abstract
How should history of education be written? To put the question is far more easier than to provide a concrete answer. In contemporary research, there continue to be pedagogistic complaints about finding answers to present-day educational problems via history. In our view, such an ahistorical utilitarianism as well as the legitimizing and/or mythologizing belief in a particular pedagogical system, in which the history of this field is so rich since the institutionalization of the discipline at the end of the nineteenth century, should be avoided at all costs. But the danger of presentism lurks around the corner as a sine qua non condition in any form of historical research. As can be found out via the comments on our own work, much of the criticism goes back to old conceptions of the discipline, conceived as “historical pedagogy” rather than as history of education. Apparently, in the field of pedagogy people are still convinced that the history of education, even if it does not provide edifying examples and useful lessons, must in any case have a training value for professionals – which in the light of modern, advanced research is rather a difficult idea to defend.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
W. Brezinka (1971) Von der Pädagogik zur Erziehungswissenschaft. Eine Einführung in die Metatheorie der Erziehung Weinheim Beltz.
P. Caspard (2000) ArticleTitleVingt années d’Histoire de l’éducation Histoire de l’éducation 85 73–87 Occurrence Handle10.4000/histoire-education.1235
S. Cohen A. Lawrence (1999) Cremin: Lives and transformations S. Cohen (Eds) Challenging orthodoxies. Toward a new cultural history of education Peter Lang New York 273–299
S. Cohen (2002) ArticleTitleReview of the book Order in Progress Historical Studies in Education/Revue de l’histoire de l’éducation 14 157–162
Compère M.M. (1995) L’histoire de l’éducation en Europe. Essai comparatif sur la façon dont elle s’écrit Peter Lang/ Institut National de Recherche Pédagogique Bern/Paris
D. Crook R. Aldrich (Eds) (2000) History of education for the twenty-first century Institute of Education. London
D Crook G. McCulloch (2002) ArticleTitleIntroduction: Comparative approaches to the history of education History of Education 31 397–400 Occurrence Handle10.1080/00467600210151944
K. Dams M. Depaepe F. Simon (1999) Sneaking into school: Classroom history at work I. Grosvenor M. Lawn K. Rousmaniere (Eds) Silences images. The social history of the classroom Peter Lang New York 13–46
K. Dams M. Depaepe F. Simon (2002) “By indirections finding directions out”. Classroom history, sources and objectives W. Jamrozek D. Zoladz-Strzelczyk (Eds) W dialogu przesloscia. Ksiega poswiecona Profesorowi Janowi Hellwigowi [Dialogue with the past. To professor Jan Hellwig in memoriam] Adam Micikiewicz University Press Poznan 57–92
De Clerck, K. Souvage, J. (1985–1989). Index Bibliographicus. Bibliographie sélective se rapportant à la philosophie et théorie, l’historiographie et la métho-dologie de l’histoire de l’éducation – selective bibliographie of publications relating to the philosophy and theory, historiography, and methodology of the history of education, 1984–1989. Paedagogica Historica, 25, 775–793.
M. Depaepe (1983) On the relationship of theory and history in pedagogy. An introduction to the West German discussion on the significance of the history of education (1950–1980. Leuven University Press Leuven
M. Depaepe (1993a) Some statements about the nature of the history of education. K. Salimova E.V. Johanningmeier (Eds) Why should we teach history of education? The Library of International Academy of Self-Improvement Moscow 31–36
M. Depaepe (1993) ArticleTitleHistory of education anno 1992 ‘A tale told by an idiot, full of sound fury, signifying nothing’? History of Education 22 1–10 Occurrence Handle10.1080/0046760930220101
M. Depaepe (1997) ArticleTitleDemythologizing the educational past: An endless task in history of education Historical Studies in Education/Revue d’histoire de l’éducation 9 208–223
M. Depaepe (1998a) ArticleTitleEntre pédagogie et histoire. Questions et remarques sur l’évolution des objectifs de l’enseignement de l’histoire de l’éducation. Histoire de l’éducation 77 3–18 Occurrence Handle10.3406/hedu.1998.2938
M. Depaepe (1998) ArticleTitleEducationalisation: A key concept in understanding the basic processes in the history of Western education History of Education Review 27 IssueID2 16–28
M. Depaepe (1998) ArticleTitle‘Rien ne va plus ...’ The collapse of colonial educational structures in Zaïre (1960–1995) Education and Society 16 37–53 Occurrence Handle10.7459/es/16.1.05
M. Depaepe (2001) ArticleTitleA professionally relevant history of education for teachers: Does it exist? Reply to Jurgen Herbst’s ‘State of the Art Article’ Paedagogica Historica 37 631–640 Occurrence Handle10.1080/0030923010370305
M. Depaepe (2003) ArticleTitleWhat kind of history of education may we expect for the 21 st century? Some comments on four recent readers in the field [Essay Review] Paedagogica Historica 39 IssueID1 187–199 Occurrence Handle10.1080/00309230307450
M. Depaepe F. Simon (1996) ArticleTitlePaedagogica Historica: Lever or mirror in the making of the history of education? Paedagogica Historica 32 421–450 Occurrence Handle10.1080/0030923960320207
Depaepe F. M. Simon (1997) ArticleTitleSocial characteristics of Belgian primary teachers in the twentieth century Cambridge Journal of Education 27 391–404 Occurrence Handle10.1080/0305764970270308
M. Depaepe F. Simon (1999) ArticleTitleLes écoles gardiennes en Belgique Histoire et historiographie. Histoire de l’éducation 82 73–99 Occurrence Handle10.3406/hedu.1999.3068
M. Depaepe F. Simon (2003) ArticleTitleFreiluftschulen: Eine historisch-pädagogische Randerscheinung als Reflex sozial-historischer Modernisierungsprozesse? Das Beispiel Belgiens Zeitschrift für Pädagogik 49 718–733
Depaepe M., Simon F., Dams K., Catteeuw K. (in press). Filming the blackbox. First impressions on unused sources in the study of the history of primary education in Belgium. In N. Peim, K. Myers U. Mietzner (Eds), Visualising subject and object in the history of education. New York, Peter Lang.
