Abstract
Proponents of the standard evolutionary biology paradigm explain human “altruism” in terms of either nepotism or strict reciprocity. On that basis our underlying nature is reduced to a function of inclusive fitness: human nature has to be totally selfish or nepotistic. Proposed here are three possible paths to giving costly aid to nonrelatives, paths that are controversial because they involve assumed pleiotropic effects or group selection. One path is pleiotropic subsidies that help to extend nepotistic helping behavior from close family to nonrelatives. Another is “warfare”—if and only if warfare recurred in the Paleolithic. The third and most plausible hypothesis is based on the morally based egalitarian syndrome of prehistoric hunter-gatherers, which reduced phenotypic variation at the within-group level, increased it at the between-group level, and drastically curtailed the advantages of free riders. In an analysis consistent with the fundamental tenets of evolutionary biology, these three paths are evaluated as explanations for the evolutionary development of a rather complicated human social nature.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alexander, Richard D. 1971 The Search for an Evolutionary Philosophy of Man. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Victoria 84:99–120.
1974 The Evolution of Social Behavior. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 5:325–384.
1987 The Biology of Moral Systems. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
Alexander, Richard D., and George Borgia 1978 Group Selection, Altruism and the Levels of Organization of Life. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 9:449–475.
Alexander, Richard D., and D. W. Tinkle 1968 Review of On Aggression by Konrad Lorenz and The Territorial Imperative by Robert Ardrey. Bioscience 18:245–248.
Balikci, Asen 1970 The Netsilik Eskimo. Prospect Heights, Illinois; Waveland.
Barkow, Jerome, Leda Cosmides, and John Tooby, eds. 1992 The Adapted Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and the Generation of Culture. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Barnsley, John H. 1972 The Social Reality of Ethics: The Comparative Analysis of Moral Codes. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Berndt, Ronald M., and Catherine H. Berndt 1964 The World of the First Australians: An Introduction to the Traditional Life of the Australian Aborigines. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Betzig, Laura 1982 Despotism and Differential Reproduction: A Cross-Cultural Correlation of Conflict Asymmetry, Hierarchy, and Degree of Polygyny. Ethology and Sociobiology 3:209–221.
Bigelow, R. S. 1969 The Dawn Warriors: Man’s Evolution towards Peace. Boston: Little Brown.
Biesele, Megan, and Nancy Howell 1981 “The Old People Give You Life”: Aging among !Kung Hunter-Gatherers. In Other Ways of Growing Old, P. T. Awass and S. Harrell, eds. Pp. 77–98. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Binford, Lewis 1978 Nunamiut Ethnoarchaeology. New York: Academic Press.
Black, Donald 1984 Toward a General Theory of Social Control. Orlando: Academic Press.
Blurton-Jones, Nicholas 1984 A Selfish Origin for Human Food Sharing: Tolerated Theft. Ethology and Sociobiology 41:145–157.
Boehm, Christopher 1978 Rational Preselection from Hamadryas to Homo sapiens: The Place of Decisions in Adaptive Process. American Anthropologist 80:265–296.
1979 Some Problems with “Altruism” in the Search for Moral Universals. Behavioral Science 24:15–24.
1981 Parasitic Selection and Group Selection: A Study of Conflict Interference in Rhesus and Japanese Macaque Monkeys. In Primate Behavior and Sociobiology, A. B. Chiarelli and R. S. Corruccini, eds. Pp. 160–182. Berlin: Springer-Verlag.
1982 The Evolutionary Development of Morality as an Effect of Dominance Behavior and Conflict Interference. Journal of Social and Biological Structures 5:413–422.
1983 Montenegrin Social Organization and Values. New York: AMS Press.
1986 Blood Revenge: The Enactment and Management of Conflict in Montenegro and Other Tribal Societies. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
1989 Ambivalence and Compromise in Human Nature. American Anthropologist 91:921–939.
1991 Lower-Level Teleology in Biological Evolution: Decision Behavior and Reproductive Success in Two Species. Cultural Dynamics 4:115–134.
