Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to briefly describe and compare the original goals and perspectives of both rhetoric and dialectic in theory and in practice. Dialectic is the practice and theory of conversations; rhetoric that of speeches. For theory of dialectic, this paper will turn to Aristotle's Topics and Sophistical Refutations; for theory of rhetoric, to his Rhetoric. Thus it will appear that rhetoric and dialectic are pretty close. Yet, on the other hand, there is a long tradition of mutual antagonism. The paper tries to summarize the common features of, as well as the differences between, the two. To get a taste of both dialectic and rhetoric in practice the reader is invited to enter the House of Callias, as we know it from Plato's Protagoras. After this visit there remains no doubt that rhetoric and dialectic are intertwined on the level of practice. Moreover, we may look forward to their integration on the level of theory.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Aristotle: 1965, On Sophistical Refutations, On Coming-to-be and Passing Away(translated by E.S. Forster), On the Cosmos(translated by D.J. Furley), Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA and William Heinemann, London (Loeb Classical Library). First printed 1955.
Aristotle: 1976, Posterior Analytics(translated by Hugh Tredennick), Topica(translated by E.S. Forster), Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA and William Heinemann, London (Loeb Classical Library). First printed 1960.
Aristotle: 1976a, Aristotelis Ars Rhetorica(Rudolf Kassel, ed.), Walter de Gruyter, Berlin and New York.
Aristotle: 1991, The 'Art' of Rhetoric(translated by John Henry Freese), Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA and William Heinemann, London (Loeb Classical Library). First published 1926.
Barth, Else M. and Erik C. W. Krabbe: 1982, From Axiom to Dialogue: A Philosophical Study of Logics and Argumentation, Walter de Gruyter, Berlin and New York.
Blair, J. Anthony: 1998, ‘The Limits of the Dialogue Model of Argument,' Argumentation 12, 325-339.
Bolton, Robert: 1994, ‘The Problem of Dialectical Reasoning in Aristotle’, Ancient Philosophy 14, 99-132.
Eemeren, Frans H. van and Rob Grootendorst: 1984, Speech Acts in Argumentative Discussions: A Theoretical Model for the Analysis of Discussions Directed towards Solving Conflicts of Opinion, Foris, Dordrecht and Cinnaminson.
Eemeren, Frans H. van and Rob Grootendorst: 1992, Argumentation, Communication, and Fallacies, Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ, Hove, and London.
Eemeren, Frans H. van and Peter Houtlosser: 1999, ‘Delivering the Goods in Critical Discussion’, in Frans H. van Eemeren, Rob Grootendorst, J. Anthony Blair and Charles A. Willard (eds.), Proceedings of the Fourth International Conference of the International Society for the Study of Argumentation, SIC SAT, Amsterdam, International Centre for the Study of Argumentation, pp. 163-167.
Eemeren, Frans H. van and Peter Houtlosser: 1999a, ‘William the Silent's Argumentative Discourse’, in Frans H. van Eemeren, Rob Grootendorst, J. Anthony Blair and Charles A. Willard (eds.), Proceedings of the Fourth International Conference of the International Society for the Study of Argumentation, SIC SAT, Amsterdam, International Centre for the Study of Argumentation, pp. 168-171.
Irwin, Terence H.: 1988, Aristotle's First Principles, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Plato: 1961, The Collected Dialogues of Plato Including the Letters(Edith Hamilton and Huntington Cairns, eds.), Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ (Bollingen Series 71).
Plato: 1965, Platonis Opera, III(John Burnet, ed.), Clarendon Press, Oxford. First published 1903.
Plato: 1991, Protagoras(transl. with notes by C.C.W. Taylor), Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Robinson, Richard: 1970, Plato's Earlier Dialectic, 2nd ed., Clarendon Press, Oxford. First publ. of 2nd ed. 1953.
Smith, Robin: 1993, ‘Aristotle on the Uses of Dialectic’, Synthese 96, 335-358.
Walton, Douglas N. and Erik C. W, Krabbe: 1995, Commitment in Dialogue: Basic Concepts of Interpersonal Reasoning, State University of New York Press, Albany, NY.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Krabbe, E.C.W. Meeting in the House of Callias: Rhetoric and Dialectic. Argumentation 14, 205–217 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1007888626395
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1007888626395