Abstract
This study addresses whether businesses discriminate against employees who smoke, which for the purposes of this study is called smokism. It began with a description of the employers’ costs which led to the development of these smoking bans and examined several company policies as a result of these costs. The viewpoints from several perspectives toward these policies and their perceptions about smokers were also reviewed. This was followed by surveying the corporate smoking policies of 76 companies representing 287 employees in the New York City metropolitan, as well as the viewpoints of these employees on these smoking policies. Several laws regarding the rights of smokers and nonsmokers were discussed and along with the company smoking policies described earlier were compared to those firms surveyed. Next, the philosophies of Locke, Kant, Rawls, and Nozick were examined to determine whether the current smoking policies would be deemed just or discriminatory. Conclusions and implications of this research then followed the analysis of these philosophical and legislative findings.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
American Lung Association: 2006, ‘State Legislated Actions on Tobacco Issues 2005’. Last accessed November 26, 2006. Available at http://slati.lungusa.org/reports/SLATI_05.pdf
A Smoker on Payroll Can Cost Firms up to $3,800: 2006, February 21, Buffalo News, LexisNexis, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed October 30, 2006. Available at http://ezproxy.sunyrockland.edu:2053/universe/doclist?_m=84f9c2e911a9a9f58820c1ac7b19f535&wchp=dGLbVzW-zSkVb&_md5=ab08127e004d6dff01e236f81c350636
Cadrain, D.: June 2004, ‘Smoking and the Workplace Laws Ensnaring HR’, HR Magazine, 49(6), 38–39. Business Source Premier, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed October 20, 2006. Available at http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=buh&AN=13301444&site=bsi-live)
Chafee, J.: 2005, The Philosopher’s Way: Thinking Critically About Profound Ideas (Pearson Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ)
Christie, L.: 2005 March 11, ‘New Ways to Get Fired’, CNNMoney.com Website. Last accessed November 25, 2006. Available at http://money.cnn.com/2005/03/11/pf/companiescrackdown/index.htm
Cornell, L.: 2006, ‘Smokers Paying for Their Habit’, The Journal News (February 20), 11C
Cornwell, L.: 2006, February 20, ‘At Work, Smokers Hit Where It Hurts: More Firms Charge Higher Health Premiums’, Houston Chronicle, 1. ProQuest, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed November 20, 2006. Available at http://proquest.umi.com/pqdweb?did=990522841&sid=3&Fmt=3&clientId=52717&RQT=309&VName=PQD
DelPo, A.: 2006, ‘Smoking in the Workplace’, Nolo Lawyers Website. Last accessed December 12, 2006. Available at http://www.nolo.com/article.cfm/pg/1/objectId/5622E54E-CA6F-4494-B1138C4BE5D0FD32/catId/F2C14D23-A0D0-47A8-BC16CAF780AB47BF/104/150/299/ART
Douville J. 1990, Active and Passive Smoking Hazards in the Workplace. Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, NY
Drake, L.: 2005, August, ‘Employers can do More for Smokers’, HR Magazine, AllBusiness.com Website. Last accessed November 11, 2006. Available at http://www.allbusiness.com/public-administration/administration-human/508031-1.html
Ezra, D. B.: 1993, Summer, Tennessee Law Review, 60 Tenn. L. Rev. 905, Lexis-Nexis, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY
Fahmy, S.: 2005, November 19, ‘Many Companies Charging Smokers More on Insurance’, Action on Smoking and Health Website. Last accessed December 3, 2006. Available at http://www.ash.org/no-smoking/nov05/11-21-05-1.html
Farrelly, M. C., W. N. Evans and E. S. Sfekas: 1999, March, ‘The Impact of Workplace Smoking Bans: Results from a National Survey’, Tobacco Control 8, 272–277. Tobacco Control Online Website. Last accessed December 3, 2006. Available at http://tc.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/8/3/272#SEC1
Friedman, S. and L. Chagala: 2006, September, ‘Penalizing Applicants and Employees for Smoking: A Potential Smoking Gun?’ Employee Benefit Plan Review 61(3), 7–9, LexisNexis, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed December 10, 2006. Available at http://ezproxy.sunyrockland.edu:2320/ehost/pdf?vid=29&hid=19&sid=46404410-defb-4282-96b5-bf609efe4c62%40sessionmgr8
