Abstract
This paper reviews the psychological investigation of reasoning with conditionals, putting an emphasis on recent work. In the first part, a few methodological remarks are presented. In the second part, the main theories of deductive reasoning (mental rules, mental models, and the probabilistic approach) are considered in turn; their content is summarised and the semantics they assume for if and the way they explain formal conditional reasoning are discussed, in particular in the light of experimental work on the probability of conditionals. The last part presents the recent shift of interest towards the study of conditional reasoning in context, that is, with large knowledge bases and uncertain premises.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adams E (1975) The logic of conditionals. Dordrecht, Reidel
Adams E (1998) A primer of probability logic. CSLI Publications, Stanford
Bacchus F (1990) Representing and reasoning with probabilistic knowledge. MIT Press, Cambridge
Bell VA, Johnson-Laird PN (1998) A model theory of modal reasoning. Cognit Sci 22:25–51
Bonnefon J-F, Hilton DJ (2004) Consequential conditionals: Invited and suppressed inferences from valued outcomes. J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cognit 30:28–37
Braine MDS, O’Brien DP (1991) A theory of IF: a lexical entry, reasoning program, and pragmatic principles. Psychol Rev 98:182–203
Braine MDS, O’Brien DP (1998) Mental logic. N. J. Lawrence Erlbaum, Mahwah
Braine MDS, Reiser BJ, Rumain B (1984) Some empirical justification for a theory of natural propositional logic. In: Bower GH (ed) The psychology of learning and motivation, vol. 18. Academic Press, NY, pp 313–371
Byrne RMJ (1989) Suppressing valid inferences with conditionals. Cognition 31:61–83
Byrne RMJ, Johnson-Laird PN (1989) Spatial reasoning. J Mem Lang 28:564–575
Byrne RMJ, Espino O, Santamaria C (1999) Counterexamples and the suppression of interfaces. J Mem Lang 40:347–373
Chater N, Oaksford M (2000) The rational analysis of mind and behavior. Synthese 122:93–131
Cummins DD (1995) Naive theories and causal deduction. Mem Cognit 23:646–658
Cummins DD, Lubart T, Alksnis O, Rist R (1991) Conditional reasoning and causation. Mem Cognit 19:274–282
Dancygier B (1998) Conditionals and prediction. Time, knowledge, and causation in conditional constructions. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Da Silva Neves R, Bonnefon J-F, Raufaste E (2002) An empirical test of patterns for nonmonotonic inference. Annl Math Artif Intel 34:107–130
Delval JA, Rivière A (1975) “Si llueve, Elisa lleva sombrero”: Una investigacion psicologica sobre la tabla de verdad del condicional. Revista Psicologia General y Aplicada 30(136):825–850
De Neys W, Schaeken W, d’Ydewalle G (2003) Inference suppression and semantic memory retrieval: every counterexample counts. Mem Cognit 31:581–595
Evans J St BT (1972) Reasoning with negatives. Brit J Psychol 63:213–219
Evans J St BT (1996) Deciding before you think: relevance and reasoning in the selection task. Brit J Psychol 87:223–240
Evans J St BT, Legrenzi P, Girotto V (1999) The influence of linguistic form on reasoning: The case of matching bias. Quart J Exp Psychol 52A:185–216
Evans J St BT, Handley SJ, Over DE (2003) Conditionals and conditional probability. J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cognit 29:321–335
Evans J St BT, Over DE (2004) If. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Fillenbaum S (1975) A note on memory for sense: incidental recognition of warning phrased as conditionals, disjunctives, and conjunctives. Bull Psychon Soc 6:293–294
Fillenbaum S (1976) Inducements: on the phrasing and logic of conditional promises, threats, and warnings. Psychol Res 38:231–250
Gärdenfors P (1988) Knowledge in flux. MIT Press, Cambridge
Gazdar G (1979) Pragmatics. Implicature, presupposition and logical form. Academic Press, New York
Geis ML, Zwicky AM (1971) On invited inferences. Linguist Inquiry 2:561–566
