Abstract
Engaging a listener’s trust imposes moral demands upon a presenter in respect of truthtelling and completeness. An agent lies by an utterance that satisfies what are herein defined as signal and mendacity conditions; an agent deceives when, in satisfaction of those conditions, the agent’s utterances contribute to a false belief or thwart a true one. I advert to how we may fool ourselves in observation and in the perception of our originality. Communication with others depends upon a convention or practice of presumed nonuniversal truthfulness. In support of an asserted duty of nondeceptiveness, I offer a reconciliation of pertinent Kantian passages, a sketch of arguments within utilitarianism, contractarianism, and other views, and an account arguing for application of that duty to assertions, implicatures, omissions, equivocation, prevarication, and sophistry insofar as they affect listeners’ doxastic states. For scholarship, this duty is exceptionless. I describe the kernel of intellectual honesty as a virtuous disposition such that when presented with an incentive to deceive, the agent will not deceive. Intellectual honesty delivers candor when it counts. I contrast this with complementary virtues and the surpassing virtue of ingenuousness. An account is given of the connection between intellectual honesty and an influential physical model of integrity.
Similar content being viewed by others
Reference
R. Adams (1999) Finite and Infinite Goods Oxford University Press Oxford
American Association of University Professors: 1989, ‘Statement on Plagiarism’.
Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics, in McKeon, R.: 1968, The Basic Works of Aristotle, Random House, New York.
Aristotle, Sophistical Refutations, trans. Forster, E.: 1955, Loeb Classical Library, vol. 3, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
K. Arrow (1972) The Limits of Organization Norton New York
S. Bok (1978) Lying Random House New York
W. Broad N. Wade (1993) ‘Self-deception and Gullibility’ R. Bulger E. Heitman S. Reiser (Eds) The Ethical Dimensions of the Biological Sciences Cambridge University Press Cambridge
C. Calhoun (1995) ArticleTitle‘Standing for Something’ Journal of Philosophy 92 235–260
R. Chisholm T. Feehan (1977) ArticleTitle‘The Intent to Deceive’ Journal of Philosophy 74 143–159
S. Darwall (1988) ‘Self-Deception, Autonomy, and Moral Constitution’ B. McLaughlin A. Rorty (Eds) Perspectives on Self-Deception University of California Press Berkeley
D. Davidson (1980) ‘Mental Events’. in Essays on Actions and Events Oxford University Press Oxford
D. Davidson (1984) Inquiries into Truth and Interpretation Oxford University Press Oxford
B. Davis (2002) ArticleTitle‘The Scientist’s World’ Microbiology and Molecular Biology Reviews 64 1–12
R. Feynman (1986) Surely You’re Joking, Mr Feynman! Bantam New York
G. Geison (1995) The Private Science of Louis Pasteur Princeton University Press Princeton
B. Glass (1993) ‘The Ethical Basis of Science’ R. Bulger E. Heitman S. Reiser (Eds) The Ethical Dimensions of the Biological Sciences Cambridge University Press Cambridge
P. Grice (1989) Studies in the Way of Words Harvard University Press Cambridge
L. Guenin (1999) ArticleTitle‘Expressing a Consensus on Candour’ Nature 402 577–578 Occurrence Handle10.1038/45068
L. Guenin (2001) ArticleTitle‘Morals and Primordials’ Science 292 1659–1660 Occurrence Handle10.1126/science.1062513
R. Hare (1997) ‘Could Kant Have Been a Utilitarian?’. in Sorting Out Ethics Oxford University Press Oxford
R. Harrod (1936) ArticleTitle‘Utilitarianism Revised’ Mind 45 137–156
J. Harsanyi (1982) ‘Morality and the Theory of Rational Behavior’ A. Sen B. Williams (Eds) Utilitarianism and Beyond Cambridge University Press Cambridge
B. Herman (1993) The Practice of Moral Judgment Harvard University Press Cambridge
Homer, The Illiad, trans. Lattimore, R.: 1951, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
R. Hursthouse (1999) On Virtue Oxford University Press Oxford
A. Jonsen S. Toulmin (1988) The Abuse of Casuistry University of California Press Berkeley
Kant I., Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals; The Doctrine of Virtue. Part II of The Metaphysics of Morals; Critique of Practical Reason; and ‘On a Supposed Right to Lie from Altruistic Motives’. in Gregor M., trans., ed., (1996), The Cambridge Edition of the Works of Immanuel Kant, Practical Philosophy, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
I. Kant (1997) Lectures on Ethics P. Heath J. Schneewind (Eds) The Cambridge Edition of the Works of Immanuel Kant, Lectures on Ethics Cambridge University Press Cambridge
Kant, I., The Conflict of the Faculties, trans. Gregor, M.: 1979, Abaris Books, New York.
