David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Canadian Journal of Philosophy 29 (2):205 - 223 (1999)
Peter Geach famously holds that there is no such thing as absolute identity. There are rather, as Geach sees it, a variety of relative identity relations, each essentially connected with a particular monadic predicate. Though we can strictly and meaningfully say that an individual a is the same man as the individual b, or that a is the same statue as b, we cannot, on this view, strictly and meaningfully say that the individual a simply is b. It is difficult to find anything like a persuasive argument for this doctrine in Geach's work. But one claim made by Geach is that his account of identity is the account most naturally aligned with Frege's widely admired treatment of cardinality. And though this claim of an affinity between Frege's and Geach's doctrines has been challenged, the challenge has been resisted. William Alston and Jonathan Bennett, indeed, go further than Geach to argue that Frege's doctrine implies Geach's. If Alston and Bennett are right, then those who favor a broadly Fregean treatment of cardinality have no choice but to adopt Geach's doctrine of relative identity. And because contemporary set-theoretic accounts of cardinality are essentially Fregean in all respects relevant to this issue (see §11 below), it follows from Alston and Bennett's claim that virtually every standard modern treatment of cardinality requires a 'relativized' treatment of identity. The purpose of this paper is to argue against the implication claimed by Alston and Bennett. Despite some superficial similarities between Frege's treatment of cardinality and Geach's treatment of identity, the two doctrines are fundamentally opposed. Frege's account of cardinality, and its set-theoretic descendants, are all inconsistent with the claim that identity is 'relative' in Geach's sense
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
No categories specified
(categorize this paper)
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
Massimiliano Carrara & Elisabetta Sacchi (2007). Cardinality and Identity. Journal of Philosophical Logic 36 (5):539 - 556.
Massimiliano Carrara (2009). Relative Identity and the Number of Artifacts. Techné 13 (2):108-122.
William P. Alston & Jonathan Bennett (1984). Identity and Cardinality: Geach and Frege. Philosophical Review 93 (4):553-567.
Harold W. Noonan (1980). Objects and Identity: An Examination of the Relative Identity Thesis and its Consequences. Distributors for the U.S. And Canada [by] Kluwer Boston.
P. Garbacz (2004). Subsumption and Relative Identity. Axiomathes 14 (4):341-360.
Athanassios Tzouvaras (2005). Cardinality Without Enumeration. Studia Logica 80 (1):121 - 141.
James Cain (1989). The Doctrine of the Trinity and the Logic of Relative Identity. Religious Studies 25 (2):141 - 152.
Till Tantau (2005). Weak Cardinality Theorems. Journal of Symbolic Logic 70 (3):861 - 878.
Benjamin C. Jantzen (2011). No Two Entities Without Identity. Synthese 181 (3):433-450.
Donald V. Poochigian (2008). Mathematical Identity. Proceedings of the Xxii World Congress of Philosophy 41:27-36.
E. J. Borowski (1975). Diachronic Identity as Relative Identity. Philosophical Quarterly 25 (100):271-276.
Rami Grossberg (1991). On Chains of Relatively Saturated Submodels of a Model Without the Order Property. Journal of Symbolic Logic 56 (1):124-128.
Nicholas Griffin (1977). Relative Identity. Clarendon Press.
Saharon Shelah & Pauli Vaisanen (2000). On Inverse Γ-Systems and the Number of L∞Λ- Equivalent, Non-Isomorphic Models for Λ Singular. Journal of Symbolic Logic 65 (1):272 - 284.
Added to index2011-05-29
Total downloads10 ( #139,316 of 1,096,518 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #246,097 of 1,096,518 )
How can I increase my downloads?