Abstract
No evidence exists that the accidental origin of life is too improbable to have occurred naturally, but there are numerous attempts to argue so. Dizzying statistics are cited to show that a god had to be responsible. This paper identifies the Argument from Biogenesis, then explains why all these arguments so far fail, and what would actually have to be done to make such an argument succeed. Describes seven general types of error, with examples. Includes a table of forty-seven statistics used by over twenty authors to date.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
J. Barrow F. Tipler (1986) The Anthropic Cosmological Principle Oxford University Press New York
B.L. Bass T.R. Cech (1984) ArticleTitleSpecific Interaction Between Self-Splicing of RNA of Tetrahymena and Its Guanosine Substrate Nature 308 820
M. Baudin (1962) Probabilities and Life Dover New York
W.A. Bonner (1995) ArticleTitleChirality and Life Origins of Life and Evolution of the Biosphere 25 IssueID1–3 175–190
E. Borel (1943) Les Probabilites et la Vie Presses Universitaires de France Paris
A. Brack (Eds) (1998) The Molecular Origins of Life: Assembling Pieces of the Puzzle Cambridge University Press Cambridge
W. Bradley C. Thaxton R. Olsen (1984) The Mystery of Life’s Origin: Reassessing Current Theories Philosophical Library New York
W. Bradley C. Thaxton (1994) Information Theory and the Origin of Life J.P. Moreland (Eds) The Creation Hypothesis: Scientific Evidence for an Intelligent Designer InterVarsity Press Downer’s Grove, IL 173–234
A.G. Cairns-Smith (1985) Seven Clues to the Origin of Life Cambridge University Press New York
Carrier, R.: 2000 (July/August), ‘Are the Odds Against the Origin of Life Too Great?’, Reports of the National Center for Science Education 20(4), 25–34 (with supplementary material at: http://www.infidels.org/library/modern/richard_carrier/addendaB.html).
T.R. Cech et al. (1981) ArticleTitleIn Vitro Splicing of the Ribosomal RNA Precursor of Tetrahymena Cell 27 487
S. Chandrasekhar (1996) ArticleTitleAuto-catalysis as the Possible Origin of Biomolecular Chirality Current Science 70 IssueID4 259–260
J. Cohen (1995) ArticleTitleGetting All Turned Around Over the Origins of Life Science 267 1265–1266
J. Coppedge (1973) Evolution: Possible or Impossible? Zondervan Grand Rapids
R. Cowen (2001) ArticleTitleLife’s Housing May Come from Space Science News 159 IssueID5 68
Cramer, G.: 1998, ‘The Crutches of Atheism’, in Trinity Consulting (http://www.direct.ca/trinity/crutches.html).
W. Dembski (1998) The Design Inference: Eliminating Chance Through Small Probabilities Cambridge University New York
W. Dembski (2002) No Free Lunch: Why Specified Complexity Cannot Be Purchased without Intelligence Rowman & Littlefield Lanham, MD
M. Eden (1967) Inadequacies of Neo-Darwinian Evolution as a Scientific Theory P. Moorhead M. Kaplan (Eds) Mathematical Challenges to the Neo-Darwinian Interpretation of Evolution: A Symposium Held at the Wistar Institute of Anatomy and Biology April 25 and 26, 1966 Wistar Institute Philadelphia 5–20
T. Fenchel (2003) Origin and Early Evolution of Life Oxford University Press New York
D. Foster (1993) The Philosophical Scientists Barnes & Noble New York
I. Fry (2000) The Emergence of Life on Earth: A Historical and Scientific Overview Rutgers University Press New Brunswick, NJ
A. Goho (2003) ArticleTitleAmino Acid Lends a Heavy Hand Science News 164 IssueID10 157–158
A. Goho (2003) ArticleTitleClays Catalyze Life? Science News 164 IssueID18 285
