Skip to main content
Log in

Did Einstein Stumble? The debate over general covariance

  • Published:
Erkenntnis Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

The objection that Einstein's principle of general covariance is not a relativity principle and has no physical content is reviewed. The principal escapes offered for Einstein's viewpoint are evaluated.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Similar content being viewed by others

References

  • Anderson, J. L.: 1967,Principles of Relativity Physics, Academic Press, New York.

    Google Scholar 

  • Bergmann, P. G.: 1942,Introduction to the Theory of Relativity, Prentice-Hall, New Jersey; expanded with new appendix, Dover, New York, 1975.

    Google Scholar 

  • Bondi, H.: 1959, ‘Relativity’,Reports on Progress in Physics 22, 97–120.

    Google Scholar 

  • Cartan, E.: 1923, ‘Sur les variétés a connexion affine et la théorie de la relativité generalisée’,Annales Scientifique de I'Ecole Normale Supérieure 40, 325–412, in A. Magnon and A. Ashtekhar (trans.),On Manifolds with an Affine Connection and the Theory of General Relativity, Bibliopolis, Naples, 1986.

    Google Scholar 

  • Cartan, E.: 1924, ‘Sur les variétés a connexion affine et la théorie de la relativité generalisée’,Annales Scientifique de I'Ecole Normale Supérieure 41, 1–25, in A. Magnon and A. Ashtekhar (trans.),On Manifolds with an Affine Connection and the Theory of General Relativity, Bibliopolis, Naples, 1986.

    Google Scholar 

  • Earman, J.: 1974, ‘Covariance, Invariance and the Equivalence of Frames’,Foundations of Physics 4, 267–289.

    Google Scholar 

  • Einstein, A.: 1905, ‘Zur Elektrodynamik bewegter Körper’,Annalen der Physik,17, 891–921; translated as ‘On the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies’, in H. A. Lorentz et al.,The Principle of Relativity, Dover, New York, pp. 37–65, 1952.

    Google Scholar 

  • Einstein, A.: 1907, ‘Über das Relativitätsprinzip und die aus demselben gezogenen Folgerungen’,Jahrbuch der Radioaktivität und Elektronik 4, 411–462.

    Google Scholar 

  • Einstein, A.: 1908, ‘Berichtigungen zu der Arbeit: Über das Relativitätsprinzip und die aus demselben gezogenen Folgerungen’,Jahrbuch der Radioaktivität und Elektronik 5, 98–99.

    Google Scholar 

  • Einstein, A.: 1911, ‘Über den Einfluss der Schwerkraft auf die Ausbreitung des Lichtes’,Annalen der Physik 35, 898–908; translated as ‘On the Influence of Gravitation on the Propagation of Light, in H. A. Lorentz et al.,The Principle of Relativity, Dover, New York, pp. 99–108, 1952.

    Google Scholar 

  • Einstein, A.: 1912a, ‘Lichtgeschwindigkeit und Statik des Gravitationsfeldes’,Annalen der Physik 38, 355–369.

    Google Scholar 

  • Einstein, A.: 1912b, ‘Zur Theorie des Statischen Gravitationsfeldes’,Annalen der Physik 38, 443–458.

    Google Scholar 

  • Einstein, A.: 1912c, ‘Gibt es eine Gravitationswirkung, die der elektrodynamischen Induktionswirkung analog ist?’,Vierteljahrsschrift für gerichtliche Medizin und öffentliches Sanitätswesen 44, 37–40.

    Google Scholar 

  • Einstein, A.: 1913, ‘Zum gegenwärtigen Stande des Gravitationsproblems’,Physikalische Zeitschrift 14, 1249–1262.

    Google Scholar 

  • Einstein, A.: 1916, ‘Die Grundlage der allgemeinen Relativitätstheorie’,Annalen der Physik 49, 769–822, translated without p. 769 as ‘The Foundation of the General Theory of Relativity’, in H. A. Lorentz et al.,The Principle of Relativity. Dover, New York, pp. 111–164, 1952.

    Google Scholar 

  • Einstein, A.: 1918, ‘Prinzipielles zur allgemeinen Relativitätstheorie’,Annalen der Physik 55, 240–244.

    Google Scholar 

  • Einstein, A.: 1918a, ‘Dialog über Einwande gegen die Relativitätstheorie’,Naturwissenschaften 6, 697–702.

    Google Scholar 

  • Einstein, A.: 1922,The Meaning of Relativity, 5th ed., Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey, 1974.