Gasper v. Louisiana Stadium & Exposition District: 1979, January 8, Supreme Court of the United States, 439 U.S. 1073, LexisNexis, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed December 9, 2006. Available at http://ezproxy.sunyrockland.edu:2053/universe/document?M=3c6635abd4feddf4f4a3e302dd0c0b91&_docnum=3&wchp=dGLbVtb-zSkVA&_md5=3c668c49197c8c27beec40b30cd48ee7
Goodin R. E. 1989, No Smoking. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL
Grusendorf v. Oklahoma City, No. 85–1807: 1987, April 17, United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, 816 F.2d 539; 1987 U.S. App., LexisNexis, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed December 9, 2006. Available at http://ezproxy.sunyrockland.edu:2053/universe/doclist?M=3e19dc5dc1719987f0e5682bc05d9f55_&wchp=dGLbVtb-zSkVb&_md5=6e2854f6ff78fe44df1252dc8d998e73
Gurchiek, K.: 2005, January, ‘Study: Smoking Ban Improved Air’, HR Magazine, 50(1), Business Source Permier, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed October 20, 2006. Available at http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=buh&AN=15611445&site=bsi-live
Hennessy, M.: 2006 February, ‘Right to Smoke?’ CFO, 22(3), 54. Business Source Premier, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed October 20, 2006. Available at http://web.ebscohost.com
Hoffman, K. B.: 2005, February 8, ‘Workers Told no Smoking, Even if It’s at Home’, Associated Press State and Local Wire, LexisNexis, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed November 11, 2006. Available at http://ezproxy.sunyrockland.edu:2053/universe/document?_m=21d79142bb7b6ba06e25e34541e42eb0&_docnum=1&wchp=dGLzVlz-zSkVb&_md5=004894906234ab3f8792767a9b8e78da
How Much Does It Cost: 2006, National Association for Health Underwriters Website. Last accessed November 30, 2006. Available at http://www.nahu.org/consumer/DI-Cost.pdf
Kant, I.: 1784/1997, Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals, 2nd Edition, L. W. Beck (trans.) (Prentice Hall Incorporated, Upper Saddle River, NJ)
Kinsman, M.: 2005, February 20, ‘More Employers Looking into Workers’ Off-Duty Activities’, The San Diego Union-Tribune, Business, H2, LexisNexis, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed December 9, 2006. Available at http://ezproxy.sunyrockland.edu:2053/universe/document?_m=e49a1bddaa3a90846cb0628db9adea273&_docnum=1&wchp=dGLbVtb-418cd318d3eee004a5b3323dd6
Legislative Briefing Kit: Lifestyle Discrimination in the Workplace: 1998 (December 31), American Civil Liberties Union Website. Last accessed October 3, 2006. Available at http://www.aclu.org/workpalcerights/gen/13388res19981231.html
Lifestyle Discrimination: Employer Control of Legal Off Duty Employee Activities: 2005, (National Workrights Institute, Princeton, New Jersey). Last accessed October 7, 2006. Available at http://www.workrights.org/issue_lifestyle/ldbrief2.pdf
Lifestyle Discrimination in the Workplace: Your Right To Privacy Under Attack: 1998, December 31, American Civil Liberties Union Website. Last accessed October 9, 2006. Available at http://www.aclu.org/workplacerights/gen/13384res19981231/html
Locke, J.: 1690/1952, in T. P. Peardon (ed.), ‘Of the State of Nature’, The Second Treatise of Government (The Bobbs-Merrill Company, New York, NY)
McCabe v. Workers’ Compensation Appeal Board (Department of Revenue): 1999, 738 A. 2d503, LexisNexis, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed December 11, 2006. Available at http://ezproxy.sunyrockland.edu:2053/universe/document?_m=6f6c5184c4b38bf65cf271d3c8d1a841&_docnum=2&wchp=dGLbVtb-zSkVb&_md5=b86cfe8e40459ccbc3159b89d594ddc
McCabe v. Workers Compensation Appeal Board (Department of Revenue): 2002, September 5, 806 A. 2d 512; Pa. Commw., LexisNexis, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed December 11, 2006. Available at http://ezproxy.sunyrockland.edu:2053/universe/document?_m=6f6c5184c4b38bf65cf271d3c8d1a841&_docnum=1&wchp=dGLbVtb-zSkVb&_md5=61915897a03a5f41ff4a7c46d1844f43
McGrath, M.: 2006, ‘Smoking Surcharge may be Omen for Other Lifestyle Choice’, The Idaho Statesman (January 1). Lexus Nexis Academic. Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed April 9, 2006. Available at http://ezproxy.sunyrockland.edu