M. Golay (1961) ArticleTitleReflections of a Communications Engineer Analytical Chemistry 33 IssueID7 23A
J.M. Greenberg et al. (1994) ArticleTitleInterstellar Dust, Chirality, Comets and the Origins of Life -Life from Dead Stars Journal of Biological Physics 20 IssueID1–4 61–70
Y. He F. Qi S. Qi (1998) ArticleTitleEffect of Chiral Helical Force Field on Molecular Helical Enantiomers and Possible Origin of Biomolecular Homochirality Medical Hypotheses 51 IssueID2 125–128
T. Hesman (2000) ArticleTitleCode Breakers: Scientists are Altering Bacteria in a Most Fundamental Way Science News 157 IssueID23 360–362
J. Horgan (1991) ArticleTitleIn the Beginning ... Scientific American 264 IssueID2 116–125 Occurrence Handle10.1038/scientificamerican0291-116
F. Hoyle (1981) ArticleTitleThe Big Bang in Astronomy New Scientist 92 521–527
F. Hoyle (1982) Evolution From Space: The Omni Lecture and Other Papers on the Origin of Life Enslow Hillside, NJ
F. Hoyle (1983) The Intelligent Universe Joseph London
F. Hoyle N.C. Wickramasinghe (1981) Evolution From Space: A Theory of Cosmic Creationism Simon & Schuster New York
F. Hoyle N.C. Wickramasinghe (1993) Our Place in the Cosmos: The Unfinished Revolution J. M. Dent London
J. Huxley (1953) Evolution in Action: Based on the Patten Foundation Lectures Delivered at Indiana University in 1951 Scientific Book Club London
U. Jelinek (1961) Campus Challenge, Campus Crusade for Christ Arrowhead Springs, CA
S. Kauffman (1993) The Origins of Order: Self-Organization and Selection in Evolution Oxford University Press New York
B.-O. Küppers (1990) Information and the Origin of Life MIT Press Cambridge, MA
N. Lahav (1999) Biogenesis: Theories of Life’s Origin Oxford University New York
P. Lecompte du Noüy (1947) Human Destiny Longmans London
D.H. Lee et al. (1996) ArticleTitleA Self-replicating Peptide Nature 382 525–528
M. Ludwig (1993) Computer Viruses, Artificial Life and Evolution American Eagle Tucson, AR
S.F. Mason (1991) ArticleTitlePrebiotic Sources of Biomolecular Handedness Chirality 3 IssueID4 223–226
J. Maynard Smith E. Szathmáry (1999) The Origins of Life: From the Birth of Life to the Origin of Language Oxford University Press New York
J. McFadden (2000) Quantum Evolution W. W. Norton New York
McHarris, W.: 1986 (January), ‘Handedness in Nature’, Analog: Science Fiction & Fact, 68.
J.P. Moreland (Eds) (1994) The Creation Hypothesis: Scientific Evidence for an Intelligent Designer Intervarsity Press Downers Grove, IL
J.P. Moreland (1989) Christianity and the Nature of Science: A Philosophical Investigation Baker Book House Grand Rapids, MI
K. Morgan (2003) ArticleTitleA Rocky Start: Fresh Take on Life’s Oldest Story Science News 163 IssueID17 264–266
H. Morowitz (1969) Biological Self-Replicating Systems F. Snell (Eds) Progress in Theoretical Biology Academic Press New York 35 ff
H. Morowitz (1968) Energy Flow in Biology: Biological Organization as a Problem in Thermal Physics Academic Press New York
Morris, H.: 1974, Scientific Creationism, Creation Life, El Cajon, CA (now past its 11th printing).
Mulkidjanian, A.Y., Cherepanov, D.A. and Galperin, M.Y.: 2003 (May 28), ‘Survival of the Fittest Before the Beginning of Life: Selection of the First Oligonucleotide-like Polymers by UV Light’, BMC Evolutionary Biology 3(12), at http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2148/3/12.
Musgrave, I.: 1998, ‘Lies, Damned Lies, Statistics, and Probability of Abiogenesis Calculations’, in the Talk.Origins Archive (http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/abioprob/abioprob.html).
