Abstract
The increased usage of questionable environmental marketing claims has become an issue of concern for academics, policy makers and consumers. Much of the research to date, has focused on the accuracy of environmental claims in advertisements, with the information on product packaging being largely ignored. This study uses a content analysis to examine the environmental information on packaging. More specifically it examines the packaging of the population of dishwashing liquid bottles available in grocery stores in a large city in Australia. Evaluation criteria are developed to classify the various types of information and the degree to which the information is "misleading". Seven different informational categories and four accuracy categories are developed. These criteria are developed based on the existing environmental advertising literature and environmental marketing regulations in the U.S. and Australia. It was found that a majority of the packaging information can be classified as being not accurate.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Balderjahn, Ingo: 1988, ‘Personality Variables and Environmental Attitudes as Predictors of Ecologically Responsible Consumer Patterns’, Journal of Business Research 17, 51–56.
Belch, George E. and Michael A. Belch: 1990, Introduction to Advertising and Promotion Management (Richard D. Irwin, Inc., Howewood JL, U.S.A.).
Burger, I. E. and R. M. Corbin: 1992, ‘Perceived Consumer Effectiveness and Faith in Others as Moderators of Environmentally Responsible Behaviors’, Journal of Public Policy and Marketing 11(2), 79–89.
Carlson, Les, Stephen J. Grove and Norman Kangun: 1993, ‘A Content Analysis of Environmental Advertising Claims: A Matrix Approach’, Journal of Advertising 22(3), 27–40.
Caudill, Eva M.: 1994, ‘Nutritional Information Research: A Review of the Issue’, Advances in Consumer Research 21, 213–217.
Choice: 1990, ‘Green Cleaners’, Choice(September), 10–14.
Cude, Brenda J.: 1993, ‘Consumer Perceptions of Environmental Marketing Claims: An Exploratory Study’, Journal of Consumer Studies and Home Economics 17(3), 207–225.
Davis, Joel J.: 1993, ‘Strategies for Environmental Advertising’, The Journal of Consumer Marketing 10(2), 19–36.
Davis, Joel J.: ‘Consumer Response to Corporate Environmental Advertising’, Journal of Consumer Marketing 11(2), 25–37.
De George, Richard: 1990, Business Ethics (Macmillian Publishing Company, New York, New York).
Federal Trade Commission: 1992, Guides for the Use of Environmental Marketing Claims: The Application of Section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission Act to Environmental Advertising and Marketing Practices, ( July) (Washington, DC).
Flint, Jerry: 1994, ‘Electric Car Surcharge’, Forbes 154(11), 18–19.
Gill, J. D., L. A. Grosby and J. R. Taylor: 1986, ‘Ecological Concern, Attitudes and Social Norms in Voting Behaviour’, Public Opinion Quarterly 50, 537–554.
Gray-Lee, Jason; Debra L. Scammon and Robert N. Mayer: 1994, ‘Review of Legal Standards for Environmental Marketing Claims’, Journal of Public Policy and Marketing 13(1), 155–159.
Henion, Karl E.: 1972, ‘The Effect of Ecological Relevant Information on Detergent Sales’, Journal of Marketing 9(1), 10–14.
Kangun, N., L. Carlson and S. J. Grove: 1991, ‘Environmental Advertising Claims: A Preliminary Investigation’, Journal of Public Policy and Marketing 10(2), 47–58.
Kangun, N. and Michael Jay Polonsky: 1995, ‘Regulation of Environmental Marketing Claims: A Comparative Perspective’, International Journal of Advertising 13(4), 1–24.
Kassarjian, Harold H.: 1977, ‘Content Analysis in Consumer Research’, Journal of Consumer Research 4, 8–18.
Lans, Maxine S.: 1993, ‘New Laws on Green Marketing are Popping Up All the Time’, Marking News, 27(4), 22, 24.
Lautenberg, F. R.: 1992, ‘Environmental Marketing Claims Act: Pulling the “Green” over our Eyes’, Seton Hall Legislation Journal 16, 305–340.
Lawrence, J.: 1991, ‘Mobil’, Advertising Age 62(5), 12–13.
Ludwig, Dean C. and Judith A. Ludwig: 1993, ‘The Regulation of Green Marketing: Learning Lessons from the Regulation of Health and Nutrition Claims’, Business and Professional Ethics Journal 11(3&4), 73–91.
Maloney, M. P., M. P. Ward and G. N. Braught: 1975, ‘A Revised Scale for the Measurement of Ecological Attitudes and Knowledge’, American Psychologist 32, 787–790.
Micklitz, H. W.: 1992, ‘The German Packaging Order - A Model for State-Induced Waste Avoidance?’, The Columbia Journal of World Business (September), 120–127.
Millar, Alistair: 1994, ‘Effective Green Product Position in Your Market and Distribution Channel Selection’, Environmental Marketing: Critical Success Strategies for Reaching the Green Consumer Proceedings of the 1994 Conference(February), 45–57.
Myburgh-Louw, Jacqui and N. J. O'shaughnessy: 1994, ‘Consumer Perception of Misleading and Deceptive Claims on the Packaging of “Green” Fast Moving Goods’, American Marketing Association Educators Proceedings Enhancing Knowledge Development in Marketing 4, 334–353.
Polonsky, Michael: 1995, ‘A Stakeholder Theory Approach to Designing Environmental Marketing Strategy’, Journal of Business and Industrial Marketing 10(3), 29–46.
Prothero, A.: 1990, ‘Green Consumerism and the Societal Marketing Concept: Marketing Strategies for the 1990's’, Journal of Marketing Management 6(2), 87–103.
Resnik, Alan J. and Bruce L. Stern: 1977,’ Information Content in Television Advertising: A Replication and Extension’, Journal of Marketing 41(1), 50–53.
Sayre, S.: 1992, ‘Content Analysis as a Tool for Consumer Research’, Journal of Consumer Marketing 9(1), 15–23.
Schlossberg, Howard: 1993, ‘Envirothon Attracts Students, Corporate Sponsors’, Marketing News 27(1), 10.
Smith, N. Craig and John A. Quelch: 1993, Ethics in Marketing(Richard D. Irwin Inc: Homewood IL).
SPSS: 1990, SPSS Reference Guide(SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL).
Starik, Mark: 1995, ‘Should Trees Have Managerial Standing? Toward Stakeholder Status for Non-Human Nature’, Business Ethics 4, 207–217.
Stern, Bruce L. and Alan J. Resnik: 1991, ‘Information Content in Television Advertising: A Replication and Extension’, Journal of Advertising Research 31(3), 36–46.
Trade Practices Commission: 1992, Environmental Claims in Marketing - A Guideline(Government Printing Office, Canberra ACT Australia).
Verplanken, Bas and Mieneke W. H. Weening: 1993, ‘Graphical Energy Label and Consumers' Decisions About Home Appliances: A Process Tracing Approach’, Journal of Economic Psychology 14, 739–752.
Wynne, R. D.: 1991, ‘Defining “Green”: Toward Regulation of Environmental Marketing Claims’, University of Michigan Journal of Law Reform 24(3&4), 785–820.
Weber, R. P.: 1990, Basic Content Analysis(Sage Publications, California).
Weiss, Joseph: 1994, Business Ethics: A Managerial, Stakeholder Approach(Wadsworth Publishing Company: Belmont, California).
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Polonsky, M.J., Bailey, J., Baker, H. et al. Communicating Environmental Information: Are Marketing Claims on Packaging Misleading?. Journal of Business Ethics 17, 281–294 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005731914135
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1005731914135