David Bourget (Western Ontario)
David Chalmers (ANU, NYU)
Rafael De Clercq
Ezio Di Nucci
Jack Alan Reynolds
Learn more about PhilPapers
Classical Quarterly 41 (02):365- (1991)
One of the distinctions that Plato in the Laws stresses most heavily in his discussion of the proper relation between the individual citizen and the laws of the city is that between persuasion and compulsion. Law, Plato believes, should try to persuade rather than compel the citizens. Near the end of the fourth book of the Laws, the Athenian Stranger, Plato's spokesman in this dialogue, asks whether the lawgiver for their new city of Magnesia should in making laws ‘explain straightaway what must and must not be done, add the threat of a penalty, and turn to another law, without adding a single bit of encouragement or persuasion [παραμυθας δ κα πειθος … ν] to his legislative edicts’ . A few lines later, the Athenian Stranger himself condemns such a procedure as ‘the worse and more savage alternative’ . The better method is for the laws themselves to try to persuade the citizens to act in the manner that they prescribe. And as a means of doing this, Plato proposes attaching preludes to particular laws and to the legal code as a whole: such preludes will supplement the sanctions attached to the laws and will aim at persuading the citizens to act in the way that the laws direct for reasons other than fear of the penalties attached to the law. Such a practice, Plato believes, is an innovation: it is something that no lawgiver has ever thought of doing before . And we have no reason to think that Plato is here excluding his earlier self, e.g. the Plato of the Republic and the Politicus, from this criticism
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
|Through your library|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
Robert Mayhew (forthcoming). Plato's Erotic Citizens. L. Prauscello Performing Citizenship in Plato's Laws. Pp. X + 272. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2014. Cased, £60, Us$95. Isbn: 978-1-107-07288-6. [REVIEW] The Classical Review:1-2.
Similar books and articles
R. F. Stalley (1998). Plato's Doctrine of Freedom. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 98 (2):145–158.
Christopher Bobonich (ed.) (2010). Plato's "Laws": A Critical Guide. Cambridge University Press.
Christopher Buckels (2013). Compulsion to Rule in Plato's Republic. Apeiron 46 (1):63-84.
Michael Shalom Kochin (2002). Gender and Rhetoric in Plato's Political Thought. Cambridge University Press.
J. Wilson (1958). Freedom and Compulsion. Mind 67 (January):60-69.
Vincent Brümmer (1995). On Not Confusing Necessity with Compulsion: A Reply to Paul Helm. Religious Studies 31 (1):105-109.
Robert N. Audi (1974). Moral Responsibility, Freedom, and Compulsion. American Philosophical Quarterly 11 (January):1-14.
André Laks (2007). Freedom, Liberality, and Liberty in Plato's Laws. Social Philosophy and Policy 24 (2):130-152.
Christopher Bobonich (2002). Plato's Utopia Recast: His Later Ethics and Politics. Oxford University Press.
William Ferraiolo (2004). Against Compatibilism: Compulsion, Free Agency and Moral Responsibility. Sorites 15 (December):67-72.
Christopher Shields (2007). Forcing Goodness in Plato's Republic. Social Philosophy and Policy 24 (2):21-39.
Zena Hitz (2012). Plato's Laws: A Critical Guide. Edited by Christopher Bobonich. Ancient Philosophy 32 (2):441-446.
Christopher Bobonich (1994). Akrasia and Agency in Plato's Laws and Republic. Archiv für Geschichte der Philosophie 76 (1):3-36.
I. M. Crombie (1984). Plato's Laws R. F. Stalley: An Introduction to Plato's Laws. Pp. X + 208. Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1933. £15. The Classical Review 34 (02):207-209.
Eric Sanday (forthcoming). Property, Impiety, and the Problem of Ending: Plato’s Laws Books XI & XII. In Gregory Recco & Eric Sanday (eds.), Plato's Laws: Force and Truth In Politics. Indiana University Press
Added to index2010-12-09
Total downloads26 ( #154,633 of 1,911,611 )
Recent downloads (6 months)7 ( #97,666 of 1,911,611 )
How can I increase my downloads?