    Google Scholar 

  • Einstein, A.: 1933, ‘On the Methods of Theoretical Physics’, inIdeas and Opinions, Bonanza, New York, pp. 270–276.

    Google Scholar 

  • Einstein, A.: 1940 ‘The Fundamentals of Theoretical Physics’, inIdeas and Opinions, Bonanza, New York, pp. 323–335.

    Google Scholar 

  • Einstein, A.: 1950, ‘On the Generalized Theory of Gravitation’ inIdeas and Opinions, Bonanza, New York, pp. 341–356, 1954.

    Google Scholar 

  • Einstein, A. and M. Grossmann: 1913,Entwurf einer verallgemeinerten Relativitätstheorie und einer Theorie der Gravitation, B. G. Teubner, Leibzig (separatum); with addendum by Einstein inZeitschrift für Mathematik und Physik 63, 225–261.

    Google Scholar 

  • Fock, V. (1957) ‘Three Lectures on Relativity Theory’,Reviews of Modern Physics 29, 325–333.

    Google Scholar 

  • Fock, V.: 1959,The Theory of Space Time and Gravitation, in N. Kemmer (trans.), Pergamon Press, New York.

    Google Scholar 

  • Friedman, M.: 1973, ‘Relativity Principles, Absolute Objects and Symmetry Groups’, in P. Suppes (ed.),Space, Time and Geometry, D. Reidel, Dordrecht, pp. 296–320.

    Google Scholar 

  • Friedman, M.: 1983,Foundations of Space-Time Theories, Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey.

    Google Scholar 

  • Friedrichs, K: 1927, ‘Eine invariante Formulierung des Newtonschen Gravitationsgesetzes und des Grenzüberganges vom Einsteinschen zum Newtonschen Gesetz’,Mathematische Annalen 98, 566–575.

    Google Scholar 

  • Howard D. and J. D. Norton: 1993, ‘Out of the Labyrinth? Einstein, Hertz and the Göttingen Answer to the Hole Argument’, in J. Earman, M. Janssen and J. D. Norton (eds.),The Attraction of Gravitation: New Studies in History of General Relativity, Birkhäuser, Boston, pp. 30–62.

    Google Scholar 

  • Jones, R.: 1981, ‘The Special and General Principles of Relativity’, in P. Barker and C. G. Shugart (eds.),After Einstein, Memphis State University Press, Tennessee, pp. 159–173.

    Google Scholar 

  • Kretschmann, E.: 1917, ‘Über den physikalischen Sinn der Relativitätspostulat, A. Einsteins neue und seine ursprüngliche Relativitätstheorie’,Annalen der Physik 53, 575–614.

    Google Scholar 

  • Lenard, P.: 1921, ‘Über Relativitätsprinzip, Äther. Gravitätion 3rd ed., S. Hirzel, Leipzig.

    Google Scholar 

  • Minkowski, H: 1908, ‘Die Grundgleichungen fur die elektromagnetischen Vorgänge in bewegten Körpern’,Königlichen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen. Mathematisch-Physikalische Klasse, Nachrichten, pp. 53–111.

  • Minkowski, H: 1909, ‘Raum und Zeit’,Physikalische Zeitschrift 10, 104–111; translated as ‘Space and Time’, in H. A. Lorentz et al.,Principle of Relativity, pp. 75–91, 1923; reprinted, Dover, New York, 1952.

    Google Scholar 

  • Misner, C. W., K. S. Thorne and J. A. Wheeler: 1973,Gravitation, Freeman, San Francisco.

    Google Scholar 

  • Norton, J. D.: 1984, ‘How Einstein Found his Field Equations: 1912–1915’,Historical Studies in the Physical Sciences 14, 253–316; reprinted in Don Howard and John Stachel (eds.),Einstein and the History of General Relativity:Einstein Studies, Vol. 1, Birkhäuser, Boston, pp. 101–159, 1989.

    Google Scholar 

  • Norton, J. D.: 1985 ‘What was Einstein's Principle of Equivalence?’,Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 16, 203–246; reprinted in Don Howard and John Stachel (eds.),Einstein and the History of General Relativity:Einstein Studies, Vol. 1, Birkhäuser, Boston, pp. 3–47, 1989.

    Google Scholar 

  • Norton, J. D.: 1987, ‘Einstein, the Hole Argument and the Reality of Space’, in J. Forge (ed.),Measurement. Realism and Objectivity, D. Reidel, Dordrecht, pp. 153–188.

