Abstract
In this paper I present a historiography of the recent emergence of philosophy of chemistry. Special attention is given to the interest in this domain in Eastern Europe before the collapse of the USSR. It is shown that the initial neglect of the philosophy of chemistry is due to the unanimous view in philosophy and philosophy of science that only physics is a proper science (to put in Kant's words). More recently, due to the common though incorrect assumption that chemistry can in principle be reduced to physics, the neglect continued, even when interest in sciences such as biology and psychology entered more strongly in philosophy of science. It is concluded that chemistry is an autonomous science and is perhaps a more ‘typical’ science than physics.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
B. Abbott, A Note on the Nature of ‘Water’. Mind 106: 311–319, 1997.
F. Abbri, Lavoisier and the Foundations of Chemistry. In Mosini (Ed.), 1996, pp. 143–154.
N.T. Abramova, R.W. Garawenko and E.F. Solonov, Voprosi Filosofii 17(8): 176, 1963.
F.M. Akeroyd, A Challenge to the Followers of Lakatos. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 37: 359–362, 1986.
F.M. Akeroyd, Research Programmes and Empirical Results. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 39: 51–58, 1988.
F.M. Akeroyd, An Oscillatory Model of the Growth of Scientific Knowledge. The British Journal of the Philosophy of Science 41: 407–414, 1990.
F.M. Akeroyd, The Challenge to Lakatos Restated. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 39: 437–439, 1990a.
F.M. Akeroyd, Laudan's Problem Solving Model. The British Journal of the Philosophy of Science 44: 785–788, 1993.
F.M. Akeroyd, Poppers Beitrag für eine Philosophie der Chemie. In K. Ruthenberg and J. Schummer (Eds.), Philosophie der Chemie: Bestandsaufnahme und Ausblick. Königshausen & Neumann, Würzburg, 1996 Psarros et al. (Eds.), 1996, pp. 67–76.
F.M. Akeroyd, Conceptual Aspects of Theory Appraisal: Some Biochemical Examples. Hyle 3: 95–102, 1997.
D. Allchin, A Twentieth-Century Phlogiston: Constructing Error and Differentiating Domains. Perspectives on Science 5: 81–127, 1997.
A. Amman, Chirality: A Superselection Rule Generated by the Molecular Environment? Journal of Mathematical Chemistry 6: 1–15, 1990.
A. Amann, Must a Molecule have a Shape? South African Journal of Chemistry 45: 29–38, 1992.
A. Amman, The Gestalt Problem in Quantum Theory: Generation of Molecular Shape by the Environment. Synthese 97: 125–156, 1993.
A. Amman, Individual Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics and Quantum Theory of Molecular Shape. In Mosini (Ed.), 1996, pp. 21–48.
AN SSSR Der gegenwärtige Stand der Strukturtheorie in der organischen Chemie, translated from the Russian (USSR Academy of Science, Department of Chemical Sciences) by G. Rudakoff and published by the Chemical Society of the DDR (1956), Akademie-Verlag, Berlin, 1954.
G. Bachelard, Le pluralisme cohérent de la chimie moderne, 2nd edn. Vrin, Paris, 1975, p. 1932.
G. Bachelard, Le nouvel esprit scientifique. Alcan, Paris; Presses Universitaires de France, Paris (reprint 1973), 1934.
G. Bachelard, L'eau et les rêves: essai sur l'imagination de la matière. Corti, Paris, 1942.
G. Bachelard, Le rationalisme appliqué. Presses Universitaires de France, Paris, 1949.
G. Bachelard, Épistémologie de la chimie. In Épistémologie. Presses Universitaires de France, Paris, 1971.
R.F.W. Bader, P.L.A. Popelier and T.A. Keith, Die theoretische Definition einer funktionellen Gruppe und das Paradigma des Molekülorbitals. Angewandte Chemie 106: 647–659, 1994.
W. Balzer, C.-U. Moulines and J.D. Sneed, The Structure of Daltonian Stoichiometry. Erkenntnis 26: 103–127, 1987.
D.A. Bantz, The Structure of Discovery: Evolution of Structural Accounts of Chemical Bonding. In T. Nickles (Ed.), Scientific Discovery: Case Studies. Reidel, Dordrecht, 1980, pp. 291–329.
A. Baracca, Chemistry's Leading Role in the Scientific Revolution at the Turn of the Century. In Mosini, 1996, pp. 61–80.
A. Beckermann, Supervenience, Emergence, and Reduction. In A. Beckermann, H. Flohr and J. Kim (Eds.), Emergence or Reduction? Essays on the Prospects of Nonreductive Physicalism. de Gruyter, Berlin/New York, 1992.
E. Bellu, The Dialectical Significance of Chemistry in the Works of Fr. Engels. Revue roumaine des sciences sociales: serie de philosophie et logique 17: 163–169, 1973.
E. Bellu, Conservation-transformation au niveau chimique. Revue roumaine des sciences sociales: serie de philosophie et logique 23: 559–569, 1979.
O.T. Benfey, Concepts of Time in Chemistry. Journal of Chemical Education 40: 574–577, 1963.
A. Benrath, Chemische Grundbegriffe: Eine Erkenntnistheoretische Studie. Chemiker Zeitung 77: 282–286, 1953.
B. Bensaude-Vincent, La chimie: un statut toujours problèmatique dans la classification du savoir. Revue de Synthèse 115: 135–148, 1974.
B. Bensaude-Vincent and F. Abbri, Lavoisier in European Context: Negotiating a New Language for Chemistry. Science History Publications, Canton, MA, 1995.
J.D. Bernal, Science in History, four volumes. Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, 1954.
N. Bhushan and S. Rosenfeld, Metaphorical Models in Chemistry. Journal of Chemical Education 72: 578–582, 1995.
O.R. Bloch, La Philosophie de Gassendi: Nominalisme, Matérialisme et Métaphysique. Nijhoff, The Hague, 1971.
