Abstract
Modern biology is ambivalent about the notion of evolutionary progress. Although most evolutionists imply in their writings that they still understand large-scale macroevolution as a somewhat progressive process, the use of the term “progress” is increasingly criticized and avoided. The paper shows that this ambivalence has a long history and results mainly from three problems: (1) The term “progress” carries historical, theoretical and social implications which are not congruent with modern knowledge of the course of evolution; (2) An incongruence exists between the notion of progress and Darwin’s theory of selection; (3) It is still not possible to give more than a rudimentary definition of the general patterns that were generated during the macroevolution of organisms. The paper consists of two parts: the first is a historical overview of the roots of the term “progress” in evolutionary biology, the second discusses epistemological, ontological and empirical problems. It is stated that the term has so far served as a metaphor for general patterns generated amongst organisms during evolution. It is proposed that a reformulation is needed to eliminate historically imported implications and that it is necessary to develop a concept for an appropriate empirical description of macroevolutionary patterns. This is the third way between, on the one hand, using the term indiscriminately and, on the other hand, ignoring the general patterns that evolution has produced.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
A.J. Arnold K. Fristrup (1982) ArticleTitleThe theory of evolution by natural selection: a hierarchical expansion Paleobiology 8 113–129
F.J. Ayala (1974) The concept of biological progress F.J. Ayala T. Dobzhansky (Eds) Studies in the Philosophy of Biology: Reduction and Related Problems University of California Press Berkeley and Los Angeles 339–355
F.J. Ayala (1988) Can “progress” be defined as a biological concept? M.H. Nitecki (Eds) Evolutionary Progress? The University of Chicago Press Chicago 75–96
A.F. Bennett (1991) ArticleTitleThe evolution of aerobic capacity J. Exp. Biol. 160 1–23
Bernard C. 1859. Lecons sur les Propriétés Physiologiques et les Alté rations Pathologiques des Liquides de l’Organisme, Paris.
Bernard C. 1878. Lecons sur les Phénomènes de la Vie Communs aux Animaux et aux Végétaux, Paris.
Lv. Bertalanffy (1949) Vom Molekül zur Organismenwelt. Grundfragen der modernen Biologie Athenaion Potsdamm
K. Beurlen (1937) Die stammesgeschichtlichen Grundlagen der Abstammungslehre G. Fischer Jena
Beurlen K. 1949. Urweltleben und Abstammungslehre, Stuttgart.
J.T. Bonner (1988) The Evolution of Complexity Princeton University Press Princeton, NJ
J.T. Bonner (1998) ArticleTitleThe origins of multicellularity Integr. Biol. 1 27–36
P.J. Bowler (1983) Evolution: The History of an Idea University of California Press Berkely and Los Angeles
P.J. Bowler (1989a) The Non-Darwinian Revolution John Hopkins University Press Baltimore
P.J. Bowler (1989b) The Invention of Progress. The Victorians and the Past Basil Blackwell Cambridge, MA
Bronn H.G. 1853. Allgemeine Einleitung in die Naturgeschichte, Stuttgart.
Bronn H.G. 1858. Morphologische Studien über die Gestaltungsgesetze der Naturkörper überhaupt und der organischen insbesondere, Leipzig, Heidelberg.
