Thank you. The best thing I can do now is encourage you to read the paper(s), which discuss or relate significantly to these questions. We've been at this awhile
and pulling things out bit by bit will go on indefinitely and may not be understood half as well as simply reading the papers. For example, I discuss alleged Protestant
counter-examples. The second paper is probably more important, as the first was refuted.

The papers were published in an important journal, they are easy
enough to read, and the issue is an interesting one. If upon reading the second paper you still have these (or other) concerns, I'd like to hear them.
Either here or at [email protected]. Thanks again, Jim