I.M. Bochénski, The Dogmatic Principles of Soviet Philosophy. Reidel, Dordrecht, 1963.
G. Böhme, Aristotelische Wissenschaft — Aristoteles' Chemie: eine Stoffwechselchemie. In Alternativen der Wissenschaft. Suhrkamp, Frankfurt a/M, 1980, pp. 101–120.
J. Bradley, On the Operational Interpretation of Classical Chemistry. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 6: 32–42, 1955.
P.W. Bridgman, Reflection of a Physicist. Philosophical Library, New York, NY, 1950.
C.D. Broad, The Mind and Its Place In Nature. Routledge & Kegan Paul, London, 1925.
J.H. Brooke, Organic Synthesis and the Unification of Chemistry — A Reappraisal. The British Journal for the History of Science 5: 363–392, 1971.
S.G. Brush, Why Chemistry Needs History — and How It Can Get Some. Journal of College Science Teaching, May 1978.
N.A. Budreiko, Philosophical Problems in Chemistry [in Russian]. Shkola, Moscov, 1970.
M. Bunge, Is Chemistry a Branch of Physics? Zeitschrift für allgemeine Wissenschaftstheorie 13: 209–223, 1982.
M. Bunge, Treatise on Basic Philosophy, vol. 7. Reidel, Dordrecht, 1985, pp. 219–230.
J.W. Burbidge, Chemistry and Hegel's Logic. In M.J. Petry (Ed.), Hegel and Newtonianism. Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1993, pp. 609–617.
J.W. Burbidge, Real Process: How Logic and Chemistry Combine in Hegel's Philosophy of Nature, 1996.
G.V. Bykov, The Origin of the Theory of Chemical Structure. Journal of Chemical Education 39: 220–224, 1962.
E.F. Caldin, Theories and the Development of Chemistry. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 10: 209–222, 1959.
E.F. Caldin, The Structure of Chemistry in Relation to the Philosophy of Science. Sheed and Ward, London and New York, NY, 1961.
M. Carrier, Kants Theorie der Materie und ihre Wirkung auf die zeitgenossische Chemie. Kantstudien 81: 170–210, 1990.
R. Causey, Unity of Science. Reidel, Dordrecht, 1977.
N. Chomsky, Language and Nature. Mind 104: 1–62, 1995.
M. Christie, Philosophers Versus Chemists Concerning ‘Laws of Nature'. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 25: 613–630, 1994.
C.W. Churchman and B.G. Buchanan, On the Design of Inductive Systems: Some Philosophical Problems. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 20: 311–323, 1969.
P. Claverie and S. Diner, The Concept of Molecular Structure in Quantum Theory: Interpretation Problems. Israel Journal of Chemistry 19: 54–81, 1980.
C.A. Coulson, Recent Developments in Valence Theory. Pure and Applied Chemistry 24: 257–287, 1970.
G. Del Re, Binding: A Unifying Notion or a Pseudoconcept? International Journal of Quantum Chemistry 19: 1057–1072, 1981.
G. Del Re, The Historical Perspective and the Specificity of Chemistry. Epistemologia 10: 231–240, 1987.
G. Del Re, The Specificity of Chemistry and the Philosophy of Science. In Mosini (Ed.), 1996, pp. 11–20.
R. Delhez, Bachelard et la chimie. In Bachelard, Publication of the Centre Culturel Internationale de Cerisy-La-Salle, 1974, pp. 121–133.
K.G. Denbigh and M.L.G. Redhead, Gibbs' Paradox and Non-Uniform Convergence. Synthese 81: 283–313, 1989.
A.M. Diamond, The Polywater Episode and the Appraisal of Theories. In A. Donovan, L. Laudan and R. Laudan (Eds.), Scrutinizing Science. Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1988, pp. 181–198.
H. Dingle, The Nature of Scientific Philosophy. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 4: 409, 1949.
P.A.M. Dirac, Quantum Mechanics of Many-Electron Systems. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A123: 714–733, 1929.
A. Donovan, and others, The Chemical Revolution: Essays in Reinterpretation, Osiris, 2nd series, volume 4, 1988.
A. Drews, Kants Naturphilosophie als Grundlage seines Systems. Mitscher & Röstell, Berlin, 1894.
P. Duhem, Le mixte et la combinaison chimique: Essai sur l'évolution d'une idée. Naud, Paris; reprint Fayard, Paris (1985); originally published in Revue de Philosophie 1 (1900) 69–99, 167–197, 331–357, 430–467, 730–745, 1902.
A. Duncan, Laws and Order in Eighteenth-Century Chemistry. Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1996.
J. Dupré, The Disorder of Things: Metaphysical Foundations of the Disunity of Science. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 1993.
I. Düring, Aristotle's Chemical Treatise: Meteorologica Book IV. Göteborgs Högskolas Årsskrift, 1944: 2; reprint Garland, New York (1980), 1944.
M. Eisvogel, Wem nützt eine Philosophie der Chemie — den Chemikern oder den Philosophen. In K. Ruthenberg and J. Schummer (Eds.), Philosophie der Chemie: Bestandsaufnahme und Ausblick. Königshausen & Neumann, Würzburg, 1996 Psarros et al. (Eds.), 1996, pp. 95–110.
B. Ellis, A Comparison of Process and Non-Process Theories in the Physical Sciences. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 8: 45–56, 1957.
F. Engels, Dialectics of Nature. International Publishers, New York, NY, 1940.
F. Engels, Friedrich Engels über die Dialektik der Naturwissenschafte (texts collected and published by B.M. Kedrov). Pahl-Rugenstein Köln, Dietz, Berlin, 1979.
J.D. Farmer, A Rosetta Stone for Connectionism. Physica D 42: 153–187, 1990.
J.K. Feibleman, Theory of Integrative Levels. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 5: 59–66, 1954.