1992 Segmentary "Warfare" and the Management of Conflict: Comparison of East African Chimpanzees and Patrilineal-Patrilocal Humans. In Coalitions and Alliances in Humans and Other Animals, A. H. Harcourt and F. B. M. de Waal, eds. Pp. 137–173. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
1993 Egalitarian Society and Reverse Dominance Hierarchy. Current Anthropology 34:227–254.
1994a Pacifying Interventions at Arnhem Zoo and Gombe. In Chimpanzee Cultures, Richard W. Wrangham, W. C. McGrew, Frans B. M. de Waal, and Paul G. Heltne, eds. Pp. 211–226. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
1994b Reply to David Erdal and Andrew Whiten. Current Anthropology 35:178–180.
1996 Emergency Decisions, Cultural Selection Mechanics, and Group Selection. Current Anthropology 37:763–793.
1997a Egalitarian Behavior and the Evolution of Political Intelligence. In Machiavellian Intelligence R. W. Byrne, II and A. Whiten, eds. Pp. 341–364. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
1997b Impact of the Human Egalitarian Syndrome on Darwinian Selection Mechanics. American Naturalist 150:100–121.
1999a Forager Hierarchies and Their Effect on Human Behavioral Dispositions. In Hierarchies in Action, Michael Diehl, ed. Proceedings of 1997 Visiting Scholar’s Conference. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press, in press.
1999b Hierarchy in the Forest: The Evolution of Egalitarian Behavior. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Bohannan, Paul J. 1954 The Migration and Expansion of the Tiv. Africa 24:2–16.
Bowles, Samuel, and Herbert Gintis 1998 The Evolution of Strong Reciprocity. Paper presented at Santa Fe Institute, Santa Fe, New Mexico.
Boyd, Richard, and Peter J. Richerson 1985 Culture and Evolutionary Process. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
1992 Punishment Allows the Evolution of Cooperation (or Anything Else) in Sizable Groups. Ethology and Sociobiology 13:171–195.
Briggs, Jean L. 1970 Never in Anger. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Campbell, Donald T. 1965a Ethnocentric and Other Altruistic Motives. In Nebraska Symposium on Motivation, David Levine, ed. pp. 283–311. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.
1965b Variation and Selective Retention in Socio-Cultural Evolution. In Social Change in Developing Areas, H. R. Barringer, B. I. Blanksten, and R. W. Mack, eds. Pp. 19–49. Cambridge: Schenkman.
1972 On the Genetics of Altruism and the Counter-Hedonic Component of Human Culture. Journal of Social Issues 28:21–37.
1975 On the Conflicts between Biological and Social Evolution and between Psychology and Moral Tradition. American Psychologist 30:1103–1126.
Campbell, Donald T., and John B. Gatewood 1994 Ambivalently Held Group-Optimizing Predispositions. Commentary on D. S. Wilson and Eliot Sober, Reintroducing Group Selection to the Human Behavioral Sciences. Behavior and Brain Sciences 17:614.
Cashdan, Elizabeth 1980 Egalitarianism among Hunters and Gatherers. American Anthropologist 82:116–120.
1983 Territoriality among Human Foragers: Ecological Models and an Application to Four Bushman Groups. Current Anthropology 24:47–66.
Cashdan, Elizabeth, ed. 1990 Risk and Uncertainty in Tribal and Peasant Economies. Boulder: Westview.
Chagnon, Napoleon 1983 Yanomamo: The Fierce People. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
1988a Is Reproductive Success Equal in Egalitarian Societies? In Evolutionary Biology and Human Social Behavior: An Anthropological Perspective, N. A. Chagnon and W. Irons, eds. Pp. 374–401. North Scituate: Duxbury.
1988b Life Histories, Blood Revenge, and Warfare in a Tribal Population. Science 239:985–992.