McShulskis, E.: 1996, June, ‘Smoke-Free Workplaces Prevalent’, HR Magazine 41(6), 118. Business Source Premier, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed November 24, 2006. Available at http://ezproxy.sunyrockland.edu:2320/bsi/detail?vid=20&hid=114&sid=17e21e59-49db-49cc-a862-70d76f6836c4%40sessionmgr109
Miller, J. L., et al.: 1993, April, ‘Employer Restrictions on Employees’ Legal Off-Duty Conduct’, Labor Law Journal 44(4), 208–219. Business Source Premier, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed November 11, 2006. Available at http://ezproxy.sunyrockland.edu:2320/bsi/pdf?vid=62&hid=4&sid=c6a749cf-8446-4b0d-82ec-5d33e48cfae6%40SRCSM2
More Employers Eyeing No-Smoker Hiring Policies: 2005, Benefits Management Strategies, LLC Newsletter for June 2005. Last accessed October 19, 2006. Available at␣http://www.b-m-s.net/Newsletters/newsletter0506.html
Naidoff, C.: 1991, September-October, ‘Do you Mind if I Smoke?’ Industrial Management, AllBusiness.com. Last accessed November 11, 2006. Available at http://www.allbusiness.com/human-resources/workplace-health-safety/266385-1.html
National Health Interview Survey: 2006, September 28, National Center for Health Statistics. Current Smoking Figure 8.1. Last accessed November 27, 2006. Available at http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nhis/earlyrelease/200609_08.pdf
New Law Protects New York Employees from Discrimination Based on Legal-Off Duty Conduct: 1992 (October 1), Kauff, McClain & McGuire, LLP website. Last accessed October 19, 2006. Available at http://www.kmm.com/archived-article.html?id=33
Nixon J. C., J. West 1989, The Ethics of Smoking Policies. Journal of Business Ethics, 8, 409–414
Nocera, J.: 2006, June 18, ‘If It’s Good for Philip Morris, Can It also be Good for Public Health?’, New York Times, Magazine Section, 46–78
Nozick, R.: 1974, Anarchy, State, and Utopia (Basic Books Incorporated, New York, New York)
Ong, M. and Glantz, S. A.: 2005, June, ‘Free Nicotine Replacement Therapy Programs vs. Implementing Smoke-Free Workplaces: A Cost Effectiveness Comparison’, American Journal of Public Health 95(6), Business Source Premier, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed December 2, 2006. Available at http://ezproxy.sunyrockland.edu:2320/bsi/detail?vid=8&hid=16&sid=880512e8-251a-4d0c-adc8-55cface12703%40sessionmgr2
Ozuls, J. B.: 2005, February 24, ‘A Job or Cigarette?’, Newsweek, Last accessed November 3, 2006. Available at http://www.workrights.org/in_the_news/in_the_news_newsweek.html
Paul R. J., J. B. Townsend 1998, Smoking in the Workplace: Balancing Smoker and Nonsmoker Rights. Employee and Responsibilities and Rights Journal, 11(2), 117–133
Pickney, B.: 2005, July 1, ‘Employers Act to Curb Costs Associated with Smoking’, The Business Review. Last accessed October 20, 2006. Available at http://albany.bizjournals.com/albany.stories/2005/07/04/story1.html?t=printable
Powell, C.: 2006, November 12, ‘Employers Crack Down on Smoking’, Beacon Journal. Last accessed November 20, 2006. Available at http://www.ohio.com/mld/ohio/15994257.htm?template=contentModules/printstory.jsp
Pulliam, L.: 1993, Winter, ‘Smoking in the Workplace: Developing A Policy that Works for your Company’, Employee Relations Law Journal, 19(3), 279–286, LegalTracThomsonGale, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed accessed September 12, 2006. Available at (http://find.galegroup.com/itxinfomark.do?&contentSet=IAC-documents&type=retrieve&tabID=T002&prodID=LT&docID=A147098398&source=tale&srcprod=LT&userGroupName=rocklandcc&version=1.0
Rawls J. 1999, A Theory of Justice. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts
Rives, A. L.: 2006, April, ‘You’re not the Boss of me: A Call for Federal Lifestyle Discrimination Legislation’, The George Washington University Law Review 533, LexisNexusAcademic, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed November 4, 2006. Available at http://ezproxy.sunyrockland.edu:2053/universe/document?_m=b28e3b5bd2bc2e14ed0c1048c431c2bc&_docnum=15&wchp=dGLzVzz-zSkVA&_md5=95bf02b3398fabf4537e46552773c357
