Abstract
This paper examines the relationship between North American beef consumption and deforestation in South and Central America. Some writers have argued that consumption of hamburgers in North America, particularly hamburgers consumed in fast food restaurants, contributes to the depletion of the rainforest in South and Central America. We survey the published policy literature on the causes of rainforest depletion in the region. We also review the published estimates of the rate and extent of clearing of rainforest that has occurred in South and Central America since 1970. Finally, we review the data on beef imports and consumption in Canada and the United States in a effort to assess the importance of South and Central America as suppliers of beef to the North American market. We conclude that the relationship between beef consumption in North America should not be considered an important cause of forest depletion in South and Central America. Domestic policies and market forces in the countries where rainforests are located are the leading causes of rainforest depletion in this region. This lesson seems to have been lost on some popular and even some textbook writers on this subject.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Allen, J. and D. Barnes, "The Causes of Deforestation in Developing Countries," Annals of the Association of American Geographers75(2) (1985), 161–184.
Barbier, E., N. Bockstael, J. Burgess and I. Strand, "Timber Trade and Tropical Deforestation–Indonesia," Annex! Of E. Barbier, J. Burgess, J. Bishop, B. Aylward and C. Bann. 1993. The Economic Linkages Between the International Trade in Tropical Timber and the Sustainable Management of Tropical Forests. Report prepared for the International Tropical Timber Organization by the London Environmental Economics Centre, London, 1990.
Binswanger, Hans P., Fiscal and Legal Incentives with Environmental Effects on the Brazilian Amazon, Unpublished discussion paper, Agriculture and Rural Development Department, World Bank. Washington, D.C., May 1987.
Binswanger, Hans P., "Brazilian Policies that Encourage Deforestation in the Amazon," World Development19(70) (1991), 821–29.
Browder, J., "Public Policy and Deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon," in Repetto and Gillis (eds.) (1988), 247–297.
Brown, S. and A.E. Lugo, "Aboveground Biomass Estimates for Tropical Moist Forests of the Brazilian Amazon," Intercienic17(1) (1992, Jan–Feb), 8–18.
Brown, S. and A.E. Lugo, "Biomass of Brazilian Amazonian Forests: The Need for Good Science," Interciencia17(4) (1992, Jul–Aug), 201–203.
Burgress, J., "Timber Production, Timber Trade and Tropical Deforestation," Ambio22(2–3) (1993), 136–143.
Buschbacher, R., "Tropical Deforestation and Pasture Development," Bioscience36(1) (1986), 22–28.
Buschbacher, R., "Deforestation for Sovereignty over Remote Frontiers," Amazonia Rainforests: Ecosystem Disturbance and Recovery(New York: Springer-Verlag, 1987).
Buschbacker, R., C. Uhl and E.A.S. Serrao, "Forest Development Following Pasture Use in the North of Para, Brazil," Proc. First Symposium on the Humid Tropics. Expresa Brasileira de Pesquisa Agropecuaria, Belem, Para, Brazil (1984).
Capistrano, A. and C. Kiker, Global Economic Influences on Tropical Closed Broadleaved Forest Depletion, 1967–1985(Food Resources Economics Department, University of Florida, 1990).
Dunlop, S., Towards Tomorrow: Canada in a Changing World Geography(Toronto: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich).
Faminow,., "Spatial Economics of Local Demand for Cattle Products in Amazon Development," Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment(In Press).
Faminow, M., "The Disappearing Amazon Rainforest Problem," Newsletter of the International Association of Agricultural Economists–Canadian Council(1996, August).
Fearnside, Philip M., "Deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon: How Fast is it Occurring?" Interciencia7(2) (1982, Mar–Apr), 82–88.
Fearnside, P., "The Causes of Deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon," paper presented at the United Nations University. International Conference on Climatic, Biotic and Human Interactions in the Humid Tropics: Vegetation and Climatic Interactions in the Amazona. February 25–March 1. Sao Paulo. Sao Jose dos Campos (1985).
Fearnside, P., "Brazil’s Amazon Forest and the Global Carbon Problem," Interciencia10(4) (1985, Jul–Aug), 179–186.
Fearnside, P., "Spatial Concentration of Deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon," Ambio 15(2) (1986), 74—81.
Fearnside, P., "Causes of Deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon," in Robert Dickinson (ed.), The Geophysiology of Amazonia: Vegetation and Climate Interactions(New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1987).
Fearnside, P., "Forest Biomass in Brazilian Amazonia: Comments on the Estimate By Brown and Lugo," in Robert Dickinson (ed.) (New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1992), 19–27.
Fearnside, P., "Rebuttal to the Lugo Brown Critique of Deforestation of the Amazon," Interciencia7(6) (1992, Nov–Dec), 362.
Fearnside, P., "Biomass of Brazil’s Amazonian Forests: Reply to Brown and Lugo Revisited," Interciencia18(1) (1993), Jan–Feb), 5–7.
Fearnside, P., "Deforestation in Brazilian Amazonian: The Effect of Population and Land Tenure," Ambio22(8) (1993), 535–545.
Food and Agricultural Organisation, F.A.O. Yearbook: Forest Products(Rome: Various issues).
Food and Agricultural Organisation, F.A.O. Yearbook: Production(Rome: Various issues).
Hecht, S., "The Logic of Livestock and Deforestation in Amazona," Bioscience43(10) (1993), 687–695.
