,S.R., Clendenen,D.A.and Wiley,J.W.2000. ''Demography of the California Condor:Implications for Reestablishment.''Conservation Biology 14:957-967.

    Google Scholar 

  • Mertz,D.B.1971.''The Mathematical Demography of the California Condor Population.''The American Naturalist 105:437-453.

  • Miller,A.H., McMillan,I.I.and McMillan,E.1965.''The Current status and Welfare of the California Condor.''Research Report No.6.National Audubon Society.

  • Miller,C.2001.Gifford Pinchot and the Making of Modern Environmentalism.Island Press/Shearwater Books.

  • Miller,J.M.1995.''Condor 'Preschool 'Teaches Fear.''Los Angeles Times,August 17: A-3.

  • Nash,R.1967.Wilderness and the American Mind.Yale University Press.

  • Noss,R.1991a.''Sustainability and Wilderness.''Conservation Biology 5:120-122.

  • Noss,R.1991b.''What Can Wilderness Do For Biodiversity?''Wild Earth 1:51-56.

  • Oelschlaeger,M.1991.The Idea of Wilderness:From Prehistory to the Age of Ecology. Yale University Press.

  • Pielou,E.C.1991.After the Ice Age:The Return of Glaciated Life to North America. The University of Chicago Press.

  • Pols,M.F.1996.''Condor Conundrum.''Los Angeles Times,April 28:A-3.

  • Renshaw,G.1907.''The California Condor.''Ovid 11:295-298.

  • Revkin,A.C.1985.''The Condor:Is Money Being Wasted on Doomed Species?''Los Angeles Times,September 23:I-3.

    Google Scholar 

  • Rich,P.V.1983.''The Fossil History of Vultures:A World Perspective.''In S.R. Wilbur and J.A. Jackson,(eds.),Vulture Biology and Management.University of California Press.

  • Ryder,O., McLaren,A., Brenner,S., Zhang,Y.-P.and Benirschke,K.2000.''Preservation of DNA from Endangered Species.''Science 288:275-277.

    Google Scholar 

  • Sarkar,S.,2005.Biodiversity and Environmental Philosophy:An Introduction to the Issues.Cambridge University Press,forthcoming

  • Simon,S.1995.''Biologists Hope to Save Condors With 'Tough Love.'''Los Angeles Times,February 5:A-1.

  • Simons,D.D.1983.''Interactions Between California Condors and humans in prehistoric far western North America.''In S.R.Wilbur,and J.A.Jackson,(eds.), Vulture Biology and Management.University of California Press.

  • Sheldon,H.H.1939.''What Price Condor:The bird with the Greatest Wing-Spread has Outlived its Time and is on the Trail of the Dodo.''Field and Stream 44:61-62.

  • Smith,D.and Easton,R.1964.California Condor:Vanishing American.McNally and Loftin,Publishers.

  • Smollar,D.1987.''California 's Last Condor in Wild Captured.''Los Angeles Times, April 20:A-1.

  • Snyder,N., Derrickson,S.R., Beissinger,S.R., Wiley,J.W., Smith,T.B., Toone,W. D.and Miller,B.1996.''Limits of Captive Breeding in Endangered Species Recovery.''Conservation Biology 10:338-348.

    Google Scholar 

  • Snyder,N.and Snyder,H.2000.The California Condor:A Saga of Natural History and Conservation.Natural World Academic Press.

  • Stammer,L.B.1991.''1st California Condors Return to Reclaim Wild.''Los Angeles Times,October 11:A-1.

  • Stammer,L.B.1992.''First Captive California Condors Freed in Wild.''Los Angeles Times,January 15:A-1.

  • Steadman,D.W.and Miller,N.G.1986.''California Condor associated with spruce-jack pine woodland in late Pleistocene New York.''Quaternary Research 28:415-426.

    Google Scholar 

  • Stoms,D.M., Davis F.W., Cogan,C.B., Painho,M.O., Duncan,B.W., Scepan,J. and Scott,M.J.1993.''Geographic Analysis of California Condor Sighting Data.'' Conservation Biology 7:148-159.

    Google Scholar 

  • Ventana Wilderness Society,2003.Mission Statement retrieved from http://www.ventanaws.org/aboutvws.htm.

  • Wilbur,S.R.1978.''The California Condor,1966-1976:A Look at its Past and Future.''North American Fauna,No.72.United States Department of the Interior.

  • Ybarra,M.J.1997.''Is This Bird Worth $20 Million?''Los Angeles Times Magazine, September 14:16-17,31-36.

    Google Scholar 

Download references

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Authors

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Alagona, P.S. Biography of a "Feathered Pig": The California Condor Conservation Controversy. Journal of the History of Biology 37, 557–583 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-004-2083-6

Download citation

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-004-2083-6

Navigation