Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-42gr6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-23T09:20:52.629Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Electoral Rights beyond Territory and beyond Citizenship? The Case of South Korea

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  30 October 2009

KONRAD KALICKI
KONRAD KALICKI*
Affiliation:
The University of British Columbia, Canadakkalicki@interchange.ubc.ca
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Current world migration is disrupting conceptual boundaries of national democratic polities. One area where the traditional sense of political community is being challenged concerns electoral rights for non-resident citizens and non-citizen residents. With the right to vote being an ultimate expression of political membership in a democratic nation-state, any debates about these two groups’ suffrage rights constitute a critical source of empirical insights into how democracies re-imagine themselves away from fixed identities under the pressure of globalization. In view of this, this paper examines the understudied case of South Korea, utilizing the most systematic theoretical framework currently available: one developed by Rainer Bauböck. It provides direct empirical evidence that undermines the conventional wisdom that Koreans define their polity purely on the basis of their ethnicity. Contrary to our expectations, a close scrutiny of the Korean debates in question reveals ample references to the civic ideals of political community. The line of reasoning that emphasizes duties towards the welfare of the polity has produced powerful justifications for denying political franchise to overseas compatriots, while granting limited electoral rights to qualified resident foreigners. A broader implication of this empirical finding is that it highlights a fundamental limitation of Bauböck's theoretical framework: it conceives political franchise only as an expression of people's rights in regard to law-making. The case of South Korea, thus, suggests that Bauböck's scheme should be modified to address both the rights-based logics and the somewhat obsolete duty-based logic of franchise extension.

Type
Research Article
Information
Japanese Journal of Political Science , Volume 10 , Issue 3 , December 2009 , pp. 289 - 311
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2009

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Ahn, H.L. (2007a), ‘Overseas Koreans Lobby for Suffrage’, Korea Herald, 17 April: 2.Google Scholar
Ahn, H.L. (2007b), ‘Momentum Builds for Overseas Koreans’ Suffrage’, Korea Herald, 24 April: 4.Google Scholar
Ahn, H.L. (2007c), ‘Voting Rights Belong to all Citizens’, Korea Herald, 24 April: 4.Google Scholar
Ahn, H.L. (2007d), ‘Court Backs Suffrage for Overseas Koreans: Current Laws to Remain Effective until 2009 to Avoid Legal Confusion’, Korea Herald, 29 June: 1, 15.Google Scholar
Bartolini, S. (2000), ‘Franchise Expansion’, in Rose, R. (ed.), International Encyclopedia of Elections, Washington, DC: CQ Press, pp. 117–30.Google Scholar
Bauböck, R. (2005), ‘Expansive Citizenship – Voting Beyond Territory and Membership’, PS: Politics Science and Politics, 48 (4): 683–87.Google Scholar
Beckman, L. (2006), ‘Citizenship and Voting Rights: Should Resident Aliens Vote?’, Citizenship Studies, 10 (2): 153–65.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Beckman, L. (2007), ‘Who Should Vote? Conceptualizing Universal Suffrage in Studies of Democracy’, Democratization, 15 (1): 29–48.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Birch, S. (2009), Full Participation: A Comparative Study of Compulsory Voting, Tokyo, Japan; New York: United Nations University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Blais, A., Massoicotte, L., and Yoshinaka, A. (2001), ‘Deciding Who Has the Right to Vote: A Comparative Analysis of Election Laws’, Electoral Studies, 20: 41–62.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cho, C.U. (2006a), ‘Government Rejects Suffrage Calls from Overseas Koreans’, Korea Herald, 8 June: 3.Google Scholar
Cho, C.U. (2006b), ‘Overseas Korean Urge for Right to Vote’, Korea Herald, 7 June: 3.Google Scholar
Choe, S.C. (1999), ‘Move to Grant Foreign Residents Suffrage may Challenge Constitution’, Korea Herald, 6 April: 1, 2.Google Scholar
Choe, Y. (1997), How to Manage Free and Fair Elections: A Comparison of Korea, Sweden and the United Kingdom, Göteborg, Sweden: Göteborg University.Google Scholar
Chosun Ilbo Online (2006), ‘Overseas Koreans to be Given Chance to Vote’, 13 December, available on line at: http://english.chosun.com/w21data/html/news/200612/200612130011.htmlGoogle Scholar
