Abstract
The field of cognitive imaging is explodingboth in terms of the amount of our scientificresources dedicated to it and the associatedpublication rate. However, all of this effortis based on a critical question – Do cognitivemodules exist? Both of the reviewers of my book(Uttal, 2001) and I agree that this questionhas not yet been satisfactorily answered and,depending on the ultimate answer, the cognitiveimaging approach as well as some other parts ofthe quest for mechanistic models of mind mightnot be successful. Our views of how our scienceshould respond to this serious problem,however, are quite different. Both ProfessorBechtel and Lloyd argue for an optimisticattack on the problem of the localization ofcognitive processes in the brain based on thehistory of other sciences. I argue that arealistic appreciation of the limits of thisapproach should temper the enthusiasm for whatultimately will go the way of other attempts tounravel the mind-brain problem.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bremermann, H.J., 1971: What mathematics can and cannot do for pattern recognition, in O.–J. Grusser and R. Klinke (eds), Pattern Recognition in Biological and Technical Systems, Springer–Verlag, Heidelberg.
Bremermann, H.J., 1977: Complexity and transcomputability, in R. Duncan and M. Weston–Smith (eds), The Encyclopedia of Ignorance, Pocket Books, New York.
Cabeza, R., and Nyberg, L., 2000: Imaging Cognition II: An empirical review of 275 PET and fMRI studies, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 12, 1–47.
Cohen, J.D., and Tong, F., 2001: The face of controversy, Science 293, 2405–2407.
Hilgetag, C.C., O'Neill, M.A., and Young, M.P., 1996: Indeterminate organization of the visual system, Science 271, 776–777.
MacCorquodale, K., and Meehl, P.E., 1948: On a distinction between hypothetical constructs and intervening variables, Psychological Review 55, 95–107.
Moore, E.F., 1956: Automata Studies, Princeton University Press, Princeton NJ.
Pachella, R.G., 1974: The interpretation of reaction time in information processing research, in B.H. Kantowitz (ed.), Human Information Processing: Tutorials in Performance and Cognition, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ, pp. 41–82.
Platt, J.R., 1964: Strong inference, Science 146, 347–353.
Pulvermüller, F., 1999: Words in the brain's language, Behavioral and Brain Science 22, 253–336.
Stoker, J.J., 1950: Nonlinear Vibrations in Mechanical and Electrical Systems, Interscience, New York.
Uttal, W.R., 1998: Toward a New Behaviorism: The Case Against Perceptual Reductionism, Erlbaum, Mahwah NJ.
Uttal, W.R., 2000: The War Between Mentalism and Behaviorism: On the Accessibility of Mental Processes, Erlbaum, Mahwah NJ.
Uttal, W.R., 2001: The New Phrenology: The Limits of Localizing Cognitive Processes in the Brain, MIT Press, Cambridge MA.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Uttal, W.R. Response to Bechtel and Lloyd. Brain and Mind 3, 261–273 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1019944825779
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1019944825779