Abstract
This essay seeks to start a dialogue between two traditions that historically have interpreted the economy in opposing ways: the individualism of classic economic liberalism (CEL), represented by Adam Smith and Milton Friedman, and the communitarianism of Catholic social teaching (CST), interpreted primarily through the teachings of popes and secondarily the U.S. Catholic bishops. The present authors, an economist and a moral theologian who identify with one or the other of the two traditions, strive to clarify objectively their similarities and differences with the opposing perspective. Section one focuses on each position's perspective of love of self and love of others. We find both CEL and CST saying that self-love, rightly understood, constitutes a moral good and that the love of others serves as an important principle in the political economy. We find less agreement in section two regarding justice and rights, but even here, we discover a few surprises. Both traditions uphold justice (giving to each party what is due) as essential to the political economy, and recognize some similarity in that type of justice called commutative. We note, however, substantial differences regarding a second type of justice that we call "public justice." First, they differ over the extent to which government should be involved. Here the meaning of rights, especially that of individual freedom, arises. Secondly, the traditions diverge over whether benevolence as a motivator ought to serve as a partner for public justice. Thirdly, CEL in general opposes CST's emphasis on social justice that calls upon institutions to be proactive in helping citizens and groups to become active participants in the economy. We conclude our essay by summarizing our discoveries and by suggesting areas for further dialogue.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aquinas, Thomas: 1947, Summa Theologica. Three Volumes, (trans.) Fathers of the English Dominican Province (Benziger Brothers, New York).
Aristotle: 1941, 'Nichomachean Ethics', in Richard McKeon (ed.), The Basic Works of Aristotle (Random House, New York), pp. 935–1126.
Boaz, David: 1997, 'Spontaneous Order', in David Boaz (ed.), The Libertarian Reader (The Free Press, New York), pp. 203–205.
Etzioni, Amitai: 1988, The Moral Dimension: Toward a New Economics (The Free Press, New York).
Evensky, Jerry: 1993, 'Ethics and the Invisible Hand', Journal of Economic Perspectives 7(2), 197–205.
Fitzgibbons, Athol: 1995, Adam Smith's System of Liberty, Wealth, and Virtue (Oxford University Press, New York).
Frank, Robert H.: 1988, Passions within Reason (W. W. Norton, New York).
Friedman, Milton, with the assistance of Rose D. Friedman: 1962, Capitalism and Freedom (University of Chicago Press, Chicago).
Friedman, Milton: 1970, 'The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Increase Its Profits', The New York Times Magazine, September 13.
Friedman, Milton: 1977, 'From Galbraith to Economic Freedom', The Institute of Economic Affairs, Occasional Paper 49.
Friedman, Milton and Rose Friedman: 1980, Free to Choose (Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, New York).
Friedman, Milton: 1986, 'Economists and Economic Policy', Economic Inquiry 24(1), 1–10.
Friedman, Milton and Rose Friedman: 1998, Two Lucky People: Memoirs (University of Chicago Press, Chicago).
Hehir, Bryan: 1998, 'Catholic Social Teaching and the Challenge of the Future', Woodstock Report 54 (June), 3–4.
Hollenbach, David: 1990, Justice, Peace and Human Rights: American Catholic Social Ethics in a Pluralistic World (Crossroad, New York).
John XXIII, Pope: 1963, 'Pacem in terris', in David J. O'Brien and Thomas A. Shannon (eds.), Catholic Social Thought: The Documentary Heritage (Orbis Books, Maryknoll, NY, 1992).
John Paul II, Pope: 1981, 'Laborem exercens', in David J. O'Brien and Thomas A. Shannon (eds.), Catholic Social Thought: The Documentary Heritage (Orbis Books, Maryknoll, NY, 1992).
John Paul II, Pope: 1991, 'Centesimus annus', in David J. O'Brien and Thomas A. Shannon (eds.), Catholic Social Thought: The Documentary Heritage (Orbis Books, Maryknoll, NY, 1992).
Leo XIII, Pope: 1891, 'Rerum novarum', in David J. O'Brien and Thomas A. Shannon (eds.), Catholic Social Thought: The Documentary Heritage (Orbis Books, Maryknoll, NY, 1992).
National Council of Catholic Bishops: 1986, Economic Justice for All: Pastoral Letter on Catholic Social Teaching and the U.S. Economy (United States Catholic Conference, Washington, DC).
Nell-Breuning, Oswald Von: 1936, Reorganization of Social Economy. Bernard W. Dempsey (trans. and ed.), (The Bruce Publishing Co., New York).
Pius XI, Pope: 1931, 'Quadragesimo anno', in David J. O'Brien and Thomas A. Shannon (eds.), Catholic Social Thought: The Documentary Heritage (Orbis Books, Maryknoll, NY, 1992).
Second Vatican Council: 1965, 'Gaudium et spes', in David O'Brien and Thomas Shannon (eds.), Catholic Social Thought: The Documentary Heritage (Orbis Books, Maryknoll, NY, 1992).
Smith, Adam: 1759, The Theory of Moral Sentiments, D. D. Raphael and A. L. MacFie (eds.), (Oxford University Press, London, 1982).
Smith, Adam: 1776, The Wealth of Nations, Edwin Cannan (ed.), (The Modern Library, New York, 1994).
Synod of Bishops: 1971, 'Justice in the World', in David J. O'Brien and Thomas A. Shannon (eds.), Catholic Social Thought: The Documentary Heritage (Orbis Books, Maryknoll, NY, 1992).
United Nations: 1990, 'Universal Declaration of Human Rights', in Encyclopedia of the United Nations and International Relations (Taylor and Francis, New York).
Vacek, Edward Collins: 1994, Love, Human and Divine: The Heart of Christian Ethics (Georgetown University Press, Washington, DC).
Werhane, Patricia H.: 1991, Adam Smith and His Legacy for Modern Capitalism (Oxford University Press, New York).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cima, L.R., Schubeck, T.L. Self-Interest, Love, and Economic Justice: A Dialogue Between Classical Economic Liberalism and Catholic Social Teaching. Journal of Business Ethics 30, 213–231 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1006475229374
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1006475229374