Daly, Martin, and Margo Wilson 1988 Homicide. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
Darwin, Charles 1871 The Descent of Man and Selection in Relation to Sex. London: John Murray. (reprinted in 1971)
de Waal, Frans 1996 Conflict as Negotiation. In Great Ape Societies, W. C. McGrew, L. F. Marchant, and T. Nishida, eds. Pp. 159–172. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Dirks, Robert 1980 Social Responses during Severe Food Shortages and Famine. Current Anthropology 21:21–44.
Dunbar, Robin 1996 Grooming, Gossip and the Evolution of Language. London: Faber and Faber.
Dyson-Hudson, Rada, and Eric A. Smith 1978 Human Territoriality: An Ecological Reassessment. American Anthropologist 80:21–41.
Eibl-Eibesfeldt, Irenäus 1978 Love and Hate: The Natural History of Behavior Patterns. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
1982 Warfare, Man’s Indoctrinability and Group Selection. Zoologische Tierpsychologie 60:177–198.
1989 Human Ethology. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
1996 Reply to Christopher Boehm. Current Anthropology 37:779–780.
Ellis, Lee 1995 Dominance and Reproductive Success among Nonhuman Animals: A Cross-Species Comparison. Ethology and Sociobiology 16:257–333.
Ember, Carol 1978 Myths about Hunter-Gatherers. Ethnology 17:439–448.
Erdal, David, and Andrew Whiten 1994 On Human Egalitarianism: An Evolutionary Product of Machiavellian Status Escalation? Current Anthropology 35:175–178.
1996 Egalitarianism and Machiavellian Intelligence in Human Evolution. In Modelling the Early Human Mind, P. Mellars and K. Gibson, eds. Pp. 139–150. Cambridge: MacDonald Institute for Archaeological Research.
Flanagan, James G. 1989 Hierarchy in Simple "Egalitarian" Societies. Annual Review of Anthropology 18:245–266.
Fox, Robin 1989 The Search for Society: Quest for a Biosocial Science and Morality. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.
Frank, Robert H. 1988 Passions within Reason: The Strategic Role of Emotions. New York: Norton.
Freilich, Morris, Doublas Raybeck, and Joel Savishinsky, eds. 1991 Deviance: Anthropological Perspectives. New York: Bergin and Garvey.
Fried, Morton H. 1967 The Evolution of Political Society: An Essay in Political Anthropology. New York: Random House.
1975 The Notion of Tribe. Menlo Park: Cummings.
Gardner, Peter 1991 Foragers’ Pursuit of Individual Autonomy. Current Anthropology 32:543–558.
Gehlen, A. 1969 Moral und Hypermoral, eine pluralistiche Ethik. Frankfurt.
Goodall, Jane 1986 The Chimpanzees of Gombe. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Goody, Esther 1991 The Learning of Prosocial Behavior in Small-Scale Egalitarian Societies: An Anthropological View. In Cooperation and Prosocial Behavior, R. A. Hinde and J. Grobel, eds. Pp. 106–128. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Gould, Richard A. 1982 To Have and Have Not: The Ecology of Sharing among Hunter-Gatherers. In Resource Managers: North American and Australian Hunter-Gatherers, N. M. Williams and E. S. Hunn, eds. Pp. 69–91. Boulder: Westview.
Haldane, J. B. S. 1932 The Causes of Evolution. London: Longmans Green.
Hamilton, William D. 1964 The Genetical Evolution of Social Behavior, Parts I and II. Journal of Theoretical Biology 7:1–52.
Hart, C., and D. Pilling 1960 The Tiwi of Northern Australia. New York: Holt Rinehart and Winston.
Hawkes, Kristen 1991 Showing Off: Tests of an Hypothesis about Men’s Foraging Goals. Ethology and Sociobiology 12:29–54.