D.L. Brooks J. Collier B.A. Maurer J. Smith E.O. Wiley (1989) ArticleTitleEntropy and information in evolving biological systems Biol. Philos. 4 407–432 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00162588
F. Brown (1986) ArticleTitleThe evolution of Darwin’s theism J. Hist. Biol. 19 1–45
R.L. Carroll (1997) Patterns and Processes of Vertebrate Evolution Cambridge University Press Cambridge
T. Cavalier-Smith (Eds) (1985) The Evolution of Genome Size Wiley New York
S. Conway Morris (2003) Life’s Solution. Inevitable Humans in a Lonely Universe Cambridge University Press Cambridge
Ch. Darwin (1872) The Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection or the Preservation of Favoured Races in the Struggle for Life Oxford University Press London
A. Desmond J. Moore (1991) Darwin: The Life of a Tormented Evolutionist Penguin Books London
T. Dobzhansky (1970) Genetics of the Evolutionary Process Columbia University Press New York
T. Dobzhansky F.J. Ayala G.L. Stebbins J.W. Valentine (1977) Evolution Freeman San Francisco
N. Eldredge (1985) Unfinished Synthesis Oxford University Press Oxford, New York
A.E. Emerson (1954) ArticleTitleDynamic homeostasis: a unifying principle in organic, social, and ethical evolution Sci. Mon. 78 67–85
D.C. Fisher (1986) Progress in organismal design D.M. Raup D. Jablonski (Eds) Patterns and Processes in the History of Life. Report of the Dahlem Workshop on Patterns and Processes in the History of Life Springer-Verlag Berlin
V. Franz (1920) Die Vervollkommnung in der lebenden Natur: Eine Studie über ein Naturgesetz G. Fischer Jena
V. Franz (1935) Der biologische Fortschritt G. Fischer Jena
V. Franz (1967) Systematik und Phylogenie der Wirbeltiere L. Bolk E. Göppert E. Kallius W. Lubosch (Eds) Handbuch der vergleichenden Anatomie der WirbeltiereVol. 1 Asher Verlag Amsterdam 185–268
J. Gerhart M. Kirschner (1997) Cells, Embryos, and Evolution. Toward a Cellular and Developmental Understanding of Phenotypic Variation and Evolutionary Adaptability Blackwell Malden, MA
M. Ghiselin (1995) ArticleTitlePerspective: Darwin, progress, and economic principles Evolution 49 1029–1037
H.-J. Gläser (1987) ArticleTitleAllgemeine und biologische Evolutionstheorie Biol. Zentralbl. 106 663–681
T.A. Goudge (1961) The Ascent of Life. A Philosophical Study of the Theory of Evolution University of Toronto Press Toronto
S.J. Gould (1985) ArticleTitleThe paradox of the first tier: an agenda for paleobiology Paleobiology 11 2–12
S.J. Gould (1988) On replacing the idea of progress with an operational notion of directionality M.H. Nitecki (Eds) Evolutionary Progress? The University of Chicago Press Chicago 319–338
S.J. Gould (1996) Full House. The Spread of Excellence from Plato to Darwin Three Rivers Press New York
S.J. Gould (2002) The Structure of Evolutionary Theory The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA, London
V. Grant (1985) The Evolutionary Process. A Critical Review of Evolutionary Theory Columbia University Press New York
J.C. Greene (1981) ScienceIdeology, and World View University of California Press Berkeley
J.C. Greene (1986) ArticleTitleThe history of ideas revisited Rev. Synth. 107 201–228
J.C. Greene (1991) ArticleTitleProgress, scienceand value: a biological dilemma Biol. Philos. 6 99–106
H.E. Gruner (1993) Lehrbuch der speziellen Zoologie, Vol. I, part 1 G. Fischer Jena, Stuttgart, New York
K. Günther (1950) Phylogenetik, Teleologie und Freiheit H. Grüneberg W. Ulrich (Eds) Moderne Biologie F.W. Peters Berlin 94–130