H. Field, Tarski's Theory of Truth. The Journal of Philosophy 69: 347–375, 1972.
E. Francoeur, The Forgotten Tool: The Design and Use of Molecular Models. Social Studies of Science 27: 7–40, 1997.
P. Frank, Foundations of Physics. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL, 1949.
M. Frické, The Rejection of Avogadro's Hypotheses. In Howson (Ed.), 1976, pp. 277–308.
G. Fuchs, Erkenntnistheoretische Probleme in der modernen Chemie (Eine Auseinandersetzung mit Georg Maria Schwab). In Philosophische Probleme der Chemie und ihrer Geschichte (published by Technische Hochschule für Chemie “Carl Schorlemmer”). Leuna-Merseburg, 1964, pp. 32–53.
G. Fuchs, Theorie und Empirie in der Quantenchemie. Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie 13 (Sonderheft): 338–344, 1965.
R.V. Garkovenko, Philosophical Problems in Modern Chemistry [in Russian]. Moscow, 1970.
R.M. Gascoigne, Basic Concepts of Modern Chemistry. In G.H. Aybward (Ed.), Approach to Chemistry. University of South Wales, Sydney, 1961, pp. 68–80.
K. Gavroglu, Appropriating the Atom at the End of the 19th Century: Chemists and Physicists at Each Other's Throat. In Mosini (Ed.), 1996, pp. 93–106.
K. Gavroglu and A. Simoes, The Americans, the Germans, and the Beginning of Quantum Chemistry: The Confluence of Diverging Traditions. Historical Studies in the Physical and Biological Sciences 25: 47–110, 1994.
H. Gay, Radicals and Types. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 7: 1–51, 1976.
H. Gay, The Asymmetric Carbon Atom. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 9: 207–308, 1978.
R.N. Giere, Cognitive Models of Science. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN, 1992.
N. Goodman, Ways of Worldmaking. Hackett, Indianapolis, IN, 1978.
L.R. Graham, Science and Philosophy in the Soviet Union. Allen Lane, London, 1971.
M. Gutmann and G. Hanekamp, Abstraktion und Ideation — Zur Semantik chemischer und biologischer Grundbegriffe. Journal for General Philosophy of Science 27: 29–53, 1996.
G. Gutting, Gaston Bachelard's Philosophy of Science. International Studies in the Philosophy of Science 2: 55–71, 1987.
W. Haberditzl and H. Laitko, Reduziert sich die theoretische Chemie auf angewandte Quantenmechanik und Quantenphysik? Wissenschaftliche Zeitschrift der Humboldt-Universität Berlin, mathematisch-naturwissenschaftliche Reihe 16: 961–962, 1967.
I. Hacking, Representing and Intervening. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1983.
P.J. Hall, The Pauli Exclusion Principle and the Foundations of Chemistry. Synthese 68: 267–272, 1986.
E. Han, Die Notwendigkeit einer Philosophie der Chemie. In K. Ruthenberg and J. Schummer (Eds.), Philosophie der Chemie: Bestandsaufnahme und Ausblick. Königshausen & Neumann, Würzburg, 1996 Psarros et al. (Eds.), 1996, pp. 59–66.
M. Hartmann, Die philosophische Grundlagen der Naturwissenschaften. Fischer, Jena, 1948.
G. Heber, Eine Bemerkung über die quantenmechanische Theorie der Valenz. Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie 12: 985–986, 1964.
W. Heisenberg, Ordnung der Wirklichkeit (quoted from his Gesammelte Werke, Physik und Erkenntnis 1927–1955). Piper, München/Zürich, 1942.
W. Heisenberg, Physik und Philosophie. Hirzel, Stuttgart, 1959.
C.G. Hempel, Aspects of Scientific Explanation. Macmillan, London, 1965.
H. Hettema and T.A. Kuipers, The Periodic Table — Its Formalization, Status, and Relaton to Atomic Theory. Erkenntnis 28: 387–408, 1988.
R. Hoffmann and P. Laszlo, Representation in Chemistry. Angewandte Chemie Int. Ed. Engl. 30: 1–16, 1991.
R. Hoffmann, V.I. Minkin and B.K. Carpenter, Ockham's Razor and Chemistry. Bulletin de la Société Chimique de France 133: 117–130 [also: Hyle 3: 3–28], 1996.
J.R. Hofmann, How the Models of Chemistry Vie. PSA 1990 1: 405–419, 1990.
J.R. Hofmann and P.A. Hofmann, Darcy's Law and Structural Explanation in Hydrology. PSA 1992 1: 23–35, 1992.
R. Hooykaas, The Concepts of ‘Individual’ and 'species’ in Chemistry. Centaurus 5: 307–322, 1958.
C. Howson (Ed.), Method and Appraisal in the Physical Sciences. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1976.
C. Howson and A. Franklin, Maher, Mendeleev and Bayesianism. Philosophy of Science 58: 574–585, 1991.
P.P. Ionidi, The Philosophical Significance of the Periodic Law of Mendeleev [in Russian]. “Enanie”, Moscow, 1958.
P. Janich, Chemie als Kulturleistung. Zum Selbstverständnis der Chemie im Spiegel der Kulturgeschichte”. In G. Stock, Chemie und Geisteswissenschaften. Akademie Verlag, Berlin, 1992 Mittelstraß and Stock (Eds.), 1992, pp. 161–173.
P. Janich, Protochemie: Programm einer konstruktiven Chemiebegründung. Journal for General Philosophy of Science 22: 71–87 [also in: Chimica Didactica 21 (1995) 111–128], 1994.
P. Janich (Ed.), Philosophische Perspektiven der Chemie. BI-Wissenschaftsverlag, Mannheim, 1994a.
P. Janich and N. Psarros (Eds.), Die Sprache der Chemie. Königshausen & Neumann, Würzburg, 1996.
M. Johnston, Manifest Kinds. The Journal of Philosophy 94: 564–583, 1997.
P. Jordan, Das Bild der modernen Physik. Ullstein, Frankfurt a/M, 1957 [1947].
A. Kamlah, A Logical Investigation of the Phlogiston Case. In W. Balzer et al. (Eds.), Reduction in Science. Reidel, Dordrecht, 1984, pp. 217–238.
