Abstract
The issue of genetic discrimination has attracted growing attention and has been the focus of a recent major Australian inquiry. It is, however, a complex and loaded notion, open to interpretation. This paper explores the concept of genetic discrimination in both its theoretical and practical dimensions. It examines its conceptual underpinnings, how it is understood, and how this understanding fits within the legal framework of disability discrimination. The paper also examines the phenomenon in practice, including the ‘fear factor’ and the resulting implications for the development of regulatory policy. The paper argues that we need to be discerning in our interpretation of this term, and differentiate between discriminatory conduct which is legal and illegal. Further, it is argued that a concerted societal response to the ‘problem’ of genetic discrimination is needed involving targeted legal reforms as well as broader non-legal strategies.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Billings PR, Kohn MA, De Cuevas M, Beckwith J, Alper JS and Natowicz MR, Discrimination as a consequence of genetic testing. American journal of Human Genetics. 1992: 50: 476–482.
Anderlik M and Rothstein M, Genetic privacy: a war fought on many fronts. Update, 2002 June/July; 2–5.
Australian Law Reform Commission and the Australian Health Ethics Committee (ALRC/AHEC),Essentially Yours Report, The Protection of Human Genetic Information in Australia. 2003.
Geller LN, Alper JS, Billings PR, Barash CI, Beckwith J and Natowicz MR, Individual, family, and societal dimensions of genetic discrimination: a case study analysis. Science and Engineering Ethics. 1996; 2 71–88.
Human Genetics Commission, ‘Public attitudes to human genetic information’, People's Panel Quantitative Study conducted for the Human Genetics Commission, 2001.
Hellman D, What makes genetic discrimination exceptional? American Journal of Law and Medicine 2003; 29: 77–116.
Carlson, L, The morality of prenatal testing and selective abortion: calrifying the expressivist objection, and Silvers, A, Meliorism at the milennium: positive molecular eugenics and the promise of progress without excess. In Parker L and Ankeny, R, (eds) Mutating concepts, evolving disciplines: genetics, medicine and society. Lordrecht/Boston/London, Kluwer Academic Publishers; 2002.
Wertz D, Genetic discrimination—an overblown fear? Nature Reviews Genetics, 2002; 3: 496.
Kosseim P, Letendre M. and Knoppers B, Protecting genetic information: a comparison of normative approaches. HumGen. 2004; 2 accessed atlhttp://www.humgen.umontreal.ca/en/GenEdit.cfm.
Geller LN, Current developments in genetic discrimination. In Alper JS, Ard C, Asch A, Beckwith J, Conrad P and Geller LN, (eds) The double-edged helix: social implications of genetics in a diverse society. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press; 2002.
Rothstein, M and Anderlik, M, What is genetic discrimination and when and how can it be prevented? Genetics IN Medicine. 2001; 3: 354–358.
National Health Act 1953 (Cth).
Discrimination Act 1991 (ACT);Anti-Discrimination Act 1977 (NSW);Anti-Discrimination Act 1992 (NT);Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld);Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (SA);Anti-Discrimination Act 1998 (Tas);Equal Opportunity Act 1995 (Vic);Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (WA).
Productivity Commission Inquiry Report, Review of the Disability Discrimination Act 1992. April 2004.
Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) s 46.
Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) s 15(4).
Otlowski, M, Employers' use of genetic test information: is there a need for regulation? Australian Journal of Labour Law. 2002; 15: 1–39.
Mainsbridge A, Employers and genetic information: a new frontier for discrimination. Macquarie Law Journal. 2002; 2: 61–85.
Barlow-Stewart K and Keays D, Genetic discrimination in Australia. Journal of Law and Medicine, 2001: 8: 250–262.
McGlennan T, Insurance and genetic information. Report prepared for and published by the Association of British Insurers. 2001.
Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) s 107(1).
Private communication with Mr David Mico, Senior Policy Manager, Investment and Financial Services Association Ltd (IFSA).
Institute of Actuaries of Australia (IAAust) (2004)IFSA Genetics Test Survey Report (Period Seven: 1 December, 2003-31 May 2004).
Harris J and Sulston J, Genetic equity. Nature. 2004; 5 796–800.
Lapham EV, Kozma C and Weiss JO, Genetic discrimination: perspectives of consumers. Science, 1996; 274: 621–624.
Low L, King S and Wilkie T, Genetic discrimination in life insurance: empirical evidence from a cross sectional survey of genetic support groups in the United Kingdom. British Medical Journal. 1998; 317: 1632–1635.
Keays D, Genetic testing and insurance: when is discrimination justified? Monash Bioethics Review, 2000; 19: 79–88.
www.gdproject.org
Otlowski M, Taylor S and Barlow-Stewart K, Major study commencing into genetic discrimination in Australia. Journal of Law and Medicine. 2002; 10: 41–48.
Taylor S, Otlowski M, Treloar S, Barlow-Stewart K, Stranger M and Chenoweth K, Investigating genetic discrimination in Australia: opportunities and challenges in the early stages. New Genetics and Society Journal. 2004; 23: 225–239.
Treloar S, Taylor S, Otlowski M, Barlow-Stewart K, Stranger M and Chenoweth K, Methodological considerations in the study of genetic discrimination: a review. Community Genetics. 2004; 7: 161–168.
Nowlan W, A scarlet letter or a red herring? Nature, 2003; 241: 313.
Rothenberg K and Terry S, Before it's too late-addressing fear of genetic information.Science. 2002; 297: 196–197.
Epps P, Policy before practice. American Journal of Pharmacogenomics. 2003; 3: 405–418.
Watson MS and Green CL, Points to consider in preventing unfair discrimination based on genetic disease: a position statement of the American College of Medical Genetics. Genetics in Medicine 2001; 3; 436–437.
Hadley D, Jenkins J, Dimond E, Nakahara K, et al Genetic counseling and testing in families with hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer. Archives of Internal Medicine, 2003; 163: 573–582.
Geer K, Ropka M, Cohn W, Jones S and Miesfeldt S, Factors influencing patients' decisions to decline cancer genetic counselling services. Journal of Genetic Counselling. 2001; 10: 25–40.
Yesley M, Genetic privacy, discrimination and social policy: challenges and dilemmas. Microbial and Comparative Genetics. 1997; 2: 19–35.
Silvers A and Stein M, Human rights and genetic discrimination: protecting genomic promise for public health. Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics. 2003; 31: 377–389.
Human Genetics Commission, Summary Report, Inside information: balancing interests in the use of personal genetic data. 2003; 7.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Otlowski, M. Exploring the concept of genetic discrimination. J. Bioethical Inquiry 2, 165–176 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02448597
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02448597