Abstract
Considering the instability of nonlinear dynamics, the deductive inference rule Modus ponens itself is not enough to guarantee the validity of reasoning sequences in the real physical world, and similar results cannot necessarily be obtained from similar causes. Some kind of stability hypothesis should be added in order to draw meaningful conclusions. Hence, the uncertainty of deductive inference appears to be like that of inductive inference, and the asymmetry between deduction and induction becomes unrecognizable such as to undermine the basis for the fundamental cleavage between analytic truth and synthetic truth, as W. V. O. Quine pointed out. Induction is not inferior to deduction from a pragmatic point of view.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Birkhoff, G. D, Surface Transformation and Their Dynamics Application, Acta Mathematica 43, 1922
Born, M., Natural Philosophy of Cause and Chance, London: Oxford University Press, 1949
Brillouin, L., Scientific Uncertainty, and Information, New York and London: Academic Press, 1964
Carroll, L., What the Tortoise Said to Achilles, Mind 4, 1895
Feigl, H., Notes on Causality, in H. Feigl and M. Brodbeck (ed.), Readings in the Philosophy of Science, New York: Appleton-Century-Frofts, 1953
Gleick, J., Chaos: Making a New Science, New York: Viking, 1987
Harman, P.M., Edinburgh Philosophy and Cambridge Physics: the Natural Philosophy of James Clerk Maxwell, in P. M. Harman (ed.), Wranglers and Physicists, Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1985
Healey, R.A., Causation, Robustness, and EPR, Philosophy of Science 59, 1992
Hume, David, An Inquiry Concerning Human Understanding, Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrili, 1955 [1748]
Hunt, B. R. and J.A. Yorke, Maxwell on Chaos, Nonlinear Science Today 3, 1993
Jackson, E.A., Perspectives of Nonlinear Dynamics, Vol. 2, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990
Kampen, N. G. V., Some Theoretical Aspects of Noise, in M, Van Vliet (ed.), Noise in Physical Systems, Singapore: World Scientific, 1987
Kellert, S. H., In the Wake of Chaos, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1994
Kostelich, E.J., Uncertain Determinism, Nature 365, 1993
Levinson, N.A., A Second Order Differential Equation with Singular Solutions, Annals of Mathematics 50, 1945
Li, T. Y. and J. A. Yorke, Period Three Implies Chaos, American Mathematical Monthly 82, 1975
Liu, H. J., The Semantics and Philosophy of Chaos, Changsha: Hunan Education Press, 1998
Lorenz, E. N., Deterministic Nonperiodic Flow, Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences 20, 1963
Mar, G. and P. Grim, Pattern and Chaos: New Images in the Sementics of Paradox, Nous 25, 1991
Maxwell, J.C., Essay for the Eranus Club on Science and Free Will (11 February 1873), in P. M. Harman (ed.), The Scientific Letters and Papers of James Clerk Maxwell, Vol. II, Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press, 1995 [1873]
van der Pol, B. and J. van der Mark, Frequency Demultiplication, Nature 120, 1927
Smith, P., Explaining Chaos, Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press, 1998
Szabó, L. E., Formal Systems as Physical Objects: a Physicalist Account of Mathematical Truth, International Studies in the Philosophy of Science 17, 2003
Winnie, J. A., Computable Chaos, Philosophy of Science 59, 1992
Zhao, Kaihua, Zhu, Zhaoxuan. and Huang, Yongnian., Introduction of Nonlinear Physics, Beijing: Center for Nonlinear Science, 1992
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
About this article
Cite this article
Liu, H. Instability, Modus ponens and uncertainty of deduction. Front. Philos. China 1, 658–674 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11466-006-0030-7
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11466-006-0030-7