I. Kant, Gesammelte Schriften. Berlin Academy of Science, Berlin, 1902-.
B.M. Kedrov, Dalton's Atomic Theory and Its Philosophical Significance. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 9: 644–662, 1949; translated from Bull. Acad. Sci. Hist. Phil. Series 4(6): 487–504, 1947.
B.M. Kedrov, Spektralanalyse. VEB, Berlin, 1956.
B.M. Kedrov, Über das Verhältnis der Bewegungsformen der Materie in der Natur. In Philosophische Probleme der modernen Naturwissenschaft. VEB, Berlin, 1962.
B.M. Kedrov, Tri aspekta atomistiki, vol. I: Paradoks Gibbsa, vol II: Uchenie Dalt'ona, vol. III: Zakon Mendeleeva. Moscow, 1969.
W. Kent, Scientific Naming. Philosophy of Science 25: 185–194, 1958.
J. Kim, Mental Causation: What? Me Worry? In E. Villanueva (Ed.), Contents. Ridgeview, Atascadero, 1995.
A.I. Kitaigorodsky, Theoretical Problems of Chemistry [in Russian]. Voprosi Filosofii 20: 75–87, 1966.
P. Kitcher, Theories, Theorists and Theoretical Change. The Philosophical Review 87: 519–547, 1978.
U. Klein, Origin of the Concept of Chemical Compound. Science in Context 7: 163–204, 1994.
U. Klein, Robert Boyle: Der Begründer der neuzeitlichen Chemie. Philosophia Naturalis 31: 63–106, 1994a.
S. Körner, On Kant's Conception of Science and the Critique of Practical Reason. Kantstudien 82: 173–178, 1991.
G.M. Kosolapoff and G.W. Wheland, Letters to Chemical and Engineering News 30: 2474, 1952.
S. Kripke, Naming and Necessity. Blackwell, Oxford (1980), 1972.
H.H. Kubbinga, Les première spécification dite ‘moléculaire’ de l'atomisme épicurien: Isaac Beeckman (1620) et Sébastien Basson (1621): Le concept d'individu substantiel et de d'espèce substantielle. Revue d'Histoire des Sciences 37: 215–233, 1984.
H.H. Kubbinga, The First ‘Molecular’ Theory (1620): Isaac Beeckman (1588–1637). Journal of Molecular Structure (Theochem) 181: 205–218, 1988.
T.S. Kuhn, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, International Encyclopedia of Unified Science, volume II, Number 2, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL, 1962. 2nd enlarged edition 1970.
J.H. Kultgen, Philosophic Conceptions in Mendeleev's, Principles of Chemistry, Philosophy of Science 25: 177–184, 1958.
D.N. Kursanov, M.G. Gonikberg, B.M. Dbinin, M.I. Kabachnik, E.D. Kaverzneva, E.N. Prilezhaeva, N.D. Sokolov and R. KH. Freidlina, K voprosu o sovremennom sostoianii teorii khimicheskogo stroeniia. Uspekhi Khimii 19: 529–544, 1950; translated as: The present state of the chemical structural theory, Journal of Chemical Education 29: 2–13.
V.I. Kuznetsov, On discreteness and Continuity in the Chemical Organisation of Substances [in Russian]. Voprosi Filosofii 10: 61–70, 1963.
V.I. Kuznetsov, About the Nature of Qualitative Chemical Changes [in Russian]. Voprosi Filosofii 11: 94–102, 1964.
V.I. Kuznetsov and A. Shamin, Butlerov and A. Kekulé's Contributions to the Formation of Structural Organic Chemistry. In J.H. Wotiz (Ed.), The Kekulé Riddle: A Challenge for Chemists and Psychologists, 1993, pp. 211–222.
V.I. Kuznetsov and A.A. Pechenkin, Conceptual Problems of Chemistry: The Theory of Resonance [in Russian]. Voprosi Filosofii 5: 75–86, 1972.
H. Laitko, Zum Verhältnis von Chemie und Physik”. Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie 13 (Sonderheft): 330–338, 1965.
H. Laitko, Philosophische Fragen der Chemie. Einführung in die Problemsituation. In M. Guntau and H. Wendt (Eds.), Naturforschung und Weltbild. Eine Einführung in philosophische Probleme der modernen Naturwissenschaften. VEB, Berlin, 1967, pp. 107–137.
H. Laitko, Chemie und Philosophie: Anmerkungen zur Entwicklung des Gebietes in der Geschichte der DDR. In K. Ruthenberg and J. Schummer (Eds.), Philosophie der Chemie: Bestandsaufnahme und Ausblick. Königshausen & Neumann, Würzburg, 1996 Psarros et al. (Eds.), 1996, pp. 37–58.
H. Laitko and W.-D. Sprung, Chemie und Weltanschauung: Standpunkte der marxistischen Philosophie zu einigen philosophischen Problemen der modernen Chemie, 2nd edition 1973. Urania, Leipzig-Jena-Berlin, 1970.
J. LaPorte, Chemical Kind Term Reference and the Discovery of Essence. Nous 30: 112–132, 1996.
P. Laszlo, La parole des choses ou le language de la chimie. Hermann, Paris, 1993.
B. Latour, Science in Action. Open University, Milton Keynes, 1987.
L. Laudan, Science and Values: The Aims of Science and Their Role in Scientific Debate. University of California Press, Berkeley, CA, 1984.
B. Lauth, Reference Problems in Stoichiometry. Erkenntnis 30: 339–62, 1989.
B. Lauth, Physical Constants and Reference Dynamics. Journal for General Philosophy of Science 24: 63–86, 1993.
A.L. Lavoisier, Traité élémentaire de chimie. Cuchet, Paris, 1789; Principles of Chemistry (Edinburgh, 1790); also in OEuvres de Lavoisier. Imprimerie Impériale, Paris (1864).
