Abstract
This paper presents a comprehensive pragmatic theory ofcontrastive topic and its relation to focus in English.In discussing various constructions involving contrastive topics,it argues that they make reference to complex, hierarchicalaspects of discourse structure. In this, it follows and spellsout a proposal sketched in Roberts (1996, p. 121ff),using the formal tools found in Büring (1994,1997b). It improves on existing accounts in the accuracy with which it predicts the non-occurrence of the accent patterns associated with focus and contrastive topic, and locates the analysis of contrastive topicswithin a broader picture of discourse and information structure.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Bosch, Peter and Rob van der Sandt: 1994, Focus and Natural Language Processing, 3 Volumes, IBM Deutschland GmbH.
Bosch, Peter and Rob van der Sandt: 1999, Focus – Linguistic, Cognitive, and Computational Perspectives, Cambridge University Press.
Büring, Daniel: 1994, ‘Topic’, in Peter Bosch and Rob van der Sandt (1994), pp. 271–280 (revised version in Peter Bosch and Rob van der Sandt (1999), pp. 142–165).
Büring, Daniel: 1997a, ‘The Great Scope Inversion Conspiracy’, Linguistics and Philosophy 20, 175–194.
Büring, Daniel: 1997b, The Meaning of Topic and Focus – The 59th Street Bridge Accent, Routledge, London.
Büring, Daniel: 1998, ‘Topic and Focus in a Complex Model of Discourse’, manuscript, Cologne University.
Carlson, Lauri: 1983, Dialog Games – An Approach to Discourse Analysis, Reidel, Dordrecht.
É. Kiss, Katalin: 1998, ‘Scope Inversion in Hungarian’, manuscript.
Gazdar, Gerald: 1979, Pragmatics: Implicature, Presupposition and Logical Form, Academic Press, New York.
Ginzburg, J., Z. Khasidashvili, C. Vogel, J. J. Levy and E. Vallduví, eds.: 1998, The Tbilisi Symposium on Language, Logic, and Computation: Selected Papers, CSLI Publications, Stanford, CA.
Gussenhoven, Carlos: 1983, ‘Focus, Mode, and the Nucleus’, Journal of Linguistics 19, 377–417. Reprinted as Chapter 1 in C. Gussenhoven (1984).
Gussenhoven, Carlos: 1984, On the Grammar and Semantics of Sentence Accents, Foris, Dordrecht.
Gussenhoven, Carlos: 1999, ‘On the Limits of Focus Projection in English’, in Peter Bosch and Rob van der Sandt (1999), pp. 43–55.
Jackendoff, Ray: 1972, Semantics in Generative Grammar, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Jacobs, Joachim: 1991/2a, Informationsstruktur und Grammatik, Westdeutscher Verlag, Opladen (= Linguistische Berichte Sonderheft 4).
Jacobs, Joachim: 1991/2b, ‘Neutral Stress and the Position of Heads’, in Joachim Jacobs (1991/2a), pp. 220–244.
Jacobs, Joachim: 1992, Integration, Technical Report 14, SFB 282, Köln &; Wuppertal, Düsseldorf.
Jacobs, Joachim: 1997, ‘I-Topikalisierung’, Linguistische Berichte 169, 91–133.
Jacobs, Joachim: 1999, ‘Informational Autonomy’, in Peter Bosch and Rob van der Sandt (1999), pp. 56–81.
Kanerva, Jonni M. and Leslie A. Gabriele: 1996, ‘Intonation and Focus Layers’, in Proceedings of NELS 26, 335–346.
Klein, Wolfgang and Christiane von Sutterheim: 1987, ‘Quaestio und referentielle Bewegung in Erzählungen’, Linguistische Berichte 109, 163–183.
Kratzer, Angelika: 1981, ‘The Notional Category of Modality’, in Hans Jürgen Eikmeyer and Hannes Rieser (eds.), New Approaches in World Semantics, Words, Worlds, and Contexts, Walter de Gruyter, New York/Berlin, pp. 38–74.
Krifka, Manfred: 1991/2, ‘A Compositional Semantics for Multiple Focus Constructions’, in Joachim Jacobs (1991/2a), pp. 17–53.
Krifka, Manfred: 1998, ‘Scope Inversion under the Rise-Fall Pattern in German’, Linguistic Inquiry 29(1), 75–112.
