Skip to main content
Log in

Abstract

Considerations of virtue and character appear from time to time in the agricultural biotechnology literature. Critics of the technologies often suggest that they are contrary to some virtue (usually humility) or do not fit with the image of ourselves and the human place in the world that we ought to embrace. In this article, I consider the aretaic or virtue-based objection that to engage in agricultural biotechnology is to exhibit arrogance, hubris, and disaffection. In section one, I discuss Gary Comstock's treatment of this objection. In section two, I provide an alternative interpretation of the objection that more accurately reflects the concerns of those who offer the criticism than does Comstock's standard interpretation. In sections three and four, I assess the objection. I argue that despite its merits, the objection does not justify global opposition to agricultural biotechnology. Instead, it favors a limited endorsement position not unlike the one defended by Comstock.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

REFERENCES

  • Bailey, R., “Dr. Strangelunch:Why We Should Learn to Love Genetically Modified Food,” in G.Pence (ed.), The Ethics of Food (Rowman and Littlefield, 2002), pp. 100–115.

  • Bailey, B. and M. Lappe, Against the Grain:Biotechnology and the Corporate Takeover of Your Food (Common Courage Press, 1998).

  • Berry, W., The Unsettling of America:Culture and Agriculture (Sierra Club Books, 1977).

  • Berry, W., “A Defense of the Family Farm,” in G.Comstock (ed.), Is There a Moral Obligation to Save the Family Farm?(Iowa Sate Press, 1987).

  • Borlaug, N., “Are We Going Mad?”in G.Pence (ed.), The Ethics of Food (Rowman and Littlefield, 2002), pp.74–79.

  • Cafaro, P., “Thoreau, Leopold, and Carson:Toward an Environmental Virtue Ethics,” Environmental Ethics 23(1)(2001), 3–17.

    Google Scholar 

  • Comstock, G., Vexing Nature?:On the Ethical Case Against Agricultural Biotechnology (Kluwer, 2000).

  • Conway, G., “Open Letter to Greenpeace,” in M.Ruse and D.Castle (eds.), Genetically Modified Foods:Debating Biotechnology (Prometheus Books, 2002), pp.63–64.

  • Erickson, R., “On Environmental Virtue Ethics,” Environmental Ethics 16(3)(1994), 334–336.

    Google Scholar 

  • Frasz, G., “Environmental Virtue Ethics:A New Direction for Environmental Ethics,” Environmental Ethics 15(3)(1993), 259–274.

    Google Scholar 

  • Frasz, G., “What is Environmental Virtue Ethics that We Should Be Mindful of It?” Philosophy in the Contemporary World 8(2)(2001), 5–14.

    Google Scholar 

  • GeneWatch, “Genetic Engineering:Can it Feed the World?”http://www.gene-watch.org/CropsAndFood/briefs.htm#Brief3 (1998).

  • Gifford, F., “Biotechnology,” in G.Comstock (ed.), Life Science Ethics (Iowa State Press, 2002), pp.191–224.

  • Gould, S. J., “On the Origin of Specious Critics,” Discover (January 1985), 34–42.

  • Grant, J., The State of the World 's Children (Oxford University Press, 1991).

  • Greenpeace, “Genetically Engineered 'Golden Rice 'is Fools Gold,” in M. Ruse and D. Castle (eds.), Genetically Modified Foods:Debating Biotechnology (Prometheus Books, 2002), pp.52–54.

  • Hill, T., “Ideals of Human Excellence and Preserving Natural Environments,” Environmental Ethics 5(3)(1983), 211–224.

    Google Scholar 

  • Humphrey, J., K. West Jr., and A.Sommer, “Vitamin A De ciency and Attributable Mortality among Under-5-Year-Olds,” World Health Organization Bulletin 10 (1992).

  • Jackson, W., “Our Vision for the Agricultural Sciences Need Not Include Biotechnology,” Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 4 (1991), 207–215.

    Google Scholar 

  • Katz, E., “The Big Lie,” in W.Throop (ed.), Environmental Restoration (Humanity Books, 2000), pp.83–93.

  • Lappe, M., “A Perspective on Anti-Biotechnology Convictions,” in B. Bailey and M.Lappe (eds.), Engineering the Farm:Ethical and Social Aspects of Agricultural Biotechnology (Island Press, 2002), pp.135–156.

