Abstract
Our aim in the present paper is to approach the nature of life from the perspective of autonomy, showing that this perspective can be helpful for overcoming the traditional Cartesian gap between the physical and cognitive domains. We first argue that, although the phenomenon of life manifests itself as highly complex and multidimensional, requiring various levels of description, individual organisms constitute the core of this multifarious phenomenology. Thereafter, our discussion focuses on the nature of the organization of individual living entities, proposing autonomy as the main concept to grasp it. In the second part of the article we show how autonomy is also fundamental to explaining major evolutionary transitions, in an attempt to rethink evolution from the point of view of the organizational structure of the entities/organisms involved. This gives further support to the idea of autonomy not only as a key to understanding life in general but also the complex expressions of it that we observe on our planet. Finally, we suggest a possible general principle that underlies those evolutionary transitions, which allow for the open-ended redefinition of autonomous systems: namely, the relative dynamic decoupling that must be articulated among distinct parts, modules or modes of operation in these systems.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Andrianantoandro, E., Basu, S., Karig, D., & Weiss, R. (2006). Synthetic biology: New engineering rules for an emerging discipline. Molecular Systems Biology. doi:10.1038/msb4100073.
Barandiaran, X. (2008). Mental life: A naturalized approach to the autonomy of cognitive agents. PhD Dissertation, University of the Basque Country (UPV/EHU).
Barandiaran X., Moreno A. (2006) On what makes certain dynamical systems cognitive. Adaptive Behavior 14(2): 171–185
Barandiaran X., Moreno A. (2008) Adaptivity: From metabolism to behavior. Adaptive Behavior 16(5): 325–344
Barandiaran X., Rohde M., Di Paolo E. (2009) Defining agency: Individuality, normativity, asymmetry and spatiotemporality in action. Journal of Adaptive Behavior 17(5): 367–386
Bedau M. (1996) The nature of life. In: Boden M. (Ed.) The philosophy of artificial life. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 332–357
Bedau M. (1998) Four puzzles about life. Artificial Life 4: 125–140
Bedau M. (2003) Artificial life: Organization, adaptation, and complexity from the bottom up. Trends in Cognitive Science 7: 505–512
Bechtel W. (2006) Discovering cell mechanisms: The creation of modern cell biology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Bechtel W. (2007) Biological mechanisms: Organized to maintain autonomy. In: Boogerd F., Bruggeman F., Hofmeyr J. H., Westerhoff H. V. (eds) Systems biology: Philosophical Foundations. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 269–302
Benner S. A., Sismour A. M. (2005) Synthetic biology. Nature Reviews Genetics 6: 533–543
Bickhard M. H. (2000) Autonomy, function, and representation. Communication and Cognition: Artificial Intelligence 17(3–4): 111–131
Bickhard M. H. (2009) The biological foundations of cognitive science. New Ideas in Psychology 27: 75–84
Boden M. A. (1999) Is metabolism necessary?. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 50: 231–248
Bonner J. T. (2000) First signals: The evolution of multicellular development. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Buss L. (1987) The evolution of individuality. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Calvo, P., Gomila, T. (eds) (2008) Handbook of cognitive science: An embodied approach. Elsevier, Amsterdam
Christensen W., Bickhard M. (2002) The process dynamics of normative function. Monist 85(1): 3–28
Christensen W. D., Hooker C. A. (2000) An interactivist-constructivist approach to intelligence: Self-directed anticipative learning. Philosophical Psychology 13: 5–45
Clark A. (1997) Being there: Putting brain, body and world together again. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Cleland, C. E. (2011). Life without definitions. Synthese. doi:10.1007/s11229-011-9879-7.
Cleland C. E., Chyba C. F. (2002) Defining ‘life’. Origins of Life 32: 387–393
Cleland C. E., Chyba C. F. (2007) Does ‘life’ have a definition?. In: Sullivan W. T., Baross J. A. (eds) Planets and life: The emerging science of astrobiology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Conrad M. (1979) Bootstrapping on the adaptive landscape. BioSystems 11: 167–182
Conrad M. (1990) The geometry of evolution. BioSystems 24: 61–81
Cornish-Bowden A., Cárdenas M.L., Letelier J.C., Soto-Andrade J. (2007) Beyond reductionism: metabolic circularity as a guiding vision for a real biology of system. Proteomics 7: 839–845
Craver C. F. (2001) Role functions, mechanisms, and hierarchy. Philosophy of Science 68: 53–74
Cummins, R. (1975). Functional analysis. Journal of Philosophy, 72, 741–765 (Reprinted in D. J. Buller (Ed.). (1999). Function, selection, and design (pp. 57–83). Albany, NY: SUNY Press.).
