Abstract
Life situations often seem to require dualistic, either or decision making, but this common method does not always clarify moral decisions. To show this, standard arguments on why to choose or not to choose the sex or ones child are presented. Then, our feminist thinking, which regards clusters of values, and which reframes questions rather than choosing between desirable alternatives, suggests another possibility, in a gynandrous world vision.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adimoelja, A., Hariadi, R., Amitaba, I. G. B., Adisetya, P., & Soeharna. The separation of X-and Y-spermatozoa with regard to the possible clinical application by means of artificial insemination.andrologia, 93, 1977, pp. 289–292.
Chacko, A. Too many daughters? India's drastic cure.World Paper. November 1982.
Chico, N. Personal Communication, data for Ph.D. dissertation, 1983.
Carson, S. L., Batzer, F. R., & Schlaff, S. Preconception female gender selection.Fertility and Sterility, 40:3, 1983, pp. 384–385.
deCrispigny, L. C. & Robinson, H. P. Determination of fetal sex with ultrasound.Medical Journal of Australia, 2, July 25, 1981, pp. 98–100.
Dodson Gray, E.Green Paradise Revisited. Wellesley Mass.: Roundtable Press, 1982.
Dodson Gray, E.Patriarchy as a Conceptual Trap. Wellesley Mass.: Roundtable Press, 1982.
Ee., M. Dualism. Encyclopedia Britannica. Volume 7, Chicago: William Benton, 1971, pp. 717–718.
Etizioni, A. Sex control, science, and society.Science 161 1968, pp. 1107–1112.
Gearhart, S.M. The Future—If There is One—is Female.In McAllister, P. (Ed.)Reweaving the Web of Life: Feminism and Nonviolence. Philadelphia: New Society Publishers, 1982, pp. 266–284.
Gilligan, C.In a Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women's Development. Cambridge Mass: Harvard Univ. Press, 1982.
Glass, A.R. & Klein, T. Changes in maternal serum total and free androgen levels in early pregnancy: Lack of correlation with fetal sex.American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 140: 1981, pp. 656–660.
Gosden, J.R., Mitchell, A.R., Gosden, C.M., Rodeck, C.H. & Morsman, J.M. Direct vision chorion biopsy and chromosome-specific DNA probes for determination of fetal sex, in first-trimester prenatal diagnosis.The Lancet, 2 December 25, 1982, pp. 1416–1419
Guttentag, M. & Secord, P.F.Too Many Women? The Sex Ratio Question. Beverly Hills, Sage Publications, 1983.
Held, K.R., Burck, U. & Koske-Westphal, Th. Pranatale Geschlechtsbestimmung durch den GBN-Speicheltest. Ein Vergleich mit den Ergebnissen der pranatalen Chromosomendiagnostik.Geburtshilfe und Frauenheilkunde 41, pp. 619–621.
Herzenberg, L.A., Bianchi, D.W., Schroder, J., Conn, H.M. & Iverson, G.M. Fetal cells in the blood of pregnant women: Detection and enrichment by fluorescence-activated cell sorting. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science, USA 76, 1976, pp. 1453–1455.
Holmes, H.B., Hoskins, B.B. & Gross, M. (Eds.)The Custom-Made Child? Women-centered Perspectives. Clifton NJ: Humana Press, 1981.
Hoskins, B.B. & Holmes, H.B. Technology and Prenatal Femicide. In Arditti, R., Klein, R.D. and Minden, S.Test-tube Women — What Future for Motherhood? Boston: Routledge & Kegan Paul. 1984, pp. 237–255.
Luce, C.B. Next: Pills to make most babies male.Washington Star July 9, 1978, C-1, C-4.
Markle, Boy or Girl? Should the choice be ours? First Broadcast January 2 1981. in Public Broadcasting SeriesHard Choices. Transcripts available from PTV Publications. P.O. Box 701, Kent OH 44240
Mean, M., Pescia, G., Vajda, D., Pelber, J.B., & Magrini, G. Amniotic fluid testosterone in prenatal sex determination.Journal de Genetique humaine 29 4, 1981, pp. 441–447
Powledge, T. Unnatural Selection: On Choosing Children's Sex. In Holmes, Hoskins, and Gross, op. cit., 1981, pp. 193–199.
Quinlivan, W.L., Preciado, K., Long, T.L. & Sullivan, H. Separation of human X and Y spermatozoa by albumin gradients and Sephadex chromatography.Fertility and Sterility, 37 1, 1982, pp. 104–107.
Raymond, J. (Ed.) Sex Preselection. In Holmes, Hoskins, Gross, op. cit., pp. 177–224.
Steinbacher, R. Sex Preselection: From Here to Fraternity. In Gould, Carol, editorBeyond Domination: New Perspectives on Women and Philosophy. Totawa N.J.: Littlefield, Adams, 1983.
Steeno, O., Adimoelja, A. & Steeno, J. Separation of X- and Y-bearing human spermatozoa with the Sephadex gel-filtration method.Andrologia 7: 1975, pp. 95–97.
Stolkowski, J. & Choukron, J. Preconception selection of sex in man.Israel Journal of Medical Sciences 17 1981, pp. 1061–1067.
Weldner, E-M. Accuracy of fetal sex determination by ultrasound.Acta Obstetrica et Gynecologica Scandinavia, 60 1981, pp. 333–334.
Williamson, N.E. Boys or Girls? Parents' Preferences and Sex Control.Population Bulletin. Washington DC: Population Reference Bureau, 1978.
Additional information
These ideas on dualism and feminist values develop within community. The biological and ethical considerations that provided the impetus for this article were developed for a National Women's Studies Association panel organized by Helen Bequaert Holmes for June 1983; they appear in the anthologyTest-Tube Women — What Future for Motherhood? (Hoskins and Holmes, 1984). The ethical implications of feminism for dualistic thinking were presented by Betty B. Hoskins at Collegium, an Association of Liberal Religious Scholars, in October 1983. Dr. Hoskins is an independent scholar and Senior Technical Editor, to whom reprint requests can be addressed at 5 Paradox Drive, Worcester Massachusetts 01602. Dr. Holmes is the 1984–85 guest worker at the Science and Society Program, University of Groningen, The Netherlands.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hoskins, B.B., Holmes, H.B. When not to choose: A case study. J Med Hum 6, 28–37 (1985). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01149836
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01149836