A man who is awake in the open field at night, or who wanders over silent paths, experiences the world differently than by day. Nighness vanishes, and with it distance; everything is equally far and near, close by us and yet mysteriously remote. Space loses its measures. There are whispers and sounds and we do not know where or what they are…. There is no longer a distinction between what is lifeless and living; everything is animate and soulless, vigilant and asleep at once.
Walter F. Otto [1, pp. 118–119].
Abstract
This article applies the anthropological concept of liminality to reconceptualize palliative care ethics. Liminality possesses both spatial and temporal dimensions. Both these aspects are analyzed to provide insight into the intersubjective relationship between patient and caregiver in the context of palliative care. Aristotelian practical wisdom, or phronesis, is considered to be the appropriate model for palliative care ethics, provided it is able to account for liminality. Moreover, this article argues for the importance of liminality for providing an ethical structure that grounds the doctrine of double effect and overcomes the impasse of phronesis in the treatment of the terminally ill.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Even though liminality generally refers to a social structure characterizing pre-industrial societies, the related concepts of liminality and communitas apply so readily to the hospice and palliative care contexts because they resuscitate a pre-modern form of care. Turner was aware of the problem of applying concepts derived from the study of traditional societies to modern post-industrial society. He distinguished, therefore, between “liminal” for less complex societies and “liminoid” for modern symbolic inversions and expressions of disorder. See, for example, Turner [15].
References
Otto, W.F. 1955. The Homeric gods: The spiritual significance of Greek religion (trans: Hadas, M.). London: Thames and Hudson.
Clark, D. 1999. ‘Total pain’, disciplinary power and the body in the work of Cicely Saunders, 1958–1967. Social Science and Medicine 49: 727–736.
Hamilton, J. 1995. Dr. Balfour mount and the cruel irony of our care for the dying. Canadian Medical Association Journal 153(3): 334–336.
Kleinman, A. 2008. Catastrophe and caregiving: The failure of medicine as an art. The Lancet 371(9606): 22–23.
World Health Organization. 2011. Definition of palliative care. http://www.who.int/cancer/palliative/definition/en/. Accessed November 16, 2011.
Randall, F., and R.S. Downie. 1999. Palliative care ethics: A companion for all specialties. 2nd ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
ten Have, H., and D. Clark, eds. 2002. The ethics of palliative care: European perspectives. Buckingham, Philadelphia: Open University Press.
Fins, J.J. 2005. A palliative ethics of care: Clinical wisdom at life’s end. Sudbury, MA: Jones and Bartlett.
Cimino, J.E. 2003. A clinician’s understanding of ethics in palliative care. Critical Reviews in Oncology/Hematology 46: 7–24.
Pellegrino, E. 1998. Emerging ethical issues in palliative care. Journal of Medical Association 279(19): 1521–1522.
Frank, A.W. 2004. Dignity, dialogue, and care. Journal of Palliative Care 20(3): 207–211.
van Gennep, A. 1960 [1919]. The rites of passage. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Leech, E. 1976. Culture and communication. London, New York, Melbourne: Cambridge University Press.
Turner, V.W. 1967. The forest of symbols: Aspects of Ndembu ritual. London: Cornell University Press.
Turner, V.W. 1969. The ritual process. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
Turner, V.W. 1974. Dramas, fields and metaphors: Symbolic action in human society. New York: Cornell University Press.
Turner, V.W. 1977. Variations on a theme of liminality. In Secular ritual, ed. S.F. Moore, and S.G. Myeroff, 36–52. Assen and Amsterdam: Van Gorcum.
Turner, V.W. 1982. From ritual to theatre: The human seriousness of play. New York: PAJ.
Frankenberg, R. 1986. Sickness as cultural performance: Drama, trajectory, and pilgrimage. Root metaphors and the making social of disease. International Journal of Health Services 16(4): 603–626.
Little, M., F.C. Jordens, K. Paul, K. Montgomery, and B. Philippson. 1998. Liminality: A major category of the experience of cancer illness. Social Science and Medicine 47(10): 1485–1494.
Sibbett, C. 2004. Liminality: Living and practicing at the threshold. Paper presented at the 3rd global conference of Making Sense Of: Health, Illness and Disease, St. Catherine’s College, Oxford. http://www.inter-disciplinary.net/ptb/mso/hid/hid3/sibbett%20paper.pdf.
Frank, A. 1995. The wounded storyteller: Body, illness, and ethics. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Froggatt, K. 1997. Rites of passage and the hospice culture. Mortality 2(2): 123–136.
