Abstract
After more than three centuries, Molyneux's question continues to challenge our understanding of cognition and perceptual systems. Locke, the original recipient of the question, approached it as a theoretical exercise relevant to long-standing philosophical issues, such as nativism, the possibility of common sensibles, and the empiricism-rationalism debate. However, philosophers were quick to adopt the experimentalist's stance as soon as they became aware of recoveries from congenital blindness through ophtalmic surgery. Such recoveries were widely reported to support empiricist positions, suggesting that the question had found its empirical answer. Contrary to this common view, we argue that studies of patients recovering from early blindness through surgery cannot provide an answer. In fact, because of the very nature of such ophtalmological interventions it is impossible to test the question in the empirical conditions outlined by Molyneux. Thus we propose that Molyneux's question be treated as an early thought experiment of a specific kind. Although thought experiments of this kind cannot be turned into actual experimental conditions, they provide a conceptual restructuring of theories. Such restructuring in turn leads to new predictions that can then be tested by “normal” experiments. In accord with this interpretation, we show that Molyneux's question can be analyzed into a hierarchy of specific questions about vision in its phenomenal and sensory-motor components. Some of these questions do lead to actual experimental conditions that could be studied empirically.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ackroyd, C., Humphrey, N. K., and Warrington, E. K. 1974. Lasting effects of early blindness a case study. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 26: 114–124.
Aglioti, S., De Souza, J. F., and Goodale, M. A. 1995. Size contrast illusions deceive the eye but not the hand. Current Biology 5: 679–685.
Bach-Y-Rita, P. 1972. Brain Mechanisms in Sensory Substitution System. New York: Academic Press.
Bach-Y-Rita, P. 1997. Substitution sensorielle et qualia. In: J. Proust (ed), Perception et intermodalité, pp. 81–100. Paris: Puf.
Bach-Y-Rita, P., Collins, C. C., Saunders, F., and Scadden, L. 1969. Vision substitution by tactile image projection. Nature 221: 963–964.
Bach-Y-Rita, P., Kaczmarek, K. A., Tyler, M. E., and Garcia-Lara, M. 1998. Form perception with a 49-point electrotactile stimulus array on the tongue: A technical note. Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development 35: 427–430.
Banissoni, M., Ponzo, E., and Valvo, A. 1967. Percezione strutturata e trasposizione di forme nelle prime esperienze visive di un cieco dai primi mesi di vita operato in età adulta di osteo-odonto-cheratoprotesi di Strampelli. Annuale di Oftalmologia e Clinica Oculistica 93: 1153–1188.
Banissoni, M., Ponzo, E., and Valvo, A. 1968. Prime esperienze visive di tre cieche dalla nascita operate in età adulta di osteo-odonto-cheratoprotesi di Strampelli: percezione strutturata e trasposizione di forme. Annuale di Oftalmologia e Clinica Oculistica 94: 903–925.
Beale, J. M. and Keil, F. C. 1995. Categorical effects in the perception of faces. Cognition 57: 217–239.
Berkeley, G. 1709. In: G. Berkeley (ed), Essays Towards a New Theory of Vision. The works of George Berkeley. London: Nelson and Sons, 1948.
Bianchi, C., Brancato, R., and Bandello F. 1995. Manuale di oftalmologia essenziale. Milano: Ghedini Editore.
Bonomi, L., 1998. Manuale pratico di oftalmologia. Verona: Protei.
Boullier, D. R. 1737. Essai philosophique sur l'âme des betes. Amsterdam: F. Changuion.
Bower, T. 1974. Development in Infancy. San Francisco: Freeman.
Brindley, G. S. and Lewin, W. S. 1968. The sensations produced by electrical stimulation of the visual cortex. Journal of Physiololgy 196: 479–493.
Brown, J. R. 1991. Laboratory of the Mind: Thought Experiments in the Natural Sciences. London: Routledge.
Bruner, J. S. 1957. On perceptual readiness. Psychological Review 64: 123–148.
Bruno, N. 2001. When does action resist visual illusion? Trends in Cognitive Sciences 5: 379–382.
Caviness, J. A. 1964. Visual and Tactual Perception of Solid Shape. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY.
