Graduate studies at Western
Philosophical Studies 18 (December):85-90 (1970)
|Abstract||An elementary mathematical proof is offered that mental states cannot be either intensionally or extensionally identical with brain states. the proof consists in taking a subset of mental states, namely, possible thoughts of integers and showing that this set has the cardinal number aleph null; then taking the largest physically possible set of brain states k and the number of subsets of k which is 2 to the power k, and which, no matter how large, is necessarily finite. it follows that these two sets cannot correspond one to one from which it then follows that they cannot have identical elements. i conclude with answers to likely objections and with a denial that my argument supports traditional dualism|
|Keywords||Body Identity Metaphysics Minds|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
|Through your library||Configure|
Similar books and articles
Ingrid Wallner-Ahmad (1975). The Identity Theorist's Solution to the Mind-Body Problem. Gnosis 1:28-38.
Neil Lubow (1978). Mind-Body Identity and Irreducible Properties. Philosophy Research Archives 4.
Cornelius Kampe (1974). Mind-Body Identity: A Question of Intelligibility. [REVIEW] Philosophical Studies 25 (January):63-67.
Jerome A. Shaffer (1974). Criteria for Mind-Body Identity: A Rejoinder. Behaviorism 2:120-123.
James W. Cornman (1962). The Identity of Mind and Body. Journal of Philosophy 59 (August):486-92.
Charles Crittenden (1971). Ontology and Mind-Body Identity. Philosophical Forum 2:251-70.
Stephen L. Nathanson (1972). Abelson's Refutation of Mind-Body Identity. Philosophical Studies 23 (February):116-118.
Pheroze S. Wadia (1972). On a Refutation of Mind-Body Identity. Philosophical Studies 23 (February):113-115.
Kenneth C. Clatterbaugh (1972). A Reply to an Attempted Refutation of Mind-Body Identity. Philosophical Studies 23 (February):111-112.
Added to index2009-01-28
Total downloads209 ( #1,517 of 739,318 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #61,243 of 739,318 )
How can I increase my downloads?