ABSTRACT
The connection between the probabilities of conditionals and the corresponding conditional probabilities has long been explored in the philosophical literature, but its implementation faces both technical obstacles and objections on empirical grounds. In this paper I ?rst outline the motivation for the probabilistic turn and Lewis’ triviality results, which stand in the way of what would seem to be its most straightforward implementation. I then focus on Richard Jeffrey’s ’random-variable’ approach, which circumvents these problems by giving up the notion that conditionals denote propositions in the usual sense. Even so, however, the random-variable approach makes counterintuitive predictions in simple cases of embedded conditionals. I propose to address this problem by enriching the model with an explicit representation of causal dependencies. The addition of such causal information not only remedies the shortcomings of Jeffrey’s conditional, but also opens up the possibility of a uni?ed probabilistic account of indicative and counterfactual conditionals.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
E. Adams (1965) ArticleTitle’The Logic of Conditionals’ Injury 8 166–197
E. Adams (1970) ArticleTitle’Subjunctive and Indicative Conditionals’ Foundations of Language 6 89–94
E. Adams (1975) The Logic of Conditionals Reidel Dordrecht
Adams, E.: 1976, ’Prior Probabilities and Counterfactual Conditionals’, in W. L. Harper and C. A. Hooker (1976), pp. 1– 21.
E. Adams (1998) A Primer of Probability Logic CSLI Publications Stanford
A.R. Anderson (1951) ArticleTitle’A Note on Subjunctive and Counterfactual Conditionals’ Analysis 12 35–38
Aristotelian Society: 1991, ’The Symposia Read at the Joint Session of the Aristotelian Society and the Mind Association at the University of Durham’, The Aristotelian Society, Supplementary Volume 65.
Aristotelian Society: 1995, ’Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society’, The Aristotelian Society, Supplementary Volume 69.
Athanasiadou, A. and R. Dirven (eds.): 1997, On Conditionals Again, Vol. 143 of Amsterdam Studies in the Theory and History of Linguistic Science, John Benjamins, Amsterdam/Philadelphia.
J.S. Barker (1998) ArticleTitle’Predetermination and Tense Probabilism’ Analysis 58 290–296 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-8284.00134
Barwise, J.: 1986, ’Conditionals and Conditional Information’, in E. C. Traugott et al. (1986), pp. 21– 54.
J. Bennett (1984) ArticleTitle’Counterfactuals and Temporal Direction’ The Philosophical Review 93 IssueID1 57–91
J. Bennett (1988) ArticleTitle’Farewell to the Phlogiston Theory of Conditionals’ Mind 97 IssueID388 509–527
J. Bennett (2003) A Philosophical Guide to Conditionals Oxford University Press Oxford
Braithwaite, R. B. (ed.): 1931, The Foundations of Mathematics and other Logical Essays, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London.
J.P. Burgess (1979) ArticleTitle’Logic and Time’ The Journal of Symbolic Logic 44 IssueID4 566–582
A. Cohen (2003) ’Probabilistic Approaches to Semantics’ R. Bod J. Hay S. Jannedy (Eds) Probabilistic Linguistics, Chap. 9 MIT Press Cambridge, MA 343–379
B. Comrie (1985) Tense Cambridge University Press Cambridge
Comrie, B.: 1986, ’Conditionals: A Typology’, in E. C. Traugott et al. (1986), pp. 77–99.
R.G. Cowell A.P. Dawid S.L. Lauritzen D.J. Spiegelhalter (1999) Probabilistic Networks and Expert Systems Springer New York
Dahl, O.: 1997, ’The Relation between Past Time Reference and Counterfactuality: A New Look’, in A. Athanasiadou and R. Dirven (1997), pp. 97–112.
B. Dancygier (1998) Conditionals and Prediction Cambridge University Press Cambridge
Davis, W. A. 1988, ’Probabilistic Theories of Causation’, in J. H. Fetzer (1988), pp. 133 – 160.
P.B. Downing (1959) ArticleTitle’Subjunctive Conditionals, Time Order, and Causation’ Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 59 125–140
V.H. Dudman (1984) ArticleTitle’Conditional Interpretations of If-sentences’ Australian Journal of Linguistics 4 143–204
V.H. Dudman (1988) ArticleTitle’Indicative and Subjunctive’ Analysis 48 IssueID3 113–122
V.H. Dudman (1994) ArticleTitle’On Conditionals’ Journal of Philosophy 91 113–128
D. Edgington (1986) ArticleTitle’Do Conditionals Have Truth Conditions?’ Critica 18 IssueID52 3–20
Edgington, D.: 1991, ’The Mystery of the Missing Matter of Fact’, in Aristotelian Society (1991), Supplementary Volume 65, pp. 185–209.