Chase, V. 2000. First bionic eyes: blind patients receive replacement retina. Technology Review 28.
Cheselden, W. 1728. An account of some observations made by a young gentleman, who was born blind, or lost his sight so early, that he had no Remembrance of ever having seen, and was couch'd between 13 and 14 years of age. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 35: 447–450.
Clark, A. 1997. Being There: Putting Brain, Body and World Together Again. Cambridge MA: MIT Press.
Condillac, E. 1746. Essai sur l'origine des connaissances humaines. Paris: Alive, 1998.
Condillac, E. 1754. Traité des sensations. In oeuvres complètes, vol. III, pp. 1–327. Paris: Badouin frères, 1827.
Cronly-Dillon, J., Persaud K., and Gregory, R. P. F. 1999. The perception of visual images encoded in musical form: a study in cross modality information transfert. The Royal Society 266: 2427–2433.
Cronly-Dillom, J., Persaud, K., and Blore R. 2000. Blind subjects construct conscious mental images of visual scenes encoded in musical form. The Royal Society 267: 2231–2238.
Degenaar, M. 1996. Molyneux's Problem: Three Centuries of Discussion on the Perception of Forms. London: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Diderot, D. 1749. Lettre aux aveugles (à l'usage de ceux qui voient). Paris: Garnier Flammarion, 1972.
Dobelle, W. H. 2000. Artificial vision for the blind by connecting a television camera to the visual cortex. Asaio Journal 46: 3–9.
Evans, G. 1985. Collected Papers. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Fine I., Smallman H. S., Doyle P., and MacLeod, D. (in press). Visual function before and after the removal of bilateral congenital cataracts in adulthood. Vision Research.
Franklin, A 1986. Neglect of Experiment. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Franz, W. H. 2001. Action does not resist visual illusions. Trends in Cognitive Sciences5: 457–459.
Gallagher, S. 1996. First Perception: A New Solution to the Molyneux Problem. In: Proceedings of the New York State Philosophical Association. Syracuse, New York; revised version in S. Gallagher (in press). How the Body Shapes the Mind. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Gibson, E. 1969. Principles of Perceptual Learning and Development. New York: Appleton.
Gibson, J. J. 1979. The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception. Boston: Houghton Mifflin
Gooding, D., Pinch, T. and Shaffer, S. 1989. The Use of Experiment. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Gregory, R. 1974. Concepts and Mechanisms of Perception. London: Gerald Duckworth.
Helmholtz, H. von. 1856. Handbuch der physiologischen Optik. Hamburg und Leipzig: Leopold Voss.
Horowitz, T. and Massey, G. 1991. Thought Experiments in Science and Philosophy. Savage, MD: Rowman and Littlefield.
Hutcheson, C. 1728. Original letter from Dr. Francis Hutcheson to William Mace, Professor at Gresham College, 6 September 1727. European Magazine and London Review 14 (1788): 158–160.
James, W. 1890. The Principles of Psychology. New York: Dover, 1950.
Jeannerod, M. 1988. The Neural and Behavioural Organization of Goal-Directed Movements. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Jurin, J. 1738. Dr. Jurin's solution of Molyneux's problem. In R. Smith, A Compleat System of Opticks in Four Books, viz a Popular, a Mathematical, a Mechanical and a Philosophical Treatise: to which are added remarks upon the hole, vol.2, pp. 27–29. Cambridge: Printed for the Author and Sold there by C. Crownfield.
Kaczmarek, K. A., Tyler, M., and Bach-Y-Rita, P. 1997. Pattern identification on a fingertipscanned electrotactile display. Proceedings of the 19th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society, pp. 1694–1697.
La Mettrie, J. 1745. L'histoire naturelle de l'âme. In: Oeuvres philosophiques. New York: Hidesheim-Verlag 1970.
Leibniz, G. 1765. Nouveaux essais sur l'entendement humain. Paris: PUF 1961.
Leibniz, G. 1687. Nouvelles republique des lettres. Amsterdam: Desbordes.
Locke, J. 1688. Extrait d'un livre anglais qui n'est pas encore publié, intitulé Essai philosophique concernant l'entendement, où l'on montre quelle est l'étendue de nos connaissances certaines, et la manière dont nous y parvenons. Bibliotèque universelle et Historique 8: 49–142.
