Abstract
While electronic mail has enjoyed rapid growth in the workplace, many companies have failed to establish clear expectations among employees about their e-mail privacy rights. This has resulted in controversy and even lawsuits against employers where employees later learned that management personnel monitored or read their electronic communications. It has been speculated that most employees underestimate the legal right of their employer to engage in e-mail monitoring activities. However, this issue has been virtually unexplored from a research perspective. Consequently, the purpose of this study is to assess individuals' ethical beliefs and perceptions about electronic mail privacy. This study of more than 200 e-mail users reveals that there is significant resistance to e-mail monitoring, and that many individuals have a relatively poor understanding of their e-mail privacy rights. The results also suggest that companies need to develop and communicate a policy to employees that addresses this issue. Finally, this study suggests several possibilities for further research. Building a greater body of knowledge of this domain should assist business leaders and lawmakers as they work to formulate an effective response to this workplace challenge that will equitably balance the rights of employees and employers.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anonymous: 1991, ‘Addressing the New Hazards of the High Technology Workplace’,Harvard Law Review, 1898–1916.
Cappel, J. J.: 1993, ‘Closing the E-Mail Privacy Gap’,Journal of Systems Management, Dec., 6–11.
Casarez, N. B.: 1992, ‘Electronic Mail and Employee Relations: Why Privacy Must Be Considered’,Public Relations Quarterly, 37–40.
Computerworld: 1992, (Nov. 23), ‘Unsavory Choices’, 87.
Danca, R. A.: 1993, ‘From A to Z: Privacy Policies Run the Gamut’,PC Week, June 28, 208.
Elmer-Dewitt, P.: 1993, ‘Who's Reading Your Screen?’Time, Jan. 18, 46.
Johnson, D. R. and J. Podesta: 1991,Access to and Use and Disclosure of Electronic Mail on Company Computer Systems: A Tool Kit for Formulating Your Company's Policy (Electronic Mail Association, Arlington, VA).
Nimmer, R. T.: 1991,The Law of Computer Technology (Warren, Gorham & LaMont: New York).
O'Brien, T.: 1992, ‘E-Mail to be Foundation of New Information Highway’,Network World, May 25, 23–24.
Smith, L. B.: 1993a, ‘Electronic Monitoring Raises Legal and Societal Questions’,PC Week, June 28, 204.
Smith, L. B.: 1993b, ‘Privacy Issue Comes of Age in the Networked World’PC Week, June 28, 202–203.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
James J. Cappel is a Doctoral candidate and Teaching Fellow in Business Computer Information Systems. He has published six articles in refereed journals in the United States and Great Britain, including a recent article in theJournal of Systems Management. His research interests include human-computer interaction and legal and ethical issues in information systems.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cappel, J.J. A study of individuals' ethical beliefs and perceptions of electronic mail privacy. J Bus Ethics 14, 819–827 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00872348
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00872348