Abstract
The U.S. 2010 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) exempts members of health care sharing ministries (HCSMs) from the individual mandate to have minimum essential insurance coverage. Little is generally known about these religious organizations and even less critical attention has been brought to bear on them and their ACA exemption. Both deserve close scrutiny due to the exemption’s less than clear legislative justification, their potential influence on the ACA’s policy and ethical success, and their salience to current religious liberty debates surrounding the expansion of religious exemptions from ACA responsibilities for both individuals and corporations. Analyzing documents of the United States’ three largest health care sharing ministries and related material, I examine these organizations and their ACA exemption with particular consideration of their ethical dimensions. Here a thick description of the nature and workings of health care sharing ministries precedes a similar account of the ACA exemption. From these empirical analyses, five ethical and policy concerns emerge: (1) the charity versus insurance status of these ministries; (2) the conflation of two ACA religious exemptions; (3) the tension between the values of religious liberty and of justice; (4) the potential undermining of ACA policy goals; and (5) the questionable compliance of health care sharing ministries with ACA exemption requirements. An accurate and informed understanding of HCSMs is required for policymakers and others to justify the ACA exemption of health care sharing ministry members. A sufficient justification would address at least the five ethical and policy concerns raised here.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alford, R. 2013. New Kentucky law reopens door for Christians-only medical coverage. Insurance Journal, June 25. http://www.insurancejournal.com/news/southeast/2013/06/25/296594.htm. Accessed December 10, 2013.
Alliance of Health Care Sharing Ministries. 2012a. Alliance of health care sharing ministries: What is a health care sharing ministry? http://www.healthcaresharing.org/hcsm. Accessed December 18, 2012.
Alliance of Health Care Sharing Ministries. 2012b. Alliance of health care sharing ministries: About us. http://www.healthcaresharing.org/about/. Accessed December 10, 2013.
Alliance of Health Care Sharing Ministries. 2013a. Health care sharing ministries (HCSM)—comparison chart. http://www.healthcaresharing.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/Health-Care-Sharing-Ministry-Comparison-Summer-2013.pdf. Accessed December 11, 2013.
Alliance of Health Care Sharing Ministries. 2014. Alliance of health care sharing ministries: What is a health care sharing ministry? http://www.healthcaresharing.org/hcsm. Accessed December 29, 2014.
Alonso-Zaldivar, R. 2011. Christian medical plans are exempt from insurance mandates. The Huffington Post, February 26. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/02/26/christian-medical-plans-a_n_828613.html. Accessed October 24, 2012.
American Legislative Exchange Council. 2011. Health Care Sharing Ministries Freedom to Share Act. http://www.alec.org/model-legislation/health-care-sharing-ministries-freedom-to-share-act/. Accessed December 10, 2013.
American Legislative Exchange Council. 2013. Health Care Sharing Ministries Tax Parity Act. http://www.alec.org/model-legislation/health-care-sharing-ministries-tax-parity-act/. Accessed December 10, 2013.
Andrews, M. 2011. Faith-based groups share burden of health costs … with limits. NPR, April 26. http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2011/04/26/135732459/religious-exemption-in-health-law-lets-some-skip-individual-coverage. Accessed April 29, 2011.
Baldwin, R. 2009. Healthcare sharing and healthcare reform—a position statement from Christian Care Ministry, Inc. (CCM) in response to filing of senate bill on healthcare. PRWeb, September 21. http://www.prweb.com/releases/Medi/share/prweb2903324.htm. Accessed December 10, 2013.
Christian Care Ministry. 2013a. Medi-Share 2.0 Christian care medical sharing: Program guidelines and frequently asked questions. West Melbourne, FL: Christian Care Ministry. http://mychristiancare.org/uploadedFiles/My_Christian_Care/Medi-Share/MS2.0_GL_0112_%20LR%20FINAL.pdf. Accessed December 11, 2013.
Christian Care Ministry. 2013b. Frequently asked questions about health reform. http://mychristiancare.org/Medi-Share/Public_Content/FAQs_about_Health_Reform.aspx. Accessed December 11, 2013.
Christian Healthcare Ministries. 2013a. Christian healthcare ministries information pack. Barberton, OH: Christian Healthcare Ministries.
Christian Healthcare Ministries. 2013b. Christian healthcare ministries guidelines. Barberton, OH: Christian Healthcare Ministries.
Cochran, C.A. 1996. Balancing care and cure: The place of health care reform in the welfare reform debate. In Welfare in America: Christian perspectives on a policy in crisis, edited by S.W. Carlson-Thies and J.W. Skillen, 504–525. Grand Rapids, MI: William B. Eerdmans.
Dan Rather Reports. 2011. … Do unto others. Dan Rather Reports, March 22, episode 610. http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=4&ved=0CEcQFjAD&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.axs.tv%2Fui%2Finc%2Fshow_transcripts.php%3Fami%3DA7887%26t%3DDan_Rather_Reports%26en%3D610&ei=YUreUO3bD8fV0gHGjYGQDg&usg=AFQjCNF7hGU6XueMnmiwQ9bnIQkkHLI-mQ&bvm=bv.1355534169,d.dmQ. Accessed December 28, 2012.