Locke, J. 1694. An Essay Concerning Human Understanding. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1979.
Locke, J. 1978. The Correspondence of John Locke. Oxford: Clarendon.
Marteniuk, R. G., Leavitt,. J. L., MacKenzie, C. L., and Athenes, S. 1990. Functional relationship between grasp and transport components in a prehension task. Human Movement Science 9: 149–176.
Meltzoff, A. and Borton, R. 1979. Intermodal matching by human neonates. Nature 282: 403–404.
Milner, A. D. and Goodale, M. A. 1995. The Visual Brain in Action. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Molyneux, W. 1692. Dioptrica Nova: A treatise of Dioptricks, in Two Parts, Wherein the Various Effects and Appearances of Spherick Glasses, Both Convex and Concave, Single and Combined, in Telescopes and Microscopes, Together with their Usefulness in many Concerns of Humane Life, are Explained. London: B. Tooke.
Morgan, M. J. 1977. Molyneux's Question: Vision Touch and the Philosophy of Perception. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Neisser, U. 1976. Cognition and Reality. Principles and Implications of Cognitive Psychology. San Francisco, W.H. Freeman and Company.
Parrish, R. K. 2002. Atlante di Oftalmologia. Padova: Piccin.
Peachey, N. S., and Chow, A. Y. 1999. Subretinal implantation of semiconductor-based photodiodes: progress and challenges. Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development 36: 371–376.
Piaget, J. 1952. The Origins of Intelligence in Children. NewYork: International University Press.
Reid, T. 1764. Inquiry into the Human Mind. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 1997.
Rock, I. 1983. The Logic of Perception. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Sacks, O. 1995. An Anthropologist on Mars: Seven Paradoxical Tales. New York: Alfred A Knopf.
Senden, M. von. 1932. Raum-und Gestaltauffassung bei operierten Blindgeborenen. Leipzig: Barth. English trans. by D. Heath, Space and Sight. London: Methuen, 1960.
Smallman, H. S., Fine, I., and MacLeod, D. 2000. Pre-and post-operative characterization of visual function after the removal of bilateral congenital cataracts in adulthood. Society for Neuroscience Abstracts 17: 825.
Sorensen, R. 1992. Thought Experiments. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Strampelli, B. 1963. Keratoprosthesis with osteodontal tissue. American Journal of Ophthalmology 89: 1029–1039.
Streri, A. 1987. Tactile discriminaion of shape and intermodal transfer in 2-to 3-month old infants. British Journal of Development Psychology 2: 287–294.
Streri, A. 1991. Voir atteindre toucher. Les relations entre la vision et le toucher dans le bébé. Paris: PUF.
Streri, A. and Molina, M. 1993. Visual and tactual transfer between objects and pictures in 2-month-old infants. Perception 22: 1299–1318.
Synge, E. 1693. A Gentleman's Religion. London: A. and J. Churchill and R. Sare.
Torii, S. and Mochizuki, T. 1995. Post-surgery perception of subjective contour figures in the case of the congenitally blind. Japanese Psychological Research 37: 146–157.
Umezu, H., Torii, S. and Uemura, Y. 1975. Post-operative formation of visual perception in the early blind. An International Journal of Psychology in the Orient 18: 171–186.
Valvo, A. 1968. Possibilità e limiti di recupero visivo, nella cecità congenita, ed in quella giovanile della durata di circa mezzo secolo, dopo l'operazione di osteo-odonto-cheratoprotesi di Strampelli. Annuale di Oftalmologia e Clinica Oculistica 12: 1587–1610.
Voltaire. 1740. Elements de philosophie de Newton. In: Voltaire, Oeuvres completes, vol 15, pp. 183–652. Oxford: Alden Press, 1992.
Werner, H. 1973. Comparative Psychology of Mental Development. New York: International Press.
Wilson, M. 2002. Six tenets for embodied cognition. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review 9: 625–636.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Jacomuzzi, A.C., Kobau, P. & Bruno, N. Molyneux' question redux. Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 2, 255–280 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1023/B:PHEN.0000007370.68536.2d
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/B:PHEN.0000007370.68536.2d