Abstract
Primary and methyl aliphatic halides and tosylates undergo substitution reactions with nucleophiles in one step by the classic SN2 mechanism, which is characterized by second-order kinetics and inversion of configuration at the reaction center. Tertiary aliphatic halides and tosylates undergo substitution reactions with nucleophiles in two (or more) steps by the classic SN1 mechanism, which is characterized by first-order kinetics and incomplete inversion of configuration at the reaction center due to the presence of ion pairs. When the nucleophile is also the solvent, the substitution reaction is called a solvolysis, and both the SN2 and SN1 reactions now obey first-order kinetics. Schleyer and Bentley have provided solid, but not conclusive, evidence that secondary substrates undergo solvolysis by a merged mechanism, one that blends characteristics of both the SN2 and SN1 mechanisms. The following paper presents the history of their sustained pursuit of a merged mechanism and subsequent rebuttals to this claim. Several issues related to the philosophy and sociology of science are also discussed.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abenson, P.H.: Trends in scientific research. Science 143(3603), 218–223 (1964)
Allen, A.D., Ambidge, I.C., Tidwell, T.T.: Stereochemistry of trifluoroacetolysis of optically active 2-Butyl Tosylate. A test for hydrogen bridging. J. Org. Chem. 48, 4527–4530 (1983)
Allen, A.D., Kanagasabapathy, V.M., Tidwell, T.T.: Solvolysis of 1-Arylethyl Tosylates. Kinetic and stereochemical tests for solvent participation. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 107, 4513–4519 (1985)
Anslyn, E.V., Dougherty, D.A.: Modern physical organic chemistry. University Science Books, Sausalito, CA (2006)
Bentley, T.W., Bowen, C.T., Morten, D.H., Schleyer, P., Von, R.: The SN2-SN1 Spectrum. 3. Solvolyses of secondary and tertiary alkyl sulfonates in fluorinated alcohols. Further evidence for the SN2 (Intermediate) mechanism. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 103, 5466–5475 (1981)
Bentley, T.W., Carter, G.E.: The SN2-SN1 Spectrum. 4. The SN2 (Intermediate) mechanism of tert-Butyl Chloride: A revised Y scale of solvent ionizing power based on solvolysis of 1-Adamantyl Chloride. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 104, 5741–5747 (1982)
Bentley, T.W., Schleyer, P., Von, R.: The SN2-SN1 Spectrum. 1. Role of nucleophilic solvent assistance and nucleophilically solvated ion pair intermediates in solvolyses of primary and secondary Arenesulfonates. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 98, 7658–7666 (1976)
Bentley, T.W., Schleyer, P., Von, R.: Medium effects on the rates and mechanisms of solvolytic reactions. In: Gold, V., Bethell, D. (eds.) Advances in physical organic chemistry, vol. 14, pp. 1–67. Academic Press, New York (1977)
Biale, G., Parker, A.J., Smith, S.G., Stevens, I.D.R., Winstein, S.: E2C mechanism in elimination reactions. Absence of an extreme form of merged mechanism for elimination and substitution. Comparison of Saytzeff versus Hofmann Tendencies and of Anti versus Syn Elimination. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 92, 115–122 (1970)
Bunting, J.W.: Merged mechanisms for hydride transfer from 1, 4-Dihydronicotinamides. Biorg. Chem. 19, 456–491 (1991)
Crane, D.: Fashions in science—Does it exist? Soc. Prob. 16, 433–441 (1969)
Dannenberg, J.J., Goldberg, B.J., Barton, J.K., Dill, K., Weinwurzel, D.H., Longas, M.O.: The 2-Butyl Cation in Trifluoroacetic Acid. A hydrogen-bridged carbonium ion. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 103, 7764–7768 (1981)
Diaz, A.F., Lazdins, L., Winstein, S.: Oxygen-18 scrambling in solvolyses of simple unactivated alkyl Arenesulfonates. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 90, 1904–1905 (1968)
Eliel, E.L., Ro, R.S.: Example of merged bimolecular substitution and elimination. Tetrahedron 2, 353–354 (1958)
Fainberg, A.H., Winstein, S.: Correlation of solvolysis data. III. t-Butyl Chloride in a wide range of solvent mixtures. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 78, 2770–2777 (1956)
Grunwald, E., Winstein, S.: The correlation of solvolysis rates. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 70, 846–854 (1948)