J.B.S. Haldane (1932) The Causes of Evolution Harper and Bross London, New York
G. Heberer (1967) Die Evolution der Organismen G. Fischer Stuttgart
H. Hendrichs (1988) Lebensprozesse und wissenschaftliches Denken. Zur Logik der Lebendigkeit und ihrer Erstarrung in den Wissenschaften Karl Alber Freiburg, München
E. Hennig (1932) Wesen und Wege der Paläontologie Gebrüder Borntraeger Berlin
E. Hennig (1955) ArticleTitleDer Begriff des Fortschritts im Werdegang des Lebens Forsch. Fortschr. 29 289–290
C.J. Herrick (1946) ArticleTitleProgressive evolution Science 104 469
C.J. Herrick (1956) The Evolution of Human Nature University of Texas Press Austin, London
M. Heuts (1953) ArticleTitleTheorien und Tatsachen der Biologischen Evolution Verh. Deutsch. Zool. Ges. (Zoologischer Anzeiger) 17(suppl.) 409–429
R. Hinegardner J. Engelberg (1983) ArticleTitleBiological complexity J. Theoret. Biol. 104 7–20
J. Huxley (1948) Evolution the Modern Synthesis, 1974 EditionNumber3 Allen & Unwin London
J. Huxley (1953) Evolution in Action Chatto & Windus London
J. Huxley (1954) The evolutionary process J. Huxley A.C. Hardy E.B. Ford (Eds) Evolution as a Process Allen & Unwin London 1–23
J. Huxley (1957) ArticleTitleThe three types of evolutionary process Nature 180 454–455
J. Huxley (1959) New Bottles for New Wine Chatto & Windus London
F. Jacob (1972) Die Logik des Lebenden Von der Urzeugung zum genetischen Code S. Fischer Frankfurt
I. Jahn (Eds) (2000) Geschichte der Biologie – Theorien, Methoden, Institutionen, Kurzbiographien Spektrum Verlag Heidelberg, Berlin
H. Jordan (1908) ArticleTitleÜber Entwicklung vom physiologischen Standpunkte aus Biol. Zentralbl. 28 278–287
H. Jordan (1913) Vergleichende Physiologie wirbelloser Tiere NumberInSeriesVol. 1 G. Fischer Jena
L. Kämpfe (1985) Evolution und Stammesgeschichte der Organismen G. Fischer Verlag Stuttgart
M. Kimura (1961) ArticleTitleNatural selection as the process of accumulating genetic information in adaptive evolution Genet. Res. 2 127–140
F.A. Kipp (1948) Höherentwicklung und Menschenwerdung Hippokrates Verlag Stuttgart
F.A. Kipp (1949) ArticleTitleArterhaltung und Individualisierung in der Tierreihe Verh. Deutsch. Zool. Ges. 42 24–27
R. Koselleck (1975) Fortschritt O. Brunner W. Conze R. Koselleck (Eds) Geschichtliche Grundbegriffe NumberInSeriesVol. 2 Klett Stuttgart 351–423
E. Kuhn-Schnyder (1954) ArticleTitleDer Ursprung der Säugetiere Vierteljahres Z. Naturforsch. Ges. Zürich 99 165–197
E. Kuhn-Schnyder (1967) Palaeontologie als stammesgeschichtliche Urkundenforschung G. Heberer (Eds) Die Evolution der Organismen Egebnisse und Problme der Abstammungslehre NumberInSeriesVol. 1 G. Fischer Verlag Stuttgart 350–373
C. Kummer (1987) Evolution als Höherentwicklung des Bewußtseins. Über die Intentionalen Voraussetzungen der materiellen Selbstorganisation Karl Alber Freiburg, München
M. LaBarbera (1986) The evolution and ecology of body size D.M. Raup D. Jablonsky (Eds) Patterns and Processes in the History of Life Springer Berlin 69–98
E. Lange (1976) ArticleTitleEin Beitrag zur Frage “Was ist Höherentwicklung?” Biol. Rundschau 14 206–214
J. Levinton (1988) Genetics, Paleontology, and Macroevolution Cambridge University Press Cambridge
R.C. Lewontin (1968) Evolution D.L. Sills (Eds) International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences NumberInSeriesVol. 5 The MacMillan Company and The Free Press Chicago 202–210