D. Noebel (1994) Understanding the Times: The Religious Worldviews of Our Day and the Search for Truth Harvest House Eugene, OR
D. Overman (1997) A Case Against Accident and Self-Organization Rowman & Littlefield Lanham, MD
M. Pigliucci (1999) ArticleTitleWhere Do We Come From? A Humbling Look at the Biology of Life’s Origin The Skeptical Inquirer 23 IssueID5 21–27
M.E. Popselov (1996) ArticleTitleChiral-selective Radiolysis in a Magnetic Field Physics Letters A 220 IssueID4–5 194–200
I. Prigogine et al. (1972) ArticleTitleThermodynamics of Evolution Physics Today 25 IssueID11 23–28 Occurrence Handle10.1063/1.3071090
H. Quastler (1964) The Emergence of Biological Organization Yale University Press New Haven
D. Ratzsch (2001) Nature, Design and Science: The Status of Design in Natural Science SUNY Press Albany, NY
C. Sagan (Eds) (1973) Communication with Extra-Terrestrial Intelligence MIT Press Cambridge, MA
F. Salisbury (1969) ArticleTitleNatural Selection and the Complexity of the Gene Nature 224 342–343
F. Salisbury (1971) ArticleTitleDoubts About the Modern Synthetic Theory of Evolution American Biology Teacher 33 IssueID6 335–338
Schopf (Eds) (2002) Life’s Origin: The Beginnings of Biological Evolution University of California Press Berkeley
Gerald Schroeder (1997) The Science of God: The Convergence of Scientific and Biblical Wisdom Free Press New York
A. Schwartz (1993) Biology and Theory: RNA and the Origin of Life J.M. Greenberg C.X. Mendoza-Gomez V. Pirronello (Eds) The Chemistry of Life’s Origins Kluwer Academic Boston 323–344
R. Shapiro (1988) ArticleTitlePrebiotic Ribose Synthesis Origins of Life and Evolution of the Biosphere 18 71
D. Snoke (2001) ArticleTitleIn Favor of God-of-the-Gaps Reasoning Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith 53 IssueID3 152–158
Stockwell, J.: 2002, ‘Borel’s Law and the Origin of Many Creationist Probability Assertions’, in the Talk.Origins Archive (http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/abioprob/borelfaq.html).
M. Strickberger (2000) Molecules and the Origin of Life Evolution EditionNumber3rd ed. Jones & Bartlett Boston
L. Sunderland (1984) Darwin’s Enigma: Fossils and Other Problems Master Books Santee, CA
G.E. Tranter et al. (1992) ArticleTitleComputational Studies of the Electroweak Origin of Biomolecular Handedness in Natural-Sugars Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A - Mathematical and Physical Sciences 436 IssueID1898 603–615 Occurrence Handle10.1098/rspa.1992.0037
J. Travis (2000) ArticleTitleMolecule Sparks Origin-of-Life Debate Science News 157 IssueID23 363
J.T. Trevors (1997) ArticleTitleEvolution of Bacterial Genomes Antonie van Leeuwenhoek International Journal of General and Molecular Microbiology 71 IssueID3 265–270
P. Ward D. Brownlee (2000) Rare Earth: Why Complex Life is Uncommon in the Universe Copernicus New York
P. Weiss (1998) ArticleTitleAnother Face of Entropy: Particles Self Organize to Make Room for Randomness Science News 154 IssueID7 108–109
C. Wills J. Bada (2000) The Spark of Life: Darwin and the Primeval Soup Perseus Cambridge, MA
C. Wilson J. Weldon (1978) Close Encounters: A Better Explanation, Involving Trauma, Terror, and Tragedy Master Books San Diego, CA
H. Yockey (1981) ArticleTitleSelf Organization Origin of Life Scenarios and Information Theory Journal of Theoretical Biology 91 13–31
H. Yockey (1977) ArticleTitleA Calculation of the Probability of Spontaneous Biogenesis by Information Theory Journal of Theoretical Biology 67 377–398
H. Yockey (1992) Information Theory and Molecular Biology Cambridge University Press New York
G. Zubay (2000) Origins of Life: On Earth and in the Cosmos EditionNumber2nd ed. Academic Press San Diego
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Carrier, R.C. The argument from biogenesis: Probabilities against a natural origin of life. Biol Philos 19, 739–764 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-005-6860-1
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-005-6860-1