Constitution and the explanatory gap

Synthese 161 (2):183-202 (2008)
Proponents of the explanatory gap claim that consciousness is a mystery. No one has ever given an account of how a physical thing could be identical to a phenomenal one. We fully understand the identity between water and H2O but the identity between pain and the firing of C-fibers is inconceivable. Mark Johnston [Journal of philosophy , 564–583] suggests that if water is constituted by H2O, not identical to it, then the explanatory gap becomes a pseudo-problem. This is because all “manifest kinds”—those identified in experience—are on a par in not being identical to their physical bases, so that the special problem of the inconceivability of ‘pain = the firing of C-fibers’ vanishes. Moreover, the substitute relation, constitution, raises no explanatory difficulties: pain can be constituted by its physical base, as can water. The thesis of this paper is that the EG does not disappear when we substitute constitution for identity. I examine four arguments for the EG, and show that none of them is undermined by the move from constitution to identity.
Keywords Constitution  Identity  Water  Pain  The explanatory gap  The firing of C-fibers  Manifest kinds  Strongly manifest  Weakly manifest  Natural kind  Twin-Earth  Necessary constitution
Categories (categorize this paper)
DOI 10.2307/27653688
 Save to my reading list
Follow the author(s)
My bibliography
Export citation
Find it on Scholar
Edit this record
Mark as duplicate
Revision history Request removal from index
Download options
PhilPapers Archive

Upload a copy of this paper     Check publisher's policy on self-archival     Papers currently archived: 15,865
External links
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
Through your library
References found in this work BETA
Frank Jackson (1982). Epiphenomenal Qualia. Philosophical Quarterly 32 (April):127-136.

View all 20 references / Add more references

Citations of this work BETA

No citations found.

Add more citations

Similar books and articles
Alan Sidelle (1992). Identity and the Identity-Like. Philosophical Topics 20 (1):269-292.
Hagit Benbaji (2007). Is There a Puzzle About Water? Philosophical Papers 36 (2):207-218.
Christopher S. Hill (1981). Why Cartesian Intuitions Are Compatible with the Identity Thesis. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 42 (December):254-65.
Andrei A. Buckareff & Joel S. Van Wagenen (2010). Surviving Resurrection. International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 67 (3):123-139.
Andrei A. Buckareff & Joel S. Van Wagenen (2010). Surviving Resurrection. International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 67 (3):123 - 139.
Richard M. Gaskin (1988). Experience, Agency and the Self. Dissertation, University of Oxford (United Kingdom)

Monthly downloads

Added to index


Total downloads

154 ( #10,898 of 1,724,890 )

Recent downloads (6 months)

11 ( #59,786 of 1,724,890 )

How can I increase my downloads?

My notes
Sign in to use this feature

Start a new thread
There  are no threads in this forum
Nothing in this forum yet.