R. Lewontin (2000) The Triple Helix. GeneOrganism and Environment Harvard University Press Cambridge
A. Lovejoy (1974) The great chain of being: a study of the history of an idea Harvard University Press Cambridge
P.L. Luisi (2003) ArticleTitleAutopoiesis: a review and a reappraisal Die Naturwiss. 90 49–59
M. Mandelbaum (1971) History, Man, and Reason John Hopkins University Press Baltimore
J. Maynard Smith (1988) Evolutionary progress and levels of selection M.H. Nitecki (Eds) Evolutionary Progress? The University of Chicago Press Chicago 219–230
E. Mayr (1982) The Growth of Biological Thought. Diversity, Evolution, and Inheritance Harvard University Press Cambridge
E. Mayr (1988) Toward a New Philosophy of Biology Harvard University Press Cambridge
J.W. McCoy (1977) ArticleTitleComplexity in organic evolution J. Theoret. Biol. 68 457–458
F.K. McKinney (1987) ArticleTitle“Progress” in evolution Science 237 575
M.L. McKinney (1990) Trends in body-size evolution K.J. McNamara (Eds) Evolutionary Trends Belhaven Press London 75–118
K.J. McNamara (Eds) (1990) Evolutionary Trends Belhaven Press London
D.W. McShea (1991) ArticleTitleComplexity and evolution: what everybody knows Biol. Philos. 6 303–324 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00132234
D.W. McShea (1996) ArticleTitleMetazoan complexity and evolution: is there a trend? Evolution 50 477–492
D.W. McShea (1998) ArticleTitlePossible largest-scale trends in organismal evolution: eight ‘live hypotheses’ Ann. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 29 293–318 Occurrence Handle10.1146/annurev.ecolsys.29.1.293
D.W. McShea (2001) Parts and integration. consequences of hierarchy J.B.C. Jackson S. Lidgard F.K. McKinney (Eds) Evolutionary Patterns. GrowthFormand Tempo in the Fossil Record The University of Chicago Press Chicago and London 27–60
D.W. McShea (2002) ArticleTitleA complexity drain on cells in the evolution of multicellularity Evolution 56 441–452
Meckel J.F. 1821. System der vergleichenden Anatomie, Vol. 1, Halle.
W.E. Nagl (1986) Molecular phylogeny D.M. Raup D. Jablonsky (Eds) Patterns and Processes in the History of Life Springer Berlin 232–234
R.A. Nisbet (1969) Social Change and History: Aspects of the Western Theory of Development Oxford University Press New York
M.H. Nitecki (Eds) (1988) Evolutionary Progress? The University of Chicago Press Chicago
D. Ospovat (1981) The Development of Darwin’s Theory Harvard University Press Cambridge
P. Overhage (1957) ArticleTitleDer Biologische Aufstieg und seine Kriterien Acta Biotheoret. 12 80–115
P. Overhage (1963) Die Evolution des Lebendigen – das Phänomen Herder Freiburg, Basel, Wien
F. Papentin (1980) ArticleTitleOn order and complexity, I. General considerations J. Theoret. Biol. 87 421–456
B.C. Patten (1959) ArticleTitleAn introduction to the cybernetics of the ecosystem: the trophic-dynamic aspect Ecology 40 221–231
H.M. Peters (1972) Historischesoziologische und erkenntniskritische Aspekte der Lehre Darwins H.G. Gadamer P. Vogler (Eds) Neue Anthropologie, Part 1 Thieme Verlag Stuttgart 326–352
L. Plate (1928) ArticleTitleÜber Vervollkommnung, Anpassung und die Unterscheidung von niederen und höheren Tieren Zool. Jahrb. Abteilung Allg. Zool. 45 745–798
H. Quiring (1931) ArticleTitleDie Grundlagen des Artaufstiegs Forsch. Fortschr. 7 161–162
Rapp F. 1992. Fortschrit. Entwicklung und Sinngehalt einer philosophischen Idee. Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft Darmstadt.