Hayden, B. 1986 Resources, Rivalry, and Reproduction: The Influences of Basic Resource Characteristics on Reproductive Behavior. In Culture and Reproduction: An Anthropological Critique of Demographic Transition Theory, W. Handwerker, ed. Pp. 176–195. Boulder: Westview.
Heintz, H. 1972 Territoriality among the Bushmen in General and the !Ko in Particular. Anthropos 67:405–416.
Hill, Kim, and Hillard Kaplan 1988 Tradeoffs in Male and Female Reproductive Strategies among the Ache, Parts I and II. In Human Behavior: A Darwinian Perspective, L. Betzig et al., eds. Pp. 277–305. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hinde, Robert A., and Jo Groebel, eds. 1991 Cooperation and Prosocial Behavior. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Kano, T. 1992 The Last Ape: Pygmy Chimpanzee Behavior and Ecology. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Kaplan, Hillard 1985 Hunting Ability and Reproductive Success among Male Ache Foragers. Current Anthropology 26:131–155.
Keeley, Lawrence H. 1996 War before Civilization: The Myth of the Peaceful Savage. New York: Oxford.
Kelly, Raymond 1985 The Nuer Conquest: The Structure and Content of an Expansionist System. Ann Arbor: University of Michican Press.
Kelly, Robert L. 1995 The Foraging Spectrum: Diversity in Hunter-Gatherer Lifeways. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution Press.
Knauft, Bruce B. 1991 Violence and Sociality in Human Evolution. Current Anthropology 32:391–428.
1994 Reply to Erdal and Whiten. Current Anthropology 35:181–182.
Kummer, Hans 1971 Primate Societies: Group Techniques of Ecological Adaptation. Chicago: Aldine.
Laughlin, Charles D., and Ivan A. Brady, eds. 1978 Extinction and Survival in Human Populations. New York: Columbia University Press.
Leacock, Eleanor 1969 The Montagnais-Naskapi Band. In Contributions to Anthropology: Band Societies, D. Damas, ed. Pp. 1–17. National Museum of Canada Bulletin 228. Ottawa.
Lee, Richard B. 1979 The !Kung San: Men, Women, and Work in a Foraging Society. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
LeVine, Robert A., and Donald T. Campbell 1971 Ethnocentrism: Theories of Conflict, Ethnic Attitudes, and Group Behavior. Wiley, New York.
Manson, Joseph H., and Richard W. Wrangham 1991 Intergroup Aggression in Chimpanzees and Humans. Current Anthropology 32:369–390.
Masters, Roger 1989 The Nature of Politics. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Meggitt, Mervyn 1977 Blood Is Their Argument. Mayfield, Palo Alto.
Middleton, John, and David Tait, eds. 1958 Tribes without Rulers: Studies in African Segmentary Systems. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Mithen, Steven J. 1989 Modeling Hunter-Gatherer Decision Making: Complementing Optimal Foraging Theory. Human Ecology 17:59–83.
1990 Thoughtful Foragers: A Study of Prehistoric Decision Making. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Nishida, Toshisada 1979 The Social Structure of Chimpanzees of the Mahale Mountains. In The Great Apes, D. A. Hamburg and E. R. McCown, eds. Pp. 73–122. Menlo Park: Benjamin/Cummings.
Palmer, Craig T., B. Eric Fredrickson, and Christopher F. Tilley 1998 Categories and Gatherings: Group Selection and the Mythology of Cultural Anthropology. Ethology and Sociobiology 18:291–308.
Peterson, Nicolas 1993 Demand Sharing: Reciprocity and the Pressure for Generosity among Foragers. American Anthropologist 95:860–874.
Piers, Gerhart, and Milton B. Singer 1971 Shame and Guilt. New York: Norton.
Pitt, Roger 1978 Warfare and Hominid Brain Evolution. Journal of Theoretical Biology 72:551–575.
Potts, Rick 1996 Humanity’s Descent: The Consequences of Ecological Instability. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
1998 Variability Selection in Hominid Evolution. Evolutionary Anthropology 7:81–96.
Ridley, Matt 1996 The Origins of Virtue: Human Instincts and the Evolution of Cooperation. New York: Penguin.