Ryan, J., et al.: 1992, January, ‘Occupational Risks Associated with Cigarette Smoking: A Prospective Study’, American Journal of Public Health 82(1), 29–32, Business Source Premier, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed November 11, 2006. Available at http://ezproxy.sunyrockland.edu:2320/bsi/pdf?vid=62&hid=4&sid=c6a749cf-8446-4b0d-82ec-5d33e48cfae6%40SRCSM2
Schauffler, H. H.: 1993, September, ‘Integrating Smoking Control Policies into Employee Benefits: A Survey of Large California Corporations’, American Journal of Public Health 83(9), 1226–1230, Business Source Premier, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed November 20, 2006. Available at http://ezproxy.sunyrockland.edu:2320/bsi/detail?vid=20&hid=120&sid=30e70dac-0a43-4b87-8ab6-9b1023f0a937%40sessionmgr106
Schreffler, T.: 2005, August, ‘Smoking Employees’ Jobs Go up in Flames’, Kansas Employment Law Letter, 12(5), LexisNexus, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed October 3, 2006. Available at lexisnexis@prod.lexisnexis.com
SearchLung USA, Smoking Policies in the Workplace Fact Sheet: 2006, August, American LungAssociation Website. Last accessed November 9, 2006. Available at http://www.lungusa.org/site/apps/s/content.asp?c=dvLUK9O0E&b=34706&ct=66704
Shaw, W. H. and V. Barry: 2007, Moral Issues in Business, 10th Edition (Wadsworth/Thomson Learning, Belmont, CA)
Should Smokers Pay Extra for Health Insurance: 2006, March 4, Insurelane March 2006, 2(3), Newsletter. Insurelane Website. Last accessed November 20, 2006. Available at http://www.insurelane.com/newsletter/mar06/should-smokers-pay.html
State Legislated Actions on Tobacco Issues: 2006, American Lung Association Website. Last accessed December 5, 2006. Available at http://slati.lungusa.org/StateLegislateAction.asp
Sugarman, S. D.: 2003, ‘Lifestyle Discrimination in Employment’, Berkeley Journal of Employment and Labor Law, 377, LexisNexis Academic, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed November 4, 2006. Available at http://ezproxy.sunyrockland.edu:2053/universe/document?_m=49ae09427db213a1217e14e08e4b0915&_docnum=1&wchp=dGLzVzz-zSkVA&_md5=a0ff8cb4326956fa9bd1e46acc0c0f40
The Cost of Smoking: 2006, The Cost of Smoking Website. Last accessed November 19, 2006. Available at http://www.costofsmoking.com
The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPPA): 2004, December, Fact Sheet, U.S. Department of Labor. Last accessed December 10, 2006. Available at http://www.dol.gov/ebsa/newsroom/fshipaa.html
Velasquez, M. G.: 2002, Business Ethics: Concepts and Cases, 5th Edition (Prentice-Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ)
Warner, D. M.: 1994, June, ‘We do not Hire Smokers: May Employers Discriminate Against NonSmokers’, Employee Responsibilities and Rights Journal 7(2), 129–140, Business Source Premier, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed November 11, 2006. Available at http://ezproxy.sunyrockland.edu:2320/bsi/pdf?vid=119&hid=4&sid=c6a749cf-8446-4b0d-82ec-5d33e48cfae6%40SRCSM2
Wempe, B 2005, In Defense of a Self-Disciplined, Domain-Specific Social Contract Theory Of Business Ethics. Business Ethics Quarterly 15(1), 113–135
Wolff, J. 1991, Robert Nozick Property, Justice, and the Minimal State. Stanford University Press, Stanford, California
Worker Protection in New York State: 2006, New York State Department of Labor. Last accessed December 1, 2006. Available at http://www.labor.state.ny.us/workforceindustrydata/PDFs/worker_protection_eng.pdf
Workplace Smoking: How Far Should You Go?: 2005, June, Managing Benefits Plans 5(6), 2–3, Business Source Premier, Rockland Community College, Suffern, NY. Last accessed November 20, 2006. Available at http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=buh&AN=17238101&site=bsi-live
Workplace Smoking Policies: A Balancing Act: 2001, Personnel Policy Service Incorporated Website. Last accessed December 4, 2006. Available at http://www.publishers.com/smokingpoloicylycos.htm
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lecker, M.J. The Smoking Penalty: Distributive Justice or Smokism?. J Bus Ethics 84 (Suppl 1), 47–64 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-008-9691-6
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-008-9691-6