Abstract
Philosophers of evolutionary biology favor the so-called “etiological concept” of function according to which the function of a trait is its evolutionary purpose, defined as the effect for which that trait was favored by natural selection. We term this the selected effect (SE) analysis of function. An alternative account of function was introduced by Robert Cummins in a non-evolutionary and non-purposive context. Cummins's account has received attention but little support from philosophers of biology. This paper will show that a similar non-purposive concept of function, which we term causal role (CR) function, is crucial to certain research programs in evolutionary biology, and that philosophical criticisms of Cummins's concept are ineffective in this scientific context. Specifically, we demonstrate that CR functions are a vital and ineliminable part of research in comparative and functional anatomy, and that biological categories used by anatomists are not defined by the application of SE functional analysis. Causal role functions are non-historically defined, but may themselves be used in an historical analysis. Furthermore, we show that a philosophical insistence on the primary of SE functions places practicing biologists in an untenable position, as such functions can rarely be demonstrated (in contrast to CR functions). Biologists who study the form and function of organismal design recognize that it is virtually impossible to identify the past action of selection on any particular structure retrospectively, a requirement for recognizing SE functions.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Amundson, R.: 1988, ‘Logical Adaptationism’,Behavioral and Brain Sciences 11, 505–506.
Amundson, R.: 1990, ‘Doctor Dennett and Doctor Pangloss: Perfection and Selection in Psychology and Biology’,Behavioral and Brain Sciences 13, 577–584.
Arnold, S.J.: 1983, ‘Morphology, Performance, and Fitness’,American Zoologist 23, 347–361.
Arnold, S.J.: 1986, ‘Laboratory and Field Approaches to the Study of Adaptation’, in M.E. Feder and G.V. Lauder (eds.),Predator-Prey Relationships: Perspectives and Approaches from the Study of Lower Vertebrates, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Arnold, S.J., and M.J. Wade,: 1984, ‘On the Measurement of Natural and Sexual Selection: Theory’,Evolution 38: 709–719.
Ayala, Francisco J.: 1970, ‘Teleological Explanations in Evolutionary Biology,’Philosophy of Science 37: 1–15.
Barnes, R.D.: 1991,Invertebrate Zoology, Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Fort Worth TX.
Bigelow, J., and R. Pargetter: 1987, ‘Functions’,The Journal of Philosophy 84: 181–196.
Bock, W.J.: 1958, ‘Preadaptation and multiple evolutionary pathways’,Evolution 13: 194–211.
Bock, W.J.: 1980, ‘The Definition and Recognition of Biological Adaptation’,American Zoologist 20: 217–227.
Bock, W.J., and G. von Wahlert: 1965, ‘Adaptation and the form-function complex’,Evolution 19: 269–299.
Bookstein, F., B. Chernoff, R. Elder, J. Humphries, G. Smith, and R. Strauss: 1985,Morphometrics in Evolutionary Biology, Academy of Natural Sciences, Philadelphia.
Boorse, C.: 1976, ‘Wright on Functions’,Philosophical Review 85: 70–86.
Brandon, R.N.: 1981, ‘Biological teleology: Questions and Explanations’,Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 12: 91–105.
Brandon, R.N.: 1990,Adaptation and Environment, Princeton Press, Princeton NJ.
Cummins, R.: 1975, ‘Functional Analysis’,Journal of Philosophy 72: 741–765. [Excerpts reprinted in Ned Block (ed.), Readings in Philosophy of Psychology, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.]
Cummins, R.: 1983,The Nature of Psychological Explanation, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Darwin, C.: 1859,On the Origin of Species, John Murray, London.
Dennett, D.C.: 1987,The Intentional Stance, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Emerson, S.: 1988. ‘Testing for Historical Patterns of Change: a Case Study with Frog Pectoral Girdles’,Paleobiology 14, 174–186.
Endler, J.: 1986,Natural Selection in the Wild, Princeton University Press, Princeton NJ.
Falconer, D. S.: 1989,Introduction to Quantitative Genetics, 3rd Ed, Longman, London.
Gans, C.: 1974,Biomechanics: an Approach to Vertebrate Biology, J.B. Lippincott, Philadelphia.
Goslow, G.E., K.P. Dial, and F.A. Jenkins: 1989, ‘The Avian Shoulder: an Experimental Approach’,American Zoologist 29: 287–301.
Gould, S.J. 1980,The Panda's Thumb, W. W. Norton and Company, New York.
Gould, S.J., and E. S. Vrba: 1982, ‘Exaptation — A Missing Term in the Science of Form’,Paleobiology 8: 4–15.
Hall, B.K. (ed.): 1984,Homology, Academic Press, San Diego.