Chung, I.S. (2006), Personal e-mail to author. ‘Re: Local Suffrage for Foreign Residents’, 27 January.Google Scholar
Coleman, K.J. (2004), ‘The Uniformed and Overseas Citizens Absentee Voting Act: Background and Issues’, in Avaliktos, N. (ed.), The Election Process Revisited, New York: Nova Science Publishers, pp. 149–56.Google Scholar
Dahl, R.A. (1982), Dilemmas of Pluralist Democracy, New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Dahl, R.A. (1989), Democracy and Its Critics, New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
Earnest, D.C. (2004), ‘Voting Rights for Resident Aliens: Nationalism, Postnationalism and Sovereignty in an Era of Mass Migration’, Ph.D. dissertation, George Washington University.Google Scholar
Earnest, D.C. (2005), ‘Political Incorporation and Historical Institutionalism: A Comparison of the Netherlands, Germany and Belgium’, paper delivered at the 46th Annual Convention of the International Studies Association, 1–5 March, Honolulu, Hawaii, available online at: http://www.odu.edu/~dearnest/pdfs/earnest_isa_2005_final.pdfGoogle Scholar
Earnest, D.C. (2006), ‘Neither Citizen nor Stranger: Why States Enfranchise Resident Aliens’, World Politics, 58 (2): 242–75.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fouser, R.J. (2000), ‘Rights of Resident Foreigners’, Korea Herald, 27 September: 6.Google Scholar
Grace, J. (2007), ‘External and absentee voting’, in Challenging the Norms and Standards of Elections Administration, Report: 35–57, available online at: http://www.ifes.org/publication/e5c04c69e4ee902399d9f63245f99b0e/IFES%20Challenging%20Election%20Norms%20and%20Standards%20WP.pdfGoogle Scholar
Greenfeld, L. (1992), Nationalism: Five Roads to Modernity, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
International IDEA (2006), ‘A Preview of the Forthcoming International IDEA Handbook on External Voting’, available on line at: http://www.idea.int/elections/upload/External_voting_Preview_withlayout_07june06_final.pdfGoogle Scholar
Jung, S.K. (2005), ‘GNP Head Promises Voting Rights for Ethnic Koreans’, Korea Times, 22 March: 4.Google Scholar
Kalicki, K. (2008), ‘Voting Rights of the “Marginal”: The Contested Logic of Political Membership in Japan’, Ethnopolitics, 7 (2/3): 265–86.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kalicki, K. (2009), ‘Ethnic Nationalism and Political Community: The Overseas Suffrage Debates in Japan and South Korea’, Asian Studies Review, 33 (2): 175–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Katz, R.S. (1997), Democracy and Elections, Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Katz, R.S. (2000), ‘Noncitizens and the Right to Vote’, in Rose, R. (ed.), International Encyclopedia of Elections, Washington, DC: CQ Press, p. 174.Google Scholar
Keyssar, A. (2000), The Right to Vote: The Contested History of Democracy in the United States, New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
Kil, S.H. (2001), ‘Development of Korean Politics – a Historical Profile’, in Kil, S.H. and Moon, C.I. (eds.), Understanding Korean Politics, Albany: State University of New York Press, pp. 33–69.Google Scholar
Kim, C.W. (2005), ‘Foreign Residents get Voting Rights in Cheju’, Korea Times, 28 July: 1.Google Scholar
Kim, H.J. (2002), ‘Politicians, Civic Leaders Support Suffrage for Overseas Ethnic Koreans’, Korea Herald, 8 February: 2.Google Scholar
Kim, K.H. (2003), ‘Bonds with Koreans Overseas: Foundation Head Recognizes Human Assets Abroad’, Korea Herald, 15 January: 3.Google Scholar
Kim, K.T. (2001), ‘Bill Calls for Granting Permanent Residency to Long-Term Foreigners’, Korea Times, 28 March: 1.Google Scholar
Kim, K.T. (2002a), ‘Gov't Urged to Allow Koreans Abroad to Cast Absentee Votes’, Korea Times, 8 February: 2.Google Scholar
Kim, K.T. (2002b), ‘20,000 Foreigners to be Given Suffrage in Local Elections’, Korea Times, 28 February: 2.Google Scholar
Kim, Y.B. (1999), ‘Gov't Mulls Foreigners’ Suffrage’, Korea Times, 10 September: 10.Google Scholar
Korea Herald (1999), ‘President Repeats Call to Grant Foreign Residents Voting Rights’, 26 March: 2.Google Scholar
Korea Herald (2002), ‘North Asia Needs Security Mechanism’, an interview with Lee Hoi-chang, 3 December: 2, 3.Google Scholar
Korea Times (1998), ‘Voting Rights for Koreans Overseas’, 21 September: 2.Google Scholar
Korea Times (2001), ‘MDP to Seek Voting Rights for Foreigners’, 6 February: 2.Google Scholar
Korea Times (2005), ‘More Foreigners to Get Permanent Residency Status’, 25–26 June: 2.Google Scholar
Korea Times (2007), ‘Extending Voting Rights: It's Time to Work Out Details on Suffrage for Koreans Abroad’, 30 June–1 July: 6.Google Scholar