Rosman, Abraham, and Paula G. Rubel 1986 Feasting with Mine Enemy: Rank and Exchange among Northwest Coast Societies. Prospect Heights, Illinois: Waveland.
Sahlins, Marshall 1961 The Segmentary Lineage: Instrument of Predatory Expansion. American Anthropologist 63:322–345.
Service, Elman R. 1962 Primitive Social Organization: An Evolutionary Perspective. New York: Random House.
1971 Cultural Evolutionism: Theory in Practice. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
1975 Origin of the State and Civilization: The Process of Cultural Evolution. New York: Norton.
Silk, Joan 1990 Human Adoption in Evolutionary Perspective. Human Nature 1:25–52.
Simon, Herbert 1983 Reason and Human Affairs. Palo Alto: Stanford University Press.
1990 A Mechanism for Social Selection and Successful Altruism. Science 250: 1665–1668.
Smith, Eric Alden 1987 Optimization Theory in Anthropology: Applications and Critiques. In The Latest on the Best: Essays on Evolution and Optimality, J. Dupre, ed. Pp. 201–249. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
1988 Risk and Uncertainty in the “Original Affluent Society”: Evolutionary Ecology of Resource Sharing and Land Tenure. In Hunters and Gatherers, Vol. I: History, Evolution, and Social Change, T. Ingold, D. Riches, and J. Woodburn, eds. Pp. 221–251. Oxford: Berg.
1991 Inujjuamiut Foraging Strategies. Hawthorne, New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
Smith, Eric Alden, and Robert Boyd 1990 Risk and Reciprocity: Hunter-Gatherer Socioecology and the Problem of Collective Action. In Risk and Uncertainty in Tribal and Peasant Economies, Elizabeth A. Cashdan, ed. Pp. 167–192. Boulder: Westview.
Sober, Elliott, and David S. Wilson 1998 Unto Others: The Evolution and Psychology of Unselfish Behavior. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Soltis, Joseph, Robert Boyd, and Peter J. Richerson 1995 Can Group-Functional Behaviors Evolve by Cultural Group Selection? An Empirical Test. Current Anthropology 36:473–494.
Sorokin, Ptirim 1942 Man and Society in Calamity. New York: Dutton.
Stanford, Craig 1998 Chimpanzee and Colobus: A Study in Primate Predator-Prey Ecology. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Tattersall, Ian 1999 Becoming Human: Evolution and Human Uniqueness. San Diego: Harvest Books.
Thomas, Elizabeth Marshall 1958 The Harmless People. New York: Vintage.
Tiger, Lionel 1969 Men in Groups. New York: Random House.
Tiger, Lionel, and Robin Fox 1971 The Imperial Animal. Delta, New York.
Tooby, John, and Leda Cosmides 1992 The Psychological Foundations of Culture. In The Adapted Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and the Generation of Culture, J. H. Barkow, L. Cosmides, and J. Tooby, eds. Pp. 19–136. New York: Oxford University Press.
Trivers, Robert L. 1971 The Evolution of Reciprocal Altruism. Quarterly Review of Biology 46:35–57.
1972 Parental Investment and Sexual Selection. In Sexual Selection and the Descent of Man, 1871–1971, B. G. Campbell, ed. Pp. 136–179. Chicago: Aldine.
Turnbull, Colin 1972 The Mountain People. New York: Simon and Schuster.
Turton, David 1977 War, Peace, and Mursi Identity. In Warfare among East African Herders, K. Fukui and D. Turton, eds. Pp. 179–210. Osaka: National Museum of Ethnology.
Van de Velde, Franz 1956 Les regles du partage des phoques pris par la chasse aux aglus. Anthropologica 3:5–15.