George C (1995) The endorsement of the premises: assumption-based or belief-based reasoning. Brit J Psychol 86:93–111
George C (1997) Reasoning from uncertain premises. Think Reason 3:161–189
Girotto V, Johnson-Laird PN (2004) The probability of conditionals. Psychologia 47:207–225
Grice HP (1975) Logic and conversation. In: Cole P, Morgan JL (eds) Syntax and semantics, vol 3, Speech acts, Academic Press, New York
Grice P (1989) Studies in the way of words. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Hailperin T (1996) Sentential probability logic. Lehigh University Press, Bethlehem
Horn LR (1989) A natural history of negation. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Johnson-Laird PN (1999) Deductive reasoning. Annl Rev Psychol 50:109–135
Johnson-Laird PN (2001) Mental models and deduction. Trends Cognit Sci 5:434–442
Johnson-Laird PN, Bara BG (1984) Syllogistic inference. Cognition 16:1–61
Johnson-Laird PN, Byrne RMJ (1991) Deduction. Lawrence Erlbaum, Hove
Johnson-Laird PN, Byrne RMJ (2002) Conditionals: a theory of meaning, pragmatics, and inference. Psychol Rev 109:646–678
Johnson-Laird PN, Tagart J (1969) How implication is understood. Amer J Psychol 82:367–373
Josephson JR, Josephson SG (1994) Abductive inference. Computation, philosophy, technology, C.U.P, Cambridge
Kraus S, Lehmann D, Magidor M (1990) Nonmonotonic reasoning, preferential models and cumulative logics. Artif Intel 44:167–207
Levinson SC (2000) Presumptive meanings. MIT Press, Cambridge
Liu I-M, Lo K-C, Wu J-T (1996) A probabilistic interpretation of “If-Then”. Quart J Exp Psychol 49A:828–844
Magnani L (2001) Abduction, reason, and science: processes of discovery and explanation. Kluwer, New York
Manktelow K, Fairley N (2000) Superordinate principles in reasoning with causal and deontic conditionals. Think Reason 6:41–65
Noveck IA, Sperber D (2004) Experimental pragmatics. Palgrave McMillan, Houndmills
Oaksford M Chater N (1991) Against logicist cognitive science. Mind Lang 6:1–38
Oaksford M, Chater N (1994) A rational analysis of the selection task as optimal data selection. Psychol Rev 101:608–631
Oaksford M, Chater N (2003a) Computational levels and conditional inference: Reply to Schroyens and Schaeken. J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cognit 29:150–156
Oaksford M, Chater N (2003b) Probabilities and pragmatics in conditional inference: suppression and order effects. In: Hardman D, Macchi L (eds) Thinking: psychological perspectives on reasoning, judgment and decision making. John Wiley, Chichester, pp 95–122
Oaksford M, Chater N, Larkin J (2000) Probabilities and polarity biases in conditional inference. J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cognit 26:883–899
Oaksford M, Stenning K (1992) Reasoning with conditionals containing negated constituents. J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cognit 18:835–854
Oberauer K, Weidenfeld A, Hörnig R (2004) Logical reasoning and probabilities: A comprehensive test of Oaksford and Chater (2001). Psychon Bull Rev 11:521–527
Oberauer K, Wilhelm O (2003) The meaning(s) of conditionals: Conditional probabilities, mental models, and personal utilities. J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cognit 29:680–693
Over DE, Hadjichristidis C, Evans J St BT, Handley SJ, Sloman SA (in press) The probability of ordinary indicative conditionals. Cognit Psychol
Paris SG (1973) Comprehension of language connectives and propositional logical relationships. J Exp Child Psychol 16:278–291
Pearl J (1991) Probabilistic reasoning in intelligent systems: networks of plausible inference, 2nd ed. Morgan Kaufmann, San Francisco
Pfeifer N, Kleiter GD (in press) Inference in conditional probability logic. Kybernetica 40
Pfeifer N, Kleiter GD (2005a) Coherence and nonmonotonocity in human reasoning. Synthese 146:93–109
Pfeifer N, Kleiter GD (2005b) Towards a mental probability logic. Psychol Belgica 45:71–99