D.M. Raup (1989) Testing the fossil record for evolutionary biology M.H. Nitecki (Eds) Evolutionary Progress? The University of Chicago Press Chicago, London 293–317
D.M. Raup J.J. Sepkoski (1982) ArticleTitleMass extinctions in the marine fossil record Science 215 1501–1503
A. Remane (1967) Die Geschichte der Tiere G. Heberer (Eds) Die Evolution der Organismen. Ergebnisse und Problme der Abstammungslehre NumberInSeriesVol. 1 G. Fischer Verlag Stuttgart 589–677
B. Rensch (1959) Evolution above the Species Level Columbia University Press New York
B. Rensch (1974) Polynomistic determination of biological processes F.J. Ayala T. Dobzhansky (Eds) Studies in the Philosophy of Biology: Reduction and Related Problems University of California Press Berkeley, Los Angeles 241–258
R.J. Richards (1992) The Meaning of Evolution: The Morphological Construction and Ideological Reconstruction of Darwin’s Theory University of Chicago Press Chicago
O. Rieppel (1991) ArticleTitleProgress in evolution: snakes as an example Z. Zool. Syst. Evol. Forsch. 29 208–212
O. Rieppel (1992) Unterwegs zum Anfang- Geschichte und Konsequenzen der Evolutionstheorie Deutscher Taschenbuch Verlag München
B. Rosslenbroich (2005) ArticleTitleThe Evolution of multicellularity in animals as a shift in biological autonomy Theory Biosci. 123 243–262
G. Roth (1981) Biological systems theory and the problem of reductionism G. Roth H. Schwegler (Eds) Self-organizing Systems. An Interdisciplinary Approach Campus Verlag Frankfurt, New York 106–120
J. Ruben (1995) ArticleTitleThe evolution of endothermy in mammals and birds: from physiology to fossils Ann. Rev. Physiol. 57 69–95
Ruben J. 1996. Evolution of endothermy in mammals, birds and their ancestors. In: Johnston I.A. and Bennett A.F. (eds), Animals and Temperature: Phenotypic and Evolutionary Adaptation. pp. 347–376.
M. Ruse (1988) Molecules to men: evolutionary biology and thoughts of progress M.H. Nitecki (Eds) Evolutionary Progress? The University of Chicago Press Chicago
M. Ruse (1996) Monad to Man. The Concept of Progress in Evolutionary Biology Harvard University Press Cambridge
P.T. Saunders M.W. Ho (1976) ArticleTitleOn the increase in complexity in evolution J. Theoret. Biol. 63 375–384
P.T. Saunders M.W. Ho (1981) ArticleTitleOn the increase in complexity in Evolution II. The relativity of complexity and the principle of minimum increase J. Theoret. Biol. 90 515–530
Schad W. 1992. Der Heterochronie-Modus in der Evolution der Wirbeltierklassen und Hominiden. Doctoral dissertation. University of Witten/Herdecke.
W. Schad (1993) ArticleTitleHeterochronical patterns of evolution in the transitional stages of vertebrate classes Acta Biotheoret. 41 383–389
W. Schad (1997) Die Zeitintegration als Evolutionsmodus University of Witten/Herdecke Habilitation
W. Schad (1998) Zeitgestalten der Natur. Goethe und die Evolutionsbiologie P. Matussek (Eds) Goethe und die Verzeitlichung der Natur Beck München 345–382
I.I. Schmalhausen (1949) Factors of Evolution The University of Chicago Press Chicago
F. Schuh (1937) ArticleTitleGedanken über die bei der tierischen Entwicklung hervortretenden Entwicklungsrichtungen Paläontol. Z. 19 117–126
P. Sima V. Vetvicka (1993) ArticleTitleEvolution of immune reactions Crit. Rev. Immunol. 13 83–114
G.G. Simpson (1971) The Meaning of Evolution Yale University Press New Haven, London
G.G. Simpson (1973) ArticleTitleThe concept of progress in organic evolution Social Res. 41 28–51
L.B. Slobodkin (1964) ArticleTitleThe strategy of evolution Am. Sci. 52 342–357
H. Smith (1953) From Fish to Philosopher Little Brown Boston
H. Spencer (1864) Principles of Biology Williams & Norgate London
S.M. Stanley (1973) ArticleTitleAn explanation for Cope’s Rule Evolution 27 1–26
S.M. Stanley (1979) Macroevolution Freeman San Francisco
G.L. Stebbins (1969) The Basis of Progressive Evolution University of North Carolina Press Chapel Hill
