Abstract
Criteria of identity should mirror the identity relation in being reflexive, symmetrical, and transitive. However, this logical requirement is only rarely met by the criteria that we are most inclined to propose as candidates. The present paper addresses the question how such obvious candidates are best approximated by means of relations that have all of the aforementioned features, i.e., which are equivalence relations. This question divides into two more basic questions. First, what is to be considered a ‘best’ approximation. And second, how can these best approximations be found? In answering these questions, we both rely on and constructively criticize ground-breaking work done by Timothy Williamson. Guiding ideas of our approach are that we allow approximations by means of overlapping equivalence-relations, and that closeness of approximation is measured in terms of the number of mistakes made by the approximation when compared to the obvious candidate criterion.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
R. Carnap (1967) The Logical Structure of the World Routledge London
H.P. Grice (1941) ArticleTitle‘Personal Identity’ Mind 50 330–350
S. Delvaux L. Horsten (2004) ArticleTitle‘On Best Transitive Approximations to Simple Graphs’. Acta Informatica 40 637–655 Occurrence Handle10.1007/s00236-004-0144-0 Occurrence HandleMR2090610
M. Krivanek J. Moravek (1986) ArticleTitle‘NP-Hard Problems in Hierarchical Tree-Clustering’ Acta Informatica 23 311–323 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00289116
T. Williamson (1986) ArticleTitle‘Criteria of Identity and the Axiom of Choice’ Journal of Philosophy 83 380–394
T. Williamson (1990) Identity and Discrimination Blackwell Oxford
T. Williamson (1994) Vagueness Routledge London
C.T. Zahn SuffixJr. (1964) ArticleTitle‘Approximating Symmetric Relations by Equivalence Relations’. SIAM Journal of Applied Mathematics 12 840–847 Occurrence Handle10.1137/0112071
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Clercq, R.D., Horsten, L. Closer. Synthese 146, 371–393 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-004-6219-1
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-004-6219-1