to be recognized as a “tobacco man” was to be accorded an honor such as other cultures bestowed on the finest hunters or warriors or poets. The accolade “He’s a tobacco man!” would be accompanied by a shake of the head to indicate that such surpassing excellence was, finally, a mystery; there was more to it than met the eye.– Wendell Berry (1992: 54)
Abstract
Why do tobacco farmers continue to produce tobacco in light of the bleak future of this crop? Given the changing political economy of tobacco, we might expect producers to respond by diversifying their enterprises. This study of Kentucky burley tobacco farmers finds that farmers express contradictory values toward the economic role of production and the social value of tobacco consumption. The economic value of tobacco is articulated by drawing upon experiential lessons with the crop. These, in turn, are used to inform production processes (reproduction of tobacco farming), all the while castigating the consumption of their commodity. Farmers persist in producing tobacco because of the structural and historical conditions of the region that have engendered a culture of tobacco production. The contradiction in production and consumption values suggests that the “cultural turn” in agro-food studies needs to move away from a linear approach of cultural values as determinants of social action and become sensitive to the differential ways commodity actors produce, use, and reproduce a culture of commodity production and a culture of commodity consumption. This unproblematic and linear association between values and economic activity misinforms social science research about seemingly “individual” motivations that are shaped by historical and structural conditions.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
A. Arce T. Marsden (1993) ArticleTitle“The social construction of international food: A new research agenda” Economic Geography 69 291–311
W. Berry (1992) Sex, Economy, Freedom and Community Pantheon Books New York, New York
M. Boehlje L. Schrader (1998) The industrialization of agriculture J. S. Royer Rogers (Eds) The Industrialization of Agriculture Ashgate Hants, UK 3–25
InstitutionalAuthorNameBTGCA (Burley Tobacco Growers Cooperative Association, Inc.) (1991) The Producer’s Program: Fifty Golden Years and More Green Communications Lexington, Kentucky
InstitutionalAuthorNameCafé Sisters Production and Kentucky Educational Television (1997) Tobacco Blues (Video) Lexington Kentucky
T. Campbell (1993) The Politics of Despair: Power and Resistance in the Tobacco Wars University Press of Kentucky Lexington, Kentucky
D. Chaney (1996) Lifestyles Routledge London, UK
W. Cunningham (1983) On Bended Knees: The True Story of the Knight Rider Tobacco War in Kentucky and Tennessee McClanahan Publishing Nashville, Tennessee
J. Dixon (1999) ArticleTitle“A cultural economy model for studying food systems” Agriculture and Human Values 16 151–160 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1007531129846
E. M. DuPuis (2000) ArticleTitle“Not in my body: rBGH and the rise of organic milk” Agriculture and Human Values 17 285–295 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1007604704026
B. Fine (1995) From political economy to consumption D. Miller (Eds) Acknowledging Consumption: A Review of New Studies Routledge London, UK 127–163
B. Fine E. Leopold (1993) The World of Consumption Routledge London, UK
B. Fine M. Heasman J. Wright (1996) Consumption in the Age of Affluence Routledge London, UK
W. H. Friedland (2001) ArticleTitle“Reprise on commodity systems analysis” International Journal of Sociology of Agriculture and Food 9 IssueID1 82–103
H. F. Gale L. Foreman T. Capehart (2000) “Tobacco and the economy: Farms, jobs, and communities, Agricultural Economic Report No. 789.” Economic Research Service, US Department of Agriculture Washington DC
Gardner, B. L. (1997). “Issues in a buyout for tobacco growers.” Testimony: Senate Committee on Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry. September 18, 1997. Accessed on June 18, 2003, at http://www.senate.gov/agriculture/~gardner.html
D. Goodman (1999) ArticleTitle“Agro-food studies in the ‘age of ecology’: Nature, corporeality, bio-politics” Sociologia Ruralis 39 IssueID1 17–38 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-9523.00091
D. Goodman E. M. DuPuis (2002) ArticleTitle“Knowing food and growing food: Beyond the production–consumption debate in the sociology of agriculture” Sociologia Ruralis 42 IssueID1 5–22 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-9523.00199
C. C. Hinrichs (1998) ArticleTitle“Sideline or lifeline: The cultural economy of maple syrup production” Rural Sociology 63 IssueID4 507–532
