Philosophy and Phenomenological Research

Volume 67, Issue 3, November 2003

Paul O’Grady
Pages 649-653

The Scope of Deflationism
Reply to Gregory

Paul Gregory’s careful and insightful response to “Camap and Two Dogmas of Empiricism” highlights a number of points which were underdeveloped in that paper. I think that he has brought into relief a central issue between Camap and Quine by supplying a crucial distinction. However I still maintain that Quine’s assault is less than successful and that Gregory’s further analysis of the debate sheds light on why this is so.