Poletiek FH (2001) Hypothesis-testing behaviour. Psychology Press, Hove
Politzer G (1981) Differences in interpretation of implication. Amer J Psychol 94:461–477
Politzer G (2004) Reasoning, judgement and pragmatics. In: Noveck IN, Sperber D (eds) Experimental pragmatics, Palgrave, Houndmills, pp 94–115
Politzer G (2005) Uncertainty and the suppression of inferences. Think Reason 11:5–33
Politzer G, Bonnefon J-F (2006) Two varieties of conditionals and two types of defeaters help reveal two fundamental types of reasoning. Mind Lang 21:484–503
Politzer G, Bourmaud G (2002) Deductive reasoning from uncertain conditionals. Brit J Psychol 93:345–381
Politzer G, Braine MDS (1991) Responses to inconsistent premisses cannot count as suppression of valid inferences. Cognition 38:103–108
Politzer G, Carles L (2001) Belief revision and uncertain reasoning. Think Reason 7:217–234
Politzer G, Macchi L (2000) Reasoning and pragmatics. Mind Soc 1:73–93
Pollock JL (1987) Defeasable reasoning. Cognit Sci 11:481–518
Quinn S, Markovits H (1998) Conditional reasoning, causality, and the structure of semantic memory: strength of association as a predictive factor for content effects. Cognition 68:B93–B101
Ramsey FP (1931) General propositions and causality. In: Braithwaite RB (ed) The foundations of mathematics and other logical essays. Routledge, Kegan Paul, London, pp 237–255
Rips LJ (1994) The psychology of proof. M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, MA
Rumain B, Connell J, Braine MDS (1983) Conversational comprehension processes are responsible for reasoning fallacies in children as well as adults: If is not the biconditional. Develop Psychol 19:471–481
Scholnick EK, Wing CS (1991) Speaking deductively: preschoolers’ use of If in conversation and in conditional inference. Develop Psychol 27:249–258
Scholnick EK, Wing CS (1992) Speaking deductively: using conversation to trace the origins of conditional thought in children. Merrill-Palmer Quart 38:1–20
Schroyens W, Schaeken W (2003) A critique of Oaksford, Chater, and Larkin’s (2000) conditional probability model of conditional reasoning. J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cognit 29:140–149
Smets P (1998) (ed) Quantified representation of uncertainty and imprecision, vol. 1. In: Gabbay DM, Smets P (eds) Handbook of defeasible reasoning and uncertainty management systems. Dordrecht, Kluwer
Sperber D, Cara F, Girotto V (1995) Relevance theory explains the selection task. Cognition 57:31–95
Sperber D, Wilson D (1986) Relevance: communication and cognition. Blackwell, London (2nd ed., 1995)
Stalnaker RC, Thomason RH (1970) A semantic analysis of conditional logic. Theoria 36:23–42
Stenning K, Van Lambalgen M (2004) A litle logic goes a long way: basing experiment on semantic theory in the cognitive science of conditional reasoning. Cognit Sci 28:481–529
Stenning K, Van Lambalgen M (2005) Semantic interpretation as computation in nonmonotonic logic: the real meaning of the suppression task. Cognit Sci 29:919–960
Stevenson RJ, Over DE (1995) Deduction from uncertain premises. Quart J Exp Psychol 48A:613–643
Sweetser E (1990) From etymology to pragmatics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, MA
Thomason RH (1970) A Fitch-style formulation of conditional logic. Logique Analyse 52:397–412
Thompson VA (1994) Interpretational factors in conditional reasoning. Mem Cognit 22:742–758
Thompson VA (1995) Conditional reasoning: the necessary and sufficient conditions. Can J Exp Psychol 49:1–60
Walton D (2004) Abductive reasoning. University of Alabama Press, Tuscaloosa
Wason PC (1966) Reasoning. In: Foss BM (ed) New horizons in psychology, vol. 1, Pelican Book
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Politzer, G. Reasoning with conditionals. Topoi 26, 79–95 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11245-006-9001-9
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11245-006-9001-9