Guthrie, R.D., Jencks, W.P.: IUPAC recommendations for the representation of reaction mechanims. Acc. Chem. Res. 22, 343–349 (1989)
Hagstrom, W.O.: Production of culture in science. Am. Behav. Scie. 19, 753–768 (1976)
Hammett, L.P.: The effect of structure on the reactions of organic compounds. Benzene derivatives. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 59, 96–103 (1937)
Hoffmann, R., Minkin, V.I., Carpenter, B.K.: Ockham’s Razor and chemistry. Bull. Chim. Soc. Fr. 133, 117–130 (1996)
Hoffmann, R., Minkin, V.I., Carpenter, B.K.: Ockham’s Razor and chemistry. HYLE 3, 3–28 (1997)
Katritzky, A.R.: The mechanisms of nucleophilic substitution in aliphatic compounds. Chem. Soc. Rev. 19, 83–105 (1990)
McLennan, D.J.: A neutral nucleophilic probe of borderline kinetic in the 2-Octyl Mesylate-Urea Reaction. Tetrahedron Lett. 16, 4689–4692 (1975)
Milton Harris, J., Raber, D.J., Hall, R.E., Schleyer, P., Von, R.: Solvent assistance in the solvolysis of secondary substrates. The use of added Azide Ion as a mechanistic probe. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 92, 5729–5731 (1970)
Milton Harris, J., Hall, R.E., Schleyer, P., Von, R.: The magnitude of secondary α-Deuterium isotope effects for limiting solvolses. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 93, 2551–2553 (1971)
Okuno, Y.: A cluster model of ion pair formation of t-BuCl in aqueous solution: calculations evidence for nucleophilic solvent assistance in SN1 Reaction. J. Phys. Chem. A 103, 190–196 (1999)
Paradisi, C., Bunnett, J.F.: Strong dependence of the incidence of internal return during sovolysis of sec-Alkyl Benzenesulfonates on the structure of the alkyl group. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 103, 946–948 (1981)
Reichardt, C.: Solvents and solvent effects in organic chemistry (3rd ed.). Wiley-VCH. Weinheim, Germany (2003)
Richard, J.P., Jencks, W.P.: Concerted Bimolecular Substitution Reactions of 1-Phenylethyl Derivatives. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 106, 1383–1396 (1984)
San Filippo Jr, J., Romano, L.J.: A convenient preparation of optically active 2-Halooctanes and related compound. J. Org. Chem. 40, 1514–1515 (1975)
Schadt, F.L., Schleyer, P., von, R., Bentley, T.W.: Hexafluoroisopropanol—a solvent of high ionizing power and low nucleophilicity. Tetrahedron Lett. 15, 2335–2338 (1974)
Schadt, F.L., Bentley, T.W., Schleyer, P., von, R.: The SN2-SN1 Spectrum. 2. Quantitative treatments of nucleophilic solvent assistance. A scale of solvent nucleophilcities. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 98, 7667–7674 (1976)
Schleyer, P., Von, R.: A simple preparation of Adamantane. J. Am Chem. Soc. 79, 3292 (1957)
Schleyer, P., Von, R., Nichols, R.D.: The preparation and reactivity of 2-substituted derivatives of Adamantane. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 83, 182–187 (1961)
Shiner Jr., V.J., Fisher, P., Dowd, W.: Enhancement of solvolysis rates by Wagner-Meerwein rearrangements of ion pairs. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 91, 7748–7749 (1969)
Sneen, R.A., Larsen, J.W.: Identification of an ion-pair intermediate in an SN2 reaction. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 88, 2593–2594 (1966)
Sneen, R.A., Larsen, J.W.: Substitution at a saturated carbon. X. Unification of mechanisms for SN1 or SN2. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 91, 362–366 (1969)
Sober, E.: Simplicity. In a companion to the philosophy of science (Newton-Smith, W. H. ed.). Blackwell, Malden, MA (2001), pp 433–441
Streitwieser, A.: Solvolytic displacement reactions. McGraw-Hill, New York (1962)
Ziman, J.M.: The problem of “Problem Choice”. Minerva 25, 92–106 (1987)
Acknowledgments
The author thanks Mark Goodwin, Michael Weisberg and Jeffrey Kovac for their advice and encouragement about this paper.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Pagni, R.M. Do the solvolysis reactions of secondary substrates occur by the SN1 or SN2 mechanism: or something else?. Found Chem 13, 131–143 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10698-011-9111-3
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10698-011-9111-3