Abstract
The ethics research community has all but ignored issues of oversight ethics – the vices and virtues of overseers. This study develops a conceptual framework for exploring the ethics of oversight and provides insights into the design of codes of ethics for oversight institutions and for overseers. Analysis of business licensing in Israel reveals prospective and retrospective oversight ethics problems at the levels of national and local policy and implementation: Overseers failed to act on knowledge of breaches of business licensing stipulations and took action known to be slow and ineffective; policymakers neglected their duty to enact significant policy change in an oversight system that was clearly not working. Partially as a result of these oversight failures, over one third of Israeli businesses are unlicensed, 23 people were killed in the collapse of an unlicensed banquet hall, 2 major fires erupted in the same shopping mall, and a fire in a fertilizer warehouse very nearly became a mega-disaster.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Birkland, T.: 1997, After Disaster: Agenda Setting, Public Policy, and Focusing Events (Georgetown University Press, Washington, DC).
Birkland, T.: 1998, 'Focusing Events, Mobilization, and Agenda Setting', Journal of Public Policy 18 (1), 53–74.
Bovens, M.: 1998, The Quest for Responsibility: Accountability and Citizenship in Complex Organisations (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
Busenberg, G.: 1999, 'The Evolution of Vigilance: Disasters, Sentinels and Policy Change', Environmental Politics 8 (4), 90–109.
Commission on New Building Methods: 2001, Recommendations for Institutionalizing Procedures for Checking and Approving New Building Methods.
Devas, N. and R. Kelly: 2001, 'Regulation or Revenues? An Analysis of Local Business Licenses, with a Case Study of the Single Business Permit Reform in Kenya', Public Administration and Development 21, 381–391.
Dror, Y.: 1988, 'Public Administration in Israel', in D. C. Rowat (ed.), Public Administration in Developed Democracies: A Comparative Study (Marcel Dekker, New York), pp. 357–375.
Feiock, R. and M. Jeong: 2002, 'Regulatory Reform and Urban Economic Development', State and Local Government Review 34 (3), 153–159.
Friedberg, A.: 1985, Public Audit in the Margins of the Public Administration System in Israel, Doctoral Thesis, submitted to the Hebrew University, Jerusalem.
Friedberg, A.: 1988, 'Public and Internal Audit in the Local Government Sector in Israel', City and Region 18, 27–47 (Hebrew).
Friedberg, A.: 1998, 'Ethical Aspects of Internal Auditing', Journal of Business Ethics 17, 895–904.
Friedberg, A.: 1999, 'State and Internal Audit in Local Authorities in Israel: Examination and Evaluation', in A. Friedberg (ed.), Auditing Local Authorities in Israel (Ministry of Interior, Jerusalem), pp. 75–96 (Hebrew). Haaretz 03.05.01
Knesset: 2001a, Protocol of the Meeting of the Committee for the Interior and Environment on August 8th, 2000.
Knesset: 2001b, Protocol of the Meeting of the Committee for the Interior and Environment on June 5th, 2001.
Knesset: 2001c, Protocol of the Meeting of the Committee for the Interior and Environment on July 7th, 2001.
Menzel, D.: 1999, 'A Review and Assessment of Empirical Research on Public Administration Ethics: Implications for Scholars and Managers', Public Integrity 1(Summer), 239–264.
Menzel, D.: 2003, 'State of the Art of Empirical Research on Ethics and Integrity in Governance', Paper presented at the Annual Conference of the European Group of Public Administration, Oeiras, Portugal, 3-6 September 2003.
Ministry of Interior: 2003, 'A Look at the Business Licensing Law', Bit'on Rishui Asakim 1.
Romzek, B. and P. Ingraham: 2000, 'Cross Pressures of Accountability: Initiative, Command and Failure in the Ron Brown Plane Crash', Public Administration Review 60 (3), 240–253.
Schnuer, R.: 1997, 'Business License Reforms in Champaign, Illiniois', Government Finance Review 13 (1), 25–28.
Schwartz, R. and R. Sulitzeanu-Kenan: 2004, 'Managerial Values and Accountability Pressures: Challenges of Crisis and Disaster', Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 14 (1), 79–102.
Sprinzak, E.: 1993, 'Elite Illegalism in Israel and the Question of Democracy', in E. Sprinzak and L. Diamond (eds.), Israeli Democracy under Stress (Lynne Rienner, Boulder CO), pp. 173–198.
State Comptroller's Office: 2003, 'Prevention of Fires and Fire Extinguishing', Reports on Local Authorities, Corporations and Institutes of Higher Learning, Year 1993 (Jerusalem), pp. 87–144.
State of Israel, Ministry of Interior, Audit Department of Local Authorities: 2000, Businesses Operating Without a License, Jerusalem.
State of Israel, Ministry of Interior, Audit Department of Local Authorities: 2002, Follow up Report, Businesses Operating Without a License, Jerusalem.
Thompson, D.: 1987, Political Ethics and Public Office (Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA).
Thompson, D.: 2003, 'Restoring Distrust: The Political Ethics of Oversight', Paper presented at the Centre for Democratic Government, Oxford University-April 2003.
Turner, B. and N. Pidgeon.: 1997, Man-Made Disasters, 2nd Edition (Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford).
Vaughan, D.: 1996, The Challenger Launch Decision: Risky Technology, Culture, and Deviance at NASA (University of Chicago Press, Chicago).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Friedberg, A., Schwartz, R. & Amrani, S. Oversight Ethics: The Case of Business Licensing. J Bus Ethics 53, 371–381 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1023/B:BUSI.0000043499.27246.c8
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/B:BUSI.0000043499.27246.c8