Kousser, J.M. (2000), ‘Poll Tax’, in Rose, R. (ed.), International Encyclopedia of Elections, Washington, DC: CQ Press, pp. 208–9.Google Scholar
Kwak, Y.S. (2002), ‘Front-Runners’ Economic Policies Focus on High Growth’, Korea Herald, 7 December: 2.Google Scholar
Lardy, H. (1997), ‘Citizenship and the Right to Vote’, Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, 17: 75–100.Google Scholar
Lee, C.S. (1999), ‘Kim Calls for Law Revision for Resident Foreigners’ Suffrage’, Korea Times, 26 March: 1.Google Scholar
Lee, J.W. (2005), ‘Overseas Koreans Call for Voting Rights in Local Elections’, Korea Times, 31 March: 2.Google Scholar
Lee, S.Y. (2005), ‘Korean-Americans Want to Vote in Homeland Elections’, Korea Herald, 14 July: 4.Google Scholar
Lee, H.Y. and Moon, J.Y. (2006), ‘Comparing Korean Liberalism with British Liberalism in Their Respective Roles in the Evolution of Democracy’, Korea Journal, 46 (2): 184–207.Google Scholar
López-Guerra, C. (2005), ‘Should Expatriates Vote?’, Journal of Political Philosophy, 13 (2): 216–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Maley, M. (2000), ‘Overseas Voting’, in Rose, R. (ed.), International Encyclopedia of Elections, Washington, DC: CQ Press, pp. 193–94.Google Scholar
Marshall, T.H. (1964), Class, Citizenship, and Social Development, New York: Doubleday & Company.Google Scholar
Moon, G.L. (2005), ‘Overseas Korean's Support Penalty on Draft Dodgers’, Korea Times, 15 July: 3.Google Scholar
Munck, G.L. and Verkuilen, Y. (2002), ‘Conceptualizing and Measuring Democracy: Evaluating Alternative Indices’, Comparative Political Studies, 35 (1): 5–34.Google Scholar
Park, C.A. (2006), ‘Myth of Pure-Blood Nationalism Blocks Multi-Ethnic Society’, Korea Times, 14 August: 1, 4.Google Scholar
Raskin, J.B. (1993), ‘Legal Aliens, Local Citizens: The Historical, Constitutional and Theoretical Meanings of Alien Suffrage’, University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 141 (4): 1391–470.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rokkan, S. (1970), Citizens, Elections, Parties: Approaches to the Comparative Study of the Process of Development, Oslo: Universitetsforlaget.Google Scholar
Ryu, J. (2006), ‘Koreans Abroad Can Cast Ballots in Elections’, Korea Times, 14 December: 4.Google Scholar
Seo, D.S. (2005), ‘Overseas Koreans Given Absentee Voting Rights’, Korea Times, 3 February: 2.Google Scholar
Seo, J.Y. (2004), ‘Foreign Investors May Get Green Cards’, Korea Times, 11 August: 1.Google Scholar
Shin, G.W. (2005), ‘Asianism and Korea's Politics of Identity’, Inter-Asia Cultural Studies, 6 (4): 616–30.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shin, G.W. (2006a), Ethnic Nationalism in Korea: Genealogy, Politics, and Legacy, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shin, G.W. (2006b), ‘Ethnic Pride Source of Prejudice, Discrimination’, Korea Herald, 3 August: 4.Google Scholar
Shin, G.W. (2007), ‘Korea Faces Challenges of Multiethnic Society’, Korea Herald, 16 July: 4.Google Scholar
Shin, G.W. and Chang, P.Y. (2004), ‘The Politics of Nationalism in US–Korean Relations’, Asian Perspective, 28 (4): 119–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shin, G.W., Freda, J., and Yi, G. (1999), ‘The Politics of Ethnic Nationalism in Korea’, Nations and Nationalism, 5 (4): 465–84.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Shin, H.I. (2004), ‘Bill Proposes Voting by Overseas Koreans’, Korea Herald, 17 November: 3.Google Scholar
Shklar, J. N. (1991), American Citizenship: The Quest for Inclusion, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
Skrentny, J.D., Chan, S., Fox, J., and Kim, D. (2007), ‘Defining Nations in Asia and Europe: A Comparative Analysis of Ethnic Return Migration Policy’, International Migration Review, 41 (4): 793–825.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Spiro, P.J. (2006), ‘Perfecting Political Diaspora’, New York University Law Review, 81: 207–33.Google Scholar
Thomas, E.R. (2002), ‘Who Belongs? Competing Conceptions of Political Membership’, European Journal of Social Theory, 5 (3): 323–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Waldrauch, H. (2003), ‘Electoral Rights for Foreign Nationals: A Comparative Overview of Regulations in 36 Countries’, paper presented to conference entitled The Challenges of Immigration and Integration in the European Union and Australia, 18–20 February 2003, University of Sydney, Australia.Google Scholar
Wulf, S.J. (2008), A Philosophical Theory of Citizenship: Obligation, Authority, and Membership, Lanham, MD.: Lexington Books.Google Scholar
Yoo, J.S. (2000), ‘Regulations Keep Koreans Living Overseas from Casting Ballots’, Korea Herald, 6 April: 2, 9.Google Scholar