G.L. Stebbins (1982) Darwin to DNA Molecules to Humanity W.H. Freeman San Francisco
G.L Stebbins F.J. Ayala (1985) ArticleTitleDie Evolution des Darwinismus Spektrum Wiss. 9 58–71
V. Storch U. Welsch (1989) Evolution – Tatsachen und Probleme der Abstammungslehre Deutscher Taschenbuch Verlag München
E. Szathmary J. Maynard Smith (1995) ArticleTitleThe major evolutionary transitions Nature 374 227–232
P. Theilhard de Chardin (1959) Der Mensch im Kosmos Verlag C. H. Beck München
J.M. Thoday (1953) ArticleTitleComponents of fitness Symp. Soc. Exp. Biol. 7 96–113
J.M. Thoday (1958) Natural selection and biological progress S.A. Barnett (Eds) A Century of Darwin Allen & Unwin London 313–333
R.D.K. Thomas W.E. Reif (1993) ArticleTitleThe skeleton space: a finite set of organic designs Evolution 47 341–360
A. Urbaneck (1988) Morpho-physiological progress M.H. Nitecki (Eds) Evolutionary Progress? The University of Chicago Press Chicago 195–216
J.W. Valentine A.G. Collins C.P. Meyer (1993) ArticleTitleMorphological complexity increase in metazoans Paleobiology 20 131–142
F.J. Varela (1979) Principles of Biological Autonomy North Holland New York, Oxford
F.J. Varela (1981) Autonomy and autopoiesis G. Roth H. Schwegler (Eds) Self-organizing systems. An interdisciplinary approach Campus Verlag Frankfurt, New York 14–23
G.J. Vermeij (1987) Evolution and Escalation – an Ecological History of Life Princeton University Press Princeton
G.J. Vermeij (1999) ArticleTitleInequality and the directionality of history Am. Nat. 153 243–253 Occurrence Handle10.1086/303175
S. Vogel (1991) Struktur lebender Systeme: Grundzüge und Problematik W. Marx (Eds) Die Struktur lebendiger Systeme. Zu ihrer wissenschaftlichen und philosophischen Bestimmung Vitorio Klostermann Verlag Frankfurt 27–50
C.H. Waddington (1961a) The human animal J. Huxley (Eds) The Humanist Frame Allen & Unwin London 65–80
C.H. Waddington (1961b) The Nature of Life Allen & Unwin London
D.B. Wake (1986) Directions in the history of life group report D.M. Raup D. Jablonski (Eds) Patterns and Processes in the History of Life Report of the Dahlem Workshop on Patterns and Processes in the History of Life Springer-Verlag Berlin
B.H. Weber D.J. Depew C. Dyke S.N. Salthe E.D. Schneider R.E. Ulanowicz J.S. Wicken (1989) ArticleTitleEvolution in thermodynamic perspective: an ecological approach Biol. Philos. 4 373–405 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00162587
J.S. Wicken (1979) ArticleTitleThe generation of complexity in evolution: a thermodynamic and information-theoretical discussion J. Theoret. Biol. 77 349–365
J.S. Wicken (1987) Evolution, Thermodynamics, and Information University Press Oxford
W. Wieser (1994) Die Evolution der Evolutionstheorie. Von Darwin zur DNA Spektrum Verlag Heidelberg, Berlin
W. Wieser (1998) Die Erfindung der Individualität oder Die zwei Gesichter der Evolution Spektrum Verlag Heidelberg, Berlin
G.C. Williams (1966) Adaptation and Natural Selection. A Critique of some Current Evolutionary Thought Princeton University Press Princeton
E.O. Wilson (1992) The Diversity of Life Penguin Press London
W.C. Wimsatt J.C. Schank (1988) Two constraints on the evolution of complex adaptations and the means for their avoidance M.H. Nitecki (Eds) Evolutionary Progress? The University of Chicago Press Chicago 231–237
F.M. Wuketits (1979) ArticleTitleDie Bedeutung des Systemdenkens in der Biologie Biol. unserer Zeit 9 73–79 Occurrence Handle10.1002/biuz.19790090305
Wuketits F.M. 1982. Grundriß der Evolutionstheorie. Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft Darmstadt.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Rosslenbroich, B. The Notion of Progress in Evolutionary Biology – The Unresolved Problem and an Empirical Suggestion. Biol Philos 21, 41–70 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-005-0957-4
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-005-0957-4