Abstract
In evolutionary biology, a trait is said to be optimal if it maximizes the fitness of the organism, that is, if the trait allows the organism to survive and reproduce better than any other competing trait would. In engineering, a design is said to be optimal if it complies with its functional requirements as well as possible. Cognitive science is both a biological and engineering discipline and hence it uses both notions of optimality. Unfortunately, the lack of a clear methodological stance on this tissue has made it common for researchers to conflate these two kinds of optimality. In this paper, I argue that a strict distinction must kept in order to avoid inaccurate assumptions.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Amundson, R.: 1994, 'Two Concepts of Constraint: Adaptationism and the Challenge from Development Biology', Philosophy of Science 61, 556-578.
Aumann, R.J. and Hart, S. (eds.): 1994, Handbook of Game Theory, Volume 2, Elsevier, Amsterdam.
Barash, D.P.: 1982, Sociobiology and Behavior, 2nd ed., Elevier, New York.
Barkow, J., Cosmides, L. and Tooby, J. (eds.): 1992, The Adapted Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and the Generation of Culture, Oxford University Press, New York.
Beatty, J.: 1980, 'Optimal-Design Models and the Strategy of Model Building in Evolutionary Biology', Philosophy of Science 47, 532-561.
Byerly, H.C. and Michod, R.E.: 1991, 'Fitness and Evolutionary Explanation', Biology and Philosophy 6l, 1-22.
Cooper, L.A. and Munger, M.P.: 1993, 'Extrapolating and Remembering Positions along Cognitive Trajectories: Uses and Limitations of Analogies to Physical Motion', in N. Eilan, R. McCarthy and B. Brewer (eds.), Spatial Representation, Basil Blackwell, Oxford.
Cosmides, L. and Tooby, J: 1992, 'Cognitive Adaptations for Social Exchange', in J. Barkow, L. Cosmides and J. Tooby (eds.), The Adapted Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and the Generation of Culture, Oxford University Press, New York.
Cowie, R.J.: 1977, 'Optimal Foraging in Great Tits (Parus Major)', Nature 268, 137-139.
Cummins, R.: 1983, The Nature of Psychological Explanation, MIT Press, Cambridge.
Cummins, D.D.: 1996, 'Evidence for the Innateness of Deontic Reasoning', Mind and Language 11, 160-190.
Dennett, D.C.: 1995, 'Cognitive Science as Reverse Engineering: Several Meanings of 'Top Down' and 'Bottom Up', in D. Prawitz, B. Skyrms and D. Westerstahl (eds.), Proceeding of the 9th International Congress of Logic, Methodology and Philosophy of Science, North Holland, Dordecht.
Dennett, D.C.: 1996, Darwin's Dangerous Idea, Touchstone, New York.
Dupre, J. (ed.): 1987, The Latest on the Beset: Essays on Evolution and Optimality, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.
Gilman, D.: 1996, 'Optimization and Simplicity: Computational Vision and Biological Explanation', Synthese 107, 293-323.
Gintis, H.: 2000, Game Theory Evolving, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
Godfrey-Smith, P.: 1999, 'Adaptationism and the Power of Selection', Biology and Philosophy 14, 181-194.
Griffiths, P.E.: 1996, 'The Historical Turn in the Study of Adaptation', British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 47, 511-532.
Kamil, A.C., Krebs, J.R. and Pulliam, H.R. (eds.), 1987, Foraging Behaviour, Plenum Publishing Corporation, New York.
Kick, S.: 1982, 'Target Detection by the Echolocating Bat, Eptesicus Fuscus', The Journal of Comparative Physiology 145, 431-435.
Krebs, J.R. and Davies, N.B. (eds.): 1991, Behavioural Ecology. An Evolutionary Approach, Blackwell Scientific, Oxford.
Manktelow, K. and Over, D.: 1995, 'Deontic Reasoning', in S. Newstead and J. St. B. Evans (eds.), Perspectives on Thinking and Reasoning, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, N.J.