Davies P. S. (2001) Norms of nature: Naturalism and the nature of functions. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Dawkins R. (1976) The selfish gene. Oxford University Press, New York
De Duve C. (1991) Blueprint for a cell: The nature and origin of life. Neil Patterson Publishers, Burlington, NC
De Duve C. (2002) Life evolving. Oxford University Press, New York
Delancey C. (2006) Ontology and teleofunctions: A defense and revision of the systematic account of teleological explanation. Synthese 150: 69–98
Dennett D. (1995) Darwin’s dangerous idea. Simon and Schuster, New York, NY
Di Paolo E. (2005) Autopoiesis, adaptivity, teleology, agency. Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 4(4): 429–452
Dupré J., O’Malley M.A. (2009) Varieties of living things: Life at the intersection of lineage and metabolism. Philosophy and Theory in Biology 1(e003): 1–25
Edin B. (2008) Assigning biological functions: Making sense of causal chains. Synthese 161: 203–218
Eigen M., Schuster P. (1979) The hypercycle: A principle of natural self-organization. Springer, Berlin
Elsasser W. M. (1966) Atom and organism. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ
Emmeche C., Hoffmeyer J. (1991) From language to nature: The semiotic metaphor in biology. Semiotica 84(1/2): 1–42
Endy D. (2005) Foundations for engineering biology. Nature 438: 449–453
Gánti T. (1971) The principle of life (1st ed.). Gondolat, Budapest
Gerhart J., Kirschner M. (1997) Cells, embryos, and evolution. Blackwell Science, Malden, MA. (in Hungarian)
Gibas R. W. (2005) Embodiment and cognitive science. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Godfrey-Smith P. (1994) A modern history theory of functions. Noûs 28: 344–362
Gould, S. J. (1985). The flamingo’s smile (Chapt. 1.5). New York: W. W. Norton.
Griesemer J., Szathmáry E. (2009) Ganti’s chemoton model and life criteria. In: Rasmussen S., Bedau M. A., Chen L., Deamer D., Krakauer D. C., Packard N. H., Stadler P. F. (eds) Protocells: Bridging nonliving and living matter. MIT Press, Cambridge, pp 481–512
Haldane, J. B. S. (1994/1929). The origin of life. In D. W. Deamer & G. R. Fleischaker (Eds.), Origins of life: The central concepts (pp. 73–81). Boston: Jones and Barlett.
Haraway D. (1976) Crystals, fabrics, and fields. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore
Harold F. (1986) The vital force: A study of bioenergetics. Freeman, New York
Harold H. (2001) The way of the cell. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Hertel J., Lindemeyer M., Missal K., Fried C., Tanzer A., Flamm C., Hofacker I. L., Stadler P. F. (2006) The expansion of the metazoan microRNA repertoire. BMC Genomics 7(1): 25
Hoffmeyer J. (1996) Signs of meaning in the universe: The natural history of signification. Indiana University Press, Bloomington, IN
Hooker C. A. (1995) Reason, regulation and realism: Toward a regulatory systems theory of reason and evolutionary epistemology. State University of New York Press, Albany
Hooker C. (2009) Interaction and bio-cognitive order. Synthese 166: 513–546
Jonas H. (1966) The phenomenon of life: Toward a philosophical biology. Harper and Row, New York
Kant, I. (1790/1952). Critique of judgment. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Kauffman S. (2000) Investigations. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Kauffman S. (2003) Molecular autonomous agents. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London A 361: 1089–1099
Keim C. N., Martins J. L., Abreu F., Rosado A. S., Linsde Barros H., Borojevic R., Lins U., Farina M. (2004) Multicellular life cycle of magnetotactic prokaryotes. FEMS Microbiology Letters 240(2): 203–208
Keller E. F. et al (2008) What is wrong with the question, What is Life?. In: Marrati P. (Ed.) Concepts of life. Stanford University Press, Stanford
Kirschner M., Gerhart J. (1998) Evolvability. PNAS 95(15): 8420–8427
Kitano H. (2002) Computational systems biology. Nature 420: 206–210
Lewontin R. C. (1970) The units of selection. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 1: 1–18
López-García P., Moreira D. (2004) The synthrophy hypothesis for the origin of eukaryotes. In: Seckbach J. (Ed.) Symbiosis: Mechanisms and model systems. Kluwer Academia Publishers, Dordrecht, Boston, London, pp 133–147
Lyon P. (2006) The biogenic approach to cognition. Cognitive processes 7: 11–29
Lyon P., Keijzer F. et al (2007) The human stain: Why cognitivism can’t tell us what cognition is and what it does. In: Wallace B. (Ed.) The mind, the body and the world: Psychology after cognitivism?. Imprint Academic, London, pp 132–165
Mansy S. et al (2008) Template directed synthesis of a genetic polymer in a model protocell. Nature 454: 122–126
Margulis L. (1991) Symbiosis as a source of evolutionary innovation: Speciation and morphogenesis. MIT Press, Cambridge, London
Margulis L., Sagan D. (2002) Acquiring genomes: A theory of the origins of species. Basic Books, New York
Mattick J. (2004) The hidden genetic program of complex organisms. Scientific American 291(4): 60–67
Maturana H., Varela F. J. (1973) De máquinas y seres vivos: Una teoría sobre la organización biológica. Editorial Universitaria S.A, Santiago de Chile
Maturana H., Varela F. (1992) The tree of knowledge. Shambala, Boston
Maynard Smith J. (1986) The problems of biology. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Mayr E. (1982) The growth of biological thought. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
McLaughlin P. (2001) What functions explain: Functional explanation and self-reproducing systems. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Michod R. E. (1999) Darwinian dynamics: Evolutionary transitions in fitness and individuality. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ
Michod, R. E., & Roze, D. (1999). Cooperation and conflict in the evolution of individuality. Part III. Transitions in the unit of fitness. In C. L. Nehaniv (Ed.), Mathematical and computational biology: Digital evolution, hierachical complexity, and computational morphogenesis. American Mathematical Society Series: Lectures on Mathematics in the Life Sciences (Vol. 26, pp. 47–91).
