Abstract
This article presents an overview ofregulations, guidelines and societal debates ineight member states of the EC about a)embryonic and fetal tissue transplantation(EFTT), and b) the use of human embryonic stemcells (hES cells) for research into celltherapy, including `therapeutic' cloning. Thereappears to be a broad acceptance of EFTT inthese countries. In most countries guidance hasbeen developed. There is a `strong' consensusabout some of the central conditions for `goodclinical practice' regarding EFTT.International differences concern, amongstothers, some of the informed consent issuesinvolved, and the questions whether anintermediary organisation is necessary, whetherthe methods of abortion may be influenced bythe possible use of EFT, and whether EFTTshould only be used for the experimentaltreatment of rare disorders. The potential useof hES cells for research into cell therapy hasgiven a new impetus to the debate about (human)embryo research. The therapeutic prospects withregard to the retrieval and research use of hEScells appear to function as a catalyst for theintroduction of less restrictive regulationsconcerning research with spare embryos, atleast in some European countries. It remains tobe seen whether the prospect of treatingpatients suffering from serious disorders withtransplants produced by therapeutic cloningwill decrease the societal and moral resistanceto allowing the generation of embryos for`instrumental' use.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bill on the Protection of embryos in vitro: 1998 (Belgium).
Bill on Embryos: 2000 (The Netherlands).
Bill on Fetal Tissue: 1999 (The Netherlands).
Bjornson, C.R.R., R.L. Rietze, B.A. Reynolds et al.: 1999, 'Turning Brain into Blood', Science 283, 534-537.
Boer, G.J.: 1994, 'Network of European CNS Transplantation and Regeneration (NECTAR). Ethical Guidelines for the Use of Human Embryonic or Fetal Tissue for Experimental and Clinical Neurotransplantation and Research', J Neurology 242, 1-13.
Council of Europe, Parliamentary Assembly: 1986, 'Use of Human Embryos and Fetuses for Diagnostic, Therapeutic, Scientific, Industrial and Commercial Purposes', Recommendation, 1046.
Council of Europe: 1989, Recommendation on the Use of Human Embryos and Fetuses in Scientific Research (no. 1100).
Council of Europe: 1996, Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Dignity of the Human Being with Regard to the Application of Biology and Biomedicine; Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine. Strasbourg.
Council of Europe: 1997, Additional Protocol to the Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine. On the Prohibition of Cloning Human Beings. Strasbourg.
Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft: 1999, Stellungnahme zum Problemkreis 'Humane Embryonale Stammzellen'.
Dickson, D.: 2000, 'Europe Asks UK to Reject Cloning Approval', Nature Medicine 6, 1068.
Dunnett, S.B., and A. Björklund: 1999, 'Prospect for New Restorative and Neuroprotective Treatments in Parkinson's Disease', Nature (Supp. 399), A32-A39.
Embryo Protection Law: 1991 (Germany).
European Community Working Group on Human Embryos and Research: 1994, Second Report. Brussels.
European Group on Ethics in Science and New Technologies to the European Commission: 2000, Ethical Aspects of Human Stem Cell Research and Use, November, 14. Brussels.
Fink, J.S., J.M Schumacher, S.L. Ellias, et al.: 2000, 'Porcine Xenografts in Parkinson's Disease and Huntington's Disease Patients: Preliminary Results', Cell Transplantation 9, 273-278.
Government Response to the Recommendations made in the Chief Medical Officer's Expert Group Report: Stem Cell Research: Medical Progress with Responsibility, August 2000. London.
Health Council of the Netherlands: 1994, Advies inzake beschikbaarstelling en gebruik van foetussen, foetaal weefsel of andere stoffelijke resten na abortus, voor wetenschappelijke doeleinden. 's-Gravenhage.
Health Council of the Netherlands: 1997, Research with Embryonic Stem Cells (Gezondheidsraad. Onderzoek met embryonale stamcellen. Signalement). Rijswijk: Gezondheidsraad.
Health Council of the Netherlands: 1997, Fetal Tissue Transplantation. Grounds for Reconsideration of a Prohibition Order. Rijswijk: Health Council of the Netherlands.
Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990.
Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority: 1994, 'Donated Ovarian Tissue in Embryo Research and Assisted Conception', Public Consultation Document. London.
Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority: 1994, 'Donated Ovarian Tissue in Embryo Research and Assisted Conception', Report. London.
Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority: 1998, Code of Practice, 4th edn. London.
Human Genetics Advisory Commission: 1998, Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. Cloning Issues in Reproduction, Science, and Medicine. London.
Humanistisch Studiecentrum Nederland: 1992, De foetus als medicinale bron. Amsterdam.