P. Kitcher (1991) ‘Persuasion’ M. Pera W. Shea (Eds) Persuading Science : The Art of Scientific Rhetoric Science History Publications Canton, MA
P. Kitcher (1982) Abusing Science MIT Press Cambridge
C. Korsgaard (1996) Creating the Kingdom of Ends Cambridge University Press Cambridge
C.I. Lewis (1955) The Ground and the Nature of the Right Columbia University Press New York
D. Lewis (1969) Convention Harvard University Press Cambridge
Lewis D., (1983), ‘Languages and Language’. in Philosophical Papers, vol. 1, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
A. MacIntyre (1995) ‘Truthfulness, Lies, and Moral Philosophers: What Can We Learn from Mill and Kant?’ G. Peterson (Eds) The Tanner Lectures on Human Values NumberInSeries16 University of Utah Press Salt Lake City
L. McFall (1987) ArticleTitle‘Integrity’ Ethics 98 5–20 Occurrence Handle10.1086/292912
Mill, J.S., (1861), Utilitarianism, ed. In: Piest, O.: (1957), Bobbs Merrill, Indianapolis.
Plato, Apology; Gorgias; Laws; and Protagoras, in Hamilton E., Cairns H., eds., (1961), Plato, Collected Dialogues Princeton University Press, Princeton.
Plato, The Republic, trans. Cornford, F.: 1945, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
W.V. Quine (1970) Philosophy of Logic Prentice-Hall Englewood Cliffs, N.J
J. Rawls (1971) A Theory of Justice Harvard University Press Cambridge
J. Rawls (1993) Political Liberalism Columbia University Press New York
Rawls J., (2000), Lectures on the History of Moral Philosophy, ed. Herman B., Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
W. Riordan (1963) Plunkitt of Tammany Hall E. P. Dutton New York
W.D. Ross (1930) The Right and the Good Oxford University Press Oxford
T. Scanlon (1998) What We Owe to Each Other Harvard University Press Cambridge
T. Scanlon (2002) ArticleTitle‘Reasons, Responsibility, and Reliance: Replies to Wallace, Dworkin, and Deigh’ Ethics 112 507–528 Occurrence Handle10.1086/339221
H. Sidgwick (1907) The Methods of Ethics EditionNumber7 Macmillan London
E. Sober (1994) ‘The Primacy of Truthtelling and the Evolution of Lying’. in From a Biological Point of View Oxford University Press Oxford
Taylor G., (1981), ‘Integrity’. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society Supplement LV, 143–159.
L. Trilling (1972) Sincerity and Authenticity Harvard University Press Cambridge
D. Vines (1999) ‘Integrity and the Economy’ A. Montefiore D. Vines (Eds) Integrity in the Public and Private Domains Routledge London
G. Vlastos (1991) ‘Does Socrates Cheat?’. ch. 5 of Socrates, Ironist and Moral Philosopher Cornell University Press Ithaca
A. Walker (1978) ArticleTitle‘The Ideal of Sincerity’ Mind 87 481–497
G. Warnock (1971) The Object of Morality Methuen & Co London
B. Williams (1973) ‘A Critique of Utilitarianism’ B. Williams J. Smart (Eds) Utilitarianism For and Against Cambridge University Press Cambridge
Williams B., (1981), ‘Persons, Character, and Morality’. in Moral Luck, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
B. Williams (2002) Truth and Truthfulness Princeton University Press Princeton
P. Winch (1972) Ethics and Action Routledge and Kegan Paul London
A. Wood (1999) Kant’s Ethical Thought Cambridge University Press Cambridge
A. Wood (2002a) ‘What is Kantian Ethics?’ A. Wood (Eds) Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals Yale University Press New Haven
A. Wood (2002b) ‘W. K. Clifford and the Ethics of Belief’. in Unsettling Obligations CSLI Publications Stanford
Wood A., (2004), ‘The Duty to Believe According to the Evidence’ (unpublished ms.).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Guenin, L.M. Intellectual Honesty. Synthese 145, 177–232 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-005-3746-3
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-005-3746-3