R. Le Poidevin, The Chemistry of Space. Australasian Journal of Philosophy 72: 77–88, 1994.
M. Lévy, Les relations entre chimie et physique et le problème de la réduction. Epistemologia 2: 337–70, 1979.
E. Lewis, Introduction to Alexander of Aphrodisias: On Aristotle Meteorology 4. Duckworth, London, 1996.
C. Liegener and G. Del Re, The Relation of Chemistry to Other fields of Science: Atomism, Reductionism, and Inversion of Reduction. Epistemologia 10: 269–284, 1987.
C. Liegener and G. Del Re, Chemistry vs. Physics, the Reduction Myth and the Unity of Science. Zeitschrift für allgemeine Wissenschaftstheorie 18: 165–174, 1987a.
C.-M. Liegener, Die Stellung der Chemie zur Physik — Symptome des Reduktionismus. In Janich (Ed.), 1994.
A. Maccoll, Space and Time in Chemistry. Lewis, London, 1964.
D.K.C. MacDonald, Physics and Chemistry: Comments on Caldin's View of Chemistry. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 11: 222–223, 1960.
P. Maher, Howson and Franklin on Prediction. Philosophy of Science 60: 329–340, 1993.
K. Mainzer, Symmetry and Complexity: Fundamental Concepts of Research in Chemistry. Hyle 3: 29–49, 1997.
U. Majer, Ist die Sprache der Chemie eine Begriffsschrift in Freges Sinne? In N. Psarros (Eds.), Die Sprache der Chemie. Königshausen & Neumann, Würzburg, 1996 Janich and Psarros (Eds.), 1996, pp. 91–100.
W.M. Malisoff, Chemistry: Emergence Without Mystification. Philosophy of Science 8: 39–52, 1941.
P. Manzelli, To What Extent do We Understand Chemical Reactions? In Mosini (Ed.), 1996, pp. 133–142.
G. Marino (Ed.), Storia e Fondamenti della Chimica. Accademia Nazionale delle Scienze, Roma, 1994.
J.G. McEvoy, Lavoisier, Priestley, and the Philosophes: Epistemic and Linguistic Dimensions to the Chemical Revolution. Man and Nature 8: 91–98, 1989.
M. Jones McAllester, Gaston Bachelard, Subsersive Humanist: Texts and Readings. University of Wisconsin Press, Madison, WI, 1991.
J.W. McAllister, Scientific Realism and the Criteria for Theory-Choice. Erkenntnis 38: 203–222, 1993.
L. McIntyre, Gould on Laws in Biological Sciences. Biology and Philosophy 12: 357–367, 1997.
D.H. Mellor, Natural Kinds. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 28: 299–312, 1977.
D. Mendeleev, The Periodic Law of the Chemical Elements. Faraday Lectures. Chemical Society, London, 1889.
É. Meyerson, Explanation in the Sciences. Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1991.
É. Meyerson, Identity and Reality. Allen & Unwin, London, 1930.
A. Mittasch, Von der Chemie zur Philosophie. Ebner, Ulm/Donau, 1948.
J. Mittelstraß and G. Stock, Chemie und Geisteswissenschaften. Akademie Verlag, Berlin, 1992.
V. Mosini, Some Considerations on the Reducibility of Chemistry to Physics. Epistemologia 17: 205–223, 1994.
V. Mosini, Fundamentalism, Antifundamentalism, and Gibbs's Paradox. Studies in the History and Philosophy of Modern Physics 26: 151–162, 1995.
V. Mosini (Ed.), Philosophers in the Laboratory. Euroma/Musis/Accademia Nazionale di Scieze Lettere e Arti Modena, Rome, 1996.
V. Mosini, Chemical Properties, Inherent Relations and the Structure of Science. In Mosini (Ed.), 1996, 1996a, pp. 107–121.
J.J. Mulckhuyse, Molecules and Models. Synthese 12: 257–275, 1961; reprint: in The Concept and the Role of the Model in Mathematics and Natural and Social Sciences. Reidel, Dordrecht, pp. 133–151.
E. Nagel, The Structure of Science. Harcourt, Brace and World, London, 1961.
A.C. Nayak and E. Sotnak, Kant on the Impossibility of the “Soft Sciences”. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 55: 133–151, 1995.
P. Needham, Stuff. Australasian Journal of Philosophy 71: 270–290, 1993.
P. Needham, Aristotelian Chemistry: A Prelude to Dumeian Metaphysics. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 27: 251–270, 1996.
P. Needham, Macroscopic Objects: An Exercise in Duhemian Ontology. Philosophy of Science 63: 205–224, 1996a.
P. Needham, Substitition: Duhem's Explication of a Chemical Paradigm. Perspectives on Science 4: 408–433, 1996b.
P. Needham, Duhem's Physicalism. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 29: 33–62, 1998.
P. Needham, Reduction and Abduction in Chemistry — A Response to Scerri. International Studies in the Philosophy of Science, forthcoming, 1999.
G. Nerlich, On the One Hand: Reflections on Enantiomorphy. Australasian Journal of Philosophy 73: 432–443, 1995.
U. Niedersen, Chemie heute: Bemerkungen zur Klassifikation der Naturwissenschaften. Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie 31: 363–373, 1983.
U. Niedersen, Prozeßstrukturen: Schellings Philosophie und einige ausgewählte Theorie-und Praxisbereiche der Physikochemie. Selbstorganisation 5: 183–199, 1994.
R. Nola, Fixing the Reference of Theoretical Terms. Philosophy of Science 47: 505–531, 1980.
M.J. Nye, From Chemical Philosophy to Theoretical Chemistry. Dynamics of Matter and Dynamics of Disciplines 1800–1950. University of California Press, Berkeley, CA, 1993.