Interim Central Committee on Ethical Aspects of Medical Research (KEMO, The Netherlands): 1992, Fetal Tissue.
Lanza, R.P., J.B. Cibelli and M.D. West: 1999, 'Human Therapeutic Cloning', Nat Med 5, 975-977.
Law on Assisted Reproduction: 1997 (Denmark).
Law on the Donation and Use of Human Embryos and Fetuses: 1988 (Spain).
Law 94/654 on the Donation and Use of Parts and Products of the Human Body, Artificial Reproduction, and Prenatal Diagnosis: 1994 (France).
Nagy, A. et al.: 1993, 'Derivation of Completely Cell Culture-Derived Mice from Early-Passage Embryonic Stem Cells', Proc Natl Sci USA 90, 8424-8428.
National Committee on Bioethics: 1994, Points of View on Assisted Reproductive Technologies. Rome.
National Consultative Ethics Committee for Health and Life Sciences (CCNE): 1984, Opinion on Sampling of Dead Human Embryonic and Fetal Tissue for Therapeutic, Diagnostic, and Scientific Purposes. Paris.
National Consultative Ethics Committee for Health and Life sciences (CCNE): 1986, Opinion on Research and Uses of in vitro Human Embryos for Scientifc and Medical Purposes. Paris.
National Consultative Ethics Committee for Health and Life Sciences: 1989, Opinion on the Transplantation of Nerve Cells in the Treatment of Parkinson's Disease. Paris.
National Consultative Ethics Committee for Health and Life Sciences: 1990, Opinion Concerning Intracerebral Transplants of Mesencephalic Tissue from Human Embryos to Five Patients with Parkinson's Disease for the Purpose of Therapeutic Experimentation. Paris.
National Consultative Ethics Committee for Health and Life Sciences: 1997, Opinion on the Establishment of Collections of Human Embryo Cells and Their Use for Therapeutic or Scientific Purposes. Paris.
National Council on Ethics for Life Sciences: 1997, Statement 15: Embryo Experimentation (Portugal).
National Council on Ethics for Life Sciences: 1997, Opinion: Ethical Implications of Cloning (Portugal).
Nuffield Council on Bioethics: 2000, Stem Cell Therapy: The Ethical Issues. A Discussion Paper. London.
Parkinson's Disease Society: 2000, Parliamentary Background Briefing on Stem Cell Research, 7 November. London.
Organ Donation Act: 1996 (The Netherlands).
Reubinoff, B.E., M.F. Pera, C.Y. Fong et al.: 2000, 'Embryonic Stem Cell Lines from Human Blastocysts: Somatic Differentiation In Vitro', Nature Biotechnology 18, 399-404.
Review of the Guidance on the Research Use of Fetuses and Fetal Material: 1989, London: H.M. Stationary Office.
Steghaus-Kovac, S.: 1999, 'Ethical Loophole Closing Up for Stem Cell Researchers', Science 286, 31.
Stem Cell Research: Medical Progress with Responsibility: 2000, 'A Report from the Chief Medical Officer's Expert Group Reviewing the Potential of Developments in Stem Cell Research and Cell Nuclear Replacement to Benefit Human Health', Department of Health. London.
Thomson, J.A., J. Itskovitz-Eldor, S.S. Shapiro et al.: 1998, 'Embryonic Stem Cell Lines Derived from Human Blastocysts', Science 282, 1145-1147.
Tweede Kamer 1994-1995, Handelingen 23016, nr. 7.
United Kingdom Xenotransplantation Interim Regulatory Authority: 1999, Draft Report of the Infection Surveillance Steering Group of the UKXIRA. London.
Wert, G. de: 2000, 'Human Cloning: The Case of the (Preimplantation) Embryo', in: J. Gunning (ed.), Assisted Conception: Research, Ethics and Law. Aldershot: Ashgate/Dartmouth, pp. 83-98.
Wert, G. de and R. Berghmans: 1996, 'Kritiek op medisch gebruik van foetaal weefsel snijdt geen hout', NRC, May 31.
Wert, G. de, R. Berghmans and G.J. Boer: 2001 (submitted), Human Embryonic and Fetal Tissue Transplantation: A Survey of Ethical Issues.
Westerman, E.J., T. van Laar and H. Jochemsen: 1995, De foetus als donor? Amsterdam: Buijten & Schipperheijn.
Widner, H.: 1999, 'Review of Allo-and Xenogeneic Neural Grafts in Neurodegenerative Disorders', Transplantation Proceedings 31, 936-938.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
de Wert, G., Berghmans, R., Boer, G. et al. Ethical guidance on human embryonic and fetal tissue transplantation: A European overview. Med Health Care Philos 5, 79–90 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1014213125573
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1014213125573