Hecht, S., R. Norgaard and G. Possion, The Economics of Cattle Ranching in Eastern Amazona(Graduate School of Architecture and Urban Planning, University of California at Los angeles, n.d.).
Hecht, S. and A. Cockburn, The Fate of the Forest(London, New York: Verso, 1989).
International Monetary Fund, International Financial Statistics Yearbook(Washington D.C., 1993).
Jackstadt, S. and M. Sanera, "Environmental Education: Turning Kids Into Political Activists," The Freeman45(10) (1995), 645–649.
Janzen, D.H., "Buy Costa Rican Beef," Oikos51(3) (1988), 257–258.
Jordan, C., "Shifting Cultivation, Case Study No. 1: Slash and Burn Agriculture Near San Carlos, De Rio Negro, Venezuela, Amazon Rainforest: Ecosystem Disturbance and Recovery(New York: Springer-Verlag, 1987).
Lewis, S., The Hamburger Connection Revisited: The Status of Tropical Deforestation and Conservation in Central America and Southern Mexico(San Francisco: Rain Forest Action Network, 1991).
London, H., "Why Are They Lying to Our Children?" (London: Stein and Day, 1984).
Lugo, Ariel E. and Sandra Brown, "Deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon," Interciencia 7(6) (1982, Nov–Dec), 361–362.
Lugo, A.E. and S. Brown, "Brazil’s Amazon Forest and the Global Carbon Problem," Letters to the editor. Interciencia11(2) (1996, Mar–Apr), 57–58, and see the reply from Fearnside, 58–64.
Mahar, D., Government Policies and Deforestation in Brazil’s Amazon Region(Washington, D.C.: The World Bank, 1989).
Mahar, D., "Deforestation in Brazil’s Amazon Region: Magnitude, Rate and Causes," in G. Schrammand J. Warford (eds.), EnvironmentalManagement and EconomicDevelopment (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1989).
Mattos, M. and C. Uhl, "Economic and Ecological Perspectives on Ranching in the Eastern Amazon," World Development22(2) (1996), 145–158.
Myers, N., The Sinking Ark(New York: Pergamon, 1979).
Myers, N., Conversion of Tropical Moist Forests(Washington D.C.: National Academy of Sciences, 1980).
Myers, N., "The Hamburger Connection: How Central America’s Forests Became North America’s Hamburgers," Ambio10(1) (1981), 3–8.
Nigh, R. and J. Nations, "Tropical Rainforests," Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists36(3) (1980), 12–19.
Palo, M., G. Mery and J. Salmi, "Deforestation in the Tropics: Pilot Scenarios Based on Quantitative Analysis," in M. Palo and J. Salmi (eds.), Deforestation or Development in the Third World(Helsinki: Division of Social and Economic Forestry, Finnish Forest Research Institute, 1987).
Parsons, S., "Forest to Pasture: Development or Destruction?," Biol. Trop.24 (1976), 121–138.
Pingali, P., Y. Bigot, and H. Binswanger, Agricultural Mechanization and the Evolution of Farming Systems in Sub-Sahara Africa(Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press, 1987).
Poore, P. "Enviroeducation: Is it Science, Civics or Propaganda?," Garbage(1993, April/May), 26–31.
Repetto, R. and M. Gillis (eds), Public Policies and the Misuse of Forest Resources (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988).
Repetto, R., "Creating Incentives for Sustainable Development," Ambio16(2–3) (1987), 94–99.
Repetto, R., "Overview," in Repetto and Gillis (eds.) (1988a), 1–41.
Repetto, R., The Forest for the Trees? Government Policies and the Misuse of Forest Resources(Washington, D.C.: World Resources Institute, 1988b).
Repetto, R., "Deforestation in the Tropics," Scientific American262(4) (1990) 36–42.
Rifkin, J., Beyond Beef: The Rise and Fall of the Cattle Culture(New York: A Dulton Book, 1992).
Schneider, R., J. McKenna, C. Dejou, J. Butler and J. Barrows. Brazil: An Economic Analysis of Environmental Problems in the Amazon(Washington, D.C.: World Bank, 1990).
Seaborne, A. and D. Evans, Canada and Its Pacific Neighbours(Edmonton: Weigl Educational Publishers, 1988).
Simon, J., "Disappearing Species, Deforestation and Data", in Jay H. Lehr Rational Readings on Environmental Concerns(New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold, 1992).
Statistics Canada, External Trade Division. Imports by Country of Origin(Ottawa Various issues).
Uhl, C. and R. Buschbacher, "A Disturbing Synergism between Cattle Ranch Burning Practices and Selective Tree Harvesting in the Eastern Amazon," Biotropica17 1985, 265–268.
U.S. Executive Office of the President and Council on Environmental Quality, Global 2000 Report to the President. Technical Report. Vol. 2. Washington D.C.
U.S. Department of Agriculture, Foreign Agricultural Service. Dairy, Livestock and Poultry Trade(Washington D.C. Various issues).
Vanclay, J., "Saving the Tropical Forest: Needs and Prognosis," Ambio22(4) 225–231.
Yokomizo, C., "Financial and Fiscal Incentives in the Amazon: Facts, Problems and Solutions," in Amazonia: Facts, Problems and Solutions, July 31–August 2 (Brazil: University of Sao Paulo, SP, 1989).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bonti-Ankomah, S., Fox, G. Hamburgers and the Rainforest – a Review of Issues and Evidence. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 10, 153–182 (1997). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1007788803086
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1007788803086