Abstract
In the problem of the relationship between chemistry and physics, many authors take for granted the ontological reduction of the chemical world to the world of physics. The autonomy of chemistry is usually defended on the basis of the failure of epistemological reduction: not all chemical concepts and laws can be derived from the theoretical framework of physics. The main aim of this paper is to argue that this line of argumentation is not strong enough for eliminate the idea of a hierarchical dependence of chemistry with respect to physics. The rejection of the secondary position of chemistry and the defense of the legitimacy of the philosophy of chemistry require a radically different philosophical perspective that denies not only epistemological reduction but also ontological reduction. Only on the basis of a philosophically grounded ontological pluralism it is possible to accept the ontological autonomy of the chemical world and, with this, to reverse the traditional idea of the ‘superiority’ of physics in the context of natural sciences.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
H. Atmanspacher (2002) Determinism is Ontic, Determinability is Epistemic H. Atmanspacher R. Bishop (Eds) Between Chance and Choice: Interdisciplinary Perspectives on Determinism Imprint-Academic Thorverton, England 49–74
H. Atmanspacher and F. Kronz. Many Realisms. In G. Farre and T. Oksala (Eds.), Acta Polytechnica Scandinavica 91: 31–43, 1998.
R. Batterman (2002) The Devil in the Details, Asymptotic Reasoning in Explanation, Reduction, and Emergence Oxford University Press Oxford
T. Benfey (2000) ArticleTitleReflections on the Philosophy of Chemistry and a Rallying Call for Our Discipline Foundations of Chemistry 2 195–205 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1009946914577
M. Castagnino O. Lombardi (2004) ArticleTitleSelf-Induced Decoherence: A New Approach Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics 35 73–107 Occurrence Handle10.1016/j.shpsb.2003.03.001
P. A. M. Dirac (1929) ArticleTitleQuantum Mechanics of Many-Electron Systems Proceedings of the Royal Society A 338 714–733
J. G. Kemeny P. Oppenheim (1956) ArticleTitleOn Reduction Philosophical Studies 7 6–19
O. Lombardi (2002) Determinism, Internalism and Objectivity H. Atmanspacher R. Bishop (Eds) Between Chance and Choice: Interdisciplinary Perspectives on Determinism Imprint-Academic Thorverton, England 75–87
P. L. Luisi (2002) ArticleTitleEmergence in Chemistry: Chemistry as the Embodiment of Emergence Foundations of Chemistry 4 183–200 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1020672005348
E. Nagel (1961) The Structure of Science Harcourt, Brace & World New York
A. R. Pérez Ransanz (1999) Kuhn y el Cambio Científico Fondo de Cultura Economica Mexico
H. Primas (1983) Chemistry, Quantum Mechanics and Reductionism Springer Berlin
H. Primas. Emergence in Exact Natural Sciences. In G. Farre and T. Oksala (Eds.), Acta Polytechnica Scandinavica 91: 83–98, 1998.
H. Putnam (1981) Reason, Truth and History Cambridge University Press Cambridge
J. Ramsey (1997) ArticleTitleMolecular Shape, Reduction, Explanation and Approximate Concepts Synthese 111 233–251 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1004901931804
F. Rohrlich (1988) ArticleTitlePluralistic Ontology and Theory Reduction in the Physical Sciences British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 39 295–312
F. Rohrlich (1990) ArticleTitleThere is Good Physics in Theory Reduction Foundations of Physics 20 1399–1412 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF01883494 Occurrence HandleMR1086766
E. Scerri (1991) ArticleTitleElectronic Configurations, Quantum Mechanics and Reduction British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 42 309–325
E. Scerri (2000a) ArticleTitleThe Failure of Reduction and How to Resist Disunity of the Sciences in the Context of Chemical Education Science & Education 9 405–425
E. Scerri (2000) Realism, Reduction and the ‘Intermediate Position’ N. Bhushan S. Rosenfeld (Eds) Of Minds and Molecules. New Philosophical Perspectives on Chemistry Oxford University Press New York 51–72
E. Scerri L. McIntyre (1997) ArticleTitleThe Case for the Philosophy of Chemistry Synthese 111 213–232 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1004949814965
E. Scheibe (1973) The Logical Analysis of Quantum Mechanics Pergamon Press Oxford
J. Brakel Particlevan (1997) ArticleTitleChemistry as the Science of the Transformation of Substances Synthese 111 253–282 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1004953915874
J. Brakel Particlevan (2000a) Philosophy of Chemistry. Between the Manifest and the Scientific Image Leuven University Press Leuven
J. Brakel Particlevan (2000b) The Nature of Chemical Substances N. Bhushan S. Rosenfeld (Eds) Of Minds and Molecules. New Philosophical Perspectives on Chemistry Oxford University Press New York 162–184
G.K. Vemulapalli H. Byerly (1999) ArticleTitleRemnants of Reductionism Foundations of Chemistry 1 17–41 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1009984310105
M. Wilson (1989) ArticleTitleJohn Earman’s: A Primer on Determinism Philosophy of Science 56 502–532 Occurrence Handle10.1086/289506
R. Woolley (1982) ArticleTitleNatural Optical Activity and the Molecular Hypothesis Structure and Bonding 52 1–35
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lombardi, O., Labarca, M. The Ontological Autonomy Of The Chemical World. Found Chem 7, 125–148 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10698-004-0980-6
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10698-004-0980-6