D. Edgington (1995) ArticleTitle’On Conditionals’ Mind 104 IssueID414 235–329
Eells, E. and B. Skyrms (eds.): 1994, Probabilities and Conditionals: Belief Revision and Rational Decision, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
B. Ellis (1978) ArticleTitle’A Unified Theory of Conditionals’ Journal of Philosophical Logic 7 107–124 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00245924
Fetzer, J. H. (ed.): 1988, Probability and Causality, Vol. 192 of Studies in Epistemology, Logic, Methodology, and Philosophy of Science, Reidel, Dordrecht.
K. Fine (1975) ArticleTitle’Review of Lewis (1973)’ Mind 84 451–458
K. Fintel Particlevon (1998) ’The Presupposition of Subjunctive Conditionals’ U. Sauerland O. Percus (Eds) The Interpretive Tract,Vol.25 of MIT Working Papers in Linguistics MIT Press Cambridge
S. Fleischman (1989) ArticleTitle’Temporal Distance: A Basic Linguistic Metaphor’ Studies in Language 13 IssueID1 1–50
van Frassen, B. C.: 1976, ’Probabilities of Conditionals’, in W. L. Harper and C. A. Hooker (1976), pp. 261 – 308.
van Fraassen, B. C.: 1981, ’A Temporal Framework for Conditionals and Chance’, in W.L. Harper et al. (1981), pp. 365 – 414.
W.-P. Funk (1985) ArticleTitle’On a Semantic Typology of Conditional Sentences’ Folia Linguistics 19 IssueID3/4 365–414
Gabbay, D. and F. Guenthner (eds.): 1984, Extensions of Classical Logic, Vol. 2 of Handbook of Philosophical Logic, Reidel, Dordrecht.
Galavotti, M. C., P. Suppes, and D. Costantini (eds.): 2001, Stochastic Causality,CSLI Publications, Stanford.
P. Gärdenfors (1982) ArticleTitle’Imaging and Conditionalization’ Journal of Philosophy 79 747–760
P. Gärdenfors (1988) Knowledge in Flux: Modeling the Dynamics of Epistemic States MIT Press Cambridge
Gibbard, A.: 1981, ’Two Recent Theories of Conditionals’, in W. L. Harper et al. (1981), pp. 211 s– 247.
N. Goodman (1947) ArticleTitle’The Problem of Counterfactual Conditionals’ The Journal of Philosophy 44 113–128
Grandy, R. E. and R. Warner (eds.): 1986, Philosophical Grounds of Rationality, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Hájek, A.: 1994, ’Triviality on the Cheap?’, in E. Eells and B. Skyrms (1994), pp. 113 – 140.
Hájek, A. and N. Hall: 1994, ’The Hypothesis of the Conditional Construal of Conditional Probability’, in E. Eells and B. Skyrms (1994), pp. 75 – 110.
Hall, N.: 1994, ’Back in the CCCP’, in E. Eells and B. Skyrms (1994), pp. 141 – 160.
Harper, W. L.: 1976, ’Rational Belief Change, Popper Functions, and Counterfactuals’, in W. L. Harper and C. A. Hooker (1976), pp. 73 – 115.
Harper, W. L.: 1981, ’A Sketch of Some Recent Developments in the Theory of Conditionals’, in W. L. Harper et al. (1981), pp. 3 – 38.
Harper, W. L. and C. A. Hooker (eds.): 1976, Foundations of Probability Theory, Statistical Inference, and Statistical Theories of Science, Vol. 1 ofThe University of Western Ontario Series in Philosophy of Science, Reidel, Dordrecht.
Harper, W. L., R. Stalnaker, and G. Pearce (eds.): 1981, Ifs: Conditionals, Belief, Decision, Chance, and Time, Reidel, Dordrecht.
D.M. Hausman (1998) Causal Asymmetries Cambridge University Press Cambridge
G. Hughes M. Cresswell (1996) A New Introduction to Modal Logic Routledge Oxford
S. Iatridou (2000) ArticleTitle’The Grammatical Ingredients of Counterfactuality’ Linguistic Inquiry 31 IssueID2 231–270 Occurrence Handle10.1162/002438900554352
F. Jackson (1979) ArticleTitle’On Assertion and Indicative Conditionals’ Philosophical Review 88 565–589
F. Jackson (1987) Conditionals Basil Blackwell Oxford
D. James (1982) ArticleTitle’Past Tense and the Hypothetical: A Cross-Linguistic Study’ Studies in Language 6 IssueID3 375–403
R.C. Jeffrey (1964) ArticleTitle’If’ Journal of Philosophy 61 702–703
Jeffrey, R. C. (ed.): 1980, Studies in Inductive Logic and Probability, Vol. 2, University of California Press.