Depaepe M. F. Simon A. Van Gorp (2003) ArticleTitleThe canonisation of Ovide Decroly as a “Saint” of the new education History of Education Quarterly 43 224–249 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1748-5959.2003.tb00121.x
M. Depaepe H. Crombrugge ParticleVan (1995) Using or abusing the educational past? Some methodological reflections on the place of Johann Heinrich Pestalozzi in the educational historiography H. Gehrig (Eds) Pestalozzi in China Zürich Pestalozzianum 51–62
M. Depaepe et al. (2000) Order in progress 1880–1970. Leuven: Leuven University Press. Everyday educational practice in primary schools. Belgium
A. Errante (2000) ArticleTitleBut sometimes you’re not part of the story: Oral histories and ways of remembering and telling Educational Researcher 29 IssueID2 16–27 Occurrence Handle10.3102/0013189X029002016
M. Gaither (2001) ArticleTitleGlobalisation and history of education. Some comments on Jurgen Herbst’s “The history of education: State of the art at the turn of the century in Europe and North America” Paedagogica Historica 37 641–647 Occurrence Handle10.1080/0030923010370306
M. Gaither (2003) American educational history revisted A critique of progress Teachers College Press New York
M. Heinemann (Eds) (1979) Die historische Pädagogik in Europa und den USA Klett-Cota. Stuttgart
History of Education Society (1971). History, sociology and education. London: Methuen Co.
K.H. Ingenkamp (1995) ArticleTitleReview of the book Zum Wohl des Kindes? Pädologie, pädagogische Psychologie und experimentelle Pädagogik in Europa und den USA, 1890–1940 Zeitschrift für Pädagogik 41 463–469
I. Jablonka (2001) ArticleTitleLes historiens américains aux prises avec leur école L’évolution récente de l’historiographie de l’éducation aux Etats-Unis (1961–2001) Histoire de l’éducation 89 3–56 Occurrence Handle10.4000/histoire-education.841
J. Laspalsas (2002) Introducción a la historiografía de la educación Pamplona EUNSA.
(Ed),Mietzner Visualising subject and object in the history of education New York:Peter Lang.
P.W. Musgrave (Eds) (1970) Sociology, history and education Methuen Co. London
A. Nóvoa (1998) Histoire comparaison (Essais sur l’éducation) Lisbon Educa.
J. Oelkers R. Horlacher (2002) John Deweys Philosophie der Erziehung im Kontext J. Oelkers R. Horlacher (Eds) John Dewey. Pädago-gische Aufsätze und Abhandlungen (1900–1944) Zürich Verlag Pestalozzianum 7–22
F. Pöggeler (2002) Zwischen Nationalbewusstsein und Weltoffenheit: Europäische Perspektiven der pädagogischen Historiographie W. Jamrozek D. Zoladz-Strzelczyk (Eds) W dialogu przeslosciq. Ksiega poswiecona Profesorowi Janowi Hellwigowi [Dialogue with the past. To professor Jan Hellwig in memoriam] Adam Micikiewicz University Press Poznan 109–125
T.S. Popkewitz B.M. Franklin (M.A.) Pereira (Eds) (2001) Cultural history and education Critical essays on knowledge and schooling. New York/London RoutledgeFalmer
M. Pronko (2000–2001) ArticleTitleUniversidades Obreras: Treinta años de Historiografía educacional Argentina y Brasileña Anuario Historia de la Educación 3 179–195
D. Ravitch (2000) Left back. A century of failed school reforms Simon Schuster New York
Richardson, W. (1999). Historians and educationists: The history of education as a field of study in post-war England. History of education, 28(1–2), 1–30 109–141.
Roy Lowe (Eds) (2000) History of education Major themes. London/New York Routledge Falmer 1–4
H.E. Tenorth (2002) Historische Bildungsforschung. R. Tippelt (Eds) Handbuch Bildungsforschung Leske und Budrich Opladen 123–139 Occurrence Handle10.1007/978-3-322-99634-3_6
R.J. Wolff (1986) ArticleTitleEuropean perspectives on the history of education: A review of four journals History of Education Quarterly 26 87–94 Occurrence Handle10.2307/368878
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Depaepe, M. HOW SHOULD THE HISTORY OF EDUCATION BE WRITTEN? SOME REFLECTIONS ABOUT THE NATURE OF THE DISCIPLINE FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF THERECEPTION OF OUR WORK. Stud Philos Educ 23, 333–345 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11217-004-4447-y
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11217-004-4447-y