Abstract
Grice's Quantity maxims have been widely misinterpreted as enjoining a speaker to make the strongest claim that she can, while respecting the other conversational maxims. Although many writers on the topic of conversational implicature interpret the Quantity maxims as enjoining such volubility, so construed the Quantity maxims are unreasonable norms for conversation. Appreciating this calls for attending more closely to the notion of what a conversation requires. When we do so, we see that eschewing an injunction to maximal informativeness need not deprive us of any ability to predict or explain genuine cases of implicature. Crucial to this explanation is an appreciation of how what a conversation, or a given stage of a conversation, requires, depends upon what kind of conversation is taking place. I close with an outline of this dependence relation that distinguishes among three importantly distinct types of conversation.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bach, K., and Harnish, R.: 1979,Linguistic Communication and Speech Acts (Cambridge, MA: MIT, Bradford).
Brandom, R.: 1983, ‘Asserting’,Nous 17, 637–650.
Carlson, L.: 1983,Dialogue Games: An Approach to Discourse Understanding (Dordrecht: D. Reidel).
Carberry, S.: 1990,Plan Recognition in Natural Language Dialogue (Cambridge, MA: MIT, Bradford).
Chierchia, G. and McConnell-Gines, S.: 1990,Meaning and Grammar: An Introduction to Semantics (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press).
Cohen, R.: 1987, ‘Analyzing the Structure of Argumentative Discourse’,Computational Linguistics 13, 13–24.
Cohen, R., Morgan, J., and Pollock J. (eds.): 1990,Intentions in Communication (MIT: Bradford).
Dascal, M.: 1979, ‘Conversational relevance’, in A. Margalit (ed.)Meaning and Use (Dordrecht: D. Reidel), pp. 153–174.
Fogelin, R.: 1967,Evidence and Meaning (New York: Humanities Press).
Gauthier, D.: 1986,Morals by Agreement (New York: Oxford University Press).
Gazdar, G.: 1979,Pragmatics: Implicature, Presupposition and Logical Form (New York: Academic Press).
Grice, H. P.: 1961, ‘The Causal Theory of Perception’,Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, Supplementary Volume 35.
Grice, H. P.: 1967,Logic and Conversation, revised and reprinted in Grice (1989). (All page references in the text are to the reprint of this in Grice (1989)).
Grice, H. P.: 1989,Studies in the Way of Words (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press).
Hamblin, C. L.: 1958, ‘Questions’,Australasian Journal of Philosophy 36.
Hamblin, C. L.: 1970,Fallacies (London: Methuen).
Hamblin, C. L.: 1971, ‘Mathematical Models of Dialogue’,Theoria 27, 130–55.
Harnish, R.: 1976, ‘Logical Form and Implicature’, in T. Bever, J. Katz and D. Langendoen (eds.)An Integrated Theory of Linguistic Ability (New York: Crowell).
Harrah, D.: 1984, ‘The Logic of Questions’, in D. Gabbay and F. Guenthner (eds.)Handbook of Philosophical Logic, Vol. II (Dordrecht: D. Reidel), 715–764.
Hinkelman, E.: 1990,Linguistic and Pragmatic Constraints on Utterance Interpretation (dissertation, Department of Computer Science, University of Rochester).
Hintikka, J.: 1984, ‘Rules, Utilities and Strategies in Dialogical Games’, in Vaina and Hintikka (eds.),Cognitive Constraints on Communication (Dordrecht: D. Reidel).
Hintikka, J.: 1988, ‘Logic of Conversation as Logic of Dialogue’, in R. Grandy and R. Warner (eds.)Philosophical Grounds of Rationality (Oxford: O.U.P.), 259–76.
Hirschberg, J.: 1985,A Theory of Scalar Implicature (dissertation, Department of Computer Science, University of Pennsylvania).
Holdcroft, D.: 1987, ‘Conversational Relevance’, in J. Verschueren and M. Bertuccelli-Papi (eds.),The Pragmatic Perspective: Selected Papers from the 1985 International Pragmatics Conference (Amsterdam: Benjamins), pp. 477–495.