Marr, D.: 1982, Vision, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.
Millikan, R.: 1984, Language, Thought and Other Biological Categories, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.
Oaksford, M. and Chater, N.: 1994, 'A Rational Analysis of the Selection Task as Optimal Data Selection', Psychological Review 101, 608-631.
Orzack S.H. and Sober, E.: 1994, 'Optimality Models and the Test of Adaptationism', The American Naturalist 143, 361-380.
Orzack S.H. and Sober, E. (eds.): 2001, Adaptationism and Optimality, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
Parker, G.A. and Maynard Smith, J.: 1990, 'Optimality Theory in Evolutionary Biology', Nature 348, 27-33.
Peacocke, C.: 1986, 'Explanation in Computational Psychology: Language, Perception and Level 1.5', Mind and Language 1, 101-123.
Peacocke, C.: 1989, 'When is a Grammar Psychologically Real'? in G. Alexander (ed.), Reflections on Chomsky, Basil Blackwell, Oxford, UK.
Peacocke, C.: 1993, 'Intuitive Mechanics, Psychological Reality and the Idea of a Material Object', in N. Eilan, R. McCarthy and B. Brewer (eds.), Spatial Representation, Basil Blackwell, Oxford, UK.
Radner, D. and Radner, M.: 1998, 'Optimality in Biology: Pangloss or Leibniz', The Monist 81, 669-686.
Richardson, R.C.: 1994, 'Optimization in Evolutionary Biology', PSA 1, 13-21.
Rode, C., Cosmides, L., Hell, W. and Tooby, J.: 1999, 'When and Why do People Avoid Unknown Probabilities in Decisions under Uncertainty? Testing Some Predictions from Optimal Foraging Theory', Cognition 72, 269-304.
Samuels, R. Stich, S. and Tremoulet, P.: 2000, 'Rethinking Rationality: From Bleak Implications to Darwinian Modules', in E. Lepore and Z. Pylyshyn (eds.), Rutgers University Invitation to Cognitive Science, Basil Blackwell. Oxford, UK.
Selten R. (ed.): 1991, Game Equilibrium Models I: Evolution and Game Dynamics, Springer-Verlag, Berlin.
Simmons, J.A.: 1989, 'A View of theWorld Through the Bat's Ear: The Formation of Acoustic Images in Echolocation', Cognition 33, 155-199.
Simmons, J., Moffat, A. and Masters, W.: 1992, 'Sonar Gain Control and Echo Detection Thresholds in the Echolocating Bat, Eptesicus fuscus', Journal of the Acoustic Society of America 91, 1150-1162.
Slater, P.J.B. and Halliday, T.R. (eds.): 1994, Behaviour and Evolution, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
Sober, E.: 1996, 'Evolution and Optimality: Feathers, Bowling Balls, and the Thesis of Adaptation', Philosophical Exchange 26, 41-57.
Sperber, D., Cara, F. and Girotto, V.: 1995, 'Relevance Theory Explains the Selection Task', Cognition 52, 3-39.
Stephens, D.W. and Krebs, J.R.: 1986, Foraging Theory, Monographs in Behaviour and Ecology, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
Thomas, D.W., Blondel, J., Perret, P., Lambrechts, M.M. and Speakman, J.R.: 2001, 'Energetic and Fitness Costs of Mismatching Resource Supply and Demand in Seasonally Breeding Birds', Science 291, 2598-2600.
Vilarroya, Ò.: 2001, 'From Functional 'Mess' to Bounded Functionality', Minds and Machines 11, 239-256.
Walsh D.M.: 1996, 'Fitness and Function', British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 47, 553-574.
Weibull, J.W.: 1996, Evolutionary Game Theory, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Vilarroya, O. ``Two'' Many Optimalities. Biology & Philosophy 17, 251–270 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1015264829309
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1015264829309