    Google Scholar 

  • Norton, J. D.: 1989, ‘Coordinates and Covariance: Einstein's View of Spacetime and the Modern View’,Foundations of Physics 19, 1215–1263.

    Google Scholar 

  • Norton, J. D.: 1992, ‘Einstein, Nordström and the Early Demise of Scalar, Lorentz-Covariant Theories of Gravitation’,Archive for the History of Exact Sciences 45, 17–94.

    Google Scholar 

  • Norton, J. D.: 1992a, ‘The Physical Content of General Covariance’, in J. Eisenstaedt and A. J. Kox (eds.),Studies in the History of General Relativity, Einstein Studies, Vol. 3, Birkhäuser, Boston, pp. 281–315.

    Google Scholar 

  • Norton, J. D.: 1993a, ‘General Covariance and the Foundations of General Relativity’,Reports on Progress in Physics 56, 791–858.

    Google Scholar 

  • Norton, J. D.: 1993b, ‘Einstein and Nordström: Some Lesser-Known Thought Experiments in Gravitation’, in J. Earman, M. Janssen and J. D. Norton (eds.),The Attraction of Gravitation:New Studies in the History of General Relativity, Birkhäuser, Boston, pp. 3–29.

    Google Scholar 

  • Pauli, W.: 1921, ‘Relativitätstheorie’, in Encyklopädie der mathematischen Wissenschaften, mit Einschluss an ihrer Anwendung, Vol. 5, in Sommerfeld (ed.),Physik, Part 2, B. G. Teubner, Leipzig, pp. 539–775, 1904–1922, [Issued 15 November 1921]. English translation in G. Field (trans.),Theory of Relativity, with supplementary notes by the author, Pergamon Press, London, 1958; reprinted Dover, New York.

    Google Scholar 

  • Ricci, G. and T. Levi-Civita: 1901, ‘Méthodes de Calcul Différentiel Absolu et leurs Application’,Math. Ann. 54, 125–201; reprinted in T. Levi-Civita, 1954,Opere Matenlatiche, Vol. 1, Bologna, pp. 479–559.

    Google Scholar 

  • Schlick, M.: 1920,Space and Time in Contemporary Physics, in H. L Brose (trans.), Oxford University Press, New York.

    Google Scholar 

  • Sesmat, A. 1937,Systèmes de Référence et Mouvements (Physique Relativiste), Hermann & Cie, Paris.

    Google Scholar 

  • Sommerfeld, A.: 1910, ‘Zur Relativitätstheorie I. Vierdimensionale Vektoralgebra’,Annalen der Physik 32, 749–776; ‘Zur Relativitätstheorie II. Vierdimensionale Vektoranalysis’,Annalen der Physik 33, 649–689.

    Google Scholar 

  • Stachel, J.: 1980, ‘Einstein's Search for General Covariance’, paper read at the Ninth International Conference on General Relativity and Gravitation, Jena; reprinted in D. Howard and J. Stachel (eds.),Einstein and the History of General Relativity:Einstein Studies, Vol. 1, Birkhäuser, Boston, pp. 63–100, 1989.

    Google Scholar 

  • Stachel, J.: 1986, ‘What can a Physicist Learn from the Discovery of General Relativity?’, in R. Ruffini (ed.),Proceedings of the Fourth Marcel Grossmann Meeting on Recent Developments in General Relativity, North-Holland, Amsterdam.

    Google Scholar 

  • Synge, J. L: 1966, ‘What is Einstein's Theory of Gravitation’, in B. Hoffmann (ed.),Perspectives in Geometry and Relativity, Indiana University Press, Bloomington, Indiana, pp. 7–15.

    Google Scholar 

  • Torretti, R.: 1984, ‘Spacetime Physics and the Philosophy of Science’,British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 35, 280–292.

    Google Scholar 

  • Trautman, A.: 1964,Lectures on General Relativity:Brandeis Summer Institute in Theoretical Physics, Vol. 1, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey, pp 1–248, 1965.

    Google Scholar 

  • Wald, R: 1984,General Relativity, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.

    Google Scholar 

  • Weinberg, S.: 1972,Gravitation and Cosmology:Principles and Applications of the General Theory of Relativity, John Wiley, New York.

    Google Scholar 

  • Weyl, H.: 1921,Space Time Matter, H. L. Brose (trans.), Dover, New York, 1952.

Download references

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Authors

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Norton, J.D. Did Einstein Stumble? The debate over general covariance. Erkenntnis 42, 223–245 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01128809

Download citation

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01128809

Keywords

Navigation