Ladd, Robert D.: 1980, The Structure of Intonational Meaning, Indiana University Press, Bloomington.
Lee, Chungmin: 1999, ‘Contrastive Topic: A Locus of Interface – Evidence from Korean and English’, in Ken Turner (1999), pp. 317–342.
McNally, Louise: 1998, ‘On Recent Formal Analyses of Topic’, in J. Ginzburg et al. (1998), pp. 147–160.
O'Connor, J. D. and G. F. Arnold: 1973, Intonation of Colloquial English, 2nd edn, Longmans, London.
Pierrehumbert, Janet: 1980, The Phonology and Phonetics of English Intonation, Ph.D. thesis, MIT.
Pierrehumbert, Janet and Julia Hirschberg: 1990, ‘The Meaning of Intonational Contours in the Interpretation of Discourse’, in P. Cohen, J. Morgan and M. Pollock (eds.), Intentions in Communications, MIT Press, Cambridge, pp. 271–311.
Reinhart, Tanya: 1982, ‘Pragmatics and Linguistics: An Analysis of Sentence Topics’, Philosophica 27, 53–94.
Roberts, Craige: 1996, ‘Information Structure in Discourse: Towards an Integrated Formal Theory of Pragmatics’, in J. H. Yoon and Andreas Kathol (eds.), OSU Working Papers in Linguistics 49: Papers in Semantics, pp. 91–136.
Rochemont, Michael: 1986, Focus in Generative Grammar, John Benjamins, Amsterdam/Philadelphia.
Rooth, Mats: 1985, Association with Focus, Ph.D. thesis, University of Massachusetts, Amherst.
Rooth, Mats: 1992, ‘A Theory of Focus Interpretation’, Natural Language Semantics 1, 75–116.
Schwarzschild, Roger: 1999, ‘GiVENness, AvoidF and Other Constraints on the Placement of Accent’, Natural Language Semantics 7(2), 141–177.
Selkirk, Elisabeth: 1984, Phonology and Syntax: The Relation between Sound and Structure, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Selkirk, Elisabeth: 1995, ‘Sentence Prosody: Intonation, Stress, and Phrasing’, in John A. Goldsmith (ed.), The Handbook of Phonological Theory, Blackwell, London, pp. 550–569.
Stalnaker, Robert C.: 1978, ‘Assertion’, in Peter Cole (ed.), Pragmatics – Syntax &; Semantics, Vol. 9, Academic Press, New York, pp. 315–332.
Steedman, Mark: 2000, ‘Information Structure and the Syntax-Phonology Interface’, Linguistic Inquiry 31, 649–689.
Turner, Ken, ed.: 1999, The Semantics/Pragmatics Interface from Different Points of View, Elsevier.
Uechi, Akihiko: 1996, ‘The Discourse Function of Wa-Marking in Japanese’, in Proceedings of NELS 12, No. 14, in the University of Washington Working Papers.
Vallduví, Enric: 1990, The Informational Component, Ph.D. thesis, University of Pennsylvania (published by Garland, 1992).
Vallduví, Enric: 1993, Information Packaging: A Survey, Technical Report, Edinburgh.
Vallduví, Enric and Elisabeth Engdahl: 1996, ‘The Linguistic Realization of Information Packaging’, Linguistics 34, 459–519.
van Kuppevelt, Jan: 1991, Topic en Comment: Expliciete en Impliciete Vraagstellingen in Discourse, Ph.D. thesis, University of Nijmegen.
van Kuppevelt, Jan: 1995, ‘Discourse Structure, Topicality and Questioning’, Linguistics 31, 109–147.
van Kuppevelt, Jan: 1996a, ‘Directionality in Discourse: Prominence Differences in Subordination Relations’, Journal of Semantics 13, 363–395.
van Kuppevelt, Jan: 1996b, Inferring from Topics’, Linguistics and Philosophy 19, 393–443.
von Stechow, Arnim: 1989, Focusing and Backgrounding Operators, Technical Report 6, Fachgruppe Sprachwissenschaft, Universität Konstanz.
Williams, Edwin: 1997, ‘Blocking and Anaphora’, Linguistics Inquiry 28, 577–628.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Büring, D. On D-Trees, Beans, And B-Accents. Linguistics and Philosophy 26, 511–545 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1025887707652
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1025887707652