Kingsolver, J.G., and M.A.R. Koehl: 1985, ‘Aerodynamics, Thermoregulation, and the Evolution of Insect Wings: Differential Scaling and Evolutionary Change’,Evolution 39: 488–504.
Lande, R., and S.J. Arnold: 1983, ‘The Measurement of Selection on Correlated Characters’,Evolution 37: 1210–1226.
Lauder, G.V.: 1981, ‘Form and Function: Structural Analysis in Evolutionary Morphology’,Paleobiology 7: 430–442.
Lauder, G.V.: 1982, ‘Historical Biology and the Problem of Design’,Journal of Theoretical Biology 97: 57–67.
Lauder, G.V.: 1990 ‘Functional Morphology and Systematics: Studying Functional Patterns in an Historical Context’,Annual Review of Ecological Systems 21: 317–40.
Lauder, G.V.: 1991, ‘Biomechanics and Evolution: Integrating Physical and Historical Biology in the Study of Complex Systems’, in J.M.V. Rayner and R.J. Wootton (eds.),Biomechanics in Evolution, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Lauder, G.V., A. Leroi, and M. Rose: 1993, ‘Adaptations and History’,Trends in Ecology and Evolution 8, 294–297.
Lauder, G.V., and K.F. Liem: 1989, ‘The role of historical factors in the evolution of complex organismal functions’, in D. B. Wake and G. Roth (eds.),Complex Organismal Functions: Integration and Evolution in Vertebrates, John Wiley and Sons, Chichester.
Lauder, G.V., and P.C. Wainwright: 1992, ‘Function and History: The Pharyngeal Jaw Apparatus in Primitive Ray-finned Fishes’, in R. Mayden (ed.),Systematics, Historical Ecology, and North American Freshwater Fishes, Stanford University Press, Stanford.
Lewontin, R.C. 1969. ‘The Bases of Conflict in Biological Explanation’,Journal of the History of Biology 2: 35–45.
Liem, K.F.: 1989, ‘Respiratory Gas Bladders in Teleosts: Functional Conservatism and Morphological Diversity’,American Zoologist 29 333–352.
Liem, K.F., and D.B. Wake: 1985, ‘Morphology: current approaches and concepts’, in M. Hildebrand, D.M. Bramble, K.F. Liem, and D.B. Wake (eds.),Functional Vertebrate Morphology, Harvard Univ. Press, Cambridge, MA.
Mayr, E.: 1982,The Growth of Biological Thought, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Millikan, R.G.: 1984,Language, Thought, and Other Biological Categories, Cambridge MA: MIT Press.
Millikan, R.G.: 1989, ‘In Defense of Proper Functions,’Philosophy of Science 56 288–302.
Millikan, R.G.; 1993,White Queen Psychology and Other Essays for Alice, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Neander, K.: 1991, ‘Functions as Selected Effects: The Conceptual Analyst's Defense’,Philosophy of Science 58 168–184.
Neander, K.: manuscript, ‘Teleology in Biology’ (Woollongong University, Australia).
Nishikawa, K., C.W. Anderson, S.M. Deban, and J. O'Reilly: 1992 ‘The Evolution of Neural Circuits Controlling Feeding Behavior in Frogs’,Brain, Behavior, and Evolution 40 125–140.
Patterson, C.: 1982, ‘Morphological Characters and Homology’, in K.A. Joysey and A.E. Friday (eds.),Problems of Phylogenetic Reconstruction, Academic Press, London.
Raup, D.M., and S.M. Stanley: 1971,Principles of Paleontology, W.H. Freeman and Co., San Francisco.
Rose, M.R.: 1982, ‘Antagonistic Pleiotropy, Dominance, and Genetic Variation’,Heredity 48 63–78.
Rosenberg, A.: 1985,The Structure of Biological Science, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Ruse, M.: 1971, ‘Function Statements in Biology,’Philosophy of Science 38 87–95.
Schaffner, K.: 1993,Discovery and Explanation in Biology and Medicine, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Sober, E.: 1984,The Nature of Selection, MIT Press, Cambridge MA.
Sober, E.: 1993,Philosophy of Biology, Westview Press, Boulder CO.
Wake, D.B., and R. Roth: 1989,Complex Organismal Functions: Integration and Evolution in Vertebrates, John Wiley and Sons, Chichester.
Wake, M.H.: 1991, ‘Morphology, the Study of Form and Function, in Modern Evolutionary Biology’,Oxford Surveys in Evolutionary Biology 8 289–346.
Williams, G.C.: 1966,Adaptation and Natural Selection, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
Wright, L.: 1973, ‘Functions’,Philosophical Review 82 139–168.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Amundson, R., Lauder, G.V. Function without purpose. Biol Philos 9, 443–469 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00850375
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00850375