Abstract
One common method of criticizing genetically modified organisms (GMOs) is to label them as “magic bullets.” However, this criticism, like many in the debate over GMOs, is not very clear. What exactly is the “magic bullet criticism”? What are its origins? What flaw is it pointing out in GM crops and agricultural biotechnology? What is the scope of the criticism? Does it apply to all GMOs, or just some? Does it point to a fatal flaw, or something that can be fixed? The goal of this paper is to answer these questions and clarify the magic bullet criticism of agricultural biotechnology. It is hoped that the results of this exercise will be helpful in advancing deliberation over the role GMOs and agricultural biotechnology should play in 21st century agriculture.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
M. Alteiri (2000) Food First Special Report No. 1. Genetic Engineering in Agriculture: The Myths, Environmental Risks, and Alternatives Food First/Institute for Food and Development Policy Oakland CA
Benbrock, C., “Do GM crops mean less pesticide use?” Pesticide Outlook. October 2001.
D. Charles (2001) Lords of the Harvest: Biotech, Big Money, and the Future of Food Perseus Publishing Cambridge, MA
R. Dubos (1993) Mirage of Health: Utopias, Progress, and Biological Change Rutgers University Press Rutgers, NJ
S. Krimsky R. Wrubel (1996) Agricultural Biotechnology and the Environment University of Illinois Press Urbana, IL
T. Kuhn (1970) The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, Second Edition University of Chicago Press Chicago
L. Nordenfelt I. Lindhal (1984) Health, Disease, and Causal Explanation in Medicine D. Reidel Publishing Co Boston
S. Norell (1984) “Models of Causation in Epidemiology” L. Nordenfelt I. Lindahls (Eds) Health, Disease, and Causal Explanation in Medicine D. Reidel Publishing Co Boston
Schuman, A. J., “A Concise History of Antimicrobial Therapy.” Contemporary Pediatrics (October 2003), 65–85.
P. Thompson (1995) The Spirit of the Soil: Agriculture and Environmental Ethics Routledge London
University of California, integrated pest management. Web site: http://www.ipm.usdavis.edu/ (accessed 1/15/04).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Scott, D. The Magic Bullet Criticism of Agricultural Biotechnology. J Agric Environ Ethics 18, 259–267 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-005-0632-4
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-005-0632-4