David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Bioethics 27 (2):81-88 (2013)
In the USA and England and Wales, involuntary treatment for mental illness is subject to the constraint that it must be necessary for the health or safety of the patient, if he poses no danger to others. I will argue against this necessary condition of administering treatment and propose that the category of individuals eligible for involuntary treatment should be extended. I begin by focusing on the common disorder of schizophrenia and proceed to demonstrate that it can be a considerable harm to a person's life without causing the person to be a danger to himself. I illuminate this claim by constructing a thought experiment concerning a person who slips on a banana peel and falls into a malfunctioning version of Robert Nozick's experience machine. I propose that the reasons why we should remove the person from the machine are the same reasons why we should administer involuntary treatment to individuals with schizophrenia. I rebut three objections to the analogy and conclude that if we believe that we have a duty to provide treatment for reasons relating to a person's wellbeing, it follows that we should reject the health or safety requirement and instead broaden the category of individuals who are eligible for involuntary treatment
|Keywords||competence coercion mental illness schizophrenia treatment autonomy lack of insight|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
Ori J. Herstein (2013). Why 'Nonexistent People' Do Not Have Zero Wellbeing but No Wellbeing at All. Journal of Applied Philosophy 30 (2):136-145.
Alexis Kaminsky, Laura Weiss Roberts & Janet L. Brody (2003). Influences Upon Willingness to Participate in Schizophrenia Research: An Analysis of Narrative Data From 63 People with Schizophrenia. Ethics and Behavior 13 (3):279 – 302.
Mari Stenlund (2011). Involuntary Antipsychotic Medication and Freedom of Thought. Dialogues in Philosophy, Mental and Neuro Sciences 4 (2):31-33.
Jillian Craigie (2011). Competence, Practical Rationality and What a Patient Values. Bioethics 25 (6):326-333.
Stephen Kershnar (2004). Respect for Persons and the Harsh Punishment of Criminals. International Journal of Applied Philosophy 18 (1):103-121.
Matt Ferkany (2012). The Objectivity of Wellbeing. Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 93 (4):472-492.
Harriet Baber (2008). The Experience Machine Deconstructed. Philosophy in the Contemporary World 15 (1):133-138.
Erick Fabris (2011). Tranquil Prisons: Chemical Incarceration Under Community Treatment Orders. University of Toronto Press.
Steven M. Silverstein & William A. Phillips (2004). Distinguishing Schizophrenia From the Mechanisms Underlying Hallucinations. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 27 (6):805-806.
Frederic Gilbert, Andrej Vranic & Samia Hurst (2013). Involuntary & Voluntary Invasive Brain Surgery: Ethical Issues Related to Acquired Aggressiveness. [REVIEW] Neuroethics 6 (1):115-128.
Maurilio Lovatti (2001). Pathology and Normality From XIX Century Positivism to the Contemporary Philosophy of Science: An Analysis of the Concept of Disease. Dissertation, Nettuno (Roma) Scuola internazionale di filosofia della biologia
O. Gambini, V. Barbieri & S. Scarone (2004). Theory of Mind in Schizophrenia: First Person Vs Third Person Perspective. Consciousness and Cognition 13 (1):39-46.
Simona Giordano (2000). For the Protection of Others. Health Care Analysis 8 (3):309-319.
Craig Edwards (2011). Respect for Other Selves. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 21 (4):349-378.
Added to index2011-08-12
Total downloads30 ( #55,807 of 1,096,707 )
Recent downloads (6 months)6 ( #39,873 of 1,096,707 )
How can I increase my downloads?