Jeffrey, R. C.: 1991, ’Matter-of-fact Conditionals’, in Aristotelian Society (1991), Supplementary Volume 65, pp. 161–183.
L. Karttunen S. Peters (1979) ’Conventional Implicature’ C.-K. Oh D. Dinneen (Eds) Presupposition,Vol. 11 of Syntax and Semantics Academic Press New York 1–56
S. Kaufmann (2001a) ’Aspects of the Meaning and Use of Conditionals’, Ph.D. thesis Stanford University Stanford
S. Kaufmann (2001b) ’Probabilities of Conditionals’ R. Hastings B. Jackson Z. Zvolenszky (Eds) , Proceedings of SALT XI, held at New York University. CLC Publications Ithaca, NY 248–267
Kaufmann, S.: 2001c, ’Tense Probabilism Properly Conceived’, in R. van Rooy and M. Stokhof (eds.), Proceedings of the Thirteenth Amsterdam Colloquium, pp. 132 – 137.
Kaufmann, S.: 2004, ’Conditional Truth and Future Reference’, semanticsarchive.net.
A. Kratzer (1979) ’Conditional Necessity and Possibility’ U. Egli R. Bäuerle A. Stechow Particlevon (Eds) Semantics from Different Points of View Springer Berlin 117–147
A. Kratzer (1991) ’Conditionals’ A. Stechow Particlevon D. Wunderlich (Eds) Semantik: Ein internationals Handbuch der zeitgenössischen Forschung [=Semantics], de Gruyter Berlin/New York 651–656
M. Lance (1991) ArticleTitle’Probabilistic Dependence among Conditionals’ Philosophical Review 100 269–276
D. Lewis (1973) Counterfactuals Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA
D. Lewis (1976) ArticleTitle’Probabilities of Conditionals and Conditional Probabilities’ Philosophical Review 85 298–315
D. Lewis (1979) ArticleTitle’Counterfactual Dependence and Time’s Arrow’ Noûs 13 455–476
Lewis, D.: 1980, ’A Subjectivist’s Guide to Objective Chance’, in R. C. Jeffrey (1980), pp.263 – 293.
D. Lewis (1981) ArticleTitle’Ordering Semantics and Premise Semantics for Counterfactuals’ Journal of Philosophical Logic 10 IssueID2 217–234 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00248850
D. Lewis (1986) ArticleTitle’Probabilities of Conditionals and Conditional Probabilities II’ Philosophical Review 95 581–589
D. Lewis (1994) ArticleTitle’Humean Supervenience Debugged’ Mind 103 473–490
P. Mackie (1973) Truth, Probability and Paradox Clarendon Press Oxford
J. Mårtensson (1999) Subjunctive Conditionals and Time: A Defense of the Classical Approach, No. 10 in Acta Philosophica Gothoburgensia, Department of Philosophy University of Göteborg Göteborg
V. McGee (1989) ArticleTitle’Conditional Probabilities and Compounds of Conditionals’ The Philosophical Review 98 IssueID4 485–541
Mellor, D. H. (ed.): 1978, Foundations: Essays in Philosophy, Logic, Mathematics and Economics, Routledge and Kegan Paul, London.
Mellor, D. H. (ed.): 1990, Philosophical Papers: F. P. Ramsey, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
D.H. Mellor (1993) ArticleTitle’How to Believe a Conditional’ The Journal of Philosophy 90 233–248
P. Milne (1997) ArticleTitle’Bruno de Finetti and the Logic of Conditional Events’ British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 48 IssueID2 195–232 Occurrence Handle10.1093/bjps/48.2.195
D. Nute (1980) Topics in Conditional Logic Reidel Dordrecht
Nute, D.: 1984, ’Conditional Logic’, in D. Gabbay and F. Guenthner (1984), pp. 387 – 439.
F.R. Palmer (1983) ArticleTitle’Future Time Reference in the Conditional Protasis: A Comment on Comrie’ Australian Journal of Linguistics 3 241–243
J. Pearl (2000) Causality: Models, Reasoning, and Inference Cambridge University Press Cambridge
M. Pendlebury (1989) ArticleTitle’The Projection Strategy and the Truth Conditions of Conditional Statements’ Mind 98 IssueID390 179–205
A. Prior (1967) Past, Present and Future Oxford University Press Oxford
R. Quirk S. Greenbaum G. Leech J. Svartvik (1985) A Comprehensive Grammar of the English Language Longman London
Ramsey, F. P.: 1929, ’General Propositions and Causality’, printed in R. B. Braithwaite (1931), pp. 237 – 255, Meller (1978), pp. 133 – 151; Meller (1990), pp. 145 – 163.