Miller S. L. (1953) A production of amino acids under possible primitive Earth conditions. Science 117: 528–529
Millikan R. G. (1989) In defense of proper functions. Philosophy of Science 56: 288–302
Montoya J. M., Solé R. V. (2002) Small world patterns in food webs. Journal of Theoretical Biology 214: 405–412
Moreno A., Etxeberria A. (2005) Agency in natural and artificial systems. Artificial Life 11(1–2): 161–176
Moreno A., Etxeberria A., Umerez J. (2008) The autonomy of biological individuals and artificial models. BioSystems 91(2): 309–319
Moreno A., Lasa A. (2003) From basic adaptivity to early mind: The origin and evolution of cognitive capacities. Evolution and Cognition 9(1): 12–24
Moreno A., Ruiz-Mirazo K. (1999) Metabolism and the problem of its universalization. BioSystems 49(1): 45–61
Moreno A., Ruiz Mirazo K. (2009) The problem of the emergence of functional diversity in prebiotic evolution. Biology and Philosophy 24(5): 585–605
Morowitz H. J., Heinz B., Deamer D. W. (1988) The chemical logic of a minimum protocell. Origins of Life and Evolution of the Biosphere 18: 281–287
Moss L. (2006) Redundancy, plasticity, and detachment: The implications of comparative genomics for evolutionary thinking. Philosophy of Science 73: 930–946
Mossio M., Saborido C., Moreno A. (2009) An organizational account for biological functions. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 60(4): 813–841
Nagel E. (1977) Teleology revisited. Journal of Philosophy 74: 261–301
Neander K. (1991) Function as selected effects: The conceptual analyst’s defense. Philosophy of Science 58: 168–184
Nehaniv C. L. (2003) Evolvability (editorial, special issue on evolvability, dedicated to the memory of Professor Michael Conrad). BioSystems 69(2–3): 77–81
Noireaux V., Libchaber A. (2004) A vesicle bioreactor as a step toward an artificial cell assembly. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 101: 17669–17674
Oliver J. D., Perry R. S. (2006) Definitely life but not definitively. Origins of Life and Evolution of the Biosphere 36: 515–521
O’Malley M. A., Dupré J. (2007) Size doesn’t matter: Towards a more inclusive philosophy of biology. Biology and Philosophy 22: 155–191
Oparin, A. I. (1994/1928). The origin of life. In D. W. Deamer & G. R. Fleischaker (Eds.), Origins of life: The central concepts (pp. 31–71). Boston: Jones and Barlett.
