Abstract
A proper understanding of the Sufi doctrine of the unity of existence is essential for following the later developments of Islamic philosophy. The doctrine of the unity of existence is divided into introversive and extroversive aspects, the former dealing with the unity of the soul of the mystic with God, and the latter with the unity of the cosmos with God. Here this latter aspect of the doctrine is explained through a comparison of the views of Ibn ‘Arabi and Meister Eckhart, both of whom are profoundly influenced by Ibn Sina at precisely the same crucial points, although Meister Eckhart makes explicit reference to Ibn Sina, while Ibn ‘Arabi generally avoids naming him. The theory of the extroversive unity of existence consists of four parts, or rather, it is the product of four steps, each of which is logically based on the previous one: (1) God is the only being or the absolute existence. (2) Everything other than God (i. e., human beings and the cosmos) is nothing or nonexistence. (3) The existence of all things is God’s existence (All are He). (4) The cosmos does not have existence but manifests existence. In other words, it is God’s self-disclosure.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Levine (1994), 46.
Otto (1976), 33.
Affifi (1366/1987), 34–5.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), vol. II, 360.
Rumi, Mathnvi, I/6 02, quoted by Mulla Sadra (1379/2000), vol. 2, 334.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), II/540.
Fox (1991), 84.
Meister Eckhart from McGinn (1986), 95.
Meister Eckhart from Blakney (1993), 171.
Blakney (1993), 171.
Ex. 3:13–14.
Fox (1991), 172.
McGinn (1986), 49.
John, 8:12.
Fox (1991), 152.
Qur’an (20:12).
Sulami (1369/1990), 42.
Otto (1976), 25.
McGinn (1986), 166.
Tobin (1986), 38.
Copleston (1963), vol. 3, part 1, 197.
Nasafi (1344/1965), 153.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), III/429.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), II/56.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), II/69.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), II/114.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), II/516.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), II/563.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), IV/89.
See Kakaie (2001), 117–119.
Chittick (1981), 172.
Sells (1994), 88.
Chittick (1991), 60.
Izutsu (1971), 38.
Literally, the Necessary of Existence, i.e., that which is necessary with respect to existence. [Ed]
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), I/415.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), III/46.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), I/703.
McGinn (1986), 95.
Ibn Sina(1376/1997), 367.
Ibn Sina (1376/1997), 370.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), III/545.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), IV/6.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), I/45.
McGinn (1986), 61.
Eckhart (1974), 83.
Ibn Sina (1376/1997), 380–381.
Eckhart (1974), 83.
Ibn Sina (1376/1997), 394.
McGinn (1986), 54.
McGinn (1986), 48.
“Anitas” is the Latinization of Ibn Sina’s anniyyah, is-ness, or individual existence. (Ed)
Ibn Sina (1376/1997), 367.
Eckhart (1974), 108.
Aquinas (1971), vol. 1, 16–17.
Caputo (1978), 220.
Aquinas (1971), vol. 1, 16–17.
Caputo (1978), 220.
Otto (1976), 25.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), I/328.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), III/566.
Tobin (1986), 22.
Otto (1976), 25.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), III/545.
McGinn (1986), 181.
McGinn (1986), 281.
Eckhart (1974), 85–86.
Chittick (1998), 12.
Tobin (1986), 39.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), IV/40.
Qur’an (53:9).
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), IV/40.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), I/406.
Ibn Sina (1376/1997), 268.
Ibn Sina (1376/1997), 364.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), III/255.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), I/279.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), III/47.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), II/55.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), II/99.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), II/99.
Davis (1988), 44.
Schürmann (1978), 287.
Schürmann (1978), 288.
McGinn (1986), 293.
Fox (1991), 293.
Copleston (1963), 201.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), III/537.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), III/384.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), II/309.
McGinn (1986), 51.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), III/398.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), III/547.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), II/519.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), III/386.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), III/410.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), I/592.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), II/272.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), IV/146.
Tobin (1986), 39.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1366/1987), 96.
Tobin (1986), 39.
Deut. 6:4.
Eckhart (1994), 266.
Eckhart (1994), 250.
Gal. 3:20.
McGinn (1986), 166.