Horn, L.: 1972,On the Semantic Properties of Logical Operators in English, Dissertation, UCLA.
Horn, L.: 1984, ‘Toward a New Taxonomy for Pragmatic Inference: Q-based and R-based Implicature’, in D. Schiffrin (ed.),Meaning, Form and Use in Context: Linguistic Applications’, (Georgetown University Roundtable).
Horn, L.: 1989,A Natural History of Negation (Chicago: University of Chicago Press).
Jeffrey, R.: 1983,The Logic of Decision, 2nd Edition (Chicago: University of Chicago Press).
Kasher, A.: 1976, ‘Conversational Maxims and Rationality’, in A. Kasher (ed.),Language in Focus (Dordrecht: D. Reidel), pp. 197–216.
Kasher, A.: 1977, ‘Foundations of Philosophical Pragmatics’, in R. Butts and J. Hintikka (eds.),Basic Problems in Methodology and Linguistics (Dordrecht: D. Reidel), 225–42.
Kempson, R.: 1975,Presupposition and the Delimitation of Semantics (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
Levinson, S. C.: 1983,Pragmatics (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
Levinson, S. C.: 1987, ‘Minimization and Conversational Inference’, in J. Verschueren and M. Bertuccelli-Papi (eds.),The Pragmatic Perspective: Selected Papers from the 1985 International Pragmatics Conference (Amsterdam: Benjamins), pp. 61–130.
Lewis, D.: 1969,Convention: A Philosophical Study (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press).
Lewis, D.: 1979, ‘Scorekeeping in a Language Game’, in hisPhilosophical Papers, Vol. I (Oxford: O.U.P., 1983).
Litman, D. and J. Allen: 1987, ‘A Plan Recognition Model for Subdialogues in Conversations’,Cognitive Science 11, 163–200.
Martinich, A. P.: 1983,Communication and Reference (Berlin: de Gruyter).
Mackenzie: 1984, ‘Begging the Question in Dialogue’,Australasian Journal of Philosophy 62.
McCawley, J. D.: 1978, ‘Conversational Implicature and the Lexicon’, in P. Cole (ed.),Syntax and Semantics 9: Pragmatics (New York: Academic Press), pp. 245–59.
Manor, R.: 1981, ‘Dialogues and the Logics of Questions and Answers’,Linguistische Berichte 73.
McCafferty, A.: 1987,Reasoning About Implicature: A Plan-Based Approach (Dissertation, Department of Philosophy, University of Pittsburgh).
O'Hair, S. G.: 1969, ‘Meaning and Implication’,Theoria 35, 38–54.
Parikh, P.: 1991, ‘Communication and Strategic Discourse’,Linguistics and Philosophy 14, 473–514.
Parikh, P.: 1992, ‘A Game Theoretic Account of Implicature’, in Y. Moses (ed.),Theoretical Aspects of Reasoning About Knowledge IV (San Mateo: Morgan Kaufmann), pp. 85–93.
Payne, S.: 1951,The Art of Asking Questions (Princeton, NJ: Frinceton University Press).
Sadock, J.: 1978, ‘On Testing for Conversational Implicature’, in P. Cole (1978)Syntax and Semantics 9: Pragmatics (New York: Academic Press), 281–98.
Sampson, G.: 1982, ‘The Economics of Conversation: Comments on Joshi's Paper’, in Smith (ed.),Mutual Knowledge (London: Academic Press).
Sperber, D., and D. Wilson: 1986,Relevance: Communication and Cognition (Oxford: Blackwell).
Strawson, P. F.: 1952,Introduction to Logical Theory (London: Methuen).
Thomson, J. J.: 1990,The Realm of Rights (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press).
Walton, D.: 1985, ‘New Directions in the Logic of Dialogue’,Synthese 63.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Green, M.S. Quantity, volubility, and some varieties of discourse. Linguist Philos 18, 83–112 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00984962
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00984962