Vehrencamp, Sandra L. 1983 A Model for the Evolution of Despotic versus Egalitarian Societies. Animal Behavior 31:667–682.
von Fürer-Haimendorf, Christoph 1967 Morals and Merit: A Study of Values and Social Controls in South Asian Societies. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Waddington, C. H. 1960 The Ethical Animal. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Wade, Michael J. 1978 A Critical Review of the Models of Group Selection. Quarterly Review of Biology 53:101–114.
Weatherford, Jack M. 1988 Indian Givers: How the Indians of the Americas Transformed the World. New York: Crown.
Wiessner, Polly 1982 Risk, Reciprocity and Social Influences on !Kung San Economics. In Politics and History in Band Societies, E. Leacock and R. B. Lee, eds. Pp. 61–84. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
1996 Leveling the Hunter: Constraints on the Status Quest in Foraging Societies. In Food and the Status Quest: An Interdisciplinary Perspective, P. Wiessner and W. Schiefenhovel, eds. Pp 171–191. Oxford: Berghahn.
Williams, George C. 1966 Adaptation and Natural Selection: A Critique of Some Current Evolutionary Thought. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Wilmsen, E. N. 1973 Interaction, Spacing Behavior, and the Organization of Hunting Bands. Journal of Anthropological Research 29:1–31.
Wilson, David S. 1975 A General Theory of Group Selection. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 72:143–146.
1977 Structured Demes and the Evolution of Group-Advantageous Traits. American Naturalist 111:157–185.
1980 The Natural Selection of Populations and Communities. Menlo Park: Cummings.
1983 The Group Selection Controversy: History and Current Status. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 14:159–187.
1989 Levels of Selection: An Alternative to Individualism in Biology and the Social Sciences. Social Networks 11:257–272.
1992 Complex Interactions in Metacommunities, with Implications for Bio-diversity and Higher Levels of Selection. Ecology 73:1984–2000.
1997 Incorporating Group Selection into the Adaptationist Program: A Case Study Involving Human Decision Making. In Evolutionary Approaches to Personality and Social Psychology, J. Simpson and D. Kendrick, eds. Pp. 345–386. Hillsdale, New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Wilson, David S., and Elliott Sober 1994 Reintroducing Group Selection to the Human Behavioral Sciences. Behavior and Brain Sciences 17:585–654.
Wilson, Edward O. 1975 Sociobiology: The New Synthesis. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
1978 On Human Nature. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Wilson, James Q. 1993 The Moral Sense. New York: Free Press
Winterhalter, Bruce 1986 Diet Choice, Risk, and Food Sharing in a Stochastic Environment. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 5:369–392.
1987 The Analysis of Hunter-Gatherer Diets: Stalking an Optimal Foraging Model. In Food and Evolution, M. Harris and E. Ross, eds. Pp. 311–339. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
Woodburn, James 1982 Egalitarian Societies. Man 17:431–451.
Wrangham, Richard 1999 Is Military Competence Adaptive? Evolution and Human Behavior 20:3–18.
Wrangham, Richard, and Dale Peterson 1996 Demonic Males: Apes and the Origins of Human Violence. Boston: Houghton-Mifflin.
Wright, Robert 1994 The Moral Animal. New York: Pantheon.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
This paper (in a series of drafts) has profited from comments by Michael Boehm, Donald T. Campbell, Bruce Knauft, Jane Lancaster, Martin Muller, Peter J. Richerson, Gary Seaman, Craig Stanford, George Williams, Edward O. Wilson, David Sloan Wilson, and two reviewers for Human Nature.
Christopher Boehm is a professor of anthropology and the director of the Jane Goodall Research Center, University of Southern California. His research interests in political anthropology concern egalitarianism, feuding, warfare, and conflict resolution (humans and chimpanzees). In biosocial anthropology he is interested in altruism, group selection, and decisions.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Boehm, C. The natural selection of altruistic traits. Hum Nat 10, 205–252 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12110-999-1003-z
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12110-999-1003-z