Wood, D. 2002. Thinking after Heidegger. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Pellegrino, E., and D.C. Thomasma. 1993. The virtues in medical practice. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Aristotle. 1962. Nicomachean ethics (trans: Ostwald, M.). Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Battin, M.P. 2010. The irony of supporting physician-assisted suicide: A personal account. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 13: 403–411.
Toulmin, S. 2001. Return to reason. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Clark, D. 2002. Between hope and acceptance: The medicalisation of dying. British Medical Journal 324: 905–907.
Graham, F., and D. Clark. 2005. The syringe driver and the subcutaneous route in palliative care: The inventor, the history and the implications. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 29(1): 32–40.
Brennan, F. 2007. Palliative care as an international human right. Journal of Pain Symptom Management 33(5): 494–499.
Gwyther, L., F. Brennan, and R. Harding. 2009. Advancing palliative care as a human right. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 38(5): 767–774.
Roy, D.R. 2005. Palliative care without borders. Journal of Palliative Care 21(3): 131–132.
Levinas, E. 1978. Otherwise than being or beyond essence (trans: Lingis, A.). Dordrecht and Boston: Kluwer.
Clarke, V., and L.F. Holtslander. 2010. Finding a balanced approach: Incorporating medicine wheel teachings in the care of aboriginal people at the end of life. Journal of Palliative Care 26(1): 34–36.
McGrath, P. 2010. The living model: An Australian model for aboriginal palliative care service delivery with international implications. Journal of Palliative Care 26(1): 59–64.
McCullough, L.M. 2010. La frontera: Responsibly managing borders and boundaries in clinical ethics. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 35: 106.
Frank, A.W. 2004. The renewal of generosity: Illness, medicine, and how to live. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Zahavi, D. 2010. Inner (time-)consciousness. In On time: New contributions to the Husserlian phenomenology of time, ed. D. Lohmar and I. Yamaguchi, 319–339. New York: Springer.
Enck, R.E. 1991. Drug-induced terminal sedation for symptom control. American Journal of Hospice and Palliative Care 8: 3–5.
Broeckaert, B., and J.M.N. Olarte. 2002. Sedation in palliative care: Facts and concepts. In The ethics of palliative care: European perspectives, ed. H. ten Have and D. Clark, 166–180. Philadelphia: Open University Press.
Krakauer, E.L., R.T. Penson, R.D. Truog, L.A. King, B.A. Chabner, and T.J. Lynch Jr. 2000. Sedation for intractable distress of a dying patient: Acute palliative care and the principle of double effect. The Oncologist 5: 53–62.
Sulmasy, D., and E. Pellegrino. 1999. The rule of double effect: Clearing up the double talk. Archives of Internal Medicine 159: 545–550.
Mangan, J. 1949. An historical analysis of the principle of double effect. Theological Studies 10: 41–61.
Boyle, J. 1991. Who is entitled to double effect? The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 16: 475–494.
Paul, J. II. 1995. The gospel of life. New York: Random House.
Hawryluck, L.A., and W.R.C. Harvey. 2000. Analgesia, virtue, and the principle of double effect. Journal of Palliative Care 16: S24–S30.
Foot, P. 1978. Virtues and vices and other essays in moral philosophy. Berkeley and Los Angeles: The University of California Press.
Quill, T.E., R. Dresser, and D.W. Brock. 1997. The rule of double effect: A critique of its role in end-of-life decision making. New England Journal of Medicine 337: 1768–1771.
Jansen, L.A. 2010. Disambiguating clinical intentions: The ethics of palliative sedation. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 35: 19–31.
Jansen, L.A. 2003. The moral irrelevance of proximity to death. Journal of Clinical Ethics 14(1–2): 49–58.
Carruthers, M. 2008. The book of memory: A study of memory in medieval culture. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge.
Levinas, E. 1987. Time and the other. Pittsburgh, PA: Duquesne University Press.
Carnavale, F. 2007. The birth of tragedy in pediatrics: A phronetic conception of bioethics. Nursing Ethics 14(5): 571–581.
Miller, F.G., R.D. Truog, and D.W. Brock. 2010. Moral fictions and medical ethics. Bioethics 24(9): 453–460.
Acknowledgments
I would like to thank palliative care physician Martin Chasen for the invitation to present an early version of this paper at the 18th International Congress on Palliative Care, and Matthew Hunt for his valuable comments.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Braude, H. Normativity unbound: Liminality in palliative care ethics. Theor Med Bioeth 33, 107–122 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11017-011-9200-2
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11017-011-9200-2