Oró J. (1961) Mechanism of synthesis of adenine from hydrogen cyanide under possible primitive earth conditions. Nature 191: 1193–1194
Pattee H. H. (1972) Laws and constraints, symbols and languages. In: Waddington C. H. (Ed.) Towards a theoretical biology 4, Essays. Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh, pp 248–258
Pattee H. H. (1977) Dynamic and linguistic modes of complex systems. International Journal of General Systems 3: 259–266
Pattee H. H. (1982) Cell psychology: An evolutionary approach to the symbol-matter problem. Cognition and Brain Theory 5(4): 325–341
Polanyi M. (1968) Life’s irreducible structure. Science 160: 1308–1312
Rasmussen, S., Bedau, M. A., Chen, L., Deamer, D., Krakauer, D. C., Packard, N. H., Stadler, P. F. (eds) (2008) Protocells: Bridging nonliving and living matter. MIT Press, Cambridge
Ravesz E., Somera A. L., Mongru D. A., Oltvai Z. N., Barabassi A. L. (2002) Hierarchical organization of modularity in metabolic networks. Science 297: 1551–1555
Rosen R. (1958) A relational theory of biological systems. Bulletin of Mathematical Biophysics 20: 245–260
Rosen R. (1991) Life itself: A comprehensive inquiry into the nature, origin and fabrication of life. Columbia University Press, New York
Rosslenbroich B. (2005) The evolution of multicellularity in animals as a shift in biological autonomy. Theory in Biosciences 123: 243–262
Rosslenbroich B. (2006) The notion of progress in evolutionary biology. The unresolved problem and an empirical suggestion. Biology and Philosophy 21: 41–70
Rosslenbroich B. (2009) The theory of increasing autonomy in evolution—a new proposal for understanding macroevolutionary innovations. Biology and Philosophy 24: 623–644
Ruiz-Mirazo K., Etxeberria A., Moreno A., Ibáñez J. (2000) Organisms and their place in biology. Theory in Biosciences 119: 43–67
Ruiz-Mirazo K., Mavelli F. (2008) On the way towards ‘basic autonomous agents’: Stochastic simulations of minimal lipid-peptide cells. BioSystems 91: 374–387
Ruiz-Mirazo K., Moreno A. (2000) Searching for the roots of autonomy: The natural and artificial paradigms revisited. CCAI (Special issue on autonomy) 17(3–4): 209–228
Ruiz-Mirazo K., Moreno A. (2004) Basic autonomy as a fundamental step in the synthesis of life. Artificial Life 10(3): 235–259
Ruiz-Mirazo K., Pereto J., Moreno A. (2004) A universal definition of life: Autonomy and open-ended evolution. Origins of Life and Evolution of the Biosphere 34: 323–346
Ruiz-Mirazo K., Peretó J., Moreno A. (2010) Defining life or bringing biology to life. Origins of Life and Evolution of the Biosphere 40: 203–213
Ruiz-Mirazo K., Umerez J., Moreno A. (2008) Enabling conditions for open-ended evolution. Biology and Philosophy 23(1): 67–85
Russell S. J., Norvig P. (1995) Artificial intelligence: A modern approach. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
Schlosser G. (1998) Self-re-production and functionality: A systems-theoretical approach to teleological explanation. Synthese 116: 303–354
Schwann, T. (1839). Mikroskopische Untersuchungen über die Übereinstimmung in der Struktur und dem Wachstum der Thiere und Pflanzen. Berlin [1847, Microscopical researches into the accordance in the structure and growth of animals and plants]. London: Sydenham Society.
Skulatchev V. P. (1992) The laws of cell energetics. European Journal of Biochemistry 208: 203–209
Smithers T. (1997) Autonomy in robots and other agents. Brain and Cognition 34: 88–106
Sniegowski P. D., Murphy H. A. (2006) Evolvability. Current Biology 16: R831–R834
Solé R. V., Munteanu A., Rodriguez-Caso C., Macía J. (2007) Synthetic protocell biology: From reproduction to computation. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B 362: 1727–1739
Stelreny K., Griffiths P. E. (1999) Sex and death: An introduction to philosophy of biology. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Szathmary E. (2006) The origin of replicators and reproducers. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B 361: 1761–1776
Taft R. J., Pheasant M., Mattick J. S. (2007) The relationship between non-protein-coding DNA and eukaryotic complexity. BioEssays 29: 288–297
Thomson E. (2007) Mind in life. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Varela F. J. (1979) Principles of biological autonomy. North Holland, New York
Varela F. J., Maturana H., Uribe R. (1974) Autopoiesis: The organization of living systems, its characterization and a model. BioSystems 5: 187–196
Varela F. J., Thomson E., Rosch E. (1991) The embodied mind. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
von Uexküll, J. (1982/1940). The theory of meaning. Semiotica, 42(1), 25–87.
Wagner G. P., Altenberg L. (1996) Complex adaptations and the evolution of evolvability. Evolution 50(3): 967–976
Watson R. A., Pollack J. B. (2003) A computational model of symbiotic composition in evolutionary transitions. Biosystems 69(2–3): 187–209
Weber A., Varela F. (2002) Life after Kant: Natural purposes and the autopoietic foundations of biological individuality. Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 1: 97–125
Wicken J. S. (1987) Evolution, thermodynamics and information: Extending the Darwinian program. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Wimsatt, W. (1980) Reductionistic research strategies and their biases in the units of selection controversy. In T. Nickles (Ed.), Scientific discovery: Case studies (Vol. II, pp. 213–259). Dordrecht: Reidel.
Wright L. (1973) Functions. Philosophical Review 82: 139–168
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Ruiz-Mirazo, K., Moreno, A. Autonomy in evolution: from minimal to complex life. Synthese 185, 21–52 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-011-9874-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-011-9874-z