Daniels, N., B. Saloner, and A.H. Gelpi. 2009. Access, cost, and financing: Achieving an ethical health reform. Health Affairs 28(5): w909–w916. doi:10.1377/hlthaff.28.5.w909.
Eck, A. 2010. Miracle on page 327. AAPS News of the Day Blog, April 21. http://www.aapsonline.org/newsoftheday/001021. Accessed December 11, 2012.
Fager, C. 2001. Health plan accused. Christianity Today 45(5): 23.
Ferngren, G.B. 1986. The evangelical-fundamentalist tradition. In Caring and curing: Health and medicine in the western religious traditions, edited by R.L. Numbers and D.W. Amundsen, 486–513. New York: Macmillan.
Fidero, J. 2012. Solidarity health share, a Catholic alternative. St. Joseph’s Vanguard, August 7. http://www.devinrose.heroicvirtuecreations.com/blog/2012/08/01/solidarity-health-share-a-catholic-alternative/. Accessed December 31, 2012.
Frago, C. 2010. Health mandate exempts sharers, no insurance rule for care ministries. Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, May 23, front section.
Galarneau, C.A. 2002. Health care as a community good: Many dimensions, many communities, many views of justice. The Hastings Center Report 32(5): 33–40.
Gibson, R., and J.P. Singh. 2012. The battle over health care: What Obama’s reform means for America’s future. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield Publishers.
Granados, L. 2012. Healthcare sharing ministries: The greatest loophole ever sold. Secular News Daily, September 4. http://networkedblogs.com/BINSf. Accessed December 11, 2013.
Grover, S.T. 2011. Religious exemptions to the PPACA’s health insurance mandate. American Journal of Law and Medicine 37(4): 624–651.
Holmes, T.E. 2012. The lowdown on medical sharing plans: Consider the risks before spending money on this health insurance alternative. Black Enterprise, August 1. http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-299885649.html. Accessed December 9, 2013.
Internal Revenue Service, Department of Treasury. 2011. Application for exemption from Social Security and Medicare taxes and waiver of benefits. http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-prior/f4029--2011.pdf. Accessed December 10, 2013.
Jacobs, L.R., and T. Skocpol. 2012. Health care reform and American politics: What everyone needs to know, 2nd ed. New York: Oxford University Press.
Jost, T.S. 2011. Loopholes in the Affordable Care Act: Regulatory gaps and border crossing techniques and how to address them. Saint Louis University Journal of Health Law and Policy 5(1): 27–82.
Kreidler, M. 2011. Samaritan ministries ordered to stop offering unauthorized insurance in Washington state. Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner, April 1. http://www.insurance.wa.gov/news/2011/4-1-2011.shtml. Accessed December 27, 2012.
McDonough, J.E. 2011. Inside national health reform. Berkeley and New York: University of California Press and Milbank Memorial Fund.
Metcalf, N. 2013. Should we sign up for a “health-care sharing ministry”? Consumer Reports News, July 11. http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/news/2011/07/should-we-sign-up-for-a-health-care-sharing-ministry/index.htm. Accessed December 10, 2013.
Montana Commissioner of Securities and Insurance. 2007. Morrison takes legal action to protect Montana consumers. http://www.csi.mt.gov/news/2007/20070503Medi-Share%20-%20Legal%20Action2.html. Accessed December 10, 2013.
Murray, T.H. 2010. American values and health care reform. The New England Journal of Medicine 362(4): 285–287. doi:10.1056/NEJMp0911116.
National Association of Evangelicals. 2012. Statement of faith. http://www.nae.net/about-us/statement-of-faith. Accessed December 13, 2012.
Obama, B. 2009. Remarks by the President at the annual conference of the American Medical Association, 2009. The Huffington Post, June 15. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/06/15/obama-ama-speech-full-texn215699.html. Accessed December 11, 2013.
Pittenger, T.A. 2013. Samaritan ministries, Dear Friend in Christ letter. Peoria, IL: Samaritan Ministries International.
Posner, S. 2010. The Lord is my insurer. The American Prospect, April 15. http://prospect.org/article/lord-my-insurer-0. Accessed December 30, 2012.
Samaritan Ministries International. 2011. IRS form 990 return of organization exempt from income tax: Schedule O. Accessed from GuideStar, December 28, 2012.
Samaritan Ministries International. 2013. Guidelines for health care sharing. http://samaritanministries.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/20130614Guidelines.pdf. Accessed October 24, 2012.
Starr, P. 2011. Remedy and reaction: The peculiar American struggle over health care reform. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Sweet, L.I. 1994. Health and medicine in the evangelical tradition: “Not by might nor power.” Valley Forge, PA: Trinity Press International.
Washington Post Company. 2010. Landmark: The inside story of America’s new health care law and what it means for us all, 1st ed. New York: Public Affairs.
Acknowledgments
My gratitude to Jane Adkins for her research assistance and comments on an earlier draft and to two anonymous reviewers for their feedback.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Galarneau, C. Health Care Sharing Ministries and Their Exemption From the Individual Mandate of the Affordable Care Act. Bioethical Inquiry 12, 269–282 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11673-015-9610-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11673-015-9610-3