Abstract
Prinz (Perceptual the Mind: Concepts and Their Perceptual Basis, MIT Press, 2002) presents a new species of concept empiricism, under which concepts are off-line long-term memory networks of representations that are ‘copies’ of perceptual representations – proxytypes. An apparent obstacle to any such empiricism is the prevailing nativism of generative linguistics. The paper critically assesses Prinz’s attempt to overcome this obstacle. The paper argues that, prima facie, proxytypes are as incapable of accounting for the structure of the linguistic mind as are the more traditional species of empiricism. This position is then confirmed by looking in detail at two suggestions (one derived from recent connectionist research) from Prinz of how certain aspects of syntactic structure might be accommodated by the proxytype theory. It is shown that the suggestions fail to come to terms with both the data and theory of contemporary linguistics.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
N. Chomsky (1959) ArticleTitle‘A Review of B.F. Skinner’s Verbal Behaviour’ Language 35 26–58 Occurrence Handle10.2307/411334
N. Chomsky (1965) Aspects of the Theory of Syntax MIT Press Cambridge, MA
N. Chomsky (1973) ‘Conditions on Transformations’ S. Anderson P. Kipasky (Eds) A Festschrift for Morris Halle Holt, Rinehart and Wiston New York 232–286
N. Chomsky (1975) Reflections on Language Fontana London
N. Chomsky (1981) Lectures on Government and Binding Foris Dordrecht
N. Chomsky (1995) The Minimalist Program MIT Press Cambridge, MA
N. Chomsky (2000a) ‘Minimalist Inquiries: The Framework’ R. Martin D. Michaels J. Uriagereka (Eds) Step by Step: Essays on Minimalist Syntax in Honor of Howard Lasnik MIT Press Cambridge, MA 89–155
N. Chomsky (2000b) The Architecture of Language Oxford University Press New Delhi
N. Chomsky (2001a) ‘Derivation by Phase’ M. Kenstowicz (Eds) Ken Hale: A Life in Language MIT Press MA,Cambridge 1–52
N. Chomsky (2001b) ArticleTitle‘Beyond Explanatory Adequacy’ MIT Occasional Papers in Linguistics 20 1–28
Chomsky, N.: 2002, ‘An Interview on Minimalism’, In Nature and Language, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, MA, pp. 92–161.
N. Chomsky (2004) The Generative Enterprise Revisited Mouton de Gruyter Berlin
N. Chomsky H. Lasnik (1977) ArticleTitle‘Filters and Control’ Linguistic Inquiry 8 425–504
J. Collins (2003) ArticleTitle‘Cowie on the Poverty of Stimulus’ Synthese 136 159–190 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1024738522031
J. Collins (2004) ArticleTitle‘Faculty Disputes’ Mind and Language 19 503–533 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.0268-1064.2004.00270.x
F. Cowie (1999) What’s Within? Nativism Reconsidered Oxford University Press Oxford
S. Crain R. Thornton (1998) Investigations in Universal Grammar: A Guide to Experiments on the Acquisition of Syntax and Semantics MIT Press Cambridge, MA
P. Culicover (1999) Syntactic Nuts: Hard Cases, Syntactic Theory, and Language Acquisition Cambridge University press Cambridge
M. Davis T. Stone (Eds) (1995a) Mental Simulation: Evaluations and Explanations Blackwell Oxford
M. Davis T. Stone (Eds) (1995b) Folk Psychology: The Theory of Mind Debate Blackwell Oxford
Ellefson, M. and M. Christiansen: 2000, ‘Subjacency Constraints without Universal Grammar: Evidence from Artificial Language Learning and Connectionist Modeling’, in Proceedings of the Twenty-Second Annual Conference of the Cognitive Science Society, Lawrence Erlbaum, Mahwah, N.J., pp. 645–650.
J. Fodor (1983) Modularity of Mind MIT Press Cambridge, MA
J. Fodor (2000) The Mind doesn’t Work That Way: The Scope and Limits of Computational Psychology MIT Press Cambridge, MA
R. Gordon (1986) ArticleTitle‘Folk Psychology as Simulation’ Mind and Language 1 158–171
J. Higginbotham (1987) ‘The Autonomy of Syntax and Semantics’ J. Garfield (Eds) Modularity in Knowledge Representation and Natural Language Understanding MIT Press Cambridge, MA 119–131
H. Lasnik J. Kupin (1977) ArticleTitle‘A Restrictive Theory of Transformational Grammar’ Theoretical Linguistics 4 173–196 Occurrence Handle10.1515/thli.1977.4.1-3.173
H. Lasnik M. Saito (1992) Move α MIT Press Cambridge, MA
D. Lightfoot (1991) How to Set Parameters: Arguments from Language Change MIT Press Cambridge, MA
G. Marcus (2001) The Algebraic Mind MIT Press Cambridge, MA
G. Miller N. Chomsky (1963) ‘Finitary Models of Language Users’ R. Luce R. Bush E. Galtner (Eds) Handbook of Mathematical Psychology NumberInSeriesVol. III Wiley New York 419–492
J. Prinz (2002) Furnishing the Mind: Concepts and their Perceptual Basis MIT Press Cambridge, MA
L. Rizzi (1982) Issues in Italian Syntax Foris Dordrecht
L. Rizzi (1990) Relativized Minimality MIT Press Cambridge, MA
J. Ross (1967) ‘Constraints on Variables in Syntax’ MIT Cambridge, MA
R. Samuels (2002) ArticleTitle‘Nativism and Cognitive Science’ Mind and Language 17 233–265 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1468-0017.00197
T. Stowell (1981) ‘Elements of Phrase Structure’ MIT Cambridge, MA
V. Yngve (1960) ArticleTitle‘A Model and an Hypothesis for Language Structure’ Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 104 444–466
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Collins, J. Proxytypes and Linguistic Nativism. Synthese 153, 69–104 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-005-4063-6
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-005-4063-6