J. Ikerd (1998) Sustainable agriculture, rural economic development, and large scale swine production K. M. Thu E. P. Durrenberger (Eds) Pigs, Profits, and Rural Communities State University of New York Press New York, New York 157–169
Kentucky Agricultural Statistics (2001). “Kentucky crops ranked by value of production.” National Agriculture Statistics Service, US Department of Agriculture. Washington DC: US Department of Agriculture. Accessed on July 29, 2003 at http://www.nass.usda.gov/ky
M. Lamont R. Wuthnow (1990) Betwixt and between: Recent cultural sociology in Europe and the United States G. Ritzer (Eds) Frontiers of Social Theory: The New Synthesis Columbia University Press New York, New York 287–315
S. Lockie S. Kitto (2000) ArticleTitle“Beyond the farm gate: Production–consumption networks and agri-food research” Sociologia Ruralis 40 IssueID1 3–19 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-9523.00128
S. Lockie K. Lyons G. Lawrence K. Mummery (2002) ArticleTitle“Eating ‘green’: Motivations behind organic food consumption in Australia” Sociologia Ruralis 42 IssueID1 23–40 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-9523.00200
T. K. Marsden N. Wrigley (1995) ArticleTitle“Regulation, retailing, and consumption” Environment and Planning A 27 1899–1912
D. McAdams (1982) Political Process and the Development of Black Insurgency, 1930–1970 University of Chicago Press Chicago, Illinois
S. Mennel (1992) On the civilizing appetite M. Featherstone M. Hepworth B. Turner (Eds) The Body: Social Process and Cultural Theory Sage London, UK 126–156
M. Miele (2001) “Creating sustainability: The social construction of the market for organic products.” Circle for Rural European Studies, Wageningen University Wageningen, The Netherlands
J. Murdoch M. Miele (1999) ArticleTitle“‘Back to nature’: Changing ‘worlds of production’ in the food sector” Sociologia Ruralis 39 IssueID4 465–483 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-9523.00119
J. Murdoch T. Marsden J. Banks (2000) ArticleTitle“Quality, nature, and embeddedness: Some theoretical considerations in the context of the food sector” Economic Geography 76 IssueID2 107–125
B. Poage (1995) The Tobacco Church II Kentucky Appalachian Ministry Richmond, Kentucky
S. Smith (1999) ArticleTitle“After tobacco” Forum For Applied Research and Public Policy 14 IssueID3 90–93
W. Snell (2003) Agricultural Situation and Outlook Department of Agricultural Economics, University of Kentucky Lexington, Kentucky
Snell, W. and D. Green (n.d.) Overview of Kentucky’s tobacco economy. Accessed on June 19, 2002, at http://www.uky.edu/Agriculture/TobaccoEcon/publications/tobovervu.pdf
A. Swidler (1986) ArticleTitle“Culture in action: Symbols and strategies” American Sociological Review 51 273–286
A. Swidler (2001) Talk of Love: How Culture Matters University of Chicago Press Chicago, Illinois
USDA (US Department of Agriculture) (1977). Land in Farms: Final Estimates by State and United States, 1993–97. Statistical Bulletin, No. 955. Agricultural Statistics Board, National Agricultural Statistics Service (NASS)
C. Waldrep (1993) Night Riders: Defending Community in the Black Patch, 1890–1915 Duke University Press Durham, North Carolina
A. Warde (1997) Consumption, Food and Taste: Culinary Antinomies and Commodity Culture Sage London, UK
M. Weber (1958) The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism Charles Scribner and Sons New York, New York
S. J. Whatmore L. Thorne (1997) Nourishing networks: Alternative geographies of food D. Goodman M. Watts (Eds) Globalizing Food: Agrarian Questions and Global Restructuring Routledge London, UK 287–304
Wright, D. W. (1999). Turning Over a New Leaf?: Socio-economic and Political Transformations in the Burley Tobacco Commodity System. PhD dissertation. University of Kentucky
P. Zhang C. Husten (1998) ArticleTitle“The impact of tobacco price support program on tobacco control” Tobacco Control: An International Journal 7 176–182
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
D. Wynne Wright is an Assistant Professor at the University of Northern Iowa specializing in agro-food systems and political sociology. Her current interests lie in the production/consumption nexus and how new lifestyle politics influence farm families and rural communities.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Wright, D.W. Fields of Cultural Contradictions: Lessons from the Tobacco Patch. Agric Hum Values 22, 465–477 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10460-005-3402-z
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10460-005-3402-z