Eckhart (1974), 78.
Ex. 3:14.
McGinn (1986), 208.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), III/307.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), IV/81.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), II/70.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), II/216.
Blakney (1993), 148.
Otto (1976), 80.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), III/403–4.
Stace, (1961), 64.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), I/633.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), II/454.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), III/516.
Ibn Sina (1376/1997), 364.
Tobin (1986), 48.
Tobin (1986), 47.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), II/216.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), II/216.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1366/1987), 255.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), I/435.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), II/484.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), I/702.
Izutsu (1983), 147.
Izutsu (1983), 153.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), III/516.
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911), III/227.
References
Affifi A (1366/1987) Ta’liqatun ‘ala Fusus al-Hikam. Zahra, Tehran
Aquinas T (1971) The summa theologiae, tr. Fathers of English Dominican, University of Chicago, Chicago
Blakney RB (1993) Meister Eckhart, A Modern Translation. Harper and Brothers, New York
Caputo J (1978) Fundamental themes in Meister Eckhart’s mysticism. The Thomist 42(2):197–225
Chittick WC (1981) Sadr al-Din Qunawi on the oneness of being. Int Phil Q 21:171–184
Chittick WC (1991) Ibn Arabi and his school, in Nasr (1991) 49–79
Chittick WC (1998) The self-disclosure of God. SUNY Press, Albany
Clark JM (2001) Eckhart. Encyclopedia Britannica 7
Copleston F (1963) A history of philosophy. Image Books, New York
Davis O (1988) God within. Paulist Press, New York
Eckhart M (1974) Parisian questions and prologues, translated by A Armand Maurer, Toronto
Eckhart M (1994) Selected writings, translated, Oliver Davis, Penguin Books, London
Fox M (1991) Breakthrough, Meister Eckhart’s creation spirituality. Image Books, New York
Ibn ‘Arabi (1911) al-Futuhat al-Makkiyya, Dar Sadir, Beirut, reprinted from Cairo edition
Ibn ‘Arabi (1366/1987) Fusus al-Hikam, A Affifi (ed) Zahra, Tehran
Ibn ‘Arabi (1366/1988) The bezels of wisdom, tr., RWJ Austin, Suhail, Lahore
Ibn Sina (1376/1997) Al-ilahiyyat min kitab al-shifa, Hasan Hasanzade Amuli (ed), Daftar Tabilighat, Qom
Izutsu T (1971) An analysis of Wahdat al-Wujud. in Toshihiko Izutsu, The concept and reality of existence, Tokyo
Izutsu T (1983) Sufism and taoism. University of California Press, Berkeley
Kakaie G (2001) A study of Ibn ‘Arabi’s school of thought. J Religious Thought, 6, Shiraz University, pp 115–140
Levine MPE (1994) Pantheism. Routledge, London
McGinn B (1986) Meister Eckhart, teacher and preacher. Paulist Press, New York
Mulla Sadra (1379/2000) Hikmat al-muta‘aliyyah. Mustafavi, Qom
Nasafi ‘Abd al-’Aziz (1344/1965) Kashf al-Haqa’iq, Mahadvi Damaghnai (ed) Tehran
Nasr SH (ed) (1991) Islamic spirituality. Cross Road, New York
Otto R (1976) Mysticism, East and West, tr. BL Bracey, RC Payne, Macmillan, New York
Sells MA (1994) Mystical lanuages of unsaying. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Schürmann R (1978) The loss of the origin in Soto Zen and in Meister Eckhart. The Thomist 42:281–312
Stace WT (1961) Mysticism and philosophy. Macmillan, London
Sulami Abu ‘Abd al-Rahman (1369/1990) Majmu’i-ye Athar-e Sulami, edited by Nasrullah Pourjavadi, Markaz-e Nashr-e Daneshgahi, Tehran
Tobin F (1986) Meister Eckhart, Thought and language, University of Pennsylvania Press
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
This paper has been written in English by the author and submitted for publication in Topoi.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kakaie, G. The extroversive unity of existence from Ibn ‘Arabi’s and Meister Eckhart’s viewpoints. Topoi 26, 177–189 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11245-007-9019-7
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11245-007-9019-7