  • Lappe, M. and B. Bailey, “Biotechnology 's Negative Impact on World Agriculture,” in Gregory Pence (ed.), The Ethics of Food (Rowman and Little eld, 2002), pp. 156–167.

  • McKibben, B., The End of Nature, 2nd edn.(Anchor Books, 1999).

  • McKibben, B., Enough (Times Books, 2003).

  • Osborne, L., “Got Silk,” New York Times (June 16, 2002).

  • Potrykus, I., “Golden Rice and the Greenpeace Dilemma,” in M. Ruse and D. Castle (eds.), Genetically Modi ed Foods:Debating Biotechnology (Prometheus Books, 2002), pp.55–57.

  • Raffensperger, C., “Learning to Speak Ethics in Technological Debates,” in B. Bailey and M. Lappe (eds.), Engineering the Farm:Ethical and Social Aspects of Agricultural Biotechnology (Island Press, 2002), pp.125–133.

  • Rifkin, J., Algeny (Viking Press, 1983).

  • Rossett, P., “Taking Seriously the Claim that Genetic Engineering Could End Hunger:A Critical Analysis,” in B. Bailey and M. Lappe (eds.), Engineering the Farm:Ethical and Social Aspects of Agricultural Biotechnology (Island Press, 2002), pp.81–93.

  • Shaw, B., “A Virtue Ethics Approach to Aldo Leopold 's Land Ethic,” Environmental Ethics, 19(1)(1997), 53–67.

    Google Scholar 

  • Shiva, V., Biopiracy:The Plunder of Nature and Knowledge (South End, 1997).

  • Shiva, V., “Golden Rice is a Hoax:When Public Relations Replace Science" in M. Ruse and D. Castle (eds.), Genetically Modi ed Foods:Debating Biotechnology (Prometheus Books, 2002a), pp.58–62.

  • Shiva, V., “Genetic Engineering and Food Security,” in G. Pence (ed.), The Ethics of Food (Rowman and Little eld, 2002b), pp.130–147.

  • Sommer, A., “New Imperatives for an Old Vitamin (A),” Journal of Nutrition 119 (1988).

  • Taylor, P., Respect for Nature:A Theory of Environmental Ethics (Princeton Uni-versity Press, 1986).

  • Trewavas, A., “GM Food is the Best Option We Have,” in G. Pence (ed.), The Ethics of Food (Rowman and Littlefield, 2002a), pp.158–155.

  • Trewavas, A., “The Population/Diversity Paradox:Agricultural Efficiency to Save Wilderness,” in G. Pence (ed.), The Ethics of Food (Rowman and Littlefield, 2002b), pp.168–179.

  • Vogel, S., “Environmental Philosophy after the End of Nature,” Environmental Ethics 24(1)(2002).

  • Wambugu, F., “Why Africa Needs Agricultural Biotech,” in M. Ruse and D. Castle (eds.), Genetically Modiffied Foods:Debating Biotechnology (Prometheus Books, 2002), pp.304–308.

  • Welchman, J., “The Virtues of Stewardship,” Environmental Ethics 21(4)(1999), 411–423.

    Google Scholar 

  • Wenz, P., “Just Garbage,” in L. Westra and B. Lawson (eds.), Faces of Environ-mental Racism:Confronting Issues of Global Justice, 2nd edn.(Rowman and Little field, 2001), pp.57–71.

  • West Jr., K., G. Howard, and A.Sommer, “Vitamin A and Infection:Public Health Implications,” Annual Review of Nutrition 9 (1989).

  • Worster, D., “Good Farming and the Public Good,” in W. Jackson, W. Berry, and B. Colman (eds.), Meeting the Expectations of the Land:Essays in Sustainable Agriculture and Stewardship (North Point Press, 1984).

  • Ye, X., S. Al-Babili, A. Kloti, J. Zhang, P. Lucca, P. Beyer, and I. Potrykus, “Engineering the Provitamin A (Beta-Carotene)Biosynthetic Pathway into (Carotenoid-Free)Rice Endosperm,” Science 287 (2000):303–305.

    Google Scholar 

Download references

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Authors

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Sandler, R. An Aretaic Objection to Agricultural Biotechnology. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 17, 301–317 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1023/B:JAGE.0000033078.05859.08

Download citation

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/B:JAGE.0000033078.05859.08

Navigation