W. Ostwald, Vorlesungen Ueber Naturphilosophie; Natural Philosophy. London (1911), 1902.
W. Ostwald, Prinzipien der Chemie; The Fundamental Principles of Chemistry. London (1909), 1907.
F.A. Paneth, The Epistemological Status of the Chemical Concept of Element. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 13: 1–14, 144–160, 1962; originally published in German as Über die erkenntnistheoretische Stellung des Elementbegriffs, Schriften der Königsberger Gelehrten Gesellschaft, naturwissenschaftliche Klasse 8(4): (1931) 101–125.
L. Paolini, Quantum Mechanics and the Logical Structure of Contemporary Chemistry. In Current Aspects of Quantum Chemistry. Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1981, pp. 1–16.
L. Pauling, The Place of Chemistry in the Integration of the Sciences. Main Currents in Modern Thought 7: 108–111, 1950.
L. Pauling, Teoriia rezonansa v khimii. Zhurnal vsesoiuznogo khimicheskogo obshchestva im. D.I. Mendeleeva 4: 462–467, 1962.
L. Pauling, Leben und Tod im Atomzeitalter. VEB, Berlin, 1964.
R. Pilkington, Robert Boyle: Father of Chemistry. Murray, London, 1959.
N.W. Pirie, Concepts Out of Context. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 2: 269–280, 1952.
M. Polanyi, Personal Knowledge: Towards a Post-Critical Philosophy. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL, 1958.
S. Poller, Zur Abgrenzung und Charakteristik der chemischen Bewegungsform der Materie. Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie 14: 328–338, 1966.
C.E. Prélat, Epistemología de la Química. Espasa and Calpe Argentina, Buenos Aires and Mexico, 1947.
H. Primas, Chemistry, Quantum Mechanics and Reductionism: Perspectives in Theoretical Chemistry. Springer, Berlin, 1983.
H. Primas, Kann Chemie auf Physik reduziert werden? I. Das molekulare Programm. Chemie unser Zeit 19: 109–119; 160–166, 1985.
H. Primas, Reductionism: Palaver Without Precedent. In E. Agazzi (Ed.), The Problems of Reductionism in Science. Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1991, pp. 161–172.
N. Psarros, Sind die Gesetze der konstanten und der multiplen Proportionen empirische Naturgesetze oder Normen? In Janich (Ed.), 1994, pp. 53–63.
N. Psarros, The Constructive Approach to the Philosophy of Chemistry. Epistemologia 18: 27–38, 1995.
N. Psarros, Stoffe, Verbindungen und Elemente — Eine methodische Annäherung an die Gegenstände der Chemie. Chimica didactica 21: 129–148, 1995a.
N. Psarros, The Mess with Mass Terms. In Mosini (Ed.), 1996, pp. 123–131.
N. Psarros, Die Chemie als Gegenstand philosophischer Reflexion. In K. Ruthenberg and J. Schummer (Eds.), Philosophie der Chemie: Bestandsaufnahme und Ausblick. Königshausen & Neumann, Würzburg, 1996 Psarros et al. (Eds.), 1996, 1996a, pp. 111–141.
N. Psarros, K. Ruthenberg and J. Schummer (Eds.), Philosophie der Chemie: Bestandsaufnahme und Ausblick. Königshausen & Neumann, Würzburg, 1996.
H. Putnam, The Meaning of Meaning. In his Mind, Language and Reality [Philosophical Papers Volume 2]. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1975, pp. 215–271.
H. Putnam, Meaning and theMoral Sciences. Routledge and Kegan Paul, London, 1978.
H. Putnam, Is Water Necessarily H2O? In his Realism with a Human Face. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 1990, pp. 54–79.
A. Pyle, Atomism and Its Critics: From Democritus to Newton. Thoemes Press, Bristol, 1997.
J.L. Ramsey, Beyond Numerical and Causal Accuracy: Expanding the Set of Justificational Criteria. PSA 1990 1: 485–99, 1990.
J.L. Ramsey, On Refusing to be an Epistemologically Black Box: Instruments in Chemical Kinetics During the 1920s and '30s. Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science 23: 283–304, 1992.
J.L. Ramsey, Ideal Reaction Types and the Reactions of Real Alloys. PSA 1994 1: 149–159, 1994.
J.L. Ramsey, Molecular Shape, Reduction, Explanation and Approximate Concepts. Synthese 111: 233–251, 1997.
H. Reichenbach, The Aims and Methods of Physical Knowledge. In M. Reichenbach and R.S. Cohen (Eds.), Hans Reichenbach: Selected Writings 1909–1953 (principal translations by E.H. Schneewind), volume II. Reidel, Dordrecht, 1978 [1929], pp. 81–225.
K.-H. Richter and H. Laitko, Zur Gegenstandsbestimmung der Chemie. Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie 10: 1278–1293, 1962.
A.J. Rocke, Kekulé, Butlerov, and the Historiography of the Theory of Structure. The British Journal for the History of Science 14: 27–57, 1981.
G. Röhler, Zur erkenntnistheoretischen Bedeutung von Hypothese, Modellvorstellung und Theorie in der Chemie. Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie 10: 1294–1307, 1962.
A. Rosenberg, Instrumental Biology and the Disunity of Science. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL, 1994.
A. Rosenthal, Zu einigen Aspekten des Verhältnisses von Physik und Chemie. Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie 30: 576–590, 1982.
D. Rothbart, Discovering Natural Kinds Through Inter-Theoretic Prototypes. Methodology and Science 26: 171–189, 1993.
D. Rothbart, Spectrometers as Analogues of Nature. Philosophy of Science Association (PSA) 1: 141–148, 1994.
D. Rothbart and I. Scherer, Kant's Critique of Judgment and the Scientific Investigation of Matter. Hyle 3: 65–80, 1997.
D. Rothbart and S.W. Slayden, The Epistemology of a Spectrometer. Philosophy of Science 61: 25–38, 1994.
K. Ruthenberg, Warum ist die Chemie ein Stiefkind der Philosophie? In K. Ruthenberg and J. Schummer (Eds.), Philosophie der Chemie: Bestandsaufnahme und Ausblick. Königshausen & Neumann, Würzburg, 1996 Psarros et al. (Eds.), 1996, pp. 27–35.