Read, S.: 1995, ’Conditionals and the Ramsey Test’, in Aristotelian Society (1995), Supplementary Volume 69.
H. Reichenbach (1956) The Direction of Time University of Berkeley Press Berkeley/Los Angeles CA
C. Roberts (1989) ArticleTitle’Modal Subordination and Pronomial Anaphora in Discourse’ Linguistics and Philosophy 12 683–721 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00632602
van Rooy, R.: 1997, ’Attitudes and Changing Contexts’, Ph.D. thesis, Institut für maschinelle Sprachverarbeitung (Stuttgart).
Skyrms, B.: 1981, ’The Prior Propensity Account’, in W. L. Harper et al. (1981), pp. 259 – 265.
B. Skyrms (1984) Pragmatics and Empiricism Yale University Press New Haven/London
Skyrms, B.: 1988, ’Conditional Chance’, in J. H. Fetzer (1988), pp. 161 – 178.
Skyrms, B.: 1994, ’Adams Conditionals’, in E. Eells and B. Skyrms (1994), pp. 13 – 26.
M.A. Slote (1978) ArticleTitle’Time in Counterfactuals’ The Philosophical Review 87 IssueID1 3–27
P. Spirtes C. Glymour R. Scheines (2000) Causation, Prediction, and Search MIT Press Cambridge, MA
Spohn, W.: 2001, ’Bayesian Nets are All there is to Causal Dependence’, in M. C. Galavotti et al. (2001), pp. 157 – 172.
Stalnaker, R.: 1968, ’A Theory of Conditionals’, in Studies in Logical Theory, American Philosophical Quarterly, Monograph: 2, Blackwell, Oxford, pp. 98 – 112.
R. Stalnaker (1970) ArticleTitle’Probability and Conditionals’ Philosophy of Science 37 64–80 Occurrence Handle10.1086/288280
R. Stalnaker (1975) ArticleTitle’Indicative Conditionals’ Philosophia 5 269–286
Stalnaker, R.: 1976, ’Letter to van Fraassen’, in W. L. Harper and C. A. Hooker (1976), pp.302 – 306.
Stalnaker, R.: 1991, ’Letter to Richard Jeffrey’, included in Jeffrey (1991), pp. 178 – 183.
Stalnaker, R. and R. Jeffrey: 1994, ’Conditionals as Random Variables’, in E. Eells and B.Skyrms (1994), pp. 31– 46.
Strawson, P. F.: 1986, ’ ’If’ and ” ’, in R. E. Grandy and R. Warner (1986), pp. 229 – 242.
P. Suppes (1970) A Probabilistic Theory of Causality North Holland Amsterdam
P. Tedeschi (1981) ’Some Evidence for a Branching-Futures Semantic Model’ P. Tedeschi A. Zaenen (Eds) Tense and Aspect,Vol.14of Syntax and Semantics Academic Press New York 239–270
R.H. Thomason (1970) ArticleTitle’Indeterminist Time and Truth Value Gaps’ Theoria 36 264–281
Thomason, R. H.: 1984, ’Combinations of Tense and Modality’, in D. Gabbay and F.Guenthner (1984), pp. 135 – 165.
Thomason, R. H. and A. Gupta: 1981, ’A Theory of Conditionals in the Context of Branching Time’, in W. L. Harper et al. (1981), pp. 299 – 322.
P. Tichý (1976) ArticleTitle’A Counterexample to the Lewis-Stalnaker Analysis of Counterfactuals’ Philosophical Studies 29 271–273 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00411887
Traugott, E. C., A. ter Meulen, J. Snitzer Reilly, and C. A. Ferguson (eds.): 1986, On Conditionals, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Veltman, F.: 1976, ’Prejudices, Presuppositions and the Theory of Conditionals’, in J. Groenendijk and M. Stokhof (eds.), Proceedings of the First Amsterdam Colloquium [=Amsterdam Papers in Formal Grammar, Vol. 1], pp. 248 – 281.
F. Veltman (1985) ’Logics for Conditionals’, Ph.D. thesis University of Amsterdam Amsterdam
M. Woods (1997) Conditionals Clarendon Press Oxford
Woodward, J.: 2001, ’Probabilistic Causality, Direct Causes and Counterfactual Dependence’, in M. C. Galavotti et al. (2001), pp. 39 – 63.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
KAUFMANN, S. Conditional Predictions. Linguist Philos 28, 181–231 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10988-005-3731-9
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10988-005-3731-9