David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 31 (2):107-122 (2010)
Robert Truog describes the controversial randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) therapy in newborns. Because early results with ECMO indicated that it might be a great advance, saving many lives, Truog argues that ECMO should not have been tested using RCTs, but that a long-term, large-scale observational study of actual clinical practice should have been conducted instead. Central to Truog’s argument, however, is the idea that ECMO is an unusual case. Thus, it is an open question whether Truog’s conclusions can be extended to other areas of medical research. In this paper, I look at epistemological and ethical issues arising in the care of patients with chronic diseases, using ECMO as a starting point. Both the similarities and the dissimilarities of these two cases highlight important issues in biomedical research and support a conclusion similar to Truog’s. Observational studies of clinical practice provide the best evidence to inform the treatment of patients with chronic disease.
|Keywords||Randomized controlled trials Research ethics ECMO Chronic disease Research methods|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
Robyn Bluhm (2009). Some Observations on “Observational” Research. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 52 (2):252-263.
Kirstin Borgerson (2009). Valuing Evidence: Bias and the Evidence Hierarchy of Evidence-Based Medicine. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 52 (2):218-233.
Nancy Cartwright (2007). Are Rcts the Gold Standard? Biosocieties 1:11-20.
J. Grossman & F. Mackenzie (2005). The Randomized Controlled Trial: Gold Standard or Merely Standard? Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 48 (4):516-34.
Peter Urbach (1985). Randomization and the Design of Experiments. Philosophy of Science 52 (2):256-273.
Citations of this work BETA
L. McClimans (2013). The Role of Measurement in Establishing Evidence. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 38 (5):520-538.
Similar books and articles
George Mendelson (1991). Chronic Pain, Compensation and Clinical Knowledge. Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 12 (3).
Franklin G. Miller & Howard Brody (2007). Clinical Equipoise and the Incoherence of Research Ethics. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 32 (2):151 – 165.
Annette L. Stanton, Tracey A. Revenson & Howard Tennen, Health Psychology: Psychological Adjustment to Chronic Disease.
R. J. Gatchel, Colin Allen & P. N. Fuchs (2006). Ethical Issues in Chronic Pain Research. In B. L. Gant & M. E. Schatman (eds.), Ethical Issues in Chronic Pain Management. 295.
Thea P. M. Vliet Vlieland (2002). Managing Chronic Disease: Evidence-Based Medicine or Patient Centred Medicine? [REVIEW] Health Care Analysis 10 (3):289-298.
James F. Fries (1984). The Chronic Disease Data Bank: First Principles to Future Directions. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 9 (2):161-180.
Robert J. Gatchel, Perry N. Fuchs & Colin Allen (2006). 18 Ethical Issues in Chronic Pain Research. In B. L. Gant & M. E. Schatman (eds.), Ethical Issues in Chronic Pain Management. 295.
D. Elbourne, A. Grant & D. Field (1994). Ecmo. Journal of Medical Ethics 20 (2):127-127.
V. Mike, A. N. Krauss & G. S. Ross (1993). Neonatal Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation (ECMO): Clinical Trials and the Ethics of Evidence. Journal of Medical Ethics 19 (4):212-218.
Added to index2010-03-31
Total downloads16 ( #110,906 of 1,167,998 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #140,193 of 1,167,998 )
How can I increase my downloads?