Abstract
It is sometimes objected that we cannot adopt skepticism about moral responsibility, because the criminal justice system plays an indispensable social function. In this paper, I examine the implications of moral responsibility skepticism for the punishment of those convicted of crime, with special attention to recent arguments by Saul Smilansky. Smilansky claims that the skeptic is committed to fully compensating the incarcerated for their detention, and that this compensation would both be too costly to be practical and would remove the deterrent function from incarceration. I argue that the skeptic is not committed to full compensation of the offender, and that the costs of such compensation would in any case be far smaller than Smilansky thinks. In fact, I claim, the costs of the criminal justice system to which the skeptic is committed might be very much lower than the costs – economic, social and moral – we currently pay as a consequence of our system of punishment.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Brown v Plata, ‘Supreme Court of the United States’ (2011): No. 09-1233.
Butler, Tony and Allnutt, Stephen, Mental Illness Among New South Wales Prisoners (NSW Corrections Health Service, 2003). http://www.justicehealth.nsw.gov.au/publications/Mental_Illness_Among_NSW_Prisoners_2003.pdf. Accessed 17 Aug 2011.
CASA (The National Center on Addiction and Substance Abuse at Columbia University), Behind Bars II: Substance Abuse and America’s Prison Population (2010). http://www.casacolumbia.org/download.aspx?path=/UploadedFiles/tw0t55j5.pdf. Accessed 17 Aug 2011.
Coid, Jeremy W., ‘The Management of Dangerous Psychopaths in Prison’. In Millon, T. and Birket-Smith, M. (eds.), Psychopathy: Antisocial, Criminal, and Violent Behavior (New York: Guilford Press, 1998), pp. 431–547.
Fred Feldman, Utilitarianism, Hedonism, and Desert: Essays in Moral Philosophy (Cambridge University Press, New York, 1997).
Robert D. Hare, Leslie M. McPherson and Adelle E. Forth, “Male psychopaths and their criminal careers”, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 56 (5) (1988): 710-714.
David. M. Kennedy, Deterrence and Crime Prevention: Reconsidering the prospect of sanction (London: Routledge, 2008).
Kleiman, Mark, When Brute Force Fails (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2009)
Langan, Patrick A., and Levin, David J., ‘Recidivism of Prisoners Released in 1994’. Bureau of Justice Statistics (2002). http://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/pub/pdf/rpr94.pdf. Accessed 4 Jan 2012.
Neil Levy, “The Responsibility of the Psychopath Revisited”, Philosophy, Psychiatry & Psychology 14 (2) (2007): pp. 129-138.
Neil Levy, “Psychopathy, Responsibility and the Moral/Conventional Distinction”, in L. Malatesti and J. McMillan (eds.) Responsibility and Psychopathy (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2010), pp. 213-226.
Neil Levy and Michael McKenna, “Recent Work on Free Will and Moral Responsibility”, Philosophy Compass 4 (1) (2009): 96-133.
Derk Pereboom, “Meaning in Life Without Free Will”, Philosophic Exchange 33 (2002): 19-34.
Pizarro, Jesenia M., Stenius, Vanja M. K., and Pratt, Travis C., ‘Supermax Prisons: Myths, Realities, and the Politics of Punishment in American Society’, Criminal Justice Policy Review 17 (2006): 6–21
T.M. Scanlon, Moral Dimensions: Permissibility, Meaning, Blame (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2008).
Ralph C. Serin, “Violent recidivism in criminal psychopaths”, Law and Human Behavior 20 (2) (1996): pp. 207-217.
Randall G. Shelden and William B. Brown, Criminal Justice in America: A Critical View (Boston: Allyn and Bacon, 2004).
Saul Smilansky, “Hard Determinism and Punishment: A Practical Reductio”, Law and Philosophy 30 (3) (2011): pp. 353-367.
Matthew Talbert, “Blame And Responsiveness To Moral Reasons: Are Psychopaths Blameworthy?”, Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 89 (4) (2008): 516-535.
Turbyfill, Diane, ‘Bank Robber Planned Crime and Punishment’. Gaston Gazette June 16 2011. http://www.gastongazette.com/news/bank-58397-richard-hailed.html. Accessed 11 Jan 2012.
Jan van Dijk, John van Kesteren and Paul Smit, Criminal Victimisation in International Perspective, Key findings from the 2004-2005 ICVS and EU ICS (The Hague, Boom Legal Publishers, 2008).
Vilhauer, Benjamin, ‘Persons, Punishment, and Free Will Skepticism’ Philosophical Studies. doi:10.1007/s11098-011-9752-z.
Franklin E. Zimring, The Great American Crime Decline (New York: Oxford University Press, 2007).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Levy, N. Skepticism and Sanction: The Benefits of Rejecting Moral Responsibility. Law and Philos 31, 477–493 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10982-012-9128-3
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10982-012-9128-3