K. Ruthenberg, Friedrich Adolf Paneth. Hyle 3: 103–106, 1997.
H. Sankey, Translation Failure Between Theories. Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science 22: 223–236, 1991.
E.R. Scerri, The Electronic Configuration Model, Quantum Mechanics and Reduction. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 42: 309–325, 1991.
E.R. Scerri, Chemistry, Spectroscopy, and the Question of Reduction. Journal of Chemical Education 68: 122–126, 1991a.
E.R. Scerri, Correspondence and Reduction in Chemistry. In S. French and H. Kamminga (Eds.), Correspondence, Invariance and Heuristics. Kluwer, Dordrecht/Boston/London, 1993, pp. 45–64.
E.R. Scerri, Has Chemistry Been at Least Approximately Reduced to Quantum Mechanics. PSA 1994 1: 160–170, 1994.
E.R. Scerri, The Exclusion Principle, Chemistry and Hidden Variables. Synthese 102: 165–169, 1995.
E.R. Scerri, Has the Periodic Table Been Successfully Axiomatised? Erkenntnis 47: 229–243, 1997.
E.R. Scerri, The Periodic Table and the Electron. American Scientist 85: 546–553, 1997a.
E.R. Scerri, Popper's Naturalised Approach to the Reduction of Chemistry. International Studies in the Philosophy of Science 12: 33–44, 1998.
E.R. Scerri and L. McIntyre, The Case for the Philosophy of Chemistry. Synthese 111: 213–232, 1997.
E.W.J. von Schelling, Ideas for a Philosophy of Nature (translated by E.E. Harris and P. Heach from the first German edition 1797). Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1988.
P.A. Schilpp (Ed.), The Philosophy of C.D. Broad. Tudor, New York, NY, 1959.
J. Schröder, Emergence: Non-Reducibility or Downwards Causation? The Philosophical Quarterly 48: 433–452, 1998.
J. Schummer, Realismus und Chemie: Philosophische Untersuchungen der Wissenschaft von den Stoffen. Königshausen & Neumann, Würzburg, 1996.
J. Schummer, Bibliographic chemiephilosophischer Literatur der DDR. Hyle 2: 3–11, 1996a.
J. Schummer, Zur Semiotik der chemischen Zeichensprache: Die Repräsentation dynamischer Verhältnisse mit statischen Mitteln. In N. Psarros (Eds.), Die Sprache der Chemie. Königshausen & Neumann, Würzburg, 1996 Janich and Psarros (Eds.), 1996, 1996c, pp. 113–126.
J. Schummer, Towards a Philosophy of Chemistry. Journal for General Philosophy of Science 28: 307–335, 1997.
J. Schummer, Scientometric Studies on Chemistry I: The Exponential Growth of Chemical Substances, 1800–1995. Scientometrics 39: 107–123, 1997a.
J. Schummer, Scientometric Studies on Chemistry II: Aims and Methods of Producing New Chemical Substances. Scientometrics 39: 125–140, 1997b.
J. Schummer, Challenging Standard Distinctions Between Science and Technology: The Case of Preparative Chemistry. Hyle 3: 81–94, 1997c.
J.R. Searle, Intentionality. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1983.
W. Sellars, Science, Perception and Reality. Routledge and Kegan Paul, London, 1963.
M.I. Shakparonov, Outlines of the Philosophical Problems of Chemistry [in Russian]. Moscow University Press, Moscow, 1957.
M.I. Shakparonov, Philosophical Chemistry [in Russian]. Government Publisher for Political Literature, Moscow, 1962; published as Chemie und Philosophie (mimeographed). Institute for Marxism-Leninism, Technische Hochschule für Chemie in Leuna-Merseburg, 1963.
D. Shapere, Reason and the Search for Knowledge: Investigations in the Philosophy of Science. Reidel, Boston, MA, 1984.
J. Shelton, Seeing and Paradigms in the Chemical Revolution. Philosophy of Science (Tucson) 6: 129–141, 1995.
R. Simon, Dialektik und Chemie. Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie 23: 980–984, 1975.
R. Simon, U. Niedersen and G. Kertscher, Philosophische Probleme der Chemie. VEB, Berlin, 1982.
L. Sklar, Physics and Chance: Philosophical Issues in the Foundations of Statistical Mechanics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1993.
H.A.M. Snelders, The Significance of Hegel's Treatment of Chemical Affinity. In M.J. Petry (Ed.), Hegel and Newtonianism. Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1993.
I. Stengers, Ambiguous Affinity: The Newtonian Dream of Chemistry in the Eighteenth Century. In M. Serres (Ed.), A History of Scientific Thought: Elements of a History of Science. Blackwell, Oxford, 1995, pp. 372–400.
H. Stork, Über die Diskussion und Ablehning der Resonanz-Mesomerie-Theorie in der Sowjetunion. Chemiker-Ztg./Chem. Apparatur 87: 608–619, 1963.
E. Ströker, Denkwege der Chemie — Elemente ihrer Wissenschaftstheorie. Alber, Freiburg, 1967.
B.T. Sutcliffe, The Development of the Idea of a Chemical Bond. International Journal of Quantum Chemistry 58: 645–656, 1996.
V.M. Tatevskii and M.I. Shakhparanov, Ob odnoi makhistskoi teorii v khimii i ee propagandistakh. Voprosi Filosofii 3: 176–192, 1949; excerpts translated as “About a Machistic theory in chemistry and its propagandists” in Journal of Chemical Education 29: 14–15.
P. Thagard, Explanatory Coherence. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 12: 435–502, 1989.
P. Thagard, The Conceptual Structure of the Chemical Revolution. Philosophy of Science 57: 183–209, 1990.
D.W. Theobald, Some considerations on the philosophy of chemistry. Chemical Society Reviews 5: 203–213, 1976.
D.W. Theobald, Gaston Bachelard et la philosophie de la chimie. Archives de philosophie 45: 63–83, 1982.
M. Tijiattas, Bachelard and Scientific Realism. Philosophical Forum (Spring): 203–210, 1991.
M. Tiles, Bachelard: Science and Objectivity. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1985.
M. Tiles, Epistemological History: The Legacy of Bachelard and Canguilhem. Philosophy 21(Suppl.): 141–156, 1987.
J. Timmermans, The Concept of Species in Chemistry. Chemical Publishing Company, New York, NY, 1963; revised translation of La notion d'espèce chimie (Paris 1928).
S.E. Toulmin, Crucial Experiments: Priestley and Lavoisier. Journal of the History of Ideas 18: 205–220, 1957.
C. Trindle, The Hierarchy of Models in Chemistry. Croatica Chemica Acta 57: 1231–1245, 1984.
R. Tursman, Phanerochemistry and Semiotic. Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society 25: 453–468, 1989.
J. van Brakel, The Chemistry of Substances and the Philosophy of Natural Kinds. Synthese 69: 291–324, 1986.
J. van Brakel, Units of Measurement: Some Kripkean Considerations. Erkenntnis 33: 297–317, 1990.
J. van Brakel, Chemistry. Handbook of Metaphysics and Ontology. München: Philosophia Verlag 1: 146–147, 1991.
J. van Brakel, Polywater and Experimental Realism. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 44: 775–784, 1993.
J. van Brakel, Interdiscourse or Supervenience Relations: The Priority of the Manifest Image. Synthese 106: 253–297, 1996.
J. van Brakel, Chemistry as the Science of the Transformation of Substances. Synthese 111: 253–282, 1997.
J. van Brakel, Interculturele Communicatie en Multiculturalisme: Enige Filosofische Voorbemerkingen. van Gorcum, Assen, 1998.
J. van Brakel, Supervenience and Anomalous Monism. Dialectica 53: 1–24, 1999.
J. van Brakel, The Nature of Chemical Substances, forthcoming in a book to be published by Oxford University Press (edited by N. Bhushan and S. Rosenfeld), 1999a.
J. Van Cleve and R.E. Frederick, The Philosophy of Right and Left: Incongruent Counterparts and the Nature of Space. Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1991.
P.E. van der Vet, The Debate Between F.A. Paneth, G. von Hevesy, and K. Fajans on the Concept of Chemical Identity. Janus 66: 285–303, 1979.
P.E. van der Vet, The Aborted Takeover of Chemistry by Physics. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Amsterdam, 1987.
P.E. van der Vet, Filosofie van de Scheikunde. Nijhoff, Leiden, 1989.
D. van der Waals, Lehrbuch der Thermostatik. Ambrosius Barth, Erster Teil, Leipzig, 1927.
B.C. van Frassen, The Scientific Image. Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1980.
P. Vasconi, Kant and Lavoisier's Chemistry. In Mosini (Ed.), 1996, pp. 155–162.
H.P. Vermeeren, Controversies and Existence Claims in Chemistry: The Theory of Resonance. Synthese 69: 273–290, 1986.
R. Vihalemm, Elaboration of Philosophical Problems in Chemistry [in Russian]. Voprosi Filosofii 4(6): 90–95, 187–188, 1974.
G. Villani, Sostanze e reazioni chimiche: Concetti di chimica teorica di interesse generale. Epistemologia 16: 191–212, 1993.
C. Vinti, Bachelard: Ragione e realta nella chimica contemporanea. In Mosini (Ed.), 1996, pp. 181–217.
D. von Engelhardt, The Chemical System of Substances, Forces and Processes in Hegel's Philosophy. In R.S. Cohen (Ed.), Hegel and the Sciences. Reidel, Dordrecht, 1984, pp. 41–54.
D. von Engelhardt, Philosophie und Theorie der Chemie um 1800. Philosophia Naturalis 23: 223–237, 1986.
D. von Engelhardt, Hegel on Chemistry and the Organic Sciences. In M.J. Petry (Ed.), Hegel and Newtonianism. Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1993.
P. Weatherall, Tarski's Theory of Truth and Field's Solution to the Problem of Intentionality. Australasian Journal of Philosophy 71: 291–303, 1993.
G.W. Wheland, Resonance in Organic Chemistry. Wiley, New York, NY, 1955.
W.R. Woodward and R.S. Cohen, World Views and Scientific Discipline Formation. Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1991.
R.G. Woolley, Must a Molecule Have a Shape? Journal of the American Chemical Society 100: 1073–1078, 1978.
R.G. Woolley, Molecular Shapes and Molecular Structure. Chemical Physics Letters 125: 200–205, 1986.
R.G. Woolley, Quantum Chemistry Beyond the Born-Oppenheimer Approximation. Journal of Molecular Structure (Theochem) 230: 17–46, 1991.
H. Zandvoort, Models of Scientific Development and the Case of Nuclear Magnetic Resonance. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Groningen, 1985.
H. Zandvoort, Macromolecules, Dogmatism, and Scientific Change: The Prehistory of Polymer Chemistry as Testing Ground for Philosophy of Science. Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science 19: 489–515, 1988.
Iu.A. Zhdanov, Homology in Organic Chemistry [in Russian]. Moscow University Press, Moscow, 1950.
Iu.A. Zhdanov, Outline of the Methodology of Organic Chemistry [in Russian]. Moscow University Press, Moscow, 1960.
Iu.A. Zhdanov, Modelling in Organic Chemistry [in Russian]. Voprosi Filosofii 6: 63–74, 1963.
Iu.A. Zhdanov, The Problem of the General Definition of Chemistry. Journal of General Chemistry of the USSR, 2643–2644 [cover to cover translation of Zhurnal Obscei Khimii], 1965.
A. Zucker, Davy Refuted Lavoisier not Lakatos. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 39: 537–540, 1988.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
van Brakel, J. On the Neglect of the Philosophy of Chemistry. Foundations